The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really? Any papers to back up your claims? Other piffling trolling, again.

You are the one that is trolling. If you weren't, we would have a model to assess. What we do have (T & T's poster) is shown to fail.
And papers to back up what claims? This is supposed to be about the non-existent electric comet. And there are plenty of papers to show that it fails.
 
RC, jd, it's over.

Sol88 has freely, and openly, admitted that he has no EC.

Or rather, his EC is so vague, so empty that there's no point discussing it.

Here's what he's said about his EC:

Not sure but we are seeing at 67P as well.

Ions and electrons (negatively charged dust).

Let’s find out, ay?

Plasma, funky stuff
A comet is a rock discharging in the solar plasma. Funny enough.

<snip>
Plasma, baby.


Funky stuff. :thumbsup:
It’s a rock discharging in the solar electric field.
 
Let’s contrast the above highlighted Electric Comet model....


Let’s see what the standard mainstream model of comets is, shall we?

A comet is an icy, small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing. This produces a visible atmosphere or coma, and sometimes also a tail. These phenomena are due to the effects of solar radiation and the solar wind acting upon the nucleus of the comet.
wiki

How’s that any different than,

A comet is a rock seeking electrical equilibrium with its plasma environment?

Seems bit like a double standard to me.

I know there will be howls of that’s an old outdated model no longer used by the mainstream but that’s your model and is still used, such as the first random paper in my collection corroborates

Introduction Comets formed beyond the H2O frost line, where ices can condense [e.g., A’Hearn et al., 2012]. A variety of processes have affected comets during their long storage in the Oort cloud and scattered disk (e.g., irradiation by energetic particles, heating by passing stars, collisions). Similarly, repeated solar heating leads to evolution of short period comets during their many passages close to the Sun. However, because most of these processes affect only the outer layer of comets, the pristine nature of the bulk of the nucleus is preserved [Bockel´ee-Morvan et al., 2004; Mumma et al., 1993; Stern, 2003; Weissman and Stern, 1997].
Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet 103P/Hartley 2 Silvia Protopapaa, Jessica M. Sunshinea, Lori M. Feagaa, Michael S. P. Kelleya, Michael F. A’ Hearn, Tony L. Farnhama, Olivier Groussinb, Sebastien Bessea,c, Fr´ed´eric Merlind, Jian-Yang Li

Though it has been evolving from mostly ice to mostly rock now anywho.

(c) What are comets mad of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited.
Comer looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

:D

So get of your high horse jt.
 
Last edited:
Idiocy of mentioning the icy receding cliffs that do not exist in his electric comet

Dude I’ve got icy receding cliffs, great big ones! surely that beats a bit of fluffy snow here and there.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Idiocy of mentioning the icy receding cliffs that do not exist in his electric comet insanity!

Stupidity of expecting astronomers to be excited over basic physics that has been known for over a century. A cliff of sublimating ices will erode at its edge and recede. That is high school science level science, e.g. look at how a slab of CO2 ice sublimates.
 
Repeats a lie about his electric comet insanity which has no ambipolar electric field

On the other hand electric fields are required for an ELECTRIC COMET, just like the one you refuse to acknowledge in operation at comet67P.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Repeats a lie about his electric comet insanity which has no ambipolar electric fields.
 
His "idiotic, lying question" play - the icy cliffs receded

Thought icy cliffs sublimated, now it’s backwasting?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

His "idiotic, lying question" play - the icy cliffs receded and this paper calls that backwasting and "scarp retreat".
The nucleus of Comet 9P/Tempel 1: Shape and geology from two flybys Thomas, P. et al. (incl. A'Hearn, M. & Sunshine, J.)
The nucleus of comet Tempel 1 has been investigated at close range during two spacecraft missions separated by one comet orbit of the Sun, 5½ years. The combined imaging covers ∼70% of the surface of this object which has a mean radius of 2.83 ± 0.1 km. The surface can be divided into two terrain types: rough, pitted terrain and smoother regions of varying local topography. The rough surface has round depressions from resolution limits (∼10 m/pixel) up to ∼1 km across, spanning forms from crisp steep-walled pits, to subtle albedo rings, to topographic rings, with all ranges of morphologic gradation. Three gravitationally low regions of the comet have smoother terrain, parts of which appear to be deposits from minimally modified flows, with other parts likely to be heavily eroded portions of multiple layer piles. Changes observed between the two missions are primarily due to backwasting of scarps bounding one of these probable flow deposits. This style of erosion is also suggested by remnant mesa forms in other areas of smoother terrain. The two distinct terrains suggest either an evolutionary change in processes, topographically-controlled processes, or a continuing interaction of erosion and deposition.

Highlights

► Tempel 1 has two types of terrain, rough pitted and smoother, flow-like materials. ► The smooth materials are collected in low regions. ► Changes observed between the Deep Impact and Stardust-NExT encounters involve scarp retreat. ► Timescales for formation of the surface’s topography appear to be tens to perhaps hundreds of orbits.
 
Let’s contrast the above highlighted Electric Comet model....


Let’s see what the standard mainstream model of comets is, shall we?

wiki

How’s that any different than,

A comet is a rock seeking electrical equilibrium with its plasma environment?

Seems bit like a double standard to me.

I know there will be howls of that’s an old outdated model no longer used by the mainstream but that’s your model and is still used, such as the first random paper in my collection corroborates

Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet 103P/Hartley 2 Silvia Protopapaa, Jessica M. Sunshinea, Lori M. Feagaa, Michael S. P. Kelleya, Michael F. A’ Hearn, Tony L. Farnhama, Olivier Groussinb, Sebastien Bessea,c, Fr´ed´eric Merlind, Jian-Yang Li

Though it has been evolving from mostly ice to mostly rock now anywho.

Comer looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

:D

So get of your high horse jt.

You haven't got a model. The observations at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 killed it. Not to mention those at Halley over 30 years ago, and the other comet missions, including to 67P. You have absolutely nothing. No rock, no discharges, no way of explaining the gases in the coma, no way of explaining the ice seen at comets.
tl;dr? You don't have a model.
 
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable.

And in Thornhill's model there is no dust on the surface! Fail.
 
Let’s contrast the above highlighted Electric Comet model....
Let's not.

This thread is about "The Electric Comet Theory".

<snip>

A comet is a rock seeking electrical equilibrium with its plasma environment?

Seems bit like a double standard to me.

<snip>
The "double standard" is entirely yours, Sol88.

You've changed what you mean by your EC, many, many times. Unless and until you can present a coherent, consistent, quantitative model, there's nothing to discuss.

Period.

So get of your high horse jt.
Ah the old "mainstream MUST BE WRONG! so my EC MUST BE RITE!!!"

Sorry, not interested in that sort of trolling.
 
Lies about jonesdave116 post on Whipple’s original model from the 1950's

You said Whipple’s model dead and buried.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Lies about jonesdave116 post on Whipple’s original model from the 1950's.
Another strawman. I keep telling you, nobody is still following the 1950's model. You are arguing with your own strawman, nobody else. Pointless. Stop listening to the idiot Thornhill, and get a mind of your own.
jonesdave116 stated the obvious fact that science progresses and so models change. A 70 year old model has been updated to include new evidence ands so is not the original model. Sol88 being unable to understand this real world fact is not a surprise because he has fallen for the unchanging, deleted Thunderbolts cult dogma abut the universe (not only his electric comet insanity).

The modern mainstream model is not Whipple’s original model from the 1950's because of all of the Rosetta mission papers that Sol88 has cited :jaw-dropp! Plus the thousands of other cometary paper published since the 1950's.

The modern mainstream model shares features with Whipple’s original model where the evidence for those features has become stronger, e.g. comets are made of ices and non-terrestrial dust because we have samples of the dust :eye-poppi (Stardust mission) and saw ices and dust being blown off Tempel 1 (Deep Impact mission).
 
A comet is a rock seeking electrical equilibrium with its plasma environment?

Idiotic statement. Asteroids are more charged up than comets. What are they doing? Ridiculous, unscientific nonsense.
 
Back to his delusions about the ambipolar electric field, charged dust and lies

Which brings us back to the ambipolar electric field and the fact the dust is charged.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Back to his delusions about the ambipolar electric field, charged dust and lies about the comet model.
The ambipolar electric fields are small scale fields inside a comet coma.
Dust being charged has been textbook, mainstream cometary physics for decades.
The Whipple’s model is not "simplistic" or "outdated and superseded". The modern comet model still works with comets made of ices and dust.

A "Sublimation can not remove the size of the dust observed at Rosetta’s orbit" lie.
One paper claimed that small dust particles would not be removed by gas drag and proposed other mechanisms. Rosetta observed dust sizes ranged from "nano-grains " to fluffy aggregates.

A "overestimation of water production (Haser Model)" lie when the rate of gas production from sublimation is an input to the Haser Model as pointed out many times.

Usual stupidity that Michael A'Hearn's (that "principle investigator") opinion that dust dominates in comets support Sol88's electric comet insanity that comets are rock.

Usual insane insult that the deceased Michael A'Hearn thought that comets are actual rock as in Sol88's electric comet insanity. Michael A'Hearn could read and knew the physical evidence that comets are made of ices and dust (density, Deep Impact, dust samples, observed ices,etc.). Michael A'Hearn was not insanely ignorant or deluded enough to believe that comets are actual rock.
 
Last edited:
Usual lies about irrelevant, mainstream ices and dust comet papers

POLYOXYMETHYLENE AS PARENT MOLECULE FOR THE FORMALDEHYDE EXTENDED SOURCE IN COMET HALLEY
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Usual lies about irrelevant, mainstream ices and dust comet papers.
Polyoxymethylene as Parent Molecule for the Formaldehyde Extended Source in Comet Halley
An unexplained observation before this paper was formaldehyde in comet coma. It was not seen that a comet nucleus contained formaldehyde and thus the observed formaldehyde was not from sublimating formaldehyde. The proposed mechanism even before this paper was degrading of polyoxymethylene in dust particles in the coma. This paper is experimental evidence that supports that mechanism :eye-poppi.

Sol88's repeats the idiocy that "Unexpected and significant findings" magically support his electric comet insanity when deluded fantasies cannot explain anything and have no significance.

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view is actual science not the deluded dogma of the Thunderbolts cult.
 
Last edited:
A delusion that actual electrochemistry on comets is not electrochemistry

There is electrochemical “stuff” going on that has nothing to do with the sublimation of ice/s and everything to do with a voltage potential and the associated electric fields
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A delusion that actual electrochemistry on comets is not electrochemistry :jaw-dropp! Chemistry of any kind needs compounds to act upon. For comets that means sublimation of ices for H2O and CO2 and to eject dust particles into the coma where electrochemistry can happen.
Polyoxymethylene as Parent Molecule for the Formaldehyde Extended Source in Comet Halley
From new experimental data, we are now able to consider multiphase chemistry: POM in the solid state on cometary grains slowly degrades by solar photons and heat and produces H2CO in the gaseous phase. This is a new approach to cometary organic chemistry. We show, by considering simple assumptions about the cometary environment, that the hypothesis of POM on grains leads to a very good agreement with Giotto observations if we assume that the cometary grains are ~7% POM by mass at a temperature of 330 K.


That formaldehyde is something Sol88's electric comet insanity cannot explain.

Usual electric comet insanity that comets are rocks is extended with his another lying "consolidated compact dust" delusion. Sol88 knows that comets have high porosity (up to 70%!) and contain ices. Sol88 has been writing "comets are mostly vacuum" posts for the last few weeks :jaw-dropp!

Lies about jonesdave116's beliefs. Knowledgeable people such as jonesdave116, myself, other posters here and most educated people in the world (obviously excluding the deluded Thunderbolts cult) believe in current, evidence supported science. The physical evidence is that comets are made of ices and dust (density, Deep Impact, dust samples, observed ices, etc.).
 
Idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions yet again

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view



Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Idiocy of citing irrelevant to his electric comet insanity, already discussed mainstream ices and dust papers again and again.

Idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions yet again (ambipolar electric field).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom