Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
An insane citation of models of planets stopping migrating billions of years ago

Why impossible woo?
4 July 2018: A triply insane citation of models of gas planets stopping migrating billions of years ago.

The main insanity is that this is the nebula hypothesis that results in the mainstream, evidence based formation of comets.

The Grand Tack and Nice models show that Jupiter, etc. migrate due to their gravitational interaction with the early solar system gas disk and later "a remnant planetesimal disk and with each other".

The migration in the models ends ~3.8 billion years ago :jaw-dropp!

The Thunderbolts comet origins insanity is that rocky planets (Mercury, Venus, Mars and of course Earth :eye-poppi) whizz around the Solar System to be record by us in myths so in the last few 10s of thousand years. Physics makes this not even wrong. Earth being magically exempt from the whizzing around makes it insane.

"]A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE GRAND TACK AND NICE MODELS (PDF)
 
Last edited:
A lying citation of a "Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind ..." paper

So what’s happening here?

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Jan Deca
4 July 2018: A lying question and citation of a "Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet" paper
No double layer or ambipolar electric fields in his quote.
 
Stupidity of repeating his delusions and lies as if that makes then true

What you do in fact see ...
4 June 2018: Stupidity of just repeating his delusions and lies and adding to them as if that makes them true.

Lies about ice and dust grain observations making comets into rock.

An insanely ignorant delusion of comets being blown off say Mars when their orbits originate beyond Jupiter, they have a large % of water (not the about zero from molten rock), etc.

A stupid delusion that science (the nebula hypothesis) is a fairy tail.
 
A lie that Coulomb explosions are produced by imaginary "inrtense" electric fields

... from Coulomb explosions of the rocky nucleus from intense applied electric fields...
4 July 2018: A lie that Coulomb explosions are produced by his delusions of "intense applied electric fields"

He has known for a long time that the electric fields around comets are measured to be very small (volts per kilometer from memory).

Coulomb explosions are produced by lasers.
Coulomb explosion is a mechanism for coupling electronic excitation energy from intense electromagnetic fields into the atomic motion. The Coulombic repulsion of particles having the same electric charge can break the bonds that hold solids together. When done with a narrow laser beam, a small amount of solid explodes into a plasma of ionized atomic particles. It may be shown that the Coulomb explosion occurs in the same critical parameter regime as the superradiant phase transition i.e. when the destabilizing interactions become overwhelming and dominate over the native oscillatory phonon solid cluster binding motions which is also characteristic for the diamond synthesis.

tusenfem asked for evidence of the Coulomb explosions that would be in the RPC data and got a "microscopic scale" delusion.
 
Last edited:
Abysmal ignorance about Mars and the Thunderbolt cult comet origin insanity

...if they(comet) where blown off already formed “wet” planets, say like Mars when it had it’s oceans back when AND entrained some of that water as ice.
4 July 2018: Abysmal ignorance about Mars and the Thunderbolt cult comet origin insanity.

That "back when" was millions of years ago when humans did not exist and his cult's insanity include humans witnessing the imaginary blasts.
 
You do? Don’t you?

I do what?

Resolution of RPC instruments good enough to see to microscopic scale?

Such "coulomb explosions" from the surface, emitting jets, would hardly be "microscopic" in their EM signature.

The combined over all effect is what we observe with all of Rosetta’s instruments.

If that is so, please show us examples in the data.
 
Well, it looks like Tusenfem and I were right:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12166520&postcount=1376
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12166520&postcount=1377

On the origin of molecular oxygen in cometary comae
Heritier, K. L. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04972-5

Mind you, you didn't need to be a genius to figure it out.

It seems that ALICE measurements shows that the ratio of O2/H2O is much higher than that inferred from the ROSINA measurements.

Putting another nail into the coffin of the Yao & Giapis mechanism.
 
It seems that ALICE measurements shows that the ratio of O2/H2O is much higher than that inferred from the ROSINA measurements.

Putting another nail into the coffin of the Yao & Giapis mechanism.

Actually, I mentioned that very paper in a follow-up email to Giapis! He replied:

I recommend you write to the ROSINA team for their opinion of the discrepancy with the ALICE measurement. You’ll be amused.

How much O2 is there?
Yao: <0.1% on comet, but more on Rosetta
Fougere: 1-2% (modeling)
Bieler: 1-10% (4% avg)
Keeney: 11-68% (25% avg)
Feldman: 50% (in bursts)
Who to believe?

Before you ponder this any further, make sure you appreciate what “density" means in a rarified environment.

Why do you believe that the ALICE measurements support a source in, on, or near the nucleus? The ALICE UV absorption measurement is an integrated column density measurement. Inferring where O2 is produced in that column is not straightforward, it requires extreme care: angular deviations from the Rosetta-Nucleus Line is one way to point out an O2 source on the nucleus (Keeney’s impact parameter dependence?) but even this method cannot prove unambiguously that O2 is produced at the nucleus when there is a directional source of O2 on Rosetta.

We now have proof that Rosetta is releasing O2 itself (the subject of the correspondence) in the direction of the nucleus. Do you see a reason why such molecules will not be in the columns measured by ALICE?

Keeney also reports some other interesting trends, e.g., that their O2 measurements with impact parameter (Fig.9) suggest an extended source of O2 rather than a point source on the nucleus. This contradicts the ROSINA team. Is it consistent with an O2 source at Rosetta?

The OI lines are from atomic O emissions. Atomic O is an entirely different story, unrelated to O2. I highly recommend you read the paper by Bodewits et al.—who includes 4% O2 produced on the nucleus and still cannot explain the OI intensity near the comet.

This may be a good project for you, a balanced view of all these observations and claims. Of course, you’ll need replies from all parties and some diplomatic skills.

Cheers,
KPG
 
I do what?



Such "coulomb explosions" from the surface, emitting jets, would hardly be "microscopic" in their EM signature.



If that is so, please show us examples in the data.


Lovely in Amsterdam this time of year!

So how is the dust being liberfrom the rock?
 
Last edited:
Lovely in Amsterdam this time of year!

So how is the dust being liberfrom the rock?

Huh? Not content with inventing science, you are now inventing words?
Anyways, it is irrelevant what it means, as there is no rock. As observed.
 
Lovely in Amsterdam this time of year!

So how is the dust being liberfrom the rock?

Clearly no answer again

We have already discussed that your friend skorov probably worked with wrong numbers

And yes the weather is great in Graz
 
Huh? Not content with inventing science, you are now inventing words?
Anyways, it is irrelevant what it means, as there is no rock. As observed.

Sorry sorry, I meant liberating dust down to the microscopic scale from the LAYERED, CONSOLIDATED, REFRACTORY BEDROCK that is the rocky looking nucleus of ALL comet visited thus far.

So basically we are down to this? Is is not ROCK?

We have charge separation, applied electric fields, polarised nucleus, electric squirrels, beams/jets, ... etc etc you know kinetic plasma effects :D

So know we can focus back onto the “jets” the defining feature of a comet.

Sumblimation from an icy/dusty nucleus forming jets from rough topography ?

Or

Intense electric fields “machining” rock (including hydrated minerlas) into dust?


Let the future tell the truth, and evaluate each one according to his work and accomplishments. The present is theirs; the future, for which I have really worked, is mine. Nikola Tesla
 
Huh? Not content with inventing science, you are now inventing words?
Anyways, it is irrelevant what it means, as there is no rock. As observed.

Sorry sorry, I meant liberating dust down to the microscopic scale from the LAYERED, CONSOLIDATED, REFRACTORY BEDROCK that is the rocky looking nucleus of ALL comet visited thus far.

So basically we are down to this? Is is not ROCK?

We have charge separation, applied electric fields, polarised nucleus, electric squirrels, beams/jets, ... etc etc you know kinetic plasma effects :D

So know we can focus back onto the “jets” the defining feature of a comet.

Sumblimation from an icy/dusty nucleus forming jets from rough topography ?

Or

Intense electric fields “machining” rock (including hydrated minerlas) into dust?


Let the future tell the truth, and evaluate each one according to his work and accomplishments. The present is theirs; the future, for which I have really worked, is mine. Nikola Tesla
 
So basically we are down to this? Is is not ROCK?

No, you are down to that. Any sensible person can see from the scientific results that it isn't rock.

Intense electric fields “machining” rock (including hydrated minerlas) into dust?

What intense electric fields? Where are they? Where are their signatures? They don't exist, and you have no mechanism for your silly woo.

Still batting zero.

Let the future tell the truth, and evaluate each one according to his work and accomplishments.

Thornhill & Talbott: accomplishments? Zero. Enough said.
 
What intense electric fields? Where are they? Where are their signatures? They don't exist, and you have no mechanism for your silly woo.

no mechanism?

I only needed the one mechanism. :thumbsup:

And it’s CONFIRMED :D

The rest will just fall into place...

The DIRTYSNOWBALL is dead and the mainastream have NO viable alternative!

Unless there is a secret model no one knows about.
 
Last edited:
no mechanism?

I only needed the one mechanism. :thumbsup:

And it’s CONFIRMED :D

The rest will just fall into place...

The DIRTYSNOWBALL is dead and the mainastream have NO viable alternative!

Unless there is a secret model no one knows about.

No, you have zilch. No mechanism, no evidence. Intense electric fields not seen. Discharging not seen. Rock not seen. On the other hand, ice is seen on the surface and below it. It is seen to sublimate and entrain dust. Game over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom