The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
and maybe comment on why you talked to Tom Biscardi unless your motives have another color?

I find it highly amusing that you quote me when what I was talking about was how the BFF isn't capable of staying on topic.
 
Excellent example of what I just described.

Keep it on topic.

I just did, it came to my attention that kit has spoken to a known hoaxer, thus motives become suspect. Take the labcoat off and let him answer.
 
I just did, it came to my attention that kit has spoken to a known hoaxer, thus motives become suspect. Take the labcoat off and let him answer.

Well, he has talked to BobH, and wants to talk to BobG, both known hoaxers, your point seems completely irrelevant to an investigation about a hoax.

cGsyn.gif
 
Last edited:
how many in the US believe in a bigfoot? I would put the number at many millions.
A quick and dirty google sample:

-24% of fishermen at a fishing forum.
-A Time Magazine survey showed that 25 percent agree some UFOs are probably spaceships from other worlds and 18 percent agreed that creatures like Bigfoot and the Loch Ness monster will one day be discovered.

-The Baylor survey
I'm not prepared to defend these surveys, but if even 5% of Americans believe, that is many millions.

I certainly agree with you that it is an active folktale. That is one of the reasons to talk about it. Boy scouts are being taught this stuff. Kids are learning about in books and in schools and from their parents. Museums have exhibits. This is not small.


Millions actually truly believe that Bigfoot exists?


How to play the Bigfoot Folk Tradition that is part of our culture:

1. Tell people that you saw a Bigfoot. (You didn't but tell them that anyway.)

2. Tell people that you believe Bigfoot exists. (You don't but tell them that anyway.)
 
That style of discussion is standard fare at the BFF. Any time Kit, or anyone else, posts a fact they don't like they pick on semantics, spelling, grammar, or just take the thread a different direction with no segue. Of the hundreds of posts in Kit's 2-question thread we can count on two hands the number that actually address his opening post.
And you are certainly correct that the moderators don't attempt to stop the nonsense. In fact, some of them are/were the worst offenders...
Please, surely you're not singling out the BFF as the only culprit capable of this type of 'infraction'. The JREF is as grievous an offender as the BFF could ever hope to be when it comes to allowing/condoning 'posters' to both sidestep an issue/point/intelligence and subsequently derailing/obfuscating/denying its existence. Compared to the JREF, the BFF is a rank amateur in that regard.

ETA: Just to clarify, and ironically, I'm not speaking about the JREF's BF threads. They're quite compliant actually. I meant more the JREF as a whole and specifically just about every political, religious, current event, conspiracy thread that exists here.
 
Last edited:
Please, surely you're not singling out the BFF as the only culprit capable of this type of 'infraction'. The JREF is as grievous an offender as the BFF could ever hope to be when it comes to allowing/condoning 'posters' to both sidestep an issue/point/intelligence and subsequently derailing/obfuscating/denying its existence. Compared to the JREF, the BFF is a rank amateur in that regard.

ETA: Just to clarify, and ironically, I'm not speaking about the JREF's BF threads. They're quite compliant actually. I meant more the JREF as a whole and specifically just about every political, religious, current event, conspiracy thread that exists here.

Did I say I was singling out the BFF? Did I say the JREF does not have similar issues?

This thread is about the BFF so I described how conversations work there.

I try to stay on topic whenever possible.
 
Did I say I was singling out the BFF? Did I say the JREF does not have similar issues?

This thread is about the BFF so I described how conversations work there.

I try to stay on topic whenever possible.

Actually this forum does a decent job on threads not BF related, it seems almost as if that is the subject makes the labcoats crazy.
 
For the record GT, my complaint was directed at the general issue far more than it appeared and not so much your specific post. Truly, I wasn't picking on you.

Anyway, risking the appearance (yet once again) of defending the BFF (I'm not, there is a bigger picture), I'm confused by the attitude here that the BFF somehow needs (or needed) to be something other than what it is/was i.e. more (or simply) skeptical, for instance. Why? I don't think I'm making anything up saying the rules there even state (paraphrasing) 'most participants here believe in Bigfoot and if you don't, be prepared'. The essence of any game is contained in its rules.

I'm also confused by the 'thinking' that says not only that we should be over there trying to convince them otherwise of their 'grand illusions', but to also get mad at them (and complain about it here) when they don't accept or much appreciate such a well intentioned act of sharing one's seeming enlightenment. Our somehow being convinced they actually want to 'see the light' is our own grand illusion.

While I'm convinced enough the JREF is at the forefront of 'Bigfoot skepticism', I don't see much 'investigation' being done here as to finding the real cause of the entire Bigfoot phenomenon. I mean, there is no real Bigfoot, we're convinced there is no real Bigfoot, and thousands upon thousands of words attest to that fact, yet we have maybe two whole paragraphs someplace dedicated to 'intelligent speculation and investigation' as to what the real cause (of Bigfoot™) might be. That is, we're so convinced we see 'the truth', we don't understand we're not actually seeing it, we're just seeing what it is not. Big footed hairy man-apes might not exist in the form of flesh and blood, but they do exist, at least in the minds of a whole ******** of people.
 
For the record GT, my complaint was directed at the general issue far more than it appeared and not so much your specific post. Truly, I wasn't picking on you.

Anyway, risking the appearance (yet once again) of defending the BFF (I'm not, there is a bigger picture), I'm confused by the attitude here that the BFF somehow needs (or needed) to be something other than what it is/was i.e. more (or simply) skeptical, for instance. Why? I don't think I'm making anything up saying the rules there even state (paraphrasing) 'most participants here believe in Bigfoot and if you don't, be prepared'. The essence of any game is contained in its rules.

I'm also confused by the 'thinking' that says not only that we should be over there trying to convince them otherwise of their 'grand illusions', but to also get mad at them (and complain about it here) when they don't accept or much appreciate such a well intentioned act of sharing one's seeming enlightenment. Our somehow being convinced they actually want to 'see the light' is our own grand illusion.

While I'm convinced enough the JREF is at the forefront of 'Bigfoot skepticism', I don't see much 'investigation' being done here as to finding the real cause of the entire Bigfoot phenomenon. I mean, there is no real Bigfoot, we're convinced there is no real Bigfoot, and thousands upon thousands of words attest to that fact, yet we have maybe two whole paragraphs someplace dedicated to 'intelligent speculation and investigation' as to what the real cause (of Bigfoot™) might be. That is, we're so convinced we see 'the truth', we don't understand we're not actually seeing it, we're just seeing what it is not. Big footed hairy man-apes might not exist in the form of flesh and blood, but they do exist, at least in the minds of a whole ******** of people.

When you find the real cause of Christianity, Islam, Mormonism, Judaism and all the others you will find the cause of Big foot.
 
While I'm convinced enough the JREF is at the forefront of 'Bigfoot skepticism', I don't see much 'investigation' being done here as to finding the real cause of the entire Bigfoot phenomenon. I mean, there is no real Bigfoot, we're convinced there is no real Bigfoot, and thousands upon thousands of words attest to that fact, yet we have maybe two whole paragraphs someplace dedicated to 'intelligent speculation and investigation' as to what the real cause (of Bigfoot™) might be.


Myself alone have given far more than two paragraphs on the "causes" of Bigfootery. It's probably not a single essence. But how could you reject the following?...

There are some people who enjoy the fantasy of Bigfoot being real.
 
There have been many ideas proferred as to Bogfoot's reality. Narcolepsy, hallucination, hoaxing, mood altering drugs, mis ID, all being part of the perpetuation of am American myth.
 
In many cases I think mis-perception is a better term than mis-identification, because it implies a somewhat less rational process and one which is influenced by subtle factors or experience and expectation. People see (and hear) what they expect to see and hear.

I am struck by the number of current reports which date back to experiences many years ago... 'footers say these people were afraid to come forward. Contamination of memory can account for a number of these. Nowadays, their stories are welcomed around the campfire.
 
For the record GT, my complaint was directed at the general issue far more than it appeared and not so much your specific post. Truly, I wasn't picking on you.

Anyway, risking the appearance (yet once again) of defending the BFF (I'm not, there is a bigger picture), I'm confused by the attitude here that the BFF somehow needs (or needed) to be something other than what it is/was i.e. more (or simply) skeptical, for instance. Why? I don't think I'm making anything up saying the rules there even state (paraphrasing) 'most participants here believe in Bigfoot and if you don't, be prepared'. The essence of any game is contained in its rules.

I'm also confused by the 'thinking' that says not only that we should be over there trying to convince them otherwise of their 'grand illusions', but to also get mad at them (and complain about it here) when they don't accept or much appreciate such a well intentioned act of sharing one's seeming enlightenment. Our somehow being convinced they actually want to 'see the light' is our own grand illusion.

While I'm convinced enough the JREF is at the forefront of 'Bigfoot skepticism', I don't see much 'investigation' being done here as to finding the real cause of the entire Bigfoot phenomenon. I mean, there is no real Bigfoot, we're convinced there is no real Bigfoot, and thousands upon thousands of words attest to that fact, yet we have maybe two whole paragraphs someplace dedicated to 'intelligent speculation and investigation' as to what the real cause (of Bigfoot™) might be. That is, we're so convinced we see 'the truth', we don't understand we're not actually seeing it, we're just seeing what it is not. Big footed hairy man-apes might not exist in the form of flesh and blood, but they do exist, at least in the minds of a whole ******** of people.

Sorry about the defensive post, Harry.

I agree with your comments that JREFers think it's up to them to somehow convince the believers (on the believer's own web-site) that bigfoot does not exist, and that they shouldn't do so.
That said, I've made quite a few posts over there with that purpose in mind, but then I stop and tell myself it's their site and they should be able to enjoy themselves without some skeptic crashing their party. And that works for a month or two but then one of them will post something so incredibly arrogant, or wrong, that I just can't resist and reply.

It's an addiction that is difficult to overcome, and I'm sure the handful of people here who respond to Sweaty's post understand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom