Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I said it’s crap and not valid at a comet (MHD), the “expert” argued black and blue MHD is still valid.

Problem was the “expert” was WRONG!

Hmmm, well he wouldn't be the only one then, would he?

 
Last edited:
So I can’t sit around and wait for the “experts” to tell the plebs how a dirtyiceball works.

No need. We already know. Heat from Sun (proven), sublimation of volatiles (proven), entrains dust and ice (proven). Looks like you're out of a job.
 
So how far from the nucleus did you say before the electrons and ions “get together” per J.Decca’s paper?

So if I predicted cometary plasma double layers, does that mean I can claim the credit for them when they are PROVEN? The internet never forgets.

At the moment YOU still call them Ambipolar electric fields.

Double layers, how long have I been bang’n on about them?

Now, there they are! :thumbsup:

how big is his simulation bix?
 
how big is his simulation bix?

Can’t copy and paste?

You’ve already said how big the simulation box was.

Are you saying there all neutralised by then?

Shall we keep playing?

How far from the nucleus do the charges neutralise?
 
Last edited:
Can’t copy and paste?

You’ve already said how big the simulation box was.

Are you saying there all neutralised by then?

Shall we keep playing?

How far from the nucleus do the charges neutralise?

Playing at what? Playing at being a plasma physicist? When you're actually talking to one? What were your qualifications again? University of Velikovsky BS in BS?
Tell you what; I've done a couple of degrees and what I did when I wanted clarification was to correspond with the lead author. Much easier now than it used to be. Get on it. I'm sure Jan Deca has his email address lurking around somewheres. Want me to ask him, chicken?
 
Playing at what? Playing at being a plasma physicist? When you're actually talking to one? What were your qualifications again? University of Velikovsky BS in BS?
Tell you what; I've done a couple of degrees and what I did when I wanted clarification was to correspond with the lead author. Much easier now than it used to be. Get on it. I'm sure Jan Deca has his email address lurking around somewheres. Want me to ask him, chicken?

Sorry my bad, I thought I HAD asked the expert.

Yup said he knew too but would like to continue playing games.

Do you know, jd116?
 
Do you have any kind of physical evidence to support your ridiculous claim? Perhaps a peer-reviewed paper? Maybe some results from a simple laboratory experiment? Why don't you get the good folks at SAFIRE to knock something together for you?

Take a 100 kg rock! I suggest a dry sandstone! Stick it inside a vacuum comparable to that measured at 2 AU! Establish an electric field of any strength deemed appropriate by your model! Inject a 400 km/s "charge separated" hydrogen plasma (with a density consistent with that measured at 2 AU) over your test rock and measure the EM emissions! Don't forget to also measure the dust and water production generated by your electric discharges! So SIMPLE! So INEXPENSIVE! And yet, no one from the "eu" ever considered doing something like this?

Ya! I know!




I'll wager the results of such a simple experiment will never see the light of day! Eh? Why would a religious organization like Thunderbolts want to stop their gravy train? No doubt, Wally needs a new pair of shoes!

Sol88! Isn't it about time the electric "priests" of your religion started doing some real science?




After all, there will be absolutely no credit for the "eu" if the mainstream figures all this out first! :yikes:

Are we having fun, yet? :D

Sol88! A serious question for you - How much money have you spent on Thunderbolts merchandise?

I know! ..... I know! Never mind!


Great idea!
 
Yup wrong as well, just like Alfven said...and was ignored.

Now the cats out of the bag...

Err, jeez dummy! There is your hero Alfven saying we can use MHD in the coma. Which part of that did your remaining neurons failed to pick up? Hmmm? Spell it out, 10 year old. I love when you out these loons to be Primary School kids. Always a laugh! Need help with the homework, dear? Just ask.
 
Err, jeez dummy! There is your hero Alfven saying we can use MHD in the coma. Which part of that did your remaining neurons failed to pick up? Hmmm? Spell it out, 10 year old. I love when you out these loons to be Primary School kids. Always a laugh! Need help with the homework, dear? Just ask.

Well we can’t use MHD at a comet!

As I said. :D

And was correct :D

Sorry. :rolleyes:
 
Yup wrong as well, just like Alfven said...and was ignored.

Now the cats out of the bag...

Seriously, that just goes to show that the loons who support this electric comet garbage are totally thick. Can't even decipher a table that I spent a good deal of time highlighting and cropping in Photoshop! Thick? Or just dumb? Make your mind up people. Cross between the two, is my punt.
Add Thornhill's IQ to Talbott's? Gives you a brain damaged badger. Eh, Sol? Bit thick aren't they, dear? Science not really their thing, is it, love? Never mind; I have a bridge, in perfect order, that I am willing to sell you at a knockdown price! Send me a PM. Always happy to help.
 
Well it was wrong, ay! As stated by Alfven.

Errrrrr, no. It wasn't woo boy. Read it again. Comprehension (along with maths and science) not really your thing, is it? Want me to quote Alfven from some other papers? Happy to do it.
 
Seriously, that just goes to show that the loons who support this electric comet garbage are totally thick. Can't even decipher a table that I spent a good deal of time highlighting and cropping in Photoshop! Thick? Or just dumb? Make your mind up people. Cross between the two, is my punt.
Add Thornhill's IQ to Talbott's? Gives you a brain damaged badger. Eh, Sol? Bit thick aren't they, dear? Science not really their thing, is it, love? Never mind; I have a bridge, in perfect order, that I am willing to sell you at a knockdown price! Send me a PM. Always happy to help.

What are you on about?

Read very carefully

MHD IS NOT VALID FOR COMETS.

We have just been thru all this and I was proven correct.

Do you hav a point to make?
 
Errrrrr, no. It wasn't woo boy. Read it again. Comprehension (along with maths and science) not really your thing, is it? Want me to quote Alfven from some other papers? Happy to do it.

The quote where he said it was his greatest error?
 
Do you hav a point to make?

You'll find that 'have' has an 'e' on the end of it. As for the rest of it; yep, you are scientifically illiterate. Stop digging. You are way out of your depth. Yes?
 
The quote where he said it was his greatest error?

Comprehension is not your strong point, is it, dear? Did you clock the date of that paper? That would be 1987. Idiot! Seriously, Sol; go away. You are making as big a ....... breast of yourself as you did on BAUT. Yes? Give up. Science really isn't for you, dear. Eh? Lol.
 
Likkle reminder for wooists; when was AMPTE? When were the Halley encounters? When was the table I linked from Alfven from? Do maths, woo boys. Figure it out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom