Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Please show me up as the goose I am. :D

I didn’t say he didn’t support his own simulations ya muppet. I asked how far from the nucleus the charges got back together, not sure if your playing with a full deck. How old are you now?

And as long as you are incapable of comparing a few figures in the paper, this whole discussino is moot.

Btw his passage was this not sure if that re establishes quasi neutrality or makes Hydrogen?

Think a bit harder about it, it will come to you, when you finally understand what the paper says.

No mention of distance I could find but great paper and a bit of cold water over another recent paper!

If you say so

Even by his own admission the lead author stated!

That MHD is at some locations not applicable has been know for a loooooong time, specifically e.g. after the singing comet discovery. That is still is a surprise to you is no surprise to me.

But then straight into that ‘ol chestnut

assumed the incorrect model.

And all my efforts of trying to explain you something have been of little use. You thank me for giving explanations for "the lurkers", but apparently you don't consider the fact that even you (the expert on EC) might benifit from some explanation e.g. about MHD applicability.

And you knew all along about charge separation! That and Together with your playing with a direct answer to my question on how far those + & - are getting together.

I am not playing, just fed up with your games of trying to get people to explain stuff for you, then accepting and thanking those explanations (which are probably only for the lurkers) and then come back again with the same nonsense and questions and non-understandings.

If you don’t know ask jd116. He’s been pretty sure they got to much energy to get back together.

I am pretty sure if JD would look at figure 1 (?) of Jan Deca's paper, he would also see how the "neutralisation" takes place (within the simulation box).

Paper might be a dud, along with Y.Skorov’s dust lifting paper, you now the one?

Skorov probably worked with the wrong numbers as a group at the university where Skorov is working pointed out at the last Rosetta SWT meeting.
I am not sure if I "now" the paper.
 
Now, look I was more than chuffed when he confirmed my prediction on charge separation of the solar wind, magnetic fields moving past one another generating electric currents, CME’s flaring the comet and MHD not being applicable at comets, field aligned currents and the tail of a comet being a birkeland current!

So yeah well done M.Vowerk!

Thank you, you have a very good imagination.
 
No worries navigating Rosetta around, you just compensate for the “gravity” that is present. Problem is you’ve used Newton's law in error when you should have used Coulomb's law

Wrong. The gravity is as measured. As explained. If it wasn't, the spacecraft would not be orbiting as it was seen to for two years. Electrostatic repulsion doesn't work. If you think it does, then show us the maths. It has already been done for you, so shouldn't be difficult. What does the charge on the comet need to be? What was detected by Rosetta and Philae?
So, I'll repeat, for the hard of understanding; there is no rock. CONSERT doesn't see rock, MIRO doesn't see rock, MUPUS doesn't see rock, CASSE/ SESAME doesn't see rock. The RSI experiment doesn't see rock. The orbit of the spacecraft doesn't see rock. The Tempel 1 impactor doesn't reveal rock.
There is no rock. No amount of posting scientifically illiterate nonsense is going to change that.
 
Problem is you’ve used Newton's law in error when you should have used Coulomb's law

Which is? I think you'll find that it is precisely as used by Harvey on the Rosetta blog, and Tom Bridgman on his blog, to show that this is a totally dumb idea, and the charge you would need is impossible. And would tear the comet apart. And the spacecraft.
However, if you want to show where the derivation of that charge is wrong, then redo Harvey's calculation, here:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

You will notice that ke q1q2/r^2 used by Harvey, is indeed Coulomb's law. So get to it electric geniuses. What does the charge on the comet need to be to cancel out 80% of the 'real' gravity? Looking forward to seeing the maths.
 
So, we have The Man, Reality Check and Jean Tate all now agreeing on how pervasive charge separation is and when you talk magnitudes it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET is but a infinitesimally small part of the whole.


What do you mean "now"? Who has agreed "it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET". Exactly how powerful does it need to be to "power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET". Until EU and EC proponents can at least assert that, no one can agree with them. Not even themselves.
 
All very sensible and rational.

If you read Sol88’s posts in this thread, and earlier, you may find that what he means by certain key terms - such as “charge separation” - differs in rather important ways from what you (and physics textbooks and papers) mean (Sol88 is not unique in this regard, IMHO it’s widespread among EU fans). It’s one reason why threads like this go on for what seems like forever.

Actually my one assertion about the potential dropping below the breakdown threshold being the cut off was in error. The kinetic thermal effect would tend to maintain the plasma conduit so the cutoff potential would most likely be well below the original breakdown potential.

Sorry.

Soll88 just seems to be playing word games.
 
Yup, turtles all the way!

Nope, even the "turtles" succumb to stronger creatures further "down".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_capture

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_interaction

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_interaction


Heck it ain't even "turtles" all the way up. As large scale neutrality keeps all the up town "turtles" from working together. As already mentioned before just the very internal strife among the two types of "turtles" would limit what they could do even without that large scale neutrality.

Electric Turtle theory suffers the same deficiencies as EC and EU.
 
What do you mean "now"? Who has agreed "it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET". Exactly how powerful does it need to be to "power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET". Until EU and EC proponents can at least assert that, no one can agree with them. Not even themselves.

sol is rather creative in his interpretations of what other people say or think
 
sol is rather creative in his interpretations of what other people say or think

Sure, but seeming having grasped the impotence of magnitude of separation "now", one would expect that to become the focus of discussion. Though as expected Sol88 most likely already well knew the significance of the magnitude such separations and deliberately avoids it, while (again probably deliberately) erroneously asserting others are "all now agreeing" such (still unquantified by EU and EC proponents) magnitudes are even possible let alone maintainable.
 
Sure, but seeming having grasped the impotence of magnitude of separation "now", one would expect that to become the focus of discussion. Though as expected Sol88 most likely already well knew the significance of the magnitude such separations and deliberately avoids it, while (again probably deliberately) erroneously asserting others are "all now agreeing" such (still unquantified by EU and EC proponents) magnitudes are even possible let alone maintainable.

yes, that is why in several of my last posts i tried to get an answer about how intense is intense, what are the numbers needed, and are they feasible and/or observed.

maybe sol will get math help at thunderdolts (though from the craziness in tnat thread i greatly doubt it)
 
I'm afraid that all we will get is what we have been getting, both here and elsewhere for about 15 years; woo, word salad, obfuscation, avoidance of questions, inability to understand basic science, and a complete lack of quantification. This nonsense lives on because Thornhill and Talbott need it to live on. Even having an astronaut on the surface digging a hole wouldn't convince them to alter their fairy tale. As Talbott said way back:

If there's water ice on the surface, I'll be the first to say that my prediction, along with those of several others, was DEAD WRONG. Our critics would have good cause to celebrate such a miscalculation on our part.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10359403&postcount=2439

And how many times has ice been detected on or under the surface? Including in the ejecta from Tempel 1 in 2005!! For me, these people are no different in their debating style than YECs. Nothing will ever convince them that their fairy story is nonsense.
 
All right I ‘spose, we’ll head back to the misinterpretation of gravity for electro static repulsion .

No worries navigating Rosetta around, you just compensate for the “gravity” that is present. Problem is you’ve used Newton's law in error when you should have used Coulomb's law


So then when you divide mass by volume, p=m/V you end with some ridiculous comets are mainly empty space with only dust and a little ice!

You can’t tell everyone’s lying eyes the thing is dust with some ice when it in fact what it looks like!

And if you hold your word on the place that never forgets and this last piece of the puzzle is solved for the mainstream, is that for you, this one is all that you need?
Great post, Sol88! :thumbsup:

From what I've read of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), as posted by you in this thread, I don't see any way to estimate what the charges on any comet will be, at any point in their orbits, from "first principles" shall we say. Nor have you presented anything that looks as if it could be used to estimate the charge on Rosetta, at any point in its orbit.

But the good news is that you should be able to estimate a range for what the charge differences will be! :jaw-dropp

How?

Here's my suggestion:
1) Start with acknowledging that Rosetta and 67P could have the same charge (i.e. both either negative or both positive) or opposite charges
2) Obtain an estimate of the volume of 67P; from your library of papers that you've cited in this thread, this should be a piece of cake
3) From this, estimate the mass of 67P assuming it to be solid rock; pick a range of densities to include most likely compositions; you'll get a range
4) Using "Newton's law" and "Coulomb's law", derive an expression for q1q2, assuming the force due to the latter is a fraction of the former, say "f". If you need help with this, holler; we're here to help you
5) Derive what q1q2 must be (a range) for the estimated density to be 0.5 (say), assuming that estimated density is derived from "Newton's law" alone
6) Present us with the result (as well as your working)! :)

You may find that the work Harvey and Bridgman did, as presented in sources which I'm sure you're all too familiar with, helpful. Note that you do NOT have to follow their method(s).

You up for it?

<snip>
Sol88, you are the one defining, promoting, and defending the ELECTRIC COMET model (not me).

I cannot tell how to apply "Newton's law" and "Coulomb's law" in the case of Rosetta and 67P, within the framework of the ELECTRIC COMET model; you are the only ISF member active here who can.

So, let's see you use the ELECTRIC COMET model to estimate q1q2 (a range)! :)
 
1) Start with acknowledging that Rosetta and 67P could have the same charge (i.e. both either negative or both positive) or opposite charges

And, just to stick my two cents in; the charge on Rosetta could (indeed, did) change, both in sign and in strength. One must also assume that in the EC woo the comet, due to it discharging, is also experiencing a different charge between ~ 4 AU and perihelion, and then back out again. How to quantify this? How to calculate the bound orbits that Rosetta performed? Stick to Newton and everything works just fine (and did). Use Coulomb, and the EC, and you never bother with the mission, as there are too many unknowns.
 
Last edited:
And, just to stick my two cents in; the charge on Rosetta could (indeed, did) change, both in sign and in strength. One must also assume that in the EC woo the comet, due to it discharging, is also experiencing a different charge between ~ 4 AU and perihelion, and then back out again. How to quantify this? How to calculate the bound orbits that Rosetta performed? Stick to Newton and everything works just fine (and did). Use Coulomb, and the EC, and you never bother with the mission, as there are too many unknowns.
One step at a time, jd, one step at a time.

Let's wait for Sol88 to present his own analysis, done within/based on the ELECTRIC COMET model, and we can ask questions about it after the presentation. I'm sure Sol88 will be thorough, so it's reasonable to expect that his presentation will allow anyone to independently verify his work, and (hopefully) allow anyone to independently extend that work to more general cases.

After all, that's what we expect of everything in science isn't it (objective, independent verifiability)? And Sol88 has never, publicly, disavowed the scientific method, has he?
 
Usual lies and derails from his electric comet insanity over the weekend

More than 1060 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, insults, and lies from 6 July 2009 to 27 June 2018

Another ~115 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 16 July 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.


18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Over 4 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
I'm afraid that all we will get is what we have been getting, both here and elsewhere for about 15 years; woo, word salad, obfuscation, avoidance of questions, inability to understand basic science, and a complete lack of quantification. This nonsense lives on because Thornhill and Talbott need it to live on. Even having an astronaut on the surface digging a hole wouldn't convince them to alter their fairy tale. As Talbott said way back:



http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10359403&postcount=2439

And how many times has ice been detected on or under the surface? Including in the ejecta from Tempel 1 in 2005!! For me, these people are no different in their debating style than YECs. Nothing will ever convince them that their fairy story is nonsense.
My turn, damn you jd!

In a moment of weakness, I clicked on that link ... and spent hours, hours I tell ya! reading the rest of that thread! :eye-poppi I just couldn't stop, it was so appalling, funny, ... just when I thought it couldn't get more insane, along came a new post that blew me away yet again!

I've just got to quote two posts (links within them, and some formatting, lost):

First, by W.D. Clinger:
Haig said:
You have to laugh
Yes, but we aren't all laughing at the same things.

First - Why did I bring Miles Mathis into this thread ? ...

Electric Comets requires an Electric Sun requires an Electric Universe / Plasma Cosmology ... it's a package deal they ALL go together

And Miles Mathis has a finger in ALL those Pi(s)
Yes, that's pretty funny.

Haig said:
Second - In my list of some the Space Greats ... Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, Einstein, Birkland, Bruce, Velikovsky, Alfvén, Juergens, Scott, Thornhill, Talbott, Mathis ...
jmckaskle said:
The real question to ask is not whether anyone got anything wrong, but whether they got anything right. Bruce, Velikovsky, Juergens, Scott, Thornhill, Talbott, and Mathis are batting 0.
Let's give Haig credit for knowing Bruce, Velikovsky, Scott, Thornhill, and Talbott belong in the same sentence with Miles Mathis.

What's funny is he thought Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, Einstein, Birkeland, and Alfvén belonged in the same sentence with Miles Mathis.

Haig said:
I don't see a problem with Mathis's logic, reasoning or math and he is right to point to the "holes" in mainstream dogma.
It does require a certain degree of mathematical sophistication to realize pi is not actually equal to 4...

...just as it requires a considerable degree of scientific illiteracy to believe Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, and Einstein should be grouped with one of the more prolific crackpots of our generation.

To his credit, Sol88 seems not to have endorsed Haig/Mathis.

The second by ferd burfle:

Looks like you didn't read very closely, Haig. From your link above:

The volume of the model yields a mean density of 470 ± 45 kg/m3 when combined with the mass, 1.0 × 1013 kg, determined by the Radio Science Investigation (RSI) instrument​

That's a density of 0.47 Haig. Nowhere near that of rock. You and Sol asked for more data and there it is. Until you have a good explanation for this, discussing any other new data is useless. Pro tip: speculating that Newtonian gravity doesn't apply to comets is a fail, as are non-existent electrostatic effects.

Arm-waving and obfuscation in 3, 2, 1...
ferd's post is dated 23rd January 2015.

It does seem odd that it has taken Sol88 ~3.5 years to get around to posting a few words about how the density of a comet should be estimated, using the ELECTRIC COMET model (I note that by calling it a "model" Sol88 is explicitly contradicting David Talbott, who insisted that it be called a "hypothesis"; however, by using "model", Sol88 has - per David Talbott - explicitly signed up to doing calculations and making quantitative estimates).

I also note that, to his credit, Sol88 has started to discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model recently; in that old thread my impression is that he spent almost every post pointing to what he thought were inconsistencies in "the mainstream" explanations of various cometary phenomena, and deploying the "so the ech MUST be right!" card.
 
Great post, Sol88! :thumbsup:

From what I've read of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), as posted by you in this thread, I don't see any way to estimate what the charges on any comet will be, at any point in their orbits, from "first principles" shall we say. Nor have you presented anything that looks as if it could be used to estimate the charge on Rosetta, at any point in its orbit.

But the good news is that you should be able to estimate a range for what the charge differences will be! :jaw-dropp

How?

Here's my suggestion:
1) Start with acknowledging that Rosetta and 67P could have the same charge (i.e. both either negative or both positive) or opposite charges
2) Obtain an estimate of the volume of 67P; from your library of papers that you've cited in this thread, this should be a piece of cake
3) From this, estimate the mass of 67P assuming it to be solid rock; pick a range of densities to include most likely compositions; you'll get a range
4) Using "Newton's law" and "Coulomb's law", derive an expression for q1q2, assuming the force due to the latter is a fraction of the former, say "f". If you need help with this, holler; we're here to help you
5) Derive what q1q2 must be (a range) for the estimated density to be 0.5 (say), assuming that estimated density is derived from "Newton's law" alone
6) Present us with the result (as well as your working)! :)

You may find that the work Harvey and Bridgman did, as presented in sources which I'm sure you're all too familiar with, helpful. Note that you do NOT have to follow their method(s).


Sol88, you are the one defining, promoting, and defending the ELECTRIC COMET model (not me).

I cannot tell how to apply "Newton's law" and "Coulomb's law" in the case of Rosetta and 67P, within the framework of the ELECTRIC COMET model; you are the only ISF member active here who can.

So, let's see you use the ELECTRIC COMET model to estimate q1q2 (a range)! :)


Great thats it!!!:D

Now to complicate things the nucleus and Rosetta are both - & + charged at the same time in a Sunlight/shadow/wake interaction.

Rosetta is + charged on the sunlit side and negative in the wake/shadow. I believe this is what RPC-LAP observed, tusenfem?

Now the nucleus is polarised. This is an effect of a strong ambipolar electric field (my call, they are current carrying double layers), caused by the charge separation of the super sonic solar wind plasma, via it’s eccentric orbital motion. The nucleus is sunlit a few 10’s of Volts positive and ‘000 volts negitve in the shadows/wake. These electric fields along the terminators are strong enough to cause microscopic Coulomb's explosions, “chipping” at the different types of rock present causing the production of ultra fine dust.

Some of this dust will be very fragile electrostatic aggregates, some will be bits of the rock minus any water content. The Coulomb explosions should be energetic enough to flash heat some of the minerals. The electric fields should totally dissociate any material and form fine structured filamentary jets accelerating the negatively charge dust away from the nucleus.

Some of these electric fields along the terminators at times and more likely at more energetic comets, may enter arc mode, these should be connected to outbursts.

Now we should be able to do a little averaging or something but we can make a good estimate of the charge on Rosetta and the distance to the nucleus, we can then estimate mass via compact particle density of around round number for now, 2.0g/cm3. Buckley’s and none on the 80% porosity. :)

That should be enough parameters to find the charge or capacitance of the nucleus.

How do I do that?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom