Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I'm not wrong. Like me to find the reference? And it is irrelevant anyway. The density (and therefore gravity) is as measured. Otherwise we have a dead spacecraft. QED. This is a really dumb argument.

:thumbsup:

Perhaps you and tusenfem can work together?
 
Did they not adjust the orbits using thrusters from the perceived gravity anyway?

Why would it crash ya muppet.

Ohhh, the stupid around here hurts sometimes! Do you know what a bound orbit is? Do you know how many of them Rosetta performed? How do you work out a spacecraft velocity to keep it in that bound orbit? By knowing the bloody gravity of the object you are orbiting, and at what distance you are orbiting it. If the s/c velocity, relative to 67P (~ 1 m/s, iirc) was based on gravity computed from a measured density of x, and the actual density was 5x, what do you think would happen? Do you think they had instantaneous communication with the spacecraft, and could keep firing thrusters to account for this? Use your brain for once.
 
Last edited:
Paper might be a dud, along with Y.Skorov’s dust lifting paper, you now the one?

And? Of what relevance is either to non-existent rock? And non-existent electric discharges? You seem to forget that you are still inhabiting an evidence-free zone. Time to actually find some, yes? Start with the data showing discharges from (to?) the nucleus.
 
If you don’t know ask jd116. He’s been pretty sure they got to much energy to get back together.

Huh? They aren't recombining to form neutral H! They are moved into the same space, whereby quasi-neutrality is therefore maintained. What's the point if you don't even understand the paper?
Speaking of which, the simulation by Deca et al is only for a weakly outgassing comet, such as 67P, at ~ 3 AU. It would not apply at a strongly outgassing comet, or for 67P at closer heliocentric distances, when the plasma becomes collisional. And if you look at Alfven's table again, you will see that he is talking about the collisional regime.
 
No. You have a read up on it, and present the results here. Numerically. Where are you getting protons from? How many do you need? Stop making up crap, and actually do some science.

I meant to edit this post, but forgot. I just wanted to add that a) you haven't got enough protons to account for the water production, b) the solar wind is getting nowhere near the comet for months on end, and c) the D/H ratio of the water is nothing like the D/H ratio in the solar wind H. Apart from that....... it is still a really dumb idea.
 
Well, Tusenfem is going to be happy! His paper is cited, among others on a woo site by Sol as PROOF of the electric comet garbage! I'll have to re-read it and see where he has discovered rock and EDM!
Deary me.
And if you need help with maths, Sol, it probably isn't much use asking on there. A bit like asking for a pork pie at a bar mitzvah!
http://www.thunderbolts.info/forum/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4158&start=450
 
Huh? They aren't recombining to form neutral H! They are moved into the same space, whereby quasi-neutrality is therefore maintained. What's the point if you don't even understand the paper?
Speaking of which, the simulation by Deca et al is only for a weakly outgassing comet, such as 67P, at ~ 3 AU. It would not apply at a strongly outgassing comet, or for 67P at closer heliocentric distances, when the plasma becomes collisional. And if you look at Alfven's table again, you will see that he is talking about the collisional regime.

He did not say that in the paper but you reckon that’s what he means ay?

Fair enough, it would have been my first assumption but it would nice to see it in the paper but maybe he also did mean you neutralise a proton by adding an electron and you neutralise an electron with an ion!

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions


So how far away from the nucleus does this occur per Decca’s paper? You know this return to assumed quasi neutrality?

also
total volume of the comet is 21.4 km3 and the Radio Science Instrument has measured its mass to be 10 billion tonnes, yielding a density of 470 kg/m3.

By assuming an overall composition dominated by water ice and dust with a density of 1500–2000 kg/m3, the Rosetta scientists show that the comet has a very high porosity of 70–80%, with the interior structure likely comprising weakly bonded ice-dust clumps with small void spaces between them.

And all this subsurface assumed ice is only “outgassing’
Images from the scientific and navigation cameras have shown an increase in the amount of dust flowing away from the comet over the past six months, and MIRO showed a general rise in the comet’s global water vapour production rate, from 0.3 litres per second in early June 2014 to 1.2 litres per second by late August. MIRO also found that a substantial portion of the water seen during this phase originated from the comet’s neck.
1200ml a second? Does’nt sound like a lot but hey it stands the solar wind off as well as separating charges a making ambi bipolar electric fields and beams and jets and and polarising the nucleus and all they goodly electric comets stuff. :blush:

I’m comfortable with your assumption of 1500–2000 kg/m3 as the bulk density. As well with there being no porosity there will be a mix of different rock types based on Stardust mission, GIADA, Deep impact, asteroids and meteorites...

But your balls up with the RSI experiment has giving you 70%-80% of NOTHING? :rolleyes:

So with a little help from generous soul/s over on the thunderbolts forum and with this new data and simulations at hand, I am going to prove that what we infact see, touch and taste is indeed ROCK!

So strap in champ we are going for a ride! :D

PS
‘cos it’s all youv’e got left (density).
 
Well, Tusenfem is going to be happy! His paper is cited, among others on a woo site by Sol as PROOF of the electric comet garbage! I'll have to re-read it and see where he has discovered rock and EDM!
Deary me.
And if you need help with maths, Sol, it probably isn't much use asking on there. A bit like asking for a pork pie at a bar mitzvah!
http://www.thunderbolts.info/forum/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4158&start=450

Now, look I was more than chuffed when he confirmed my prediction on charge separation of the solar wind, magnetic fields moving past one another generating electric currents, CME’s flaring the comet and MHD not being applicable at comets, field aligned currents and the tail of a comet being a birkeland current!

So yeah well done M.Vowerk!

All you have left is the RSI experiment and it will not only change the comets density measurement but a whole raft of other issues when the error is realised shown by non scientists to the mainstream.

But I CANT do the maths well enough to PROVE to you this is the case, hence forth i’ve asked for a hand over on the thunderbolts forum. Don’t go there very often but there a great bunch of people with a lot of diffent skills and knowledge between them. Oh and they already accept the premise comets are...ELECTRIC!
 
Last edited:
I meant to edit this post, but forgot. I just wanted to add that a) you haven't got enough protons to account for the water production, b) the solar wind is getting nowhere near the comet for months on end, and c) the D/H ratio of the water is nothing like the D/H ratio in the solar wind H. Apart from that....... it is still a really dumb idea.

While some water most likey forms like that, my prediction is most of the 1.2ltr/sec is coming from the hydrated minerals that compose the rock that is the nucleus of a comet!

As recorded on the internet forever by jean tate.

Is this is not different from the Wal Thornhill views but reinforces the non requirements for there to be ice either on the surface, subsurface or wherever the mainstream require it to be to explain dust jets!

Now all we need to do is prove it rock (clays,carbonates...) being totally dissociated by intense electric fields and accelerated away by the solar wind plasma is the source of the mainstreams misunderstand of the data in an effort to prove grand poobah Fred Whiple corect.
 
Last edited:
So with a little help from generous soul/s over on the thunderbolts forum and with this new data and simulations at hand, I am going to prove that what we infact see, touch and taste is indeed ROCK!

Oh dear. A bunch of thickos, none of whom understand science, are going to look at the data and find rock! Good luck, thickos. Know what you're looking for? Thought not. Stick to misinterpreting mythology, eh? Woo boys! What can you do with them? Extermination is against the law where I live. Any other ideas?
 
While some water most likey forms like that, my prediction is most of the 1.2ltr/sec is coming from the hydrated minerals that compose the rock that is the nucleus of a comet!

Errr, dumbo, no rock has been detected. Yes? Go back to school. You seem to have missed out the years between 5 - 18. Correct? Learn to science, yes?
 
Is this is not different from the Wal Thornhill views but reinforces the non requirements for there to be ice either on the surface, subsurface or wherever the mainstream require it to be to explain dust jets!

Right, assuming I've translated that into usable English: errrrr, dumbos, we have already seen ice on the surface and sub-surface, yes? Keep up, woo boys. Jeez you lot are stupid, eh?
 
Now all we need to do is prove it rock (clays,carbonates...) being totally dissociated by intense electric fields and accelerated away by the solar wind plasma is the source of the mainstreams misunderstand of the data in an effort to prove grand poobah Fred Whiple corect.

Whoops. Somebody has lost it totally, yes? Deary me. Get back to us when the scientifically illiterate loons of dunderdolts are ready to present their paper. Lol. And not before. Now go away, you useless article. In the meantime, try to learn science, yes?
 
:thumbsup: :D

All the sweeter. :cool:

Yep, that would explain why you can't do either science, nor English grammar. Correct? School was something that never happened for you, yes Sol? Learned everything you know from a pack of dingos in the outback? TBF that is probably unfair to dingos. Eh?
 
Just repeating idiocy does not make it truth, get some edumacation.
This is barely two weeks' old, yet it is IMHO a pretty good summary of those two weeks.

Sol88, no one reading this thread has been persuaded by anything that you've posted, in terms of evidence for the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) as you have defined it, here in this thread. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that this past couple of weeks' worth of posts by you has, if anything, convinced everyone that a) you have no understanding of the science involved in what you have posted, and b) the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it) is more akin to a fevered fantasy than to a logical, rational presentation of something worthy of serious consideration.

What I continue to find strange is your reluctance to address one of the simplest, yet most important, tests of the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it), namely that comets are "rock". The test is simple and straight-forward: is the observed bulk density of comets consistent with solid rock? My limited search turned up five comets with observed densities quite inconsistent with that of "rock".

There are plenty of other reasons why a rational person can conclude that the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it) is as dead as the late Polly (Norwegian Blue, lovely plumage), but for me this one is all that you need.

I was looking over some of the old "Electric Universe" (EU) threads here in ISF, and found a curious pattern: almost all the ardent proponents of EU ideas have long since stopped posting here. Even more curious (perhaps) is that the reason seems to be that their posts violated the ISF membership agreement (as far as I can tell); i.e. they did not stop posting here voluntarily. But curiousest (to coin a word) of all is that most of those threads, in their later parts, resemble the last two weeks or so of this one's! :jaw-dropp
 
Well, Tusenfem is going to be happy! His paper is cited, among others on a woo site by Sol as PROOF of the electric comet garbage! I'll have to re-read it and see where he has discovered rock and EDM!
Deary me.
And if you need help with maths, Sol, it probably isn't much use asking on there. A bit like asking for a pork pie at a bar mitzvah!
http://www.thunderbolts.info/forum/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4158&start=450
Any reference to this thread, here in ISF?

My prediction: advice that Sol88 is wasting his time by posting in ISF. Why will EU fans and groupies say that? Their #1 reason will be something like "people at ISF are closed minded, and have all swallowed the dogma; no matter how much evidence for the EU you present, they'll poo-poo it as having no quantitative basis, which we all know is just an excuse (you don't need mathemagic to prove that the universe runs on hydrinos electricity)".
 
This is barely two weeks' old, yet it is IMHO a pretty good summary of those two weeks.

Sol88, no one reading this thread has been persuaded by anything that you've posted, in terms of evidence for the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) as you have defined it, here in this thread. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that this past couple of weeks' worth of posts by you has, if anything, convinced everyone that a) you have no understanding of the science involved in what you have posted, and b) the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it) is more akin to a fevered fantasy than to a logical, rational presentation of something worthy of serious consideration.

What I continue to find strange is your reluctance to address one of the simplest, yet most important, tests of the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it), namely that comets are "rock". The test is simple and straight-forward: is the observed bulk density of comets consistent with solid rock? My limited search turned up five comets with observed densities quite inconsistent with that of "rock".

There are plenty of other reasons why a rational person can conclude that the ELECTRIC COMET model (as you have presented it) is as dead as the late Polly (Norwegian Blue, lovely plumage), but for me this one is all that you need.

sniped

All right I ‘spose, we’ll head back to the misinterpretation of gravity for electro static repulsion .

No worries navigating Rosetta around, you just compensate for the “gravity” that is present. Problem is you’ve used Newton's law in error when you should have used Coulomb's law


So then when you divide mass by volume, p=m/V you end with some ridiculous comets are mainly empty space with only dust and a little ice!

You can’t tell everyone’s lying eyes the thing is dust with some ice when it in fact what it looks like!

And if you hold your word on the place that never forgets and this last piece of the puzzle is solved for the mainstream, is that for you, this one is all that you need?

You up for it?

Comet bulk densities are the same as the compact particles densities.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom