The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
JeanTate said:
think I have never seen a quantitative EC model of 67P.

Can you post such a model, for all readers to review?

Thank you in advance.
<snip>

Sol88 said:
Try another thunderbolts video, couldn’t explain any clearer.

Pick it to pieces, if you can and I’ll show you the new mainstream papers to <snip>back Dr Anariba up.

Thanks. I'll take a look later. And write a post on what I find.
OK, I viewed the whole 8+ minutes of it.

Sadly, no mention whatsoever of any EC model/explanation/description, let alone one for 67P. And certainly nothing quantitative.

Did you not understand what's in that video, Sol88? Or are you simply trolling? :p
 
Strawman, dear Lukraak_Sisser, strawman

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Everyone here seems a little hesitant to answer this very simple question.

One wonders why?

Wait, how is it a strawman?
Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the fact that space is full of massive electrical charges that cause massive lightning blasts which would be the tails shown by comets?

And metal spacecraft moving trough such fields/currents would be massively affected. Yet none ever have been.
Why does it then matter if there are some possible minor, local effects on a comet.
No-one has ever said electrical effects cannot happen in space, and when small dust particles get moved about by sublimating ice, I have no problem imagining that generating a bit of static electricity.

But that is not the issue here. Your model thrives on the massive currents that should power everything (while being utterly undetectable on earth of course). Yet they are not seen. So your model is failing at it's most basic prediction.
 
Wait, how is it a strawman?
Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the fact that space is full of massive electrical charges that cause massive lightning blasts which would be the tails shown by comets?

And metal spacecraft moving trough such fields/currents would be massively affected. Yet none ever have been.
Why does it then matter if there are some possible minor, local effects on a comet.
No-one has ever said electrical effects cannot happen in space, and when small dust particles get moved about by sublimating ice, I have no problem imagining that generating a bit of static electricity.

But that is not the issue here. Your model thrives on the massive currents that should power everything (while being utterly undetectable on earth of course). Yet they are not seen. So your model is failing at it's most basic prediction.
I think you may have some misunderstanding here.

What you posted looks like it is about the (or a) Electric Universe idea, or possibly a Thornhill/Talbott Electric Comet one.

However, Sol88 abandoned that quite some time ago. :eek: :D

Instead, his recent EC idea is something like “comets have electrical activity” (that’s pretty much the only “E” part), that’s all.

And more recently still, Sol88’s EC idea is even simpler: “mainstream is WRONG, therefore EC is RIGHT!”. The great beauty about this most recent incarnation is that Sol88 never has to say anything concrete about the EC at all. :jaw-dropp

This is one reason, IMHO, why jd’s posts are mostly pointless (sorry jd).
 
I think you may have some misunderstanding here.

What you posted looks like it is about the (or a) Electric Universe idea, or possibly a Thornhill/Talbott Electric Comet one.

However, Sol88 abandoned that quite some time ago. :eek: :D

Instead, his recent EC idea is something like “comets have electrical activity” (that’s pretty much the only “E” part), that’s all.

And more recently still, Sol88’s EC idea is even simpler: “mainstream is WRONG, therefore EC is RIGHT!”. The great beauty about this most recent incarnation is that Sol88 never has to say anything concrete about the EC at all. :jaw-dropp

This is one reason, IMHO, why jd’s posts are mostly pointless (sorry jd).

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p, Jean tate?
 
Wait, how is it a strawman?
Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the fact that space is full of massive electrical charges that cause massive lightning blasts which would be the tails shown by comets?

And metal spacecraft moving trough such fields/currents would be massively affected. Yet none ever have been.
Why does it then matter if there are some possible minor, local effects on a comet.
No-one has ever said electrical effects cannot happen in space, and when small dust particles get moved about by sublimating ice, I have no problem imagining that generating a bit of static electricity.

But that is not the issue here. Your model thrives on the massive currents that should power everything (while being utterly undetectable on earth of course). Yet they are not seen. So your model is failing at it's most basic prediction.

How do you measure the total power of the Birkeland currents flowing up and down the tail of comets? (You call the field aligned currents)

These currents will be filamentry in nature like stock standard plasma physics dictates.

Catch up sport. :rolleyes:
 
I think you may have some misunderstanding here.

What you posted looks like it is about the (or a) Electric Universe idea, or possibly a Thornhill/Talbott Electric Comet one.

However, Sol88 abandoned that quite some time ago. :eek: :D

Instead, his recent EC idea is something like “comets have electrical activity” (that’s pretty much the only “E” part), that’s all.

And more recently still, Sol88’s EC idea is even simpler: “mainstream is WRONG, therefore EC is RIGHT!”. The great beauty about this most recent incarnation is that Sol88 never has to say anything concrete about the EC at all. :jaw-dropp

This is one reason, IMHO, why jd’s posts are mostly pointless (sorry jd).


No , I(and Thornhill’s model) has not deviated from the basic premise that comets are ROCK discharging in the solar plasma.

Pretty basic and being found to be more accurate than the standard sublimation model.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, LS?

Do you believe the dust is charged and is being accelerated of the nucleus by this ambipolar electric field at 67P?

All pretty basic stuff were sublimation is not required or observed, it’s only inferred because when you only have a hammer...:rolleyes:

Have you had a chance to go over Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae by Erik Vigren‹ and Anders I. Eriksson?

We should also emphasize that our model is based on a stationary situation with an electric field profile that remains constant in time. Speculatively, the field profile may rather vary periodically. A decaying potential profile will tend to trap electrons with insufficient energy to overcome the potential barrier. Such electrons will subsequently cool further via collisions closer to the nucleus. Unless effectively removed via dissociative recombination (a process which is more efficient the slower the electrons are), the cold electron population grows and continues to do so up to a point where the resulting reduced electron temperature leads to a diminishing (or even reversal) of the ambipolar electric field that then can allow the cold electrons to escape outwards. This in turn leads back to an outward-pointing ambipolar electric field. Such a scenario would be qualitatively consistent with the time-varying cavity boundary observed on Rosetta (Goetz et al. 2016).

Such a scenario is unrealistic (if not dissociative recombination is very efficient) as it would cause a build-up of cold electrons incapable of escaping the potential barrier associated with the ambipolar field. This leads us to speculate on a periodically varying potential structure.

This, as far as I know, is absolutely brand spanking new for the mainstream sublimation model. The paper however does not mentioned n the negatively charged dust.

This paper does however mention the dust being both charged and dehydrated.

Cometary Dust Anny-Chantal Levasseur-Regourd1·Jessica Agarwal2·Hervé Cottin3· Cécile Engrand4 ·George Flynn5·Marco Fulle6·Tamas Gombosi7· Yves Langevin8·Jérémie Lasue9·Thurid Mannel10,11·Sihane Merouane2· Olivier Poch12 · Nicolas Thomas13·Andrew Westphal

4.5 Charged Dust The amount of electric charge collected by fluffy and sub-µ m dust particles affects their motion in comae and tails and their lifetime against electrostatic fragmentation. The Rosetta mission provided the first direct evidence for the presence of electrically charged dust particles in a coma. These observations were possible as a result of the interaction between dust and the spacecraft electric potential, which was oscillating around −10 V (Nilsson et al. 2015) within 100 km from the 67P/C-G nucleus.

All pretty brand spanking new for the sublimation model.

If you’d like some more information on Birkeland currents in relation to comets, you maybe able to ask tusenfem. Though you may have to call them force free field aligned currents.
 
Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p, Jean tate?

It is irrelevant. You need rock and discharges. Neither are in evidence. You need the solar wind to reach the nucleus to make OH, which we can then mistake for H2O. It isn't happening. So your model failed. If there is a new one, tell us what it is. In detail.
 
No , I(and Thornhill’s model) has not deviated from the basic premise that comets are ROCK discharging in the solar plasma.

Pretty basic and being found to be more accurate than the standard sublimation model.

No, it has completely failed. No rock, no discharges.
 
Already answered this, Sol88: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12550985&postcount=2057

Am not going to repeat myself. And in future will ignore your trolling.

Sorry, jt. Could not find a yes/no answer in that post.

Well try again, if you are capable of understanding make mainstream peer reviewed papers.

Do YOU believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P? :rolleyes:

It rethorical any who but I seem to be running into a lot of resistance from ALL the other posters here on this very basic question.

And I’m not sure if we can discuss the fum part of cometary jets without you first acknowledging that electric fields are a part of the electric comets model.

They are required by the electric comet they are not required by the sublimation model.

They have however been confirmed by the Rosetta mission.

Yes, there electric fields in operation at comet, jt?

Or

No electric fields at comets, jt?

No trolling just, what I though, was a straight forward question.
 
It is irrelevant. You need rock and discharges. Neither are in evidence. You need the solar wind to reach the nucleus to make OH, which we can then mistake for H2O. It isn't happening. So your model failed. If there is a new one, tell us what it is. In detail.


Yeah, whatever :blush:

Again, jd116, the solar wind does not and is not required to reach the nucleus surface. An electric field and voltage potential MUST be present though.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?
 
No , I(and Thornhill’s model) has not deviated from the basic premise that comets are ROCK discharging in the solar plasma.

<snip>
True.

Except for the pesky detail that Thornhill includes, also as a basic premise, a radial electric field centered on the Sun. Your version of the EC omits that.

Also, as a basic premise, that the radial electric field creates EDM discharges. Your version of the EC omits that too.

Finally, Thornhill assumes bulk rock, with ~zero porosity, not your magical ROCK.
 
It rethorical any who but I seem to be running into a lot of resistance from ALL the other posters here on this very basic question.

Due to it being a complete irrelevance. Please explain why it isn't. It wasn't seen at Halley, and that was outgassing like a good 'un.
 
Again, jd116, the solar wind does not and is not required to reach the nucleus. An electric field MUST be present though.

That is a direct contradiction of the only written work on the Electric Comet, by Thornhill and Talbott. He says the solar wind H+ combines with invisible O-. He says nothing about an electric field. And no discharges are seen. And no EDM (lol). So, it has failed.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, jt. Could not find a yes/no answer in that post.

Well try again, if you are capable of understanding make mainstream peer reviewed papers.

Do YOU believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P? :rolleyes:

It rethorical any who but I seem to be running into a lot of resistance from ALL the other posters here on this very basic question.

And I’m not sure if we can discuss the fum part of cometary jets without you first acknowledging that electric fields are a part of the electric comets model.

They are required by the electric comet they are not required by the sublimation model.

They have however been confirmed by the Rosetta mission.

Yes, there electric fields in operation at comet, jt?

Or

No electric fields at comets, jt?

No trolling just, what I though, was a straight forward question.
Sol88, for the last time: this thread is about the Electric Comet Theory (or model). I’m very willing to discuss that.

When can I expect you to post a quantitative EC theory, here? One that we can discuss?
 
True.

Except for the pesky detail that Thornhill includes, also as a basic premise, a radial electric field centered on the Sun. Your version of the EC omits that.

Also, as a basic premise, that the radial electric field creates EDM discharges. Your version of the EC omits that too.

Finally, Thornhill assumes bulk rock, with ~zero porosity, not your magical ROCK.

Not my majik rock, A’Hearns majik rock, again.

This is all pretty new to tha mainstream and is only just entering their field of view
However, even in the case of the electrostatic mechanism, some circumstantial evidence can be found. For example, 67P/C-G shows ponded deposits (Thomas et al. 2015b) that are also seen on asteroids and have been attributed to the effect of electrostatic forces (Hartzell et al. 2013).

Further and to reinforce my long held belief
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable.

Comet Dust

:D

I do hope you are smart enough to see where this is going?

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, Jean tate?

If you do not believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p, this m not sure we can discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model.
 
Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, Jean tate?

Irrelevant. There was none at Halley, and there are far stronger fields at asteroids. Fail.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom