Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
MHD IS NOT VALID FOR COMETS.

We have just been thru all this and I was proven correct.

Wrong. You have never been right about anything, dear. Eh? Even Alfven says you are wrong. And he only had access to the AMPTE and Halley data. However, he knew that comets were composed of water ice, eh? Unlike you loons.
So, what is your problem with Alfven? Think he was a liar? A bit stupid in the head?
Spell it out, woo boys; love to hear it.
 
The quote where he said it was his greatest error?

MHD is not valid at comet.

This paper is from 2017 Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Sorry, jd116.

Have another go.

Or better still, is MHD valid at a comet jd116?
 
MHD is not valid at comet.

This paper is from 2017 Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Sorry, jd116.

Have another go.

Or better still, is MHD valid at a comet jd116?

Errr, and so what? What is this doing to turn non-rock into rock? How is it turning rock into water? Or carbon dioxide? Or carbon monoxide? How is it creating ice? How is it excavating ice from an impact into a comet.............. I could go on, but it is pointless debating somebody with the IQ of a rabbit. So, I'll leave it there. Let's see some science, woo boy.
 
Errr, and so what? What is this doing to turn non-rock into rock? How is it turning rock into water? Or carbon dioxide? Or carbon monoxide? How is it creating ice? How is it excavating ice from an impact into a comet.............. I could go on, but it is pointless debating somebody with the IQ of a rabbit. So, I'll leave it there. Let's see some science, woo boy.

Well you were wrong, again.

:D
 
Fully kinetic plasma effects are valid at a comet!

Sorry...again jd116.

Let's be honest, Sol; you don't know crap about plasma physics. Eh? Not qualified? Never even been to Uni? Trying to tell a real plasma physicist about stuff that you are clueless about? Give it up. We are not impressed. Deary me. Go away.
 
Well you were wrong, again.

Really? Where, woo boy? Discovered rock, have we? Discovered discharges in the data have we? Lol. Go away. You are boring, on top of being scientifically illiterate. Very sad.
 
Just in case Sol would prefer the written word, rather than a very easy to understand table, I quote the following:

In the present epoch magnetohydrodynamic effects are not important for the motion of the big celestial bodies (planets, satellites and also asteroids) but are still influencing the evolution of comets and, of course, the state of the magnetospheres (including the heliosphere) and ionospheres.

From Cosmic Plasma, Alfven, 1981. P110.

Not that I think it is all that important about what Alfven thought in the 1980s with regard to comets. His most important contribution to cometary science came in 1957, with his paper 'On the Theory of Comet Tails'.
However, EUists seem to hang on his every word. Except when he contradicts their beliefs. Such as nuclear fusion powering the Sun.
 
Can’t copy and paste?

You’ve already said how big the simulation box was.

Are you saying there all neutralised by then?

Shall we keep playing?

How far from the nucleus do the charges neutralise?

Please try to think about this. Why would someone make claims that are not supported by their simulations?
 
The quote where he said it was his greatest error?

We have gone through this discussion about Alfven's comment in at least two threads here (maybe even in this thread). Try to remember something that has been explained to you.
 
Just in case Sol would prefer the written word, rather than a very easy to understand table, I quote the following:



From Cosmic Plasma, Alfven, 1981. P110.

Not that I think it is all that important about what Alfven thought in the 1980s with regard to comets. His most important contribution to cometary science came in 1957, with his paper 'On the Theory of Comet Tails'.
However, EUists seem to hang on his every word. Except when he contradicts their beliefs. Such as nuclear fusion powering the Sun.

I mean that’s a great history lesson for some of the newer lurkers here but for completeness you should add his response to the over all concept of the “frozen in” magnetic field line or the maths behind it in MHD.

From a 1986 paper Double Layers and Circuits in Astrophysics

Abstract:
As the rate of energy release in a double layer with voltage ΔV is P ≈ IΔV, a double layer must be treated as a part of a circuit which delivers the current I. As neither double layer nor circuit can be derived from magnetofluid models of a plasma, such models are useless for treating energy transfer by means of double layers. They must be replaced by particle models and circuit theory

but for scope...

An absolutely scorching, hot off the press 2017 paper ????

To date, the focus of modeling studies to predict and explain the complex cometary plasma observations has been on magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) or multifluid [14–19] and hybrid (using a kinetic description for the ions but describing the electrons as a massless fluid) [20–26] simulations, leading to comprehensive models for the ion dynamics. A satisfactory explanation for the observed electron dynamics, however, is not yet available.

The bolded sections above, you should pay a great deal of attention to with regard to Alfven’s 50’s and 80‘s papers. I’m sure, as you say, hanging off his every word, if he’d have had access to the latest data...slam dunk the ELECTRIC COMET!

The sentence in italic is where we are at right now, jd116! No mainstream explanation for the observed electron dynamics!

So there’s the history, barring all the banging on I’ve done on double layer and all the other IMPOSSIBLE electric woo bloody woo that is indeed IMPOSSIBLE using MHD :p

So now the electric comet woo woo from ‘ol whoo boy himself is on the cards for just a little more of the complete picture of what a comet is.

Oh nearly forgot to mention again, your error in the application of the math and the misinterpretation of the RSI data has gone and sold you up the creek.

Gravity measurements taken by the orbiting Rosetta spacecraft show the body of comet 67 P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is about 75 percent dust and 25 percent ice all the way through, research published Wednesday shows.

By measuring slight shifts in radio waves transmitted to and from Rosetta, scientists were able to determine how the comet's gravity affected the spacecraft. They found that 67P is a highly porous body with about four times more dust than ice by mass, and twice as much dust as ice by volume.
link

If the true bulk density is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3, the nucleus is composed of mainly nothing with sheds loads of “dust” with some “ice/s??????????????


Oh and could you just ah um... give it a quick spelling and punctuation if you would mate, that’d be bonzer. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
If the true bulk density is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3, the nucleus is composed of mainly nothing with sheds loads of “dust” with some “ice/s??????????????

Correct. And if the density hadn't been as measured, by some impossible unexplained mechanism, then the spacecraft would have crashed. It didn't, ergo the density is as measured.
 
If the true bulk density is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3, the nucleus is composed of mainly nothing with sheds loads of “dust” with some “ice/s??????????????

And you also seem to have overlooked the fact that an appreciable fraction of that dust has a mass of ~ 1 kg/m3.
 
Please try to think about this. Why would someone make claims that are not supported by their simulations?

Please show me up as the goose I am. :D

I didn’t say he didn’t support his own simulations ya muppet. I asked how far from the nucleus the charges got back together, not sure if your playing with a full deck. How old are you now?

Btw his passage was this
Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
not sure if that re establishes quasi neutrality or makes Hydrogen?

No mention of distance I could find but great paper and a bit of cold water over another recent paper!

Even by his own admission the lead author stated
This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.
! :eye-poppi

But then straight into that ‘ol chestnut
Assuming that the solar wind–comet interaction is simply described by the Alfvén draping model (Alfvén 1957)

Field line draping around an active comet was rst described by Alfvén (1957), where the interaction of a strongly outgassing comet with the solar wind magnetoplasma creates a well-established cometary magnetotail, as was observed by ICE at comet 27P/Giacobini–Zinner (Slavin et al. 1986). However, this clear interaction does not take place at an weakly outgassing comet such as 67P. Instead of the expected eld line draping in the XY-plane it was found that on 28 March 2015 the eld line draping was mainly in the YZ-plane (see Fig. 2 in Koenders et al. 2016). This remarkable feature was explained using numerical simulations, which showed that because of the strong deection of the plasma ow near the comet, where the freshly pickedup ions move in the direction of the convective electric eld of the solar wind, the solar wind ions and its magnetic eld move in the opposite direction to maintain momentum balance (Newton's 2nd law), the draping mainly occurs in the YZ-plane (see Fig. 5 in Koenders et al. 2016).
assumed the incorrect model.

And you knew all along about charge separation! That and Together with your playing with a direct answer to my question on how far those + & - are getting together.

If you don’t know ask jd116. He’s been pretty sure they got to much energy to get back together.

Paper might be a dud, along with Y.Skorov’s dust lifting paper, you now the one?

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
 
Last edited:
And you also seem to have overlooked the fact that an appreciable fraction of that dust has a mass of ~ 1 kg/m3.

Completely wrong again champ.


I’m talking about the real dust
Compactanddenseparticleswithbulkdensityconstrainedintherange(1.9±1.1)×103kgm−3
like the rock that it came from
 
Completely wrong again champ.


I’m talking about the real dust like the rock that it came from

No, I'm not wrong. Like me to find the reference? And it is irrelevant anyway. The density (and therefore gravity) is as measured. Otherwise we have a dead spacecraft. QED. This is a really dumb argument.
 
No, I'm not wrong. Like me to find the reference? And it is irrelevant anyway. The density (and therefore gravity) is as measured. Otherwise we have a dead spacecraft. QED. This is a really dumb argument.

Did they not adjust the orbits using thrusters from the perceived gravity anyway?

Why would it crash ya muppet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom