The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think I have never seen a quantitative EC model of 67P.

Can you post such a model, for all readers to review?

Thank you in advance.


Like a peer reviewed mainstream paper?

Good one, :rolleyes:

Try another thunderbolts video, couldn’t explain any clearer.

Pick it to pieces, if you can and I’ll show you the new mainstream papers to back Dr Anariba up.
 
Last edited:
Other than a very old Electric Comet document, and your own posts here, Sol88, I do not recall reading EC-based, quantitative estimates of the electric field strengths, directions, and polariziations at, and associated with, comets.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

I do not recall reading any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the degree to which dust is charged, at the surface of comet nuclei. Nor any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the extent to which ions and electrons are decoupled from the neutrals there.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

Ditto, though the mainstream are cottoning on, slowly. :D

Are you able to think independently, Jean tate?

Simple yes no answer will help this discussion no end. Do you believe there are ambipolar electric fields, among others, in operation at comets and that the dust is charged?

Yes or No?
 
Last edited:
Other than a very old Electric Comet document, and your own posts here, Sol88, I do not recall reading EC-based, quantitative estimates of the electric field strengths, directions, and polariziations at, and associated with, comets.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

I do not recall reading any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the degree to which dust is charged, at the surface of comet nuclei. Nor any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the extent to which ions and electrons are decoupled from the neutrals there.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

Another direct question that will help the discussion on the electric comet theory, is, and a simple yes/no will do, which object has more water in your informed opinion, comets or asteroids?
 
Let's. first do you believe there are electric fields in operation at comet?

do you agree the dust is charged and ions and electrons are de coupledf rom the neutrals at the surface of the nucleus?

No the ions and electrons are not decoupled at the nucleus, and they weren't decoupled in the DC at Halley. Try to understand the paper, and figure out what an ion exobase is, and what an electron exobase is. This is what happens when you don't understand the papers that you link to.
 
Last edited:
Another direct question that will help the discussion on the electric comet theory, is, and a simple yes/no will do, which object has more water in your informed opinion, comets or asteroids?

Again, totally irrelevant. Some C-type asteroids may have a similar amount to comets. The mass ratio in them is 5.5:1. Comet 67P, according to Fulle, is somewhere from 3 - 9. And the water in asteroids is not in the form of ice. It is inaccessibly bound up in minerals. And has a different D/H ratio to most comets. Comets have their volatiles in the form of ices. And that is not just water ice, as observed.
 
Simple yes no answer will help this discussion no end. Do you believe there are ambipolar electric fields, among others, in operation at comets and that the dust is charged?

Probably at 67P, doesn't appear to be so at Halley. Certainly nowhere near the nucleus.
 
No the ions and electrons are not decoupled at the nucleus, and they weren't decoupled in the DC at Halley. Try to understand the paper, and figure out what an ion exobase is, and what an electron exobase is. This is what happens when you don't understand the papers that you link to.


Or indeed, what a diamagnetic cavity is and how there’re formed, hey jonesdave116!

:thumbsup:
 
Again, totally irrelevant. Some C-type asteroids may have a similar amount to comets. The mass ratio in them is 5.5:1. Comet 67P, according to Fulle, is somewhere from 3 - 9. And the water in asteroids is not in the form of ice. It is inaccessibly bound up in minerals. And has a different D/H ratio to most comets. Comets have their volatiles in the form of ices. And that is not just water ice, as observed.


Like O2 “ice” as well. :D along with the refractory dust. :thumbsup:
 
Probably at 67P, doesn't appear to be so at Halley. Certainly nowhere near the nucleus.


So, probably?

That’s a start. :)

145kv potential drop among other small potential drops not a big enough electric field for you, jonesdave116?

Wonder what would happen to charged dust in such an electric field? :jaw-dropp
 
We know how they're formed.

Your outdated way or the new way?

Electric fields or outgassing, which one?

The comet does not even slow the solar wind, just deflects it. Fail for the Dirtysnowball’s mass loading! :rolleyes:

And the solar wind ion go in a different direction than cometary ions. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
So, probably?

That’s a start. :)

145kv potential drop among other small potential drops not a big enough electric field for you, jonesdave116?

Wonder what would happen to charged dust in such an electric field? :jaw-dropp

I don't know where you got that figure from. However, if the field at 67P is accelerating ions outward, as observed, then what charge do you want your dust to be? It will not accelerate both + and - charged particles in the same direction. They also state that with electrons being trapped, the field may actually reverse occasionally;

We should also emphasize that our model is based on a stationary situation with an electric field profile that remains constant in time. Speculatively, the field profile may rather vary periodically. A decaying potential profile will tend to trap electrons with insufficient energy to overcome the potential barrier. Such electrons will subsequently cool further via collisions closer to the nucleus. Unless effectively removed via dissociative recombination (a process which is more efficient the slower the electrons are), the cold electron population grows and continues to do so up to a point where the resulting reduced electron temperature leads to a diminishing (or even reversal) of the ambipolar electric field that then can allow the cold electrons to escape outwards. This in turn leads back to an outward-pointing ambipolar electric field. Such a scenario would be qualitatively consistent with the time-varying cavity boundary observed on Rosetta.

So, do we see dust being trapped, and occasionally being released as the field reverses? No, we don't.
 
Your outdated way or the new way?

It is not my way. It is the way of every scientist who concerns themselves with the study of such things. There is no new way. If there is let's see a link to this scientific, quantified model.
 
JeanTate said:
I think I have never seen a quantitative EC model of 67P.

Can you post such a model, for all readers to review?

Thank you in advance.
Like a peer reviewed mainstream paper?

Good one, :rolleyes:
Clearly not.

Try another thunderbolts video, couldn’t explain any clearer.

Pick it to pieces, if you can and I’ll show you the new mainstream papers to back Dr Anariba up.
Thanks. I'll take a look later. And write a post on what I find.
 
JeanTate said:
Other than a very old Electric Comet document, and your own posts here, Sol88, I do not recall reading EC-based, quantitative estimates of the electric field strengths, directions, and polariziations at, and associated with, comets.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

I do not recall reading any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the degree to which dust is charged, at the surface of comet nuclei. Nor any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the extent to which ions and electrons are decoupled from the neutrals there.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?
Ditto, though the mainstream are cottoning on, slowly. :D

<stuff irrelevant to my questions snipped>
"Ditto", what, exactly Sol88?
 
JeanTate said:
Other than a very old Electric Comet document, and your own posts here, Sol88, I do not recall reading EC-based, quantitative estimates of the electric field strengths, directions, and polariziations at, and associated with, comets.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

I do not recall reading any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the degree to which dust is charged, at the surface of comet nuclei. Nor any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the extent to which ions and electrons are decoupled from the neutrals there.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?
Another direct question that will help the discussion on the electric comet theory, is, and a simple yes/no will do, which object has more water in your informed opinion, comets or asteroids?
In this thread, my sole interest is in discussing (etc) the EC (model, or Theory).

As I understand it, in the EC both asteroids and comets are "ROCK". And, as I wrote earlier, per your own posts, EC ROCK contains no water. However - again per your own posts here - when EC ROCK is blasted by EC EDM, it produces both dust and copious quantities of water.

This seems - to me - to be not only inconsistent, but high quality nonsense.

Perhaps you could clarify?

By posting an internally consistent, quantitative explanation/description of how EC ROCK can contain no water yet also produce copious quantities of it.
 
Strawman, dear Lukraak_Sisser, strawman

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Everyone here seems a little hesitant to answer this very simple question.

One wonders why?
Because you're simply trolling? :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom