Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I no longer believe that we are discussing the official EU electric comet woo. I think it has morphed into Sol88's electric comet woo. All this nonsense about hydrated minerals and coulombic explosions doesn't appear to come from Thornhill, or anything I've seen on Dunderdolts, Hollowscience or in the electric comet woo pdf.
Here is what I think has happened; Thornhill and Talbott, not being very good at science, and getting pretty much all their material from press releases, didn't realise that the solar wind was known to be not getting anywhere near the nucleus since 1986. Earlier, if you throw in the AMPTE experiments, and even earlier than that from theory. A theory which Alfven agreed with, by the way.
So, the woo merchants have come up with this idiocy about solar wind H+ combining with non-existent O-, to form OH. A dumb idea already. They also failed to realise that what had been detected on multiple occasions since 1986 wasn't just OH, but H2O. So, when these things, which were easily researchable, have been pointed out in places like this, they start to panic, and make up a whole lot more woo to try to cover their embarrassment. Now we've got coulombic explosions and hydrated minerals! Because they are also starting to realise that the spectra of the jets is purely that of reflected sunlight, rather than electric discharge woo. As shown in the 'sunset' jets, for instance, which can only be seen when they emerge from shadow into sunlight, proving that they are not intrinsically lit. And, of course, they are now starting to also realise that there is no rock. Something that should have been bleedin' obvious from the Tempel 1 impact.
They also seemed to be totally ignorant of the solid ice excavated by that impact, and of that in the CO2 jets at Hartley 2.
So, they've gone into a real tail-spin of woo-making to try to account for stuff that has been known for years (decades, in some cases). Which just goes to show that not only are they crap at science, but research skills are not high on their list of abilities, either.

ETA:
I guess I should also add to the above the fact that they didn't appear to know quite how many asteroids had comet-like orbits, as pointed out most recently by indagator. And, for what it's worth, a fair number of those asteroids will have hydrated minerals on their surface. Oh yeah, and the D/H ratio of cometary water not matching that of solar wind H. I could go on, I suppose, but it's cruel to kick a silly idea when it's already dead.

So, Sol, I was correct, yes? Just woo added to woo, as the idiots who dreamed up this garbage are confronted with facts that they already should have known?
 
Sorry my bad, thought we’d detected OH around comets. :rolleyes:

We do. You just didn't bother to research at what distance from the nucleus it is found. MIRO and VIRTIS see H2O from the surface up. OH needs time to be dissociated from the water. The average time against a water molecule becoming dissociated by UV? About 106 seconds.

EDIT:
Actually, that is the time against ionisation! Probably longer to get OH and H.
 
Last edited:
Nope, we see dust entrained by neutral gas moving away from the nucleus. Sometimes including solid ice particles. We also see the surface and subsurface ice from which the gas sublimates. Ever heard of Occam's razor? It especially applies when one method is confirmed, and the other is a scientifically impossible bunch of junk, with zero evidence for it. Fail.

You’ve got the cart before the horse there champ. ;)

What you do in fact see is the intense applied electric fields machining the dust types observed, from the various rock types.

This dust has been observed to be negatively charged, both as compact particles in the range densities for rock, along with clusters of highly porous particles. This has reinforced the misinterpretation of the RSI data.

The nucleus is observed to rather “dustier’ than expected. This dust takes on the visual and spectral appearance of certain classes of asteroids.

These are KNOW to be...rock.

Now I believe one of the very first “surprises” was the Deuterium ratio and that, at least this family of comets, did not bring water to Earth.

But asteroids did? :boggled:

Now the conundrum is, if they(comet) where blown off already formed “wet” planets, say like Mars when it had it’s oceans back when AND entrained some of that water as ice.

How do you tell the difference between that and that of the fairytale of comets being the left overs from the CREATION of the solar system and that they also contain ice?
 
Much like the neutrals too.:rolleyes:

No, we observe acceleration AWAY from the nucleus! In jets of machined dust from Coulomb explosions of the rocky nucleus from intense applied electric fields before being accelerated AWAY and into the coma!

Please show me the data that clearly show that there are "coulomb explosions" because the should most definitely have a signature in the RPC data.
 
Please show me the data that clearly show that there are "coulomb explosions" because the should most definitely have a signature in the RPC data.

You do? Don’t you?

Resolution of RPC instruments good enough to see to microscopic scale?

The combined over all effect is what we observe with all of Rosetta’s instruments.
 
Last edited:
It would appear that Soll88 fails the Turing test.
Same garbage over and over without actual dialogue and conversation

Hey DD!

Long time no see, you may have missed of few of the new papers.

What’s your take on charge separation of the solar wind wrt comet 67P?

Perhaps you’d like to jump back in?
 
You’ve got the cart before the horse there champ. ;)

What you do in fact see is the intense applied electric fields machining the dust types observed, from the various rock types.

This dust has been observed to be negatively charged, both as compact particles in the range densities for rock, along with clusters of highly porous particles. This has reinforced the misinterpretation of the RSI data.

The nucleus is observed to rather “dustier’ than expected. This dust takes on the visual and spectral appearance of certain classes of asteroids.

These are KNOW to be...rock.

Now I believe one of the very first “surprises” was the Deuterium ratio and that, at least this family of comets, did not bring water to Earth.

But asteroids did? :boggled:

Now the conundrum is, if they(comet) where blown off already formed “wet” planets, say like Mars when it had it’s oceans back when AND entrained some of that water as ice.

How do you tell the difference between that and that of the fairytale of comets being the left overs from the CREATION of the solar system and that they also contain ice?

Pure crap. You've gone full Thornhill mode. No science, just woo and word salad. In fact, if you need a new name for Dunderdolts, might I suggest 'Woo & Word Salad'? It has a ring to it, and is accurate.

Now I believe one of the very first “surprises” was the Deuterium ratio and that, at least this family of comets, did not bring water to Earth.

Back in the day, yes. Would have made things easier for you lot as well. Could then claim the comet was blasted off of Earth. Obviously wasn't. Nor Mars. And it doesn't come from any sort of solar wind woo. And wherever it formed was extremely cold, based on the N2 that was detected.

These are KNOW to be...rock.

I know asteroids are rock. We keep telling you that. However, comets definitively, provably and demonstrably, are not. So, dumb argument.

This has reinforced the misinterpretation of the RSI data.

How has dust getting charged in the coma got anything to do with the density measurement? Really dumb argument. Not been in touch with the idiot Thornhill, have you? This has got his mealy-mouthed, unscientific stench all over it. All mouth, no trousers.

The nucleus is observed to rather “dustier’ than expected. This dust takes on the visual and spectral appearance of certain classes of asteroids.

Not particularly. And the loon Thornhill told us there would be no dust, due to it all being somehow electrostatically removed. Another failure.

What you do in fact see is the intense applied electric fields machining the dust types observed, from the various rock types.

Nope, no electric fields seen on the nucleus, and no machining. Lol. As Tusenfem said, that would stick out like a sore thumb. Remember, Philae and Rosetta landed on this thing.

What we see, when we look at jets, is neutral gas entraining dust and sometimes ice. We see some of the ice from which it comes on the surface. We also know that it is subsurface. From the Tempel 1 impact, and from cliff collapses exposing boulders formed of ice, investigated spectroscopically on 67P.
In short, we don't need any idiotic woo from Velikovskian nutjobs to explain anything about comets. We know what's happening to very good accuracy, and we have the evidence to prove it. You have nothing other than the made up fantasies of fruit loops.
 
Last edited:
You do? Don’t you?

Resolution of RPC instruments good enough to see to microscopic scale?

The combined over all effect is what we observe with all of Rosetta’s instruments.

Jesus H, Christ. Coulomb explosions! Lol. Who came up with that crap? I can't believe it was you, Sol. Somebody needs to own up to this idiocy, and stop poor old Sol taking the blame!
 
I no longer believe that we are discussing the official EU electric comet woo. I think it has morphed into Sol88's electric comet woo. All this nonsense about hydrated minerals and coulombic explosions doesn't appear to come from Thornhill, or anything I've seen on Dunderdolts, Hollowscience or in the electric comet woo pdf.

<snip>

The only ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) we can discuss, realistically, is whatever Sol88 says is that model. After all, there's no one else here who claims to be able to speak to it (in a positive way).

From my perspective, it's a pity that Sol88 seems extremely reluctant to focus, to address quantitative aspects, etc.
 
Plenty OH as well tied up in the rock, mainly the clays.

If we wind the clock back some what and ask the question “if the ice was incorporated into what is the nucleus, where did that water come from?”

Do you know, jd116?

I’d wager ya a fiver EM is involved and a comet will just be a low powered version of what happens around other celestial objects. :D

Could add that to the list as well JT! Cheers.
Also, if the Thunderbolts team are on the money with the whole comets (& Asteroids) are the debris, left over from an earlier epoch of solar system wide planetary orbital disruptions causing stupendous plasma phenomena witnessed by Homo sapiens world wide and recorded in myth and religion, then water would not be unexpected!

Does not mean comets are ice sublimating in the warmth of the Sun, taking the overall form of a dirtysnowball “melting”.
(my hilite)

All in good time, Sol88, all in good time.

First, how about you answer my questions? Should I repeat them for you?
 
Well, it looks like Tusenfem and I were right:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12166520&postcount=1376
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12166520&postcount=1377

On the origin of molecular oxygen in cometary comae
Heritier, K. L. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04972-5

Mind you, you didn't need to be a genius to figure it out.

thanks for the link, it was not yet sent around to our mailing list
 
More than 1060 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, insults, and lies from 6 July 2009 to 27 June 2018

There is no point in keeping track of each of Sol88 lies now. He is just insanely* lying about just about everything, e.g. ices and dust comet papers.
* a popular definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. Repeating a fantasy that double layers have been detected at comets and getting the consistent response that is wrong fits that definition. Repeating that comets are rock and getting the responses their density has been measured to be less than water and other evidence that they are ices and dust fits that definition.

Another 53 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 3 July 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Over 4 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
A lie that the Thunderbolts cult comet origin insanity produces the observed water

..., then water would not be unexpected!
4 July 2018: A lie that the Thunderbolts cult comet origin insanity produces the observed water in comets

He knows that the ejecta from the impact on Tempel 1 was 1/6 water. His delusion of rock being blasted from the Earth in recent times produces molten rock with the composition of terrestrial rocks (not asteroids, not the comet dust grains that we have) containing only the water already bound into the rock. No or tiny amounts of water expected.
 
An admitted "wacky nut job question" to derail from his many comet delusions

Another wacky nut job question....
4 July 2018: An admitted and insane "wacky nut job question" to derail from his many comet delusions.
Insane because he knows that:
  • Comets travel through the solar wind but the solar wind does not reach comet nuclei after the coma forms,.
    This is nothing to do with his many comet delusions.
  • Real comets probably charge to the minor degree of lifting and transporting dust.
    This is does not support any of his many comet delusions.
  • The real solar electric field is tiny and does not do what the deluded Thunderbolts cult demands it do.
    This is does not support any of his many comet delusions.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom