The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it is not. It is a misleading question, because it gives the impression that it will support EC.

What? That electric fields support the sublimation model instead?

Yeah, whatever!

But what it does do is reinforce the fact that
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable.


Which is why I started this thread 10 years ago.


But, hey mainstream scientists are coming round, even if armchair crusaders don’t.
 
I have no idea. How DO you measure something that at the same time has the power to create a cometary tail yet no impact on any of our spacecraft and eludes the finest sensors humanity has put into orbit ever?

I'd love to see the theory that explains how the EC electricity can be so specific that it can only be detected by those that believe in it.
But as others have mentioned, you seem unable to provide any actual coherent theory, let alone an actual prediction.

Lets not forget all predictions from the original EU theory with regards to comets have failed.
So I too ask you, can you provide your actual theory, mathematical model explaining results, predictions and improvements on current theory?

It’s a rock discharging in the solar electric field.
 
What? That electric fields support the sublimation model instead?

Yeah, whatever!

But what it does do is reinforce the fact that


Which is why I started this thread 10 years ago.


But, hey mainstream scientists are coming round, even if armchair crusaders don’t.

Complete nonsense. The largest fields will be at asteroids, and low activity comets. What is happening there? You are just making crap up. Your model failed. Totally. Get over it.
 
Which is why I started this thread 10 years ago.


But, hey mainstream scientists are coming round, even if armchair crusaders don’t.

No they aren't. None of them support the idiotic EC woo.
 
True, it’s just our understanding of comets being mostly ice is evolving toward mostly rock.



:rolleyes:


So, yeah, whatever jonesdave116. :dig:

You can hang the shovel up at any stage. :D

No rock, and the rest is a strawman to hide your failure. It has been proposed for a long time that dust dominates the mass, as I have shown you with links to papers. So quit the lying. Your failed model requires solid rock and no ice. Thousands of tonnes of ice were excavated at Tempel 1, and left a crater far too large to have been made in rock. Therefore your model fails.
 
Complete nonsense. The largest fields will be at asteroids, and low activity comets. What is happening there? You are just making crap up. Your model failed. Totally. Get over it.

The relationship of the uppermost (optically visible) surface to icy material just below the surface and the means of releasing the dust component remains a subject of speculation.

You state it as fact, jonesdave116. :D

Sublimation, :blush:

Simpleton science at its very best.
 
What are you on about? The ambipolar field is of the wrong sign for your idiotic proposal. You fail. Again.

It’s filimentry, dear Watson. :D

Oh, and unlike the totally untenable sublimation model. The electric field can reverse.

Hard to see sublimation doing any of that.

Does not stop you believing in it though, does it now jd116?
 
Last edited:
What are you on about? The ambipolar field is of the wrong sign for your idiotic proposal. You fail. Again.

So that’s a yes?

You are starting to believe in a non negligible ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?
 
So that’s a yes?

You are starting to believe in a non negligible ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

I have already answered that question. And it is irrelevant because your woo has failed, and an ambipolar field will do nothing to save it. Asteroids, yes? Lack of a field at Halley, yes? Field is the wrong sign, yes? Field isn't reaching the nucleus, yes? Failure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom