Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Charge separation has no basis in physics?

It isn't happening. And it has nothing to do with the electric comet woo, or the observed sublimation from the nucleus, or the density of the comet, or the total lack of any scientifically impossible electric discharge woo observed. TRY AGAIN.
 
Me ‘ol chestnut, the diamagnetic cavity is back on the table now kinetic plasma effects are in play!

A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Sounds pretty much like a Langmuir sheath!

Problem is, even though they use a multi fluid plasma approach they;
I can see the error here!

The Rosetta probe flew, more or less, along the boundary of this sheath and the sheath responded to the changing solar wind, compressing and expanding in response to the increased electrical stress. This would propagate thru the rest of the double layers as they respond to the electrical potential change until all layers accomodate the new environment...which changes on very quick timescales and very small spatial scales!

CMEimpact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Mmmmm......

Give it up Sol. Science is obviously beyond you. The solar wind was nowhere near the DC. There are no DLs. Stop making crap up. What electrical stress? What the hell is electrical stress? Go look at the Halley data. O nT in that cavity. Where is your discharge woo?
 
So she might of made, like me ‘ol,mate Harvey, a slip up!

'Might HAVE'. English not one of your strong points either, is it? Tell me - did you ever attend any kind of educational institution? Which includes primary school, by the way.
So, show us where in the equations used by Harvey (and Newton & Coulomb) that the plasma environment needs to be accounted for. Which term would this be, and how does it affect the result? How does this match up with the results from Philae at the surface? Or Rosetta down to the surface?
 
All right let’s see if we can help our friend J. Agarwal,

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03



So let’s first look at pressurized sub-surface gas reservoir/s. The data from CONCERT would seem to disprove this postulate.

Ok, what about the crystallization of amorphous water ice? Seems like a bit of a long shot, at best.

Now if there where an intense applied electric field that discharged to the layer above that via charged dust jet...

that is just dropping comments
please start real data analysis, otherwise there is no point for discussion
unless you can put in actual proof/data that shows you ideas have even a hint of realism, it is just dropping comments
what is intense? how intens? would that be feasible? what is observed? where are your data?
 
'Might HAVE'. English not one of your strong points either, is it? Tell me - did you ever attend any kind of educational institution? Which includes primary school, by the way.
So, show us where in the equations used by Harvey (and Newton & Coulomb) that the plasma environment needs to be accounted for. Which term would this be, and how does it affect the result? How does this match up with the results from Philae at the surface? Or Rosetta down to the surface?

Really jd116?

Harvey assumed the nucleus was charged and only required his kettle to discharge the whole comet.

Bit simplistic and his fancy maths a good attempt at polishing a turd :D
 
Me ‘ol chestnut, the diamagnetic cavity is back on the table now kinetic plasma effects are in play!

A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Sounds pretty much like a Langmuir sheath!

Problem is, even though they use a multi fluid plasma approach they;
I can see the error here!

The Rosetta probe flew, more or less, along the boundary of this sheath and the sheath responded to the changing solar wind, compressing and expanding in response to the increased electrical stress. This would propagate thru the rest of the double layers as they respond to the electrical potential change until all layers accomodate the new environment...which changes on very quick timescales and very small spatial scales!

CMEimpact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Mmmmm......

rpc is awaiting with great interest the first draft of your paper
have you already decided which journal?
 
Though here at jref with you as my reviewer?

See who pinch’s my ideas!
 
Really jd116?

Harvey assumed the nucleus was charged and only required his kettle to discharge the whole comet.

Bit simplistic and his fancy maths a good attempt at polishing a turd :D

SO SHOW WHERE HE WAS WRONG. MATHEMATICALLY.
You can't can you? Nor how Tom Bridgman independently came up with the same equation, some months before. Plug the numbers into Tom's result in the first post here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Guess what? You get the same answer. Two PhDs, different areas, same equation, same result. Stop talking crap, and do the maths.
 
Last edited:
Harvey assumed the nucleus was charged..............

No, the EU idiots assumed it was charged, and that it was therefore cancelling out 80% of the gravity. Harvey and Tom merely show that this is complete garbage.
 
Let me clear something up here for the hard of thinking;
Sol appears to think some sort of charged dust woo interfered with the RSI measurements of the density of 67P. So, for the sake of argument, let's say it did. Was that the only measurement made of the density? Pretend that the RSI results were off by a factor of four. What would then happen when you actually plot a bound orbit based on those measurements? Crash, would be the word. So, every time Rosetta orbited this comet, particularly in bound orbits, it was confirming the RSI measurements. So, the wooists need a mechanism to explain how an object with a density of > 2000 kg/m3 could mimic one with a density of ~ 500 kg/m3.
So, what is that mechanism? Charging up the comet obviously doesn't work, as shown. Anything else?
 
Last edited:
Let me clear something up here for the hard of thinking;
Sol appears to think some sort of charged dust woo interfered with the RSI measurements of the density of 67P. So, for the sake of argument, let's say it did. Was that the only measurement made of the density? Pretend that the RSI results were off by a factor of four. What would then happen when you actually plot a bound orbit based on those measurements? Crash, would be the word. So, every time Rosetta orbited this comet, particularly in bound orbits, it was confirming the RSI measurements. So, the wooists need a mechanism to explain how an object with a density of > 2000 kg/m3 could mimic one with a density of ~ 500 kg/m3.
So, what is that mechanism? Charging up the comet obviously doesn't work, as shown. Anything else?

Regarding the bolded, then the following paper is of interest:

A homogeneous nucleus for comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko from its gravity field
Pätzold, M. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16535

From the abstract:

The mass and gravity field are derived from measured spacecraft velocity perturbations at fly-by distances between 10 and 100 kilometres. The gravitational point mass is GM = 666.2 ± 0.2 cubic metres per second squared, giving a mass M = (9,982 ± 3) × 109 kilograms. Together with the current estimate of the volume of the nucleus, the average bulk density of the nucleus is 533 ± 6 kilograms per cubic metre.

Which is what I was saying above.
 
Last edited:
So, when it comes to the density of the nucleus, what is the evidence available?

Mainstream:
We smashed an impactor into a comet. The crater was too big to have been made in rock.
We used radio science experiments at 67P, continually, as the spacecraft successfully completed orbits based on the measured gravity (and therefore density).
We tested the thermal inertia of the material with MIRO.
We tested the thermal inertia with the MUPUS-PEN.
We hammered on it with MUPUS, and used the speed of the resulting sound waves to characterise the strength.
We sent radio signals through the small lobe in the CONSERT experiment.
The list is not necessarily complete.

Electric comet woo:
It looks like rock in the piccies.
It was hard.
Wal & Dave say it was blasted off a planet by electric woo.
 
So, when it comes to the density of the nucleus, what is the evidence available?

Mainstream:
We smashed an impactor into a comet. The crater was too big to have been made in rock.
We used radio science experiments at 67P, continually, as the spacecraft successfully completed orbits based on the measured gravity (and therefore density).
We tested the thermal inertia of the material with MIRO.
We tested the thermal inertia with the MUPUS-PEN.
We hammered on it with MUPUS, and used the speed of the resulting sound waves to characterise the strength.
We sent radio signals through the small lobe in the CONSERT experiment.
The list is not necessarily complete.

Electric comet woo:
It looks like rock in the piccies.
It was hard.
Wal & Dave say it was blasted off a planet by electric woo.

Electric comet woo:
A rock causes ions and electron to seperate via various methods.
The rock is charged
Kinetic plasma effects are at play in/on/around AND away from the nucleus.
It looks like rock in the piccies.
It was hard.
Wal & Dave say it was blasted off a planet by electric woo.
 
SO SHOW WHERE HE WAS WRONG. MATHEMATICALLY.
You can't can you? Nor how Tom Bridgman independently came up with the same equation, some months before. Plug the numbers into Tom's result in the first post here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Guess what? You get the same answer. Two PhDs, different areas, same equation, same result. Stop talking crap, and do the maths.

Garbage in, garbage out.

Maths is spot on otherwise.

He’s wrong when he said the nucleus would be completely discharged in short order!

same as YOU and your charge separation canceling in short order, you are WRONG me ‘ol mate! :D

This is not a happening at comets because their ELECTRIC! :thumbsup:

Charge separation = kinetic plasma effects ;)

Game over for your, self admitted, out dated dirty snowball model!

And

Since you, the mainstream, have NO alternative model...you’re going to need some more paddles!
 
Let me clear something up here for the hard of thinking;
Sol appears to think some sort of charged dust woo interfered with the RSI measurements of the density of 67P. So, for the sake of argument, let's say it did. Was that the only measurement made of the density? Pretend that the RSI results were off by a factor of four. What would then happen when you actually plot a bound orbit based on those measurements? Crash, would be the word. So, every time Rosetta orbited this comet, particularly in bound orbits, it was confirming the RSI measurements. So, the wooists need a mechanism to explain how an object with a density of > 2000 kg/m3 could mimic one with a density of ~ 500 kg/m3.
So, what is that mechanism? Charging up the comet obviously doesn't work, as shown. Anything else?

It mimics it by the nucleus being polarised!

The dust is a red herring on your behalf, though it is important for the charge equalisation mechanism.

The nucleus, unfortunately for Tom and Harvey, does not come into the inner solar system all charged up until reaches some arbitrary point then completely discharges with a piss weak current!

So again maths is correct, their assumptions are completely WRONG!

Even Einstein has got his grubby little mitts in here as well.
 
Last edited:
SO SHOW WHERE HE WAS WRONG. MATHEMATICALLY.
You can't can you? Nor how Tom Bridgman independently came up with the same equation, some months before. Plug the numbers into Tom's result in the first post here:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet

Guess what? You get the same answer. Two PhDs, different areas, same equation, same result. Stop talking crap, and do the maths.

Just read Toms post, thought so.

And of course there's the persistent question about Electric Universe models that remain unanswered:

1. How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?

2. Where's the battery or generator that maintains the potential between the comet nucleus and the solar wind?

1.it doesn’t. It only maintains a potential difference thru it’s orbital motion, See 2.

2. Charge seperation, see 1.

So, maybe you’d like to get in touch with Tom Bridgeman and inform him he was incorrect in his assumptions!

:D
 
Last edited:
I’d estimate in the range of the compact dust particles detected by GIADA.

This would also reflect in the ROCKY LOOKING consolidated refractory bedrock material!

So without dragging the same ‘ol out again, here’s the summary jt;

I believe there is an error in the interpretation of the RSI data, leading to a very low bulk density questimate.

The nucleus is a charged object, the Rosetta spacecraft is also charged, both negatively.

The very small repulsive force is being misinterpreted as very small gravitational force.

Easy to see how’d you’d mix ‘em up. ;)
So, you cannot answer my simple, straightforward questions?

Or, maybe, you can, but choose not to?

Please note: I did not ask for your interpretations; why, may I ask, did you provide them rather than just answer the questions?
 
Garbage in, garbage out.

Maths is spot on otherwise.

He’s wrong when he said the nucleus would be completely discharged in short order!

same as YOU and your charge separation canceling in short order, you are WRONG me ‘ol mate! :D

This is not a happening at comets because their ELECTRIC! :thumbsup:

Charge separation = kinetic plasma effects ;)

Game over for your, self admitted, out dated dirty snowball model!

And

Since you, the mainstream, have NO alternative model...you’re going to need some more paddles!

Oh dear. This uneducated idiot is telling people how to understand science! Lol. Sol, do you know what a wa***r is? If you don't, can I suggest that a mirror would be a good place to start? For those with an IQ below 70ish, Sol is that loon. Science really isn't his thing.
 
Just read Toms post, thought so.



1.it doesn’t. It only maintains a potential difference thru it’s orbital motion, See 2.

2. Charge seperation, see 1.

So, maybe you’d like to get in touch with Tom Bridgeman and inform him he was incorrect in his assumptions!

:D

Thick or what? Didn't do maths at the infant school you went to, eh, dickh**d?
Bit beyond you, isn't it dear? Bit thick, aren't we?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom