The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
An insult that other posters are ignorant about ambipolar electric fields

If you don’t believe there is an ambipolar electric field at 67p and sublimation is the only mechanism then not sure if anything I say is going to get you to think about other mechanisms.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

An insult that other posters are ignorant about ambipolar electric fields and that the ambipolar electric fields inside the coma of 67P have been detected. We all know that they exist and are irrelevant to the electric comet insanity.

A lie that posters here believe that "sublimation is the only mechanism" for ejecting dust when he is the one who cited paper(s) about electrostatic ejection of dust from comet surfaces at low activity. We know that general sublimation is one of several mainstream mechanisms. We know that this is irrelevant to the electric comet insanity.
 
Sol88 still cannot understand what "dielectric liquid" means in what they cite

So simplistic even a simpleton finds it simple....
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88 still cannot understand what "dielectric liquid" means in what they cite :jaw-dropp!
Electrical discharge machining
Electrical discharge machining (EDM), also known as spark machining, spark eroding, burning, die sinking, wire burning or wire erosion, is a manufacturing process whereby a desired shape is obtained by using electrical discharges (sparks).[1] Material is removed from the work piece by a series of rapidly recurring current discharges between two electrodes, separated by a dielectric liquid and subject to an electric voltage. One of the electrodes is called the tool-electrode, or simply the "tool" or "electrode," while the other is called the workpiece-electrode, or "work piece." The process depends upon the tool and work piece not making actual contact.


There is no dielectric liquid on the surface of a comet. Plasma is simple to understand - it is a partially ionized, conducting gas. Sol88 has known this for probably years.
 
Last edited:
A blatant "ambipolar electric field" lie about his electric comet insanity

So far so good, our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock with an ambipolar electric field.

That is the electric comet.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A blatant "ambipolar electric field" lie about his electric comet insanity when it has a solar electric field.
 
"Piddley little amounts of water" and "As has been shown" lies

Piddley little amounts of water does not make the assumption that comets are mostly ice even remotely true.

As has been shown.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Irrelevant "Piddley little amounts of water" and "As has been shown" lies when it is ratios and Sol88 has shown nothing relevant to his electric comet insanity.

Mainstream comets are obviously made of varying ratios of ices and dust, e.g. the solar heat removes ices while comets accrue ices and dust in the outer solar system. We have measured 2 comets with high dust/ices ratios. There are billions of potential comets. We have cataloged thousands. 2 out of billions is too small a sample to say anything definite about an average comet.

Another part of the lies is the word "assumption" when we have measured the density of comets for over 70 years and they are below that of water. Add the formation in the early solar system as "leftovers" and it was a deduction from the evidence that comets were mostly ices.
 
A delusion that the phrase "electric fields" supports his electric comet insanity

Electric fields champ! ...
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A delusion that the phrase "electric fields" supports his electric comet insanity when he needs a specific, solar electric field that produces the deluded magic he wants, e.g. electric discharges that insanely do not emit detectable radiation :jaw-dropp. Nothing visible even when jets are emitted from shadows. No x-rays typical of electric discharges.
 
Mainstream papers are not his electric comet insanity

Because all of a sudden we are talking the electric comet model by default and not the outdated Dirtysnowball.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Mainstream papers are not his electric comet insanity, the mainstream model is not outdated. Usual "Dirtysnowball" ignorance when it was the "dirty snowball" or "icy dirtball" or "fried ice-cream" (depending on an astronomers opinion about average cometary composition) or mainstream comet model.

A "electric comet model" lie because there is no such thing. Part of what makes the electric comet insane is that it has spent 45 years as a collection of deluded fantasies spouted by maybe a dozen cranks with some other supporters parroting them who are in denial of the real world and actual science. A good way to get banned from the forum of the Thunderbolts cult is to question their dogma by asking for numeric calculations from their "model" as I found out!

Another reason that the lack of an actual model is insane is that 2 of the current cranks should be able to produce a model. The documented liar Wal Thornhill has a physics degree. Donald Scott is a (retired?) electrical engineer who has published a few "astronomy" papers.
 
"ambipolar electric fields and strong surface electric fields", etc. lies

Both have have ambipolar electric fields and strong surface electric fields and in in at least Tempel 1’s case the same composition.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Blatent "ambipolar electric fields and strong surface electric fields", etc. lies about asteroids and comet.
Ambipolar electric fields exist inside plasma and asteroids are in basically (vacuum (there is the solar wind).
Ambipolar electric fields exist inside the plasma around comets.
Any electric fields on asteroids or comets are relatively weak.

Sol88 knows that Tempel 1 does not have the same composition as an asteroid. For example, Deep Impact ejected " 5 million kg (11 million lb) of water[41] and between 10 and 25 million kg (22 and 55 million lb) of dust". That is 50 to 25% water.
When we look at mining asteroids for water there is only a small number that are worthwhile because they may be extinct comets!
 
Last edited:
Enjoy your holiday I hope rc?

Jets is the subject of today’s discussion.

Have you read “Comet Dust” yet?
 
Active Asteroid P/2017 S5 (ATLAS)

Have a chew on this me paper and tell me the electric field strength. When and get back to me.

When all you have is a hammer...

:D
 
Last edited:
This would be the electric field that you refuse to explain?

Or have you come up with the maths to make it accelerate differently charged particles in the same direction
 
Did you read the paper?

Maybe I missed where they discussed that the dust was charged and the OOM for the electric field strength.

Just a quick look but no mention, why?

When all have is a hammer...
 
A comet is a rock discharging in the solar plasma. Funny enough.

The sublimation model was thought to be the only viable model, this is increasingly untenable from the data received from the Rosetta mission.

And while the ELECTRIC COMETS may not be correct down to the finest details the SUBLIMATION model is leading mainstream up the garden path.

I’m just happy for there to be charge separation and double layers at comets and that sublimation is now an old dinosaur.

What a complete load of nonsense. Sublimation is SEEN. Your idiotic electric woo isn't. You have no mechanisms, no science and no evidence. Still batting zero.
 
What a complete load of nonsense. Sublimation is SEEN. Your idiotic electric woo isn't. You have no mechanisms, no science and no evidence. Still batting zero.

Sublimation is inferred and now untenable. It can not remove the dust from the surface of the nucleus.

Sorry. :rolleyes:

This is, of course, not applicable to the insignificant amount of condensation that happens from the water released from the hydrated minerals.
 
Sublimation is inferred and now untenable. It can not remove the dust from the surface of the nucleus.

Sorry. :rolleyes:

This is, of course, not applicable to the insignificant amount of condensation that happens from the water released from the hydrated minerals.

And another pile of crap. Sublimation is SEEN. It can remove dust, as seen. And hydrated minerals is plain idiocy. You have not got the temperatures to release the bound OH and water. Fail. You are just making stuff up, due to the complete failure of your stupid model.
 
You have precisely nothing. Other than a total failure.

The central question about the active asteroids as a group is “what drives the observed mass loss?”.The range of processes identified to date includes impact, breakup, rotational mass-shedding and the sublimation of near-surface ice.
Active Asteroid P/2017 S5 (ATLAS)

When all you have is a hammer...:rolleyes:
 
Active Asteroid P/2017 S5 (ATLAS)

When all you have is a hammer...:rolleyes:

And of what relevance is that? Do you know how many asteroids there are? Do you know how many are on highly elliptical orbits? Why aren't they outgassing? You have no model. Fail.
 
Have sublimation been abserved on asteroids?

Especially the asteroid mentioned above?
 
Have sublimation been abserved on asteroids?

Especially the asteroid mentioned above?

And what is the relevance of that? The vast majority of asteroids are not outgassing, despite having strong ambipolar fields, and being subject to the solar wind, and its motional electric field. Including many on highly elliptical orbits. The existence of such asteroids falsifies your woo.
 
Really? Any papers to back up your claims? Other piffling trolling, again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom