The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I stated in my last post kb, I agree with more of your latest post than I disagree. It's weird for me to call them HR and bipedalist because I came to know them by first name, but you're right HR and Bipedalist did their best as moderators and tried to be fair and not condescending. They were/are both fantastic, as were others.
 
I just don't recall any BFF mods saying anything resembling the following:

In my opinion, Bigfoot does not exist.
I disagree... I don't think that Bigfoot exists.
I don't think anyone is encountering Bigfoot because I don't think they exist.
Etc.

Couple things, I don't think you knew your BFF mods very well and I think a skeptic can participate in an argument without saying something absolute (i.e., something doesn't exist).

I think mod(s) did post routinely in a manner that would indicate they put their skepticals on before logging onto the forum. I was routinely called out (especially via PM) for being too skeptical by other members. Some members got very upset/agitated with me and my skeptical posts; or for not moderating skeptic's posts more. I was also routinely called a believer by others; again, told I let believers get away with too much when the hammer was coming down on skeptics. I read on JREF and via PM about more than one BFF member getting a free pass (both "believers" and skeptics) when I knew they'd all gotten warnings or worse.

I guess my thought(s) related to skeptics is that they don't have to give an absolute response, that it's ok to say, "I don't know" while still looking at things skeptically, with absolute skepticism.

I don't know why you don't recall any of those posts, but my thought is you weren't looking for/at those posts or weren't paying enough attention to those threads/posts/those posting. My signature line was "paper won't refuse ink". I would think anyone would realize that's a skeptics signature line. Doesn't mean I was going to push down someone's throat that bigfoot doesn't exist, even when they themself think they saw it with their own eyes. No reason to do that, especially as a moderator.

I actually have very good friend(s) that has seen a bigfoot. Absolutely, with their own eyes and with a witness. Does that mean I'm not skeptical or that I believe bigfoot exists? It doesn't mean that at all. The two things don't have anything to do with each other. It also doesn't mean I have to tell him/her/them they don't know what they saw.

So, if you were looking for a moderator to say, "anything resembling the following:

In my opinion, Bigfoot does not exist.
I disagree... I don't think that Bigfoot exists.
I don't think anyone is encountering Bigfoot because I don't think they exist."--emphasis added

Yep, you must have had your eyes closed when you were over there. Or maybe the tone was such that no one was fighting over it and you didn't see anything due to the lack of smoke.

I hope that helps clear things up.
 
I actually have very good friend(s) that has seen a bigfoot. Absolutely, with their own eyes and with a witness. Does that mean I'm not skeptical or that I believe bigfoot exists? It doesn't mean that at all. The two things don't have anything to do with each other. It also doesn't mean I have to tell him/her/them they don't know what they saw.

Surely if you say that in your opinion bigfoot certainly doesn't exist, you are implicitly saying to anyone who has seen bigfoot with their own eyes and with a witness that they don't know what they saw. Not in so many words, granted, but I don't see how articulating it makes any difference; what you believe about their story is clear.

By not articulating it aren't you just allowing them to believe that you don't feel as you do because you are not convinced that bigfoot doesn't exist, but are 'on the fence'. Which is why I think William Parcher would be looking for an unequivocal declaration as to the existence or non-existence, to see how they reacted to having a moderator who thought, even if he didn't say it in individual cases, that everyone claiming an encounter was either making a mistake or making it up. I may be wrong in his motivations of course.

Now personally I don't see why the BFF needs a moderator like that, if it's a site for people who broadly believe in bigfoot to talk about their belief in bigfoot and what bigfoot might be like, rather than about whether bigfoot exists. Which is what it seems to want to be. I honestly don't see how such a moderator could operate in such an environment, when you have to believe that many of the most active posters are simply wasting everyone's time with silly stories. Unfortunately along with that the BFF seems to have a tendency to congratulate itself on a perceived reputation for being skeptical because it doesn't immediately accept blurry shaky videos of men on riverbanks as bigfoots, and I can also see why this might irritate people.
 
My post obviously wasn't clear. The BFF had a good mix of skeptics on the moderating team. People may not agree.

What I was trying to get across in my last post was what I consider skepticism. I don't believe skepticism or being a skeptic has anything to do with the conclusion, it has everything with how you get to the conclusion. It's the process of examining and dealing with the "evidence". It's not about the proof, or the conclusion, it's about the reasoning or how you get to the proof. So, the moderating staff, at least a portion of it, was skeptical. They were skeptics. They did not accept what was said on it's own. They also allowed everyone to say anything related to bigfoot, as long as it was respectful of the other members. So, the moderators could allow someone's claim, could look at it skeptically, and still allow discussion or conversation about it. A skeptic, in my book, can say, "I don't know what you saw. You know what you saw, but it doesn't mean I know what you saw".

The job of the moderator wasn't to tell people whether or not bigfoot in fact exists, it was to allow people to discuss bigfoot in a respectful manner.
 
A skeptic, in my book, can say, "...You know what you saw..."


Skeptics around here are not likely to say something like this. Folks notoriously do not "know what they saw".

Anyway, in your opinion, who were the skeptical BFF mods?
 
Last edited:
My post obviously wasn't clear. The BFF had a good mix of skeptics on the moderating team. People may not agree.

What I was trying to get across in my last post was what I consider skepticism. I don't believe skepticism or being a skeptic has anything to do with the conclusion, it has everything with how you get to the conclusion. It's the process of examining and dealing with the "evidence". It's not about the proof, or the conclusion, it's about the reasoning or how you get to the proof. So, the moderating staff, at least a portion of it, was skeptical. They were skeptics. They did not accept what was said on it's own. They also allowed everyone to say anything related to bigfoot, as long as it was respectful of the other members. So, the moderators could allow someone's claim, could look at it skeptically, and still allow discussion or conversation about it. A skeptic, in my book, can say, "I don't know what you saw. You know what you saw, but it doesn't mean I know what you saw".

The job of the moderator wasn't to tell people whether or not bigfoot in fact exists, it was to allow people to discuss bigfoot in a respectful manner.

I'm not a 'skeptic'. I think a hell of a lot of the people who post on JREF are damn fools, who want to find people who believe in crap to make themselves feel better because they dont believe in crap. Many of them search out obscure rubbish so as not to believe in it. This is pathetic.

Im not a 'skeptic', I'm just a normal person. I hardly think about Bigfoot, and I believe in none of it, like everyone, although in the last few weeks ive looked into it and been shocked at the paucity of the evidence. However, I believe I represent the vast majority of people in the world in saying bigfoot doesnt exist, and it's not worth thinking about. Now, I think it's fine for people on BFF to ignore this, because they're coming from a different viewpoint. But if you want to say you're 'skeptical of Bigfoot', you have to admit that you agree with the vast majority of people in the world that there's nothing to it, and recognise that the pieces of evidence are worthless. And you have to absolutely say that anyone who claims to have seen bigfot MUST be lying or mistaken. If you say there might be something to it, you're not skeptical. This is what the guys who say they're 'skeptical' seem not to understand.
 
The job of the moderator wasn't to tell people whether or not bigfoot in fact exists, it was to allow people to discuss bigfoot in a respectful manner.

On this, I can't seen how anyone could argue. BFF isnt't about whether Bigfoot exists. That's a given on BFF. That argument should be had elsewhere.

If the owners of BFF want to have that argument, they just have to accept that half the time the only possible argument against a story is "you're making it up". And that doesn't make for a happy forum.
 
I think a hell of a lot of the people who post on JREF are damn fools, who want to find people who believe in crap to make themselves feel better because they dont believe in crap. Many of them search out obscure rubbish so as not to believe in it. This is pathetic.

Yes, that is pathetic. Fortunately it bears little resemblance to the JREF in reality.

For instance, I'm fairly certain that I have never searched out any obscure rubbish in order to not believe in it...

Whatever that means...
 
Hateman,
1) I think you may not be a resident of the US. Many people in the US believe in bigfoot. Perhaps the internet and cable television contribute to this phenomenon.
2) I haven't analyzed it but I think most of the discussion here bears on the nature and the quality of evidence and on the reasoning. It is more about "make your best case for this supposed monster; show me the evidence and I will criticize the evidence." People here who say bigfoot doesn't exist, generally mean there is no credible evidence that bigfoot exists.
3) frankly, your angry and ad hom comments suggest you have an agenda which you have not disclosed.
 
Last edited:
Many people in the US believe in bigfoot.

How many? More than 20,000?


People here who say bigfoot doesn't exist, generally mean there is no credible evidence that bigfoot exists.

It's more than just a lack of credible evidence. There is obvious evidence that Bigfoot is an active folktale. There is a strong motivation for folks to make up Bigfoot encounter stories. You better believe that they do. This is what the phenomenon is all about. All of society gets to participate in a universal campfire story. Not everyone is interested in the pastime but it is always there waiting for anyone. Who will fabricate a Bigfoot story tomorrow?
 
how many in the US believe in a bigfoot? I would put the number at many millions.
A quick and dirty google sample:

-24% of fishermen at a fishing forum.
-A Time Magazine survey showed that 25 percent agree some UFOs are probably spaceships from other worlds and 18 percent agreed that creatures like Bigfoot and the Loch Ness monster will one day be discovered.

-The Baylor survey
suggested Catholics were more likely to believe in the existence of Bigfoot/Nessie (23.9%) than Protestants (18%). Age had no significant effects, but Kerry (22.4%) and Nader (25.1%) were much more likely to find merit in cryptozoology than Bush voters (14.3%). Respondents generally become more skeptical about Bigfoot and Nessie with higher levels of education. For example, a third of those without a high school diploma (33.4%) agreed with the above statement, compared to 18% of those with a B.A. degree.
I'm not prepared to defend these surveys, but if even 5% of Americans believe, that is many millions.

I certainly agree with you that it is an active folktale. That is one of the reasons to talk about it. Boy scouts are being taught this stuff. Kids are learning about in books and in schools and from their parents. Museums have exhibits. This is not small.
 
Last edited:
How many? More than 20,000?




It's more than just a lack of credible evidence. There is obvious evidence that Bigfoot is an active folktale. There is a strong motivation for folks to make up Bigfoot encounter stories. You better believe that they do. This is what the phenomenon is all about. All of society gets to participate in a universal campfire story. Not everyone is interested in the pastime but it is always there waiting for anyone. Who will fabricate a Bigfoot story tomorrow?

makaya? eww.....................
 
Kit, I don't know why you bother posting over there. I never visited the original BFF, but I have been keeping up with things over there since the relaunch. It is a fanclub plain and simple. At first I figured it was just a lack of moderation that would clear up once they got organized. The direct insults and rambling off topic rants peppered with cheerleading and "WE DON"T CARE" posts makes it pretty much impossible to have a productive conversation over there.

That said, if you are going to continue to bang your head into that wall, try to keep your posts very very focused. You have a tendency to post more like a shotgun than a laserbeam. This allows them to go nuts with any nit they can find to pick at.

Picture of a truck: how many horses fit in a truck: did Patterson ride a shetland: discussion of breeds: ????: no profit.

Funny thing is your thread accounts for an alarming percentage of the total posts on the site so far. so much for "we don't care" eh?
 
Funny that you mention that, Derwoods. I focus my posts almost entirely into one thread. Lots of stuff comes up, and with the PGF it's easy to wander. I can say at least that Shetland ponies did not come from me. A whole lot of people do like to come and tell me they don't care. Funny, if they don't care, then why are they in there all the time?
 
Funny that you mention that, Derwoods. I focus my posts almost entirely into one thread. Lots of stuff comes up, and with the PGF it's easy to wander. I can say at least that Shetland ponies did not come from me. A whole lot of people do like to come and tell me they don't care. Funny, if they don't care, then why are they in there all the time?

But I think putting all your posts in one thread is allowing for incredible topic drift. And yeah I know the ponies didn't come from you but it was a result of some nit someone decided to pick.

You have a lot of good info that gets swallowed up by the howling bigfooters. I don't know if the moderators there are capable of keeping a thread on topic, but I feel your information would be better served as a group of much more specific threads.

If the mods would do their job and branch the thread every time someone takes off in a new direction they would only have themselves to blame for there being more than one Kit thread. (I can just imagine the uproar if you were to create the as many as your current thread should occupy)

BTW Any idea who that Washingtonian guy is who everyone immediately takes at his word while denouncing all forms of hearsay from people known to exist?
 
But I think putting all your posts in one thread is allowing for incredible topic drift. And yeah I know the ponies didn't come from you but it was a result of some nit someone decided to pick.

You have a lot of good info that gets swallowed up by the howling bigfooters. I don't know if the moderators there are capable of keeping a thread on topic, but I feel your information would be better served as a group of much more specific threads.

If the mods would do their job and branch the thread every time someone takes off in a new direction they would only have themselves to blame for there being more than one Kit thread. (I can just imagine the uproar if you were to create the as many as your current thread should occupy)

BTW Any idea who that Washingtonian guy is who everyone immediately takes at his word while denouncing all forms of hearsay from people known to exist?

and maybe comment on why you talked to Tom Biscardi unless your motives have another color?
 
That style of discussion is standard fare at the BFF. Any time Kit, or anyone else, posts a fact they don't like they pick on semantics, spelling, grammar, or just take the thread a different direction with no segue. Of the hundreds of posts in Kit's 2-question thread we can count on two hands the number that actually address his opening post.
And you are certainly correct that the moderators don't attempt to stop the nonsense. In fact, some of them are/were the worst offenders.

Kit, it's just like dealing with two dozen Sweatys. Ask one question at a time, and keep it simple so they can't ignore or 'misunderstand' it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom