The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
a "Sublimation questioned" lie about what he quotes

Let’s dig out some more old papers...
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

There is a "Sublimation questioned" lie about what he quotes. This is an uncited paper about 67P ("Seth region"). The quote is that for jetsoutdise the area of highest gas production, there is no "no simple proportionality relation between gas and dust production rates". So it is not a simple case of ices sublimating in that area.

The documented liar Wal Thornhill has no cited lies or delusions about the proportionality relation between gas and dust production rates.

A insane "Sol88 also has a large collection of papers that raise serious concerns on the standard 1950’s Whipple’s model as comets as mostly ice" lie. No paper he has ever cited states that comets are actual rock as in the electric comet insanity. What we have found is that 2 comets with measured densities lower than water have more dust than ices (Tempel 1 and 67P).
 
Some mainstream scientists are

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective
Karl-Heinz Glassmeier
Usual lies about a mainstream ices and dust paper from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is not his electric comet insanity of comets being rock.

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective
Other interesting observations concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet's plasma environment [53].
This is a comment in the summary section. [53] is Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko. That possible connection might be large grains being lifted by sublimation and being torn apart by the plasma environment. That possible connection may be dynamic electromagnetic (not electrostatic) lifting of nanoparticles from the surface.
 
Blatant lie about the Insane delusions of his documented liar Wal Thornhill

No Wal said comets would be electrostaticly cleaned I.e there is dust being electrostaticly removed from the surface in jets...
Blatant lie about the insane delusions of his documented liar Wal Thornhill from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Wal Thornhill has the insane delusion that comet jets are electric discharges, magically removing rock. His "electrostatic cleaning" delusion is that electric arcing or electric discharge machining "clean the nucleus’ surface, leaving little or no dust or debris on it" (prediction for Tempel 1).

What make the lie blatant is that Sol88 knows that the surface of 67P is covered in a layer of dust. It is thick enough in places to form "dunes"!
 
Electrostaticly removed/cleaned/emitted from the surface... as predicted by W.Thornhill and confirmed by the Rosetta mission to 67P
Blatant lie about the insane delusions of his documented liar Wal Thornhill from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.
Sol88 knows that 67P is covered in a layer of dust that has not been "Electrostaticly removed/cleaned/emitted from the surface" leaving a surface with little of no dust.
 
Last edited:
A "beam of negatively charged dust" = Thornhill's insanity lie.

Did you not pick up on the beam of negatively charged dust?
Usual mainstream paper lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Shortly after the Rosetta mission's rendezvous with 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko the RPC/IES instrument intermittently detected negative particles that were identified as singly charged nano-dust grains. These grains were recorded as a nearly mono-energetic beam of particles in the 200-500 eV range arriving from the direction of the comet. Occasionally, another population of particles in the energy range of 1-20 keV were also noticed arriving from the approximate direction of the Sun. In this paper we review the processes that can explain the energization and the directionality of the observed nano-dust populations. We show that the observations are consistent with gas-drag acceleration of the outflowing particles with radii of 3-4 nm, and with the returning fragments of bigger particles accelerated by radiation pressure with approximate radii of 30-80 nm. In addition to gas drag and radiation pressure, we also examine the role of the solar wind induced motional electric field, and its possible role in explaining the intermittency of the detection of a nano-grain population arriving from the solar direction.
This is 2 intermittent beams of charged nano-dust grains arriving from the directions of the comet and the Sun.


Thornhill's insanity is
The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.
Sol88 knows that 67P had a layer of dust when it was active and close to the Sun.
 
Last edited:
Electric comet insanity of rocks being blasted off big asteroids or dwarf planets.

...Who knows?
Expands his electric comet insanity. Rocks being blasted off big asteroids or dwarf planets. Abysmal stupidity of "comets asteroids and dwarf planets" being formed in the same location which in the electric comet insanity would include Earth :jaw-dropp!
An insane "Who knows? question because we know the physical evidence for the origins of comets, asteroids, dwarf planets, and planets.

Usual mainstream paper lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.
Ceres is not a comet :eye-poppi. A quote about the Bennu asteroid is not about a comet :eye-poppi.
 
An insane lie that planets, asteroids and comets have the same composition

Unless you can define why there all the same composition pl@nets, asteroids and comets, your argument is weak and a straw man.
An insane lie that planets, asteroids and comets have the same composition.

They all formed in the early solar system so they share some of the same minerals, e.g. carbonaceous minerals. But comets have ices. Comets are not rocks like asteroids or rocky planets. Comets do not have the same proportion of gas as our gas giants! The insanity is asserting that comets contain limestone, basalt, granite, fossils, etc. when we have samples of comet dust grains from the Stardust mission.

The insanity includes denying the many explanations that Sol88 has been given over more than 9 years (he knows abut Stardust) and even what Sol88 has cited!
 
Insane insult of astronomers and abysmal ignorance from his coet insanity playbook

So let’s keep hammering away at your first point because it’s been shown the difference between these bodies is not the uniform sedate accretion postulated by nincompoops.
Insane insult of astronomers and abysmal ignorance from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Astronomers are not nincompoops.
The formation of planets and asteroids is definitely not "uniform sedate accretion". The formation of comets might be described as "uniform sedate accretion".
 
Plasma stupidity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sit down and have good read
"99% of the visible matter in the universe is ´plasma" stupidity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

The link is broken. There is a "Heliophysics" portion so this looks like an astrophysicist stating what textbook astronomy has stated for many decades, thus the stupidity of quoting it. 99% of the visible matter in the universe is stars + hot gas. We call the state of matter comprising stars + hot gas plasma :eye-poppi!
The astronomer (but Soll88 insults them as nincompoops!) writes that a large fraction of the plasma is dusty which seems reasonable. We know that most of the visible matter in the universe is plasma between galaxies (galactic clusters can be 80% gas) and radiation distributes dust everywhere.
 
A lie that the diamagnetic cavity is a double layer

This is the diamagnetic cavity, a plasma double layer.
A lie that a diamagnetic cavity is a double layer from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

As Sol88 has been told many times: A diamagnetic cavity is an absence of a magnetic field, a double layer is 2 layers of charges which have a magnetic field between them. It is a lie that they are the same.
 
This is slowly leading to the realisation that the nucleus itself is a charged object.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

We have known for decades that objects in the solar wind have the potential (pun intended) to became charged objects. That a comet nucleus at low activity when the solar wind if not shielded by the coma can became charged is textbook astronomy.

Read the papers you have been citing for months or years. They have references to earlier papers. Use Google. You will find that electrostatic charging of the cometary nucleus has been textbook physics since maybe 1985 :jaw-dropp!
On the electrostatic charging of the cometary nucleus (1981).

That is nothing to do with the delusions spewed by the documented liar Wal Thornhill who you believe in. The deluded Thunderbolts cult insanity is that an solar electric field does whatever magical things they think up, including turning asteroids (rocks) on cometary orbits into comets which is not seen. And just as magically did not make Rosetta following an active comet explode :p!
 
abysmal ignorance that transport along the lunar surface = fluffy cometary dust

The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces

Fluffy dust anyone?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is the abysmal ignorance that transport along the lunar surface = fluffy cometary dust detected in the coma of 67P maybe hundreds of kilometers from the surface..
 
Repeats abysmal ignorance about what an ambipolar electric field is

Or do you still not believe the comet has an ambipolar electric field?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.
Repeats abysmal ignorance about what an ambipolar electric field is (an electric field within a plasma such as the cometary coma). This may be the tenth time that this link has been given to him and he still does not understand where the electric field is.

This is also a lie about the electric comet insanity which has a solar electric field doing magic.
 
idiotic repeating of an already answered question

Is that a yes, jd116?...
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is the repeating of an already answered ambipolar electric fields question. The answer was
Totally irrelevant. Your model failed. Ambipolar fields have nothing to do with that failure. Stop avoiding the failure of your model.

What makes the question idiotic is that it has been answered in full many times so Sol88 knows it is irrelevant: Repeats abysmal ignorance about what ambipolar electric fields are (field inside plasma)(
 
Idiocy that posters here do not know that charged dust exists on the solar system

More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Idiocy that posters here do not know that charged dust exists on the solar system when we have been talking about charged dust in the solar system for maybe years in this long thread.

Learn about the literature about comets, Sol88: On the electrostatic charging of the cometary nucleus (1981)
The paper demonstrates that a water-dominated cometary nucleus is not shielded from solar UV radiation or solar wind by protective atmospheres beyond a heliocentric distance of 5 AU. It is also shown that submicron dust particles can be electrostatically levitated and blown off the cometary surface. An upper limit on the total mass that can be lost from the sunlit hemisphere is derived using two solar wind models, and the dust mantle erosion is estimated at 5-12 cm. It is noted that the erosion is comparable to the mass of dust blown off a typical medium bright comet by the viscous drag of the sublimating gases during perihelium passage between 3.0 and 0.5 AU, and it is therefore proposed, that the surface dust blow-off be included in the current balance equation.
 
A "End of the Dirtysnowball snowball right there" lie by citing a mainstream paper

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

End of the Dirtysnowball snowball right there.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.
A "End of the Dirtysnowball snowball right there" lie by citing a mainstream ices and dust comet paper about decades old textbook physics.

On the electrostatic charging of the cometary nucleus (1981)
The paper demonstrates that a water-dominated cometary nucleus is not shielded from solar UV radiation or solar wind by protective atmospheres beyond a heliocentric distance of 5 AU. It is also shown that submicron dust particles can be electrostatically levitated and blown off the cometary surface. An upper limit on the total mass that can be lost from the sunlit hemisphere is derived using two solar wind models, and the dust mantle erosion is estimated at 5-12 cm. It is noted that the erosion is comparable to the mass of dust blown off a typical medium bright comet by the viscous drag of the sublimating gases during perihelium passage between 3.0 and 0.5 AU, and it is therefore proposed, that the surface dust blow-off be included in the current balance equation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom