The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
But you did read Comet Dust?

In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear.
:D

Regardless if you say or not ambipolar electric fields are causing the jets on comets.
Now you are doing it again. Yes, the dominant mechanism is still unclear, but that does not support EC at all! You do not have a theory that becomes valid by default if other theories fail.

This is the main problem with your posts here: as long as you have no numbers, you do not have a valid theory. You could have a good idea, if it was not for the fact that the only numbers that can be calculated actually show that the idea is not good at all.
 
What? That electric fields support the sublimation model instead?

You should know better by now. It is not a question of either/or. Electric fields can exist, and be too weak to invalidate one theory, and at the same time too weak to support another theory. In other words, the existence of electric fields may well be irrelevant.
 
Regardless if you say or not ambipolar electric fields are causing the jets on comets.

So why are there no jets at asteroids? Why is no ambipolar field seen at Halley, which was considerably more active than 67P?
 
Thanks.

So your EC is DOA?

As no comets have been found inside the Sun (though you may know of some), and as “solar plasma” and “solar electric field” clearly refer to what’s within the Sun. :p

:confused:
Please explain.

I'll take a risk and assume the Sol is talking about the solar wind convective electric field, and the solar wind plasma. The ambipolar field suggested by Vigren & Eriksson is assumed to have a potential of 0.03 mV/ m. It is hard to find figures for the convective field, but I did find this paper;

Solar wind dynamic pressure and electric field as the main factors controlling Saturn’s aurorae
Crary, F. J. et al.
http://www.igpp.ucla.edu/public/mkivelso/refs/PUBLICATIONS/craryAurorSatnature03333.pdf

Figure 3 in that paper shows solar wind electric field measurements of a similar magnitude. So, there are some figures we can use. If we had a model in which to use them!
 
Following on from above, we can also consider the simulations in this paper;

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids
Zimmerman, M. I. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20150011018.pdf

Figure 2 from that paper gives the field strength for a small, near-Earth asteroid. At least a couple of oom higher than the solar wind and ambipolar fields. This type of field can only form at a comet when it is at its least active. It will regularly form around asteroids, given they have no protection from the solar wind.
 
I'll take a risk and assume the Sol is talking about the solar wind convective electric field, and the solar wind plasma. The ambipolar field suggested by Vigren & Eriksson is assumed to have a potential of 0.03 mV/ m. It is hard to find figures for the convective field, but I did find this paper;

Solar wind dynamic pressure and electric field as the main factors controlling Saturn’s aurorae
Crary, F. J. et al.
http://www.igpp.ucla.edu/public/mkivelso/refs/PUBLICATIONS/craryAurorSatnature03333.pdf

Figure 3 in that paper shows solar wind electric field measurements of a similar magnitude. So, there are some figures we can use. If we had a model in which to use them!
I think you give Sol88 too much credit.

My own take on his long history of posts here is that he has only a very tenuous understanding of anything electric. One reason why I think this can be found in the posts of his I quoted, and his response ... though I admit that one could also explain this as trolling.
 
I think you give Sol88 too much credit.

My own take on his long history of posts here is that he has only a very tenuous understanding of anything electric. One reason why I think this can be found in the posts of his I quoted, and his response ... though I admit that one could also explain this as trolling.

You are most likely correct. However, just for completeness, I want to compare the ambipolar field at a comet to what we can expect for an asteroid. Which don't have clouds of dust around them!
So, from Fig. 6 of the Zimmerman paper I linked above, we see the potential created in his simulation. Figures as high as -80 V are seen.
And in one of Sol's favourite papers, Nordheim models comet 67P at 3.5 AU, when the solar wind has access to the nucleus, and finds strong localised fields of surface potential of hundreds of V.
Perhaps Sol now understands why his questions about a piffling ambipolar field are irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
You should know better by now. It is not a question of either/or. Electric fields can exist, and be too weak to invalidate one theory, and at the same time too weak to support another theory. In other words, the existence of electric fields may well be irrelevant.

But they are not irrelevant and jd116 is kicking up a stink on no viable mechanism.

Electric fields should not even exist in space plasmas, according to some.

Because they do, it’s a game changer.

Now, models will have take into account plasma circuits, charge seperation, electric fields... you know garden variety plasma physics and electrical engineering.

Welcome to the Electric Comet and asteroids and moons and planets and stars and galaxies.

We are all connected via the electric force
 
It’s a rock discharging in the solar electric field.

Theory is a VERY loose description of this. Unsupported assertion would be closer.

But lets work with it.

Three simple questions for your theory to answer.

1: What does it discharge TO? After all, that is how electricity works.

2: Why do we not see an equal and opposite tail of the other charge?

3: Since there is a claimed solar electric field, why does the solar wind contain both positive and negative ions, both moving outward at equal speeds? By your theory that would be impossible.
 
But they are not irrelevant and jd116 is kicking up a stink on no viable mechanism.
My point was that you need to show that the field strengths are sufficient to to support your EC. Just claiming that they are relevant is not enough. After all, nobody doubts that electric fields do not exist, or that electric fields are not important. If they are too weak - as measured - they are irrelevant for comets.



We are all connected via the electric force

Yes, of course, but that is another irrelevant statement.
 
Theory is a VERY loose description of this. Unsupported assertion would be closer.

But lets work with it.

Three simple questions for your theory to answer.

1: What does it discharge TO? After all, that is how electricity works.

2: Why do we not see an equal and opposite tail of the other charge?

3: Since there is a claimed solar electric field, why does the solar wind contain both positive and negative ions, both moving outward at equal speeds? By your theory that would be impossible.

Let’s!

What level of plasma understanding are you?

Complete novice?

Fairly competent?

Advanced understanding?

Just so I know how proceed!
 
Let’s!

What level of plasma understanding are you?

Complete novice?

Fairly competent?

Advanced understanding?

Just so I know how proceed!

That doesn't actually answer any of my questions. Let us assume I can understand anything you posit and work from there.

So, how does the EC electric field allow both positive and negative charges to run in the same direction as we observe in the solar wind?
 
But they are not irrelevant and jd116 is kicking up a stink on no viable mechanism.

Electric fields should not even exist in space plasmas, according to some.

Because they do, it’s a game changer.

They are irrelevant to your failed model. And the solar wind HAS to carry an electric field. It is inevitable. And every time something happens that causes quasi-neutrality to be violated, then an electric field MUST form. You simply don't know what you are talking about.
 
Now, models will have take into account plasma circuits, charge seperation, electric fields... you know garden variety plasma physics and electrical engineering.

Welcome to the Electric Comet and asteroids and moons and planets and stars and galaxies.

We are all connected via the electric force

Total rubbish, and nothing to do with the failure of your woo. You need rock and discharges. You have neither. Among many other failures.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom