Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The DIRTYSNOWBALL is dead and the mainastream have NO viable alternative!

Is that the best you can do? Parroting the idiot Thornhill? Pathetic. Go away, and spew your inanities on a crank forum.
 
No, you have zilch. No mechanism, no evidence. Intense electric fields not seen. Discharging not seen. Rock not seen. On the other hand, ice is seen on the surface and below it. It is seen to sublimate and entrain dust. Game over.

:rolleyes:

I have charge separation, you (mainstream) have sublimation.

My, (The ELECTRIC COMET) models mechanism is charge separation.

Is there any charge separation around the nucleus of comets, jd116?
 
Is that the best you can do? Parroting the idiot Thornhill? Pathetic. Go away, and spew your inanities on a crank forum.

Aaaaaand the other viable model you are using?

Not the outdated snowball with dust sublimating in the heat of the sun model?

Which one do you use?

Otherwise game on, ‘ol chap!

Dirtysnowball vs ELECTRIC COMET

And

So far yourself and tusenfem have stated unequivocally, the dirtysnowball model is outdated or dead!

So what is it? Can’t bang on about one being out dated and NOT having a viable alternative! :mad:

Now, You can be a spanner chucker if you’d like... but the thats the rules, yeah? :boggled:

One model becomes unviable and a new one is sort? Or do we just keep trying to make hard data fit the fairytale?

The Rosetta mission has confirmed the rocky, electrical nature of comets!
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

I have charge separation, you (mainstream) have sublimation.

My, (The ELECTRIC COMET) models mechanism is charge separation.

Is there any charge separation around the nucleus of comets, jd116?

No, charge separation cannot cause volatiles to sublimate and entrain dust! If you think it can, then point me to the scientific literature that says it can do this. What is this alleged charge separation doing, pray tell, and where do we see it at the surface?
 
The Rosetta mission has confirmed the rocky, electrical nature of comets!

By totally failing to see any rock, or any EDM (lol), or wandering arc discharges (lol) or any other kind of electric woo at the surface. Yep, I can see how well that has gone!
 
No, charge separation cannot cause volatiles to sublimate and entrain dust! If you think it can, then point me to the scientific literature that says it can do this. What is this alleged charge separation doing, pray tell, and where do we see it at the surface?

Only asked if there was any charge separation going on at a comet?

Literature says yes, do you agree?
 
So, where in the EC 'model' are the volatiles coming from, now? Not the solar wind, obviously. Not enough, not reaching the comet for long periods, wrong D/H ratio, and not a viable mechanism anyway. Where are the goalposts now located?
So, from whence springs H2O, CO2, CO, CH4, NH3, etc, etc?
 
So, where in the EC 'model' are the volatiles coming from, now? Not the solar wind, obviously. Not enough, not reaching the comet for long periods, wrong D/H ratio, and not a viable mechanism anyway. Where are the goalposts now located?
So, from whence springs H2O, CO2, CO, CH4, NH3, etc, etc?

Baby steps champ, baby steps.
 
Must of missed that, was that yes or no for charge separation around a comet?

I believe I said that any charge separation would quickly be removed due to an ambipolar field forming to preserve quasi-neutrality. Or words to that effect.
 
I believe I said that any charge separation would quickly be removed due to an ambipolar field forming to preserve quasi-neutrality. Or words to that effect.

Ahhhhh, I see the problem! :rolleyes:

There is electricity in space is just does not do anything!

Again I only needed one mechanism and that, no matter how much you hate it, is CHARGE SEPERATION. :D

Does not matter how quickly this separation is removed, it’s there! :cool:
 
Translation:
"We haven't figured out any alternative woo to explain that yet."

Just as he studiously avoids the questions of Indagator and Jean Tate.

Plenty in the past posts!

Or they could use the search function!

Comets are rocks in the solar plasma flow!

We disagree on the

1. Bulk Density
2. Sublimation

The rest is stock standard garden variety plasma physics!
 
Plenty in the past posts!

Or they could use the search function!

Comets are rocks in the solar plasma flow!

We disagree on the

1. Bulk Density
2. Sublimation

The rest is stock standard garden variety plasma physics!

No, the whole of the scientific world (at least those involved with comets) know what the measured bulk density is. There is no way of changing it.
And sublimation is seen to happen.
So you can disagree all you like, as nobody who knows anything about cometary science is taking any notice.
 
The rest is stock standard garden variety plasma physics!

What is? EDM (lol)? Wandering arc discharges (lol)? Undetectable Coulomb explosions? Undetectable double layers? Solar wind turning into all manner of volatiles? Etc.
There is nothing standard about this Velikovsky inspired non-science.
 
Last edited:
No, the whole of the scientific world (at least those involved with comets) know what the measured bulk density is. There is no way of changing it.

Sol88 disagrees withe density calculations, even though it is elementary math after the mass calculations.

They just repeat the same mindless drivel from the past five years.

No data no evidence.
 
It seems that ALICE measurements shows that the ratio of O2/H2O is much higher than that inferred from the ROSINA measurements.

Putting another nail into the coffin of the Yao & Giapis mechanism.

It should be mentioned that Yao & Giapis have a reply to Heritier et al:

Reply to “On the origin of molecular oxygen in cometary comae”
Yao, Y. & Giapis, K. P.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04943-w#article

They seem to concede that the surface mechanism is a non-starter. However, in what looks like a pretty lame attempt to keep their mechanism alive, they postulate that water ions impinging on the spacecraft, in particular the solar panels, could cause O2 to end up being detected by Rosina.
As I say, this looks pretty lame, and they probably should have just conceded without reply.
As Tusenfem notes above, ALICE also detected the oxygen. Y & G may claim that what they are seeing is influenced by a shed load of the stuff generated at the spacecraft (as in a reply to an email from me). That seems highly suspect to me. The ALICE team would have to answer for themselves, but the lead author of the paper linked by Tusenfem has another in preparation, for which there is only a conference abstract at the moment:

Stellar Occultation by Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Observed with the R-Alice Ultraviolet Spectrograph
Keeney, B. A. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017DPS....4950908K

The significance of that is the sentence:

We find that both the H2O column density and the relative O2/H2O abundance decrease with increasing impact parameter, in accordance with expectations.

The impact parameter is the distance between the line of sight and the nucleus. This was increasing as the two observations were made. It is therefore very difficult to see how the environment around the spacecraft could have shown a decreasing amount of O2 relative to water, in ten minutes, if the ALICE team were being fooled by O2 produced in the close vicinity of the spacecraft. For all the world, it looks like they were indeed observing the molecules close to the nucleus.

ETA:
I'm guessing that by ""in accordance with expectations", above, Keeney et al expect O2 to become ionised more rapidly than H2O.
 
Last edited:
Sol88 disagrees withe density calculations, even though it is elementary math after the mass calculations.

They just repeat the same mindless drivel from the past five years.

No data no evidence.

Oh, it'll be something to do with charged dust woo affecting the radio signal! Unfortunately for them, two spacecraft landed on the surface, and one of them was in a number of bound orbits over two years. Kind of hard to miss an error of a factor of 4-6 in the density when you are doing that!
 
:rolleyes:

I have charge separation, you (mainstream) have sublimation.

My, (The ELECTRIC COMET) models mechanism is charge separation.

Is there any charge separation around the nucleus of comets, jd116?

then it is about time you actually show evidnce, the necessary data can be found on psa and pds

expectantly looking forward to your data analysis

your's truly
tusenfem
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom