Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
These electric fields along the terminators are strong enough to cause microscopic Coulomb's explosions, “chipping” at the different types of rock present causing the production of ultra fine dust.

No, they aren't. Figures, please.
 
Now the nucleus is polarised. This is an effect of a strong ambipolar electric field (my call, they are current carrying double layers), caused by the charge separation of the super sonic solar wind plasma, via it’s eccentric orbital motion.

Nope. You just made that up. And why would it not happen to asteroids on eccentric orbits? As I've already mentioned, there is zero science involved with this electric comet nonsense.
 
Sol88 said:
How do I do that?
jd has given you some good advice.

Here's a suggestion (you don't have to accept it, or jd's advice, of course):

As you're totally new to this (mathematics, applying Newton's and Coulomb's laws, estimation, etc) - please correct me if I'm wrong on this - start small and simple.

In physics, you may hear of "spherical cows"; a physicist may treat a cow as spherical. Not because they think cows are, in fact, spherical, but because it's a good "first approximation". Once you understand how spherical cows behave, you can move on to considering more realistic cows.

Your "spherical cow" may be a spherical comet, with a charge of q1; Rosetta is also spherical, with a charge of q2. See how you go using these two first approximations, with Newton's law and with Coulomb's law. Once you're comfortable with this - please share your results! - you may consider how to model something more realistic.

Oh, and have fun! :)
 
How do I do that?

Right, let's test what we already know. I'll use Tom Bridgman's results from here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Let Q be the charge on the comet, and q be the charge on the spacecraft, in Coulombs.
Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10-4 Coulombs2 for Qq.
Therefore, rearranging, we get: Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.

So, we need to find the charge on q (spacecraft). We know the voltage was around -10V, at the time Harvey did his calculation, here:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

So, Harvey gets a capacitance for Rosetta of ~ 1 x 10-9 Farads. If you want to dispute that, you'll need to show why.
So, as Q = CV, then q = 10-9 F x -10V = -10-8 Coulombs.

So, let's get back to Tom's results. As previously shown, Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.
So now we can obtain Q (charge on comet) as being 3.65 x 10-4/ -10-8 = -3.65 x 104 Coulombs.
We now need to convert Coulombs into Volts. We therefore need to estimate the capacitance of 67P. Harvey does this and gets 3 x 10-7 F. That looks accurate to me. The capacitance of a sphere is calculated using the formula 4pi ε0 r,
where ε0 is the electric constant; 8.85418782 × 10-12 m-3 kg-1 s4 A2.

So, as Q = CV, we can obtain the voltage by rearranging to give V = Q/C.

So, V = -3.65 X 104 C/ 3 x 10-7 F = ~ -1.2 x 1011 V.

That is 120 gigavolts! As Harvey mentioned, we might have noticed that!

In Tom's calculations, he uses 2000 km/m3 for the EU claimed density, and 400 kg/m3 for the measured density. The measured density is actually ~ 530 kg/m3, so we can reduce the charge a little bit! Not enough to alter the fact that this kind of voltage is impossible, though.
 
Last edited:
Right, let's test what we already know. I'll use Tom Bridgman's results from here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Let Q be the charge on the comet, and q be the charge on the spacecraft, in Coulombs.
Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10-4 Coulombs for Qq.
Therefore, rearranging, we get: Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.

So, we need to find the charge on q (spacecraft). We know the voltage was around -10V, at the time Harvey did his calculation, here:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

So, Harvey gets a capacitance for Rosetta of ~ 1 x 10-9 Farads. If you want to dispute that, you'll need to show why.
So, as Q =CV, then q = 10-9F x -10V = 10-8 Coulombs.

So, let's get back to Tom's results. As previously shown, Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.
So now we can obtain Q (charge on comet) as being 3.65 x 10-4/ 10-8 = 3.65 x 104 Coulombs.
We now need to convert Coulombs into Volts. We therefore need to estimate the capacitance of 67P. Harvey does this and gets 3 x 10-7 F. That looks accurate to me. The capacitance of a sphere is calculated using the formula 4pi ε0 r,
where ε0 is the electric constant; 8.85418782 × 10-12 m-3 kg-1 s4 A2.

So, as Q = CV, we can obtain the voltage by rearranging to give V = Q/C.

So, V = 3.65 X 104 C/ 3 x 10-7 F = ~ 1.2 x 1011 V.

That is 120 gigavolts! As Harvey mentioned, we might have noticed that!

In Tom's calculations, he uses 2000 km/m3 for the EU claimed density, and 400 kg/m3 for the measured density. The measured density is actually ~ 530 kg/m3, so we can reduce the charge a little bit! Not enough to alter the fact that this kind of voltage is impossible, though.
You may have a typo (or two) jd:

"Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10-4 Coulombs for Qq" If both Q and q are charges (measured in C), then Qq would be C2, wouldn't it?

Anyway, Sol88: understanding what jd has posted will, I think, help you understand how you might go about doing the calculations you're interested in (I say "might" because you are, of course, free to approach this is a different way).
 
You may have a typo (or two) jd:

"Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10-4 Coulombs for Qq" If both Q and q are charges (measured in C), then Qq would be C2, wouldn't it?

True. Tom left it out of his main text, but uses it in the graphic. However, it doesn't alter the outcome of the required charges on the comet. I probably missed a - sign out somewhere, as well.
 
Irrelevant Rosetta & 67P charging to derail from his electric comet insanity

Now to complicate things the nucleus and Rosetta are both - & + charged at the same time in a Sunlight/shadow/wake interaction.
17 July 2018: Irrelevant Rosetta & 67P charging to derail from his electric comet insanity.

What Bridgman and Harvey show is that the comet needs 35 GeV to make its density rock in the in situ measurement which agrees with other measurements that the density is < water.

11 July 2018: Simply lies and more insults to derail from his many comet delusions.
11 July 2018: Yet another lie about Bridgman and Harvey's calculation.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Right, let's test what we already know. I'll use Tom Bridgman's results from here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Let Q be the charge on the comet, and q be the charge on the spacecraft, in Coulombs.
Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10-4 Coulombs2 for Qq.
Therefore, rearranging, we get: Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.

So, we need to find the charge on q (spacecraft). We know the voltage was around -10V, at the time Harvey did his calculation, here:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

So, Harvey gets a capacitance for Rosetta of ~ 1 x 10-9 Farads. If you want to dispute that, you'll need to show why.
So, as Q = CV, then q = 10-9 F x -10V = -10-8 Coulombs.

So, let's get back to Tom's results. As previously shown, Q = 3.65 x 10-4/ q.
So now we can obtain Q (charge on comet) as being 3.65 x 10-4/ -10-8 = -3.65 x 104 Coulombs.
We now need to convert Coulombs into Volts. We therefore need to estimate the capacitance of 67P. Harvey does this and gets 3 x 10-7 F. That looks accurate to me. The capacitance of a sphere is calculated using the formula 4pi ε0 r,
where ε0 is the electric constant; 8.85418782 × 10-12 m-3 kg-1 s4 A2.

So, as Q = CV, we can obtain the voltage by rearranging to give V = Q/C.

So, V = -3.65 X 104 C/ 3 x 10-7 F = ~ -1.2 x 1011 V.

That is 120 gigavolts! As Harvey mentioned, we might have noticed that!

In Tom's calculations, he uses 2000 km/m3 for the EU claimed density, and 400 kg/m3 for the measured density. The measured density is actually ~ 530 kg/m3, so we can reduce the charge a little bit! Not enough to alter the fact that this kind of voltage is impossible, though.

Which gives a voltage on 67P from Q/C of around 35 GIGAVOLTS.


35 or 120 gigavolts, jd116? That's plenty to trip the flux capacitor!

reckon that would be enough 'grunt' to cause electrostatic repulsion on a microscopic scale, liberating "dust" and water from the rock that is the nucleus of comets!

What make you reject his findings?
 
Still cannot understand the insanity of 67P with a voltage of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS

19 July 2018: Still cannot understand the insanity of 67P with a voltage of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS

One last time. Say this voltage attracts protons. The solar wind contains protons. These protons will be attracted to 67P. They will arrive at 67P with energies around 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS. That is protons with energies of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS colliding with
  • the nucleus atoms,
  • the coma atoms,
  • and the Rosetta spacecraft atoms
His insanity of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS creates a weaker Large Hadron Collider (GeV instead of Tev ) :jaw-dropp! The collisions will create particles and anti-particles. Their annihilation will produce distinctive radiation, We do not detect that radiation.

A rational person would have to wonder what the effect would be on the Rosetta spacecraft. I suspect that Rosetta would not be physically destroyed by the collisions. But Rosetta has electronics that could be destroyed by the radiation.
 
Last edited:
What Harvey did not take into account and DOES change is napkin calculation is the following.

The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be significant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric field points radially outward from the nucleus. It might be one of the reasons why close to the nucleus the modelled proton trajectories in Figure 7 depart from the observed velocity vectors. Another e.ect arising from the ambipolar term is a polarisation electric field due to the di.erent motion of the cometary new-born electrons and ions. The gyroradius of the cometary ions can be much larger than the interaction region, itself larger than the cometary electron gyroradius, which induces a charge separation, and in turn a polarisation electric field. This electric field contribution is explored in the analytical work of Nilsson et al. (2018), and results in one additional acceleration of the cometary ions with an anti-sunward component.



Looking at what the nucleus, it could be model as a polarised dielectric sphere whose properties change in conjunction with the variable ambipolar electric field.


this pic of a polarised of dielectric sphere is interesting. Look at those streamline, they look familiar
x6hbtf.jpg


So we can work of few more equations and assumption into the calculation, run that bad boy see what we come up with?

Charge 1 C = Rosetta
Charge2 C = 67P
Force N = known
Distance km = Known

We should get what we are after?
 
Modeling a comet delusions from an ignorant believer in the electric comet insanity

Looking at what the nucleus, it could be model ...
Modeling a comet delusions from an ignorant believer in the electric comet insanity.

Here is a person unable to understand simple arithmetic (0.6 is not 3.0 g/cc) or the physics used to measure comet density, etc. They want to do physics when they have been incapable of understanding physics for 9 years now!
Also: Over 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

A crazy question at the end expecting that people who know how insane his electric comet is to do calculations to support that insanity :jaw-dropp!

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:


Another effect arising from the ambipolar term is a polarisation electric field due to the different motion of the cometary new-born electrons and ions.
The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko E. Behar, H. Nilsson, P. Henri, L. Bercic, G. Nicolaou, G. Stenberg Wieser, M. Wieser, B. Tabone, M. Saillenfest, C. Goetz

It's not magic old mate, just never been applied at a comet!

Polarisation electric field, google it!
 
19 July 2018: Still cannot understand the insanity of 67P with a voltage of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS

One last time. Say this voltage attracts protons. The solar wind contains protons. These protons will be attracted to 67P. They will arrive at 67P with energies around 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS. That is protons with energies of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS colliding with
  • the nucleus atoms,
  • the coma atoms,
  • and the Rosetta spacecraft atoms
His insanity of 35 or 120 GIGAVOLTS creates a weaker Large Hadron Collider (GeV instead of Tev ) :jaw-dropp! The collisions will create particles and anti-particles. Their annihilation will produce distinctive radiation, We do not detect that radiation.

A rational person would have to wonder what the effect would be on the Rosetta spacecraft. I suspect that Rosetta would not be physically destroyed by the collisions. But Rosetta has electronics that could be destroyed by the radiation.

Who came up with 120 GIGAVOLTS?
 
this pic of a polarised of dielectric sphere is interesting. Look at those streamline, they look familiar
[qimg]http://i64.tinypic.com/x6hbtf.jpg[/qimg]

So we can work of few more equations and assumption into the calculation, run that bad boy see what we come up with?

Charge 1 C = Rosetta
Charge2 C = 67P
Force N = known
Distance km = Known

We should get what we are after?

First you should show that that pic indeed describes the situation around a comet. I think you have a false impression of what a polarization electric field is.
You talk about "stream lines" whereas what you see is electric field lines in which a sphere of dielectric material is placed.
 
Last edited:
Who came up with 120 GIGAVOLTS?

Anybody that can do maths will come up with it. Try it.

What Harvey did not take into account and DOES change is napkin calculation is the following.

No, he didn't. It is irrelevant to the calculation. Your lack of knowledge of such things is telling, and is obviously one of the reasons why a vanishingly small number of people believe in this electric comet rubbish. Correct? To believe it requires a staggering ignorance of maths and science. As shown.
 
So we can work of few more equations and assumption into the calculation, run that bad boy see what we come up with?

Errrm, it has been done. Twice, and linked, by people far smarter than you, or anybody else involved with this nonsense. The result shows it to be impossible. Now, go away, and learn some science, yes?
 
So we can work of few more equations and assumption into the calculation,

Which calculation? What equation are you using? Where did you get it from? Show us it, instead of spouting irrelevant nonsense. Just for once.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom