Once upon a time I saw the PGF on some show back in the 70s, and my interest in bigfoot was born. This continued until I kind of lost touch with it in the 80s and mid 90's. I had a passive interest in it until I found the BFF and the BFRO online. It was there that I realized how much online interest there was, and as I wasn't real into the BFRO's for profit model I ended up at the BFF instead. As time went on, I met some like interested people in my neck of the woods and Bipto was kind enough to give NESRA a thread all their own until the group got their own site set up. So I do offer Bipto our appreciation in getting us started.
As time went the BFF was seen by many as the big dog of forums, and arguably they are where many other forums were inspired. But there is room for criticism to, a given group of old timers in this person's opinion ran off more than a few newer folks they disagreed with, some times with some justification, some times out of some sense of petty entitlement, and this is where the chinks in the armor began. I've heard bits and pieces over the years of things that are behind some of this, but i see no point in rehashing them here, but I do suspect they were fuel for more than some of the bickered at the BFF. There were and possibly still are hard feelings between the BFRO, and ex-bfro founders of the AIBR and former SRI, but the bickering ballooned from there and yes, I'm leading to a point here. I personally thing the nastiness peaked during the period that was marked by the dermal ridge feud and the Georgia of 08.
Personally I think the management at that point went down hill, just my opinion, others may vary. However, before this turns into a blame game, what went in my opinion is some of the administration became embroiled in feuds and or agendas of their own and by then I basically stopped following the trends, many others I know had stopped going to the BFF at that point as a rule also.
So what happened in the end? What went wrong? I think a few things led us to where the BFF currently is. The bickering certainly didn't help, it led to a large number of people leaving to do their thing (Group/forum/Blog, fill in the blank. Personally I stopped trusting the management to be objective at all and suspect they were doing some slightly under handed things, showing favoritism to some, and reading PMs, things like that. I could be wrong but I tend to doubt it. In the end, the management there seemed to suffer from the notion that they were, for lack of a better wording, the voice of bigfootery online, often comparing other forums to the nice but smaller, insignificant competition to them, comparing themselves to being Starbucks. I always found that incredibly arrogant. The fact is, more than one forum was opened up for the benefit of a particular Research group to handle their internal business, and the BFF just isn't the place to do that. At it's peak, their Management starting trying to influence the internals of other forums, and other things already mentioned ad nauseum in other threads.
So, in the end, Bipto has placed the BFF on hiatus until whenever and here we are to conjecture over what could of or maybe should have been. Giving the BFF to the AIBR was mentioned, an interesting possibility. This would have in my opinion, caused more harm than good in the end. There are old timers presently on the BFF who would have been ill effected by this, and to be blunt, the AIBR would have likely led to a system of absentee landlord-ism in my opinion.
Also mentioned was doing a hard reboot, getting all new mods, new management, unbanning everyone and reshuffling the mix. This is the best option in my opinion, but i find myself wondering how the old bickerings would be kept at bay even in this situation. I find myself doubting that would be possible in the long term.
The option taken is sort of sad in a nostalgic way, if the BFF is to be dead, because for me it is where things started. In the end, despite the bickering I think what got us here though is not as much the bickering as two things. The first is the facebook factor, people can associate there and talk in a less "forumish" manner which filters out much of the bickering. There are folks on the BFF that I despise dealing with there, yet we are able to speak civilly at facebook. In short, the model changed. I also have to come back and blame the administrative arrogance one more time, because I think that arrogance allowed the bickery atmosphere to flourish.
Hopefully it isn't dead, but that's my take.