The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well how far does the comet tail extend? Does it remain coherent over these distances? if so why?

Do you know much about double layers and Birkeland currents? or indeed what there is an ambipolar electric field at 67P?

Why is the diamagnetic cavity filamentary or "spikey"?

I'll leave the Electric Sun to the SAFIRE team.

I'm concentrating on the ELECTRIC COMET and cometary jets in particular.

Why is the dust negatively charged?

Why does the comet emit both ions and electrons(negatively charged dust)?

Some questions that are looking for answers?
Presumably, your EC provides at least some answers, doesn’t it?

Why don’t you state what that EC is, and at least sketch how it provides some answers?
 
Presumably, your EC provides at least some answers, doesn’t it?

Why don’t you state what that EC is, and at least sketch how it provides some answers?

You should know better than to ask for a model, JT. Take this from Tim Thompson, from Cosmoquest, 12.5 years ago;

This discussion suffers from a terrible weakness, and that is the absence of any electric comet model. How are we supposed to discuss electric comets, if we don't know what they are supposed to be? Even Juergen's calls his own description a "rather sketchy qualitative explanation". So, is this the best description of an electric comet that the EU has to offer? Is there anything more precise? is there a model that actually uses real physics? Is there a model that actually has an equation in it somewhere?

I think that if there is no more precise, more physical description of an electric comet than this, then there is hardly a reason to pretend that this might be a serious discussion.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets&p=748956#post748956

'Twas ever thus, I'm afraid. Keep it as vague as possible. Unfortunately for Sol, a month or so after that post T & T produced their electric comet poster. Sod all science in it. However, it does make specific claims which have been debunked thoroughly. And then we had David Talbott making his own 'predictions' on this very site. Which have not gone well at all. So, I guess Sol has learned from their mistakes, and is keeping his own model secret.
 
Last edited:
A comet is a rock discharging in the solar plasma. Funny enough.

The sublimation model was thought to be the only viable model, this is increasingly untenable from the data received from the Rosetta mission.

And while the ELECTRIC COMETS may not be correct down to the finest details the SUBLIMATION model is leading mainstream up the garden path.

I’m just happy for there to be charge separation and double layers at comets and that sublimation is now an old dinosaur.
 
As some smart cookie said they are part of an electric curcuit.

Moving charges, double layers, loads and generators.
 
As some smart cookie said they are part of an electric curcuit.

Moving charges, double layers, loads and generators.

But measurements show that they are far below what you need, and even with the wrong signs, so your EC has failed - or can you present calculations that show that EC can make do with too little, and of the wrong sign?
 
Experimental Methods of Dust Charging and Mobilization on Surfaces with
Exposure to Ultraviolet Radiation or Plasmas
doi:10.3791/57072
Irrelevant to his electric comet insanity paper from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

The mainstream ices and dust model of comets includes the obvious fact that dust ejected from comets becomes charged by mechanisms including "Ultraviolet Radiation or Plasmas". Also ices and dust comets can have surface dust charged in this way when activity is low (no shielding coma).
 
The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications


That’s as had a rock says MUPUS. :thumbsup:
Usual papers irrelevant to his electric comet insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

More insanity and lies from Sol88 by comparing an overall comet quote ("The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice.") about porosity with the MUPUS surface layer measurement of an ices and dust strength consistent with sintered ices and dust .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom