The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no rock. How many times? In terms of volume there is likely to be a ratio of 2:1 in terms of dust: ice. In mass terms, this is 6:1.

Yeah, whatever you say, jd116.

The possible highly variable content in carbon and the ice volume fraction in comets and KBOs, lower than in CI-chondrites, suggest multiple scenarios of their formation. Icy objects in the protoplanetary disc may have formed everywhere outside the water snowline, with a composition of non-volatiles apparently independent of the solar distance during accretion, thus confirming a fast mixing of non-volatiles in the protoplanetary disc (Ciesla 2011). This is further confirmed by the sub mm aggregates of minerals of bulk density >4000 kg m−3 observed by GIADA in 67P (Fig. 1). These minerals can have been formed only in the inner solar protoplanetary disc (Brownlee 2014). The variable ice content in KBOs suggests important migrations of the most icy objects (possibly comets and KBOs with a CI-chondritic composition of non-volatiles) outside the water snowline, where they may have accreted. Memory of the accretion sun-distance may be preserved by the ratios D/H, O2/H2OandN2/H2O (Fulle et al. 2016b).
The dust-to-ices ratio in comets and Kuiper belt objects

Lower than in rocky/stoney objects? No comets are Dirtysnowball with icy cliffs, shiny stuff every where, say it ain’t so, jd116.

The CI and CI-like chondrites provide a record of aqueous alteration in the early solar system. However, the CI-like chondrites differ in having also experienced a late stage period of thermal metamorphism. In order to constrain the nature and extent of the aqueous and thermal alteration, we have investigated the bulk mineralogy and abundance of H2O in the CI and CI-like chondrites using thermogravimetric analysis and infrared spectroscopy.
Characterising the CI and CI-like carbonaceous chondrites using thermogravimetric analysis and infrared spectroscopy

Where did there water come from considering there rocky/stoney composition and with more water than comets?

Do they have jd116’s she’d load of ice to have more water than comets? Do we see any of them “outgassing” this shed load of water?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, whatever you say, jd116.

The dust-to-ices ratio in comets and Kuiper belt objects

And the relevance of that is? CI chondrites come from C-type asteroids. The water, or OH, is locked up in minerals. That is why they don't outgas. In comets it isn't locked up in minerals for the most part. That is why you can see it. And why it sublimates.
 
So, jonesdave116, which has more water by weight, asteroids or comets?

Anyone else feel free to support jd116.
 
And the relevance of that is? CI chondrites come from C-type asteroids. The water, or OH, is locked up in minerals. That is why they don't outgas. In comets it isn't locked up in minerals for the most part. That is why you can see it. And why it sublimates.

The “icy cliffs” of Tempel 1 were not sublimating and this is the most surface ice we’ve seen on a comet? Otherwise all your “ice” is hidden under a insulating dust blanket.

There is no distinction between asteroid and comets except for there orbits and electric field strengths...

:boggled:
 
Buckle up princess, this “primordial” piece of rock is going to raise more questions than answers with regard to the formation of the solar system for the mainstream, just like New Horizons found at the comet like dwarf planet Pluto.

:D

And I see first pictures in indicate a bilobate structure, much the same as a few comets we’ve imaged thus far...:D

First of all, I'd prefer it if you used my forum name, endearments can be given by people I care about, not random internet strangers.

Secondly, I know that many new things will be discovered, just like they were with Pluto/Charon, but none of that will ever show the electric universe fantasies to be true, as for those to be true, none of our spacecraft would work.
They do, therefore the EU is wrong.

You can dance, and obfuscate and repeat the same debunked irrelevancies until you die, but that won't make anyone ever take the EU seriously.
 
So, jonesdave116, which has more water by weight, asteroids or comets?

Anyone else feel free to support jd116.

What type of asteroids? And what is your point? I just pointed out to you that the water in certain types of asteroids is locked up in minerals. Hence why they don't outgas. Despite taking the full brunt of the solar wind, and having ambipolar fields (whatever the relevance of them is!).
Let's pretend an asteroid was a sungrazer. Maybe it gets hot enough to release the water or OH. That leaves a dessicated layer on the surface. Eventually this layer is thick enough to stop any further outgassing. Not that we see such things.
Have you dumped Thornhill's impossible model? Is the solar wind no longer creating the OH, which dumb scientists mistake for H2O? Has ellipticity no longer got anything to do with outgassing? Is the total absence of rock and discharges causing a problem?
 
The “icy cliffs” of Tempel 1 were not sublimating and this is the most surface ice we’ve seen on a comet? Otherwise all your “ice” is hidden under a insulating dust blanket.

There is no distinction between asteroid and comets except for there orbits and electric field strengths...

:boggled:

Of course they were bloody sublimating. Just as at 67P. I already explained this. There is a combination of thermal stress, outgassing and cliff collapse. As observed. Expose ice above ~ 150 K, and it will sublimate.
And there is a big difference between the vast majority of asteroids and comets. The water in C-type asteroids is locked up in minerals. Where it stays. Do I need to draw a picture?
 
So, jonesdave116, which has more water by weight, asteroids or comets?

Anyone else feel free to support jd116.
Both have more water than EC ROCKS. :p

No, wait ... when the EC EDM blasts EC ROCK, it produces dust, and ... water! :jaw-dropp

So EC ROCKS have more water than asteroids and more water than comets, AND EC ROCKS have less water than asteroids and less water than comets. :confused:
 
There is no distinction between asteroid and comets except for there orbits and electric field strengths...

Really? And the evidence for this is? What is an electric field doing to create ice? How is it making comets less dense than asteroids? Stop talking crap. It is getting tiresome. Go to Dunderdolts and find someone vaguely scientifically literate for us to talk to. You are out of your depth.

EDIT:
And what have the orbits got to do with anything? Indagator asked you, ages ago, about this. Explain.
 
Last edited:
Of course they were bloody sublimating. Just as at 67P. I already explained this. There is a combination of thermal stress, outgassing and cliff collapse. As observed. Expose ice above ~ 150 K, and it will sublimate.
And there is a big difference between the vast majority of asteroids and comets. The water in C-type asteroids is locked up in minerals. Where it stays. Do I need to draw a picture?
May I make a suggestion?

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory). Let’s concentrate on that, shall we?

Sol88 seems to avoid discussion of the EC, preferring to use the logical fallacy False Dichotomy. Don’t get sucked in; stick to the EC! And, in this thread, the only valid source of details of the EC is Sol88. So insist on getting details of the EC, and what observations that Sol88 thinks are consistent with the EC.
 
May I make a suggestion?

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory). Let’s concentrate on that, shall we?

Sol88 seems to avoid discussion of the EC, preferring to use the logical fallacy False Dichotomy. Don’t get sucked in; stick to the EC! And, in this thread, the only valid source of details of the EC is Sol88. So insist on getting details of the EC, and what observations that Sol88 thinks are consistent with the EC.

Fair points, JT. However, it seems Sol has usurped Thornhill and Talbott's failed model. All of a sudden we are talking about hydrated minerals and ambipolar fields. Methinks Sol is making it up as he goes along.
 
Fair points, JT. However, it seems Sol has usurped Thornhill and Talbott's failed model. All of a sudden we are talking about hydrated minerals and ambipolar fields. Methinks Sol is making it up as he goes along.
Indeed.

Where do “hydrated minerals” and “ambipolar fields” fit within the EC? How are they quantified within the EC? Etc. :p
 
Indeed.

Where do “hydrated minerals” and “ambipolar fields” fit within the EC? How are they quantified within the EC? Etc. :p


Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field and charged dust at 67P, jean Tate?
 
Fair points, JT. However, it seems Sol has usurped Thornhill and Talbott's failed model. All of a sudden we are talking about hydrated minerals and ambipolar fields. Methinks Sol is making it up as he goes along.


Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

you still refuse to answer, why?
 
Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field and charged dust at 67P, jean Tate?
I think I have never seen a quantitative EC model of 67P.

Can you post such a model, for all readers to review?

Thank you in advance.
 
May I make a suggestion?

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory). Let’s concentrate on that, shall we?

Sol88 seems to avoid discussion of the EC, preferring to use the logical fallacy False Dichotomy. Don’t get sucked in; stick to the EC! And, in this thread, the only valid source of details of the EC is Sol88. So insist on getting details of the EC, and what observations that Sol88 thinks are consistent with the EC.


Let's. first do you believe there are electric fields in operation at comet?

do you agree the dust is charged and ions and electrons are de coupledf rom the neutrals at the surface of the nucleus?
 
Let's. first do you believe there are electric fields in operation at comet?

do you agree the dust is charged and ions and electrons are de coupledf rom the neutrals at the surface of the nucleus?
Other than a very old Electric Comet document, and your own posts here, Sol88, I do not recall reading EC-based, quantitative estimates of the electric field strengths, directions, and polariziations at, and associated with, comets.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?

I do not recall reading any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the degree to which dust is charged, at the surface of comet nuclei. Nor any EC-based, quantitative estimates of the extent to which ions and electrons are decoupled from the neutrals there.

Can you provide one for readers here to review?
 
First of all, I'd prefer it if you used my forum name, endearments can be given by people I care about, not random internet strangers.

Secondly, I know that many new things will be discovered, just like they were with Pluto/Charon, but none of that will ever show the electric universe fantasies to be true, as for those to be true, none of our spacecraft would work.
They do, therefore the EU is wrong.

You can dance, and obfuscate and repeat the same debunked irrelevancies until you die, but that won't make anyone ever take the EU seriously.

Strawman, dear Lukraak_Sisser, strawman

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Everyone here seems a little hesitant to answer this very simple question.

One wonders why?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom