The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Meanwhile however, some of the above-mentioned open questions should be solved by further studies from the enormous amount of data that the Rosetta mission has provided.
Comet Dust

Yes they will and electrostatic disruption of hydrated minerals, including clays and carbonates will be found to be both the source of the observed H2O and the very fine dust.

The ambipolar electric field will be found to accelerate this dust into the coma.

Let’s just wait till the mainstream catch up, as you seem to struggle with independent thinking.
 
Irrelevant. There was none at Halley, and there are far stronger fields at asteroids. Fail.

Sorry, I’ve already asked you jonesdave116 and you refuse to answer. :D

Unless you’d like to wipe the egg of your face.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p?
 
Yes they will and electrostatic disruption of hydrated minerals, including clays and carbonates will be found to be both the source of the observed H2O and the very fine dust.

Nope, you need high temperatures to release OH and H2O from minerals. The minerals are not the dust that is being possibly electrostatically disrupted. That would be the fluffy aggregates. Fail.
 
.

There is no rock of any description. Therefore your model fails.

True, it’s just our understanding of comets being mostly ice is evolving toward mostly rock.

c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

:rolleyes:


So, yeah, whatever jonesdave116. :dig:

You can hang the shovel up at any stage. :D
 
Sorry, I’ve already asked you jonesdave116 and you refuse to answer. :D

Unless you’d like to wipe the egg of your face.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p?

I have told you already. Possibly. Probably. However, it is a total irrelevance to the failure of your idiotic woo.
 
Nope, you need high temperatures to release OH and H2O from minerals. The minerals are not the dust that is being possibly electrostatically disrupted. That would be the fluffy aggregates. Fail.


No, you need electric fields. :D

You know the ones you refuse to acknowledge. :rolleyes:
 
I have told you already. Possibly. Probably. However, it is a total irrelevance to the failure of your idiotic woo.

I asked, yes or no to ambipolar electric fields at comet 67P.

Possibly is wiggle room for you. :thumbsup:

Yes or no to electric fields at comet 67P?
 
True, it’s just our understanding of comets being mostly ice is evolving toward mostly rock.

No, it isn't. It has been known for some time that dust dominates the mass. There is no rock. Never seen at a comet. We now have better constraints. Who cares whether it is mostly ice or mostly dust? There is a **** tonne of ice. Therefore your model fails. Again.
 
I asked, yes or no to ambipolar electric fields at comet 67P.

Possibly is wiggle room for you. :thumbsup:

Yes or no to electric fields at comet 67P?

Couldn't care less. None seen at Halley. Ambipolar fields are at asteroids that contain dust and hydrated minerals. Your question is irrelevant. Your models has failed, ambipolar field or not.
 
Last edited:
No, you need electric fields.

You know the ones you refuse to acknowledge

Which is a lie. You need high temperatures. Prove otherwise, before I show that you are talking crap. Again.

EDIT:
And your field is not reaching the nucleus. It is at asteroids though. Some of which contain hydrated minerals. And dust.
 
Last edited:
I am getting sick of addressing this ambipolar field nonsense. I have already pointed out that the envisaged field is of the wrong sign to accelerate dust, if it is negatively charged. It is not reaching the nucleus, in any case. Its sign may occasionally change. It is likely very weak. Vigren and Eriksson guessed at 0.03 mV/ m. You see far higher fields in asteroid modelling. And, indeed, inactive comets. What does inactive mean? Sod all dust. It is a busted flush.
 
Last edited:
I would like to echo Jean Tate's comments; can we please have a description of the Electric Comet model as it currently stands, please? I am not even going as far as JT, and asking for a quantified model, at this stage. I want a recognition that the T & T model has failed. Elliptical asteroids? Not happening. Solar wind creating water vapour? Demonstrably wrong (not to mention impossible). Rock? 530 kg/m3. Thousands of tonnes of ice blasted out of Tempel 1. Plenty of various gas species. Etc.

So, can we please have a description of the new EC model that replaces the failed one? Quantitative, or otherwise.
 
I would like to echo Jean Tate's comments; can we please have a description of the Electric Comet model as it currently stands, please? I am not even going as far as JT, and asking for a quantified model, at this stage. I want a recognition that the T & T model has failed. Elliptical asteroids? Not happening. Solar wind creating water vapour? Demonstrably wrong (not to mention impossible). Rock? 530 kg/m3. Thousands of tonnes of ice blasted out of Tempel 1. Plenty of various gas species. Etc.

So, can we please have a description of the new EC model that replaces the failed one? Quantitative, or otherwise.

Same as it’s always been, comets are mostly rock discharging in the solar plasma.

:thumbsup:

What are they are not is sublimating mostly icy Dirtysnowballs.

As this new paper states, among others.
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable.

This was also found, awhiles back by Skorov,
Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
 
Last edited:
Same as it’s always been, comets are mostly rock discharging in the solar plasma.

<snip >
It’s good to see you so clearly breaking with the Thornhill EC (in Thornhill, comets are entirely rock, for example).

However, it’s sad to see that the Sol88 EC is still, after all these years, little more than hand waving. Where are the numbers?
 
It’s good to see you so clearly breaking with the Thornhill EC (in Thornhill, comets are entirely rock, for example).

However, it’s sad to see that the Sol88 EC is still, after all these years, little more than hand waving. Where are the numbers?

No numbers needed, old mate.

Just the juxtaposition of the sublimation model and the electric model, such as
In the accepted model, a comet is an aggregate of ice and dust evaporating in the heat of the Sun. In the electric model, a comet could be a solid rock discharging as it plunges more deeply into the Sun's electric field. A proper comparison of the two models, however, will require attention to details, accentuating the contrast between two radically different perspectives. Systematic comparison can only highlight the contrasts in predictive ability—the test of a good theory.



More than happy to let the mainstream think they’re discovering groundbreaking new science.

The numbers may or may not come but for now, I’m going to concentrate on my all time favourite, cometary “jets”.

One wonders if the charged dust is being both electrostaticly removed from the consolidated surface and accelerated in an electric field?

;)


Do you think this is a possibility, jean tate?
 
Last edited:
Do YOU believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P? :rolleyes:



It rethorical any who but I seem to be running into a lot of resistance from ALL the other posters here on this very basic question.
Of course people are reluctant to answer that question because even if the answer is irrelevant, you will regard a "yes" as a victory, which it is clearly only if it supports your model of comets.



Yes, there electric fields in operation at comet, jt?



Or



No electric fields at comets, jt?
This is a false dichotomy. Nobody denies that there are electrical fields at work at comets. The question is if they are strong enough to support your theory. As far as I can gather, they are not, and you will not be able to show otherwise without a quantitative model, which you cannot present, because nobody has made one - and I think it is because it is impossible.



No trolling just, what I though, was a straight forward question.

No, it is not. It is a misleading question, because it gives the impression that it will support EC.
 
Ok fair enough.


But you did read Comet Dust?

In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear.

:D

Regardless if you say or not ambipolar electric fields are causing the jets on comets.

But I cannot discusses any further because every time I brought up Double Layers, Birkeland currents and charge separation it’s met with a barrage of sublimation rules therefore none of the electric comets is real.
 
Last edited:
How do you measure the total power of the Birkeland currents flowing up and down the tail of comets? (You call the field aligned currents)

These currents will be filamentry in nature like stock standard plasma physics dictates.

Catch up sport. :rolleyes:

I have no idea. How DO you measure something that at the same time has the power to create a cometary tail yet no impact on any of our spacecraft and eludes the finest sensors humanity has put into orbit ever?

I'd love to see the theory that explains how the EC electricity can be so specific that it can only be detected by those that believe in it.
But as others have mentioned, you seem unable to provide any actual coherent theory, let alone an actual prediction.

Lets not forget all predictions from the original EU theory with regards to comets have failed.
So I too ask you, can you provide your actual theory, mathematical model explaining results, predictions and improvements on current theory?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom