The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
That doesn't actually answer any of my questions. Let us assume I can understand anything you posit and work from there.

So, how does the EC electric field allow both positive and negative charges to run in the same direction as we observe in the solar wind?

Not sure but we are seeing at 67P as well.

Ions and electrons (negatively charged dust).

Let’s find out, ay?

Plasma, funky stuff
 
Not sure but we are seeing at 67P as well.

Ions and electrons (negatively charged dust).

Let’s find out, ay?

Plasma, funky stuff

So, you have no model, and no explanation for why much stronger fields are doing nothing much at asteroids, or inactive comets. And no explanation for the field being of the wrong sign to accelerate dust. So, just more trolling.
 
So, you have no model, and no explanation for why much stronger fields are doing nothing much at asteroids, or inactive comets. And no explanation for the field being of the wrong sign to accelerate dust. So, just more trolling.

What sign is the field jonesdave116?

No long back you denied the ambipolar electric field all together. :boggled:

Plasma and electric fields, tricky stuff, at.

:rolleyes:
 
Not sure but we are seeing at 67P as well.

Ions and electrons (negatively charged dust).

Let’s find out, ay?

Plasma, funky stuff

So, the very core of the model you claim to represent, a massive solar electric field, is something you have no clue about as to how it would work.
Nor apparently have given any thought as to how the physics would apply differently in space except where our spacecraft are.
Remember if positive and negative charges were to run in the same direction in an electric field ALL of our electronics would instantly fail.

And your answer is 'gee, plasma must by really funky, rather than, maybe there is no massive magical electric field'
 
Not sure but we are seeing at 67P as well.

Ions and electrons (negatively charged dust).

Let’s find out, ay?

Plasma, funky stuff
Let's see some details of your EC, shall we?

That would be pretty funky, wouldn't it ay? :p
 
So, the very core of the model you claim to represent, a massive solar electric field, is something you have no clue about as to how it would work.
Nor apparently have given any thought as to how the physics would apply differently in space except where our spacecraft are.
Remember if positive and negative charges were to run in the same direction in an electric field ALL of our electronics would instantly fail.

And your answer is 'gee, plasma must by really funky, rather than, maybe there is no massive magical electric field'

Well, they do “run” together don’t they. :boggled:

How do the mainstream do it?

Bit off topic by interesting alll the same.
 
Well at comet 67P we have both ions and negatively charged dust coming from the nucleus.

Wonder how? :rolleyes:


Maybe filimentation? Non homogeneous time varying electric field?

Be interesting to see the new papers that model electrons/negatively charged dust/negatively charged Hydrogen.

Most papers just concentrate on the h2o ions.
 
Well at comet 67P we have both ions and negatively charged dust coming from the nucleus.

Wonder how? :rolleyes:


Maybe filimentation? Non homogeneous time varying electric field?

Be interesting to see the new papers that model electrons/negatively charged dust/negatively charged Hydrogen.

Most papers just concentrate on the h2o ions.

Errrm, if the field is accelerating ions (positive) what is it doing to electrons and dust (negative)? Try to understand the paper. Stop talking nonsense. Give us a model, instead of waffle.
 
Errrm, if the field is accelerating ions (positive) what is it doing to electrons and dust (negative)? Try to understand the paper. Stop talking nonsense. Give us a model, instead of waffle.

Do we see ions coming from the nucleus, yes.

Do see negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets, yes.

How jonesdave116 in the mainstream sublimating Dirtysnowball??

Think you’ll find that’s impossible. :D

Sublimation is untenable.

I’m not absolutely sure how it works but that’s what we see.
 
I’d most probably look at the ES model of the Sun and postulate that a gas discharge tube would be a good starting point to go from.

See how we go ya reckon, jonesdave116, LS, jt?
 
Last edited:
Well, they do “run” together don’t they. :boggled:

How do the mainstream do it?

Bit off topic by interesting alll the same.

No, this is not off topic, it is you not being able to explain errors in the central core of your very 'model'

You (not the rest of the world) claim that the cometary tail is not outgassing via sublimation, but rather a massive electrical discharge in a 'solar electric field'

That means that, according to you (not the rest of the world), the sun is at the center of some electrical field that would have to comprise untold volts of potential difference with.... something you never actually define, but has to be spherical and around the solar system somewhere, given how cometary tails behave.
Now it does not matter if in this 'model' the sun is positive or negative for the next set of cracks to appear in it.

After all, we have measured the solar wind in great detail.
We have measured that the solar wind contains both positive and negatively charged particles.
We have seen that both these particles move AWAY from the sun in the same direction with their speeds seemingly only dictated by the mass of the particles, not their charges in deep space.
This is not some theory, it is just a measured fact.

Now the rest of the world, or mainstream as you like to call them, has also examined electrical fields in detail. We know an electrical field emanating from a central point to a spherical acceptor is uniform in density and degrades in strength only dictated by the square of the distance.
We also know that in all electrical fields ever measured positive and negative charges move in opposite directions. Again, not a theory, just a measured fact.

So IF your theory about electrical comets is to have any form of serious discussion, it is up to YOU, not the rest of the world, to explain how it is possible that a proposed uniform electrical field permeating the solar system is capable of not causing the ions of the solar winds to move in opposite directions, because until you get that sorted, there is absolutely no reason to assume there is a solar electric field, and thus the entire electric comet theory lacks a basis.

Mind you, should you work out the maths of that little problem and thus be able to replicate it on earth you'd be a billionare overnight, so get cracking.

But all you focusing on minute details about small potential fields around a comet are imo just distractions to keep people forgetting about the major fault of your very theory.
 
No, this is not off topic, it is you not being able to explain errors in the central core of your very 'model'

You (not the rest of the world) claim that the cometary tail is not outgassing via sublimation, but rather a massive electrical discharge in a 'solar electric field'

That means that, according to you (not the rest of the world), the sun is at the center of some electrical field that would have to comprise untold volts of potential difference with.... something you never actually define, but has to be spherical and around the solar system somewhere, given how cometary tails behave.
Now it does not matter if in this 'model' the sun is positive or negative for the next set of cracks to appear in it.

After all, we have measured the solar wind in great detail.
We have measured that the solar wind contains both positive and negatively charged particles.
We have seen that both these particles move AWAY from the sun in the same direction with their speeds seemingly only dictated by the mass of the particles, not their charges in deep space.
This is not some theory, it is just a measured fact.

Now the rest of the world, or mainstream as you like to call them, has also examined electrical fields in detail. We know an electrical field emanating from a central point to a spherical acceptor is uniform in density and degrades in strength only dictated by the square of the distance.
We also know that in all electrical fields ever measured positive and negative charges move in opposite directions. Again, not a theory, just a measured fact.

So IF your theory about electrical comets is to have any form of serious discussion, it is up to YOU, not the rest of the world, to explain how it is possible that a proposed uniform electrical field permeating the solar system is capable of not causing the ions of the solar winds to move in opposite directions, because until you get that sorted, there is absolutely no reason to assume there is a solar electric field, and thus the entire electric comet theory lacks a basis.

Mind you, should you work out the maths of that little problem and thus be able to replicate it on earth you'd be a billionare overnight, so get cracking.

But all you focusing on minute details about small potential fields around a comet are imo just distractions to keep people forgetting about the major fault of your very theory.


Well how far does the comet tail extend? Does it remain coherent over these distances? if so why?

Do you know much about double layers and Birkeland currents? or indeed what there is an ambipolar electric field at 67P?

Why is the diamagnetic cavity filamentary or "spikey"?

I'll leave the Electric Sun to the SAFIRE team.

I'm concentrating on the ELECTRIC COMET and cometary jets in particular.

Why is the dust negatively charged?

Why does the comet emit both ions and electrons(negatively charged dust)?

Some questions that are looking for answers?
 
Last edited:
Do we see ions coming from the nucleus, yes.

Do see negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets, yes.

How jonesdave116 in the mainstream sublimating Dirtysnowball??

Think you’ll find that’s impossible. :D

Sublimation is untenable.

I’m not absolutely sure how it works but that’s what we see.

What the hell relevance is that? The dust is obviously not being affected by this piddling electric field. And the dust is uniformly spread with some jets. How are you getting jets from a field that is retarding the movement of negatively charged particles? Stop talking nonsense.
 
Well how far does the comet tail extend? Does it remain coherent over these distances? if so why?

Do you know much about double layers and Birkeland currents? or indeed what there is an ambipolar electric field at 67P?

Why is the diamagnetic cavity filamentary or "spikey"?

I'll leave the Electric Sun to the SAFIRE team.

I'm concentrating on the ELECTRIC COMET and cometary jets in particular.

Why is the dust negatively charged?

Why does the comet emit both ions and electrons(negatively charged dust)?

Some questions that are looking for answers?

Another bunch of irrelevant fail. Your model is dead. Get over it, and stop trolling.
 
Do we see ions coming from the nucleus, yes.

Do see negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets, yes.

What charge do ions have? What charge do electrons have? What charge are you assuming for the dust? Clue; ions are being accelerated. Electrons are being trapped.
 
Well how far does the comet tail extend? Does it remain coherent over these distances? if so why?

Do you know much about double layers and Birkeland currents? or indeed what there is an ambipolar electric field at 67P?

Why is the diamagnetic cavity filamentary or "spikey"?

I'll leave the Electric Sun to the SAFIRE team.

I'm concentrating on the ELECTRIC COMET and cometary jets in particular.

Why is the dust negatively charged?

Why does the comet emit both ions and electrons(negatively charged dust)?

Some questions that are looking for answers?

There you go with minutiae again. Any of those questions are only relevant if you can prove the core of your model, namely the putative solar electric field.

Without that proof the entire EC model is stillborn.

So, again, what is the theoretical model that explains how the solar wind ions are unaffected by an electrical field that would permeate the solar system. Until you cam answer that the rest of your questions cannot be answered in an EC model.
Really sol88 get the basis solid before you focus on details
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom