Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
then it is about time you actually show evidnce, the necessary data can be found on psa and pds

expectantly looking forward to your data analysis

your's truly
tusenfem

Thank you for your words of encouragement, tusenfem.

Now, one may start by looking at any data that’s “anomalous” to the data expected from the old out of data dirtysnowball model and see if kinetic plasma efffects might better explain the observation.

I’d start, personally, with any particles , both -&+, gaining or losing energy.

Now let’s looky looky ;)
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your words of encouragement, tusenfem.

Now, one may start by looking at any data that’s “anomalous” to the data expected from the old out of data dirtysnowball model and see if kinetic plasma efffects might better explain the observation.

I’d start, personally, with any particles , both -&+, gaining or losing energy.

Now let’s looky looky ;)

And what would any of that have to do with the observed fact that gas is seen to be entraining dust from the nucleus? Or that the comet is observed not to be rock? Or that no electric woo is detected at the surface? Or that the density of comets is nothing like rock? Or that asteroids with comet like orbits don't behave like comets? Etc, etc.
Sorry, no amount of gish-galloping is going to change the fact that the electric comet woo is a busted flush.
 
<snip>

We disagree on the

1. Bulk Density

<snip>

In the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), what is the bulk density of 67P? Of Temple-1? What do the many papers on 67P, etc, say is the estimated bulk density?
 
Thank you for your words of encouragement, tusenfem.

Now, one may start by looking at any data that’s “anomalous” to the data expected from the old out of data dirtysnowball model and see if kinetic plasma efffects might better explain the observation.

I’d start, personally, with any particles , both -&+, gaining or losing energy.

Now let’s looky looky ;)

whatever you like
keep us informed on what data you use, and brief to the point reports on your analysus methods
 
In the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), what is the bulk density of 67P? Of Temple-1? What do the many papers on 67P, etc, say is the estimated bulk density?

I’d estimate in the range of the compact dust particles detected by GIADA.

This would also reflect in the ROCKY LOOKING consolidated refractory bedrock material!

So without dragging the same ‘ol out again, here’s the summary jt;

I believe there is an error in the interpretation of the RSI data, leading to a very low bulk density questimate.

The nucleus is a charged object, the Rosetta spacecraft is also charged, both negatively.

The very small repulsive force is being misinterpreted as very small gravitational force.

Easy to see how’d you’d mix ‘em up. ;)
 
whatever you like
keep us informed on what data you use, and brief to the point reports on your analysus methods

All right let’s see if we can help our friend J. Agarwal,

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03

The high dust mass production rate is incompatible with the free sublimation of crystalline water ice under solar illumination as the only acceleration process. Additional energy stored near the surface must have increased the gas density. We suggest a pressurized sub-surface gas reservoir, or the crystallization of amorphous water ice as possible causes.

So let’s first look at pressurized sub-surface gas reservoir/s. The data from CONCERT would seem to disprove this postulate.

Ok, what about the crystallization of amorphous water ice? Seems like a bit of a long shot, at best.

Now if there where an intense applied electric field that discharged to the layer above that via charged dust jet...
 
I’d estimate in the range of the compact dust particles detected by GIADA.

This would also reflect in the ROCKY LOOKING consolidated refractory bedrock material!

So without dragging the same ‘ol out again, here’s the summary jt;

I believe there is an error in the interpretation of the RSI data, leading to a very low bulk density questimate.

The nucleus is a charged object, the Rosetta spacecraft is also charged, both negatively.

The very small repulsive force is being misinterpreted as very small gravitational force.

Easy to see how’d you’d mix ‘em up. ;)

So, let's see the maths/ data. What would the charge on the comet need to be to mimic a density of ~ 500 kg/m3, when it is really > 2000 kg/m3? This has been done elsewhere. Trust me, it would rip the comet apart, not to mention anything that landed on it . It is a non-scientific argument. Try again.
 
So, let's see the maths/ data. What would the charge on the comet need to be to mimic a density of ~ 500 kg/m3, when it is really > 2000 kg/m3? This has been done elsewhere. Trust me, it would rip the comet apart, not to mention anything that landed on it . It is a non-scientific argument. Try again.

Even I can pick that math apart. :D
 
Easy to see how’d you’d mix ‘em up.

Only if one was scientifically illiterate. What was the charge on the comet? Philae landed on it. As did Rosetta. What did they measure? Well, no magnetic field, for a start, and the fact that they weren't fried shows that there must be very little charge. If there was a huge negative charge, why don't we see it? What would happen to a bare rock in the solar wind with a huge negative charge? Lots of ions would be attracted to it, wouldn't they? And what would that do?
Sorry, but this is just more unscientific claptrap from woo central. Go do some real science, Sol, and show us the maths, and the implications, and the matching observations. Until you can do that, you are talking complete cobblers. Just like your buddy Wal.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure if Jean Tate was around the last time I posted this, and it would appear to be right up her street:

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04...comment-432278

The calculation by Prof. Harvey Rutt of the necessary charges involved for the EU woo to be true. Now, perhaps JT would like to check the equation, input parameters etc. And Sol can do the same. And then we might be doing some science, instead of woo and word salad.
I believe I said that any charge separation would quickly be removed due to an ambipolar field forming to preserve quasi-neutrality. Or words to that effect.

This is what you believe, so...

Which gives a voltage on 67P from Q/C of around 35 GIGAVOLTS.
Now I rather think we might have noticed that!
Or, if you prefer 67P to be five times heavier, multiply by five………….
(The only way to reduce that is to increase the Rosetta potential; rock & a hard place. And if you do reduce it, the problem below gets worse.)
Also, despite this insane voltage, 67P only has a charge of 10^4 Coulombs.
So a pathetically weak 1A discharge (recall, my kettle takes 13A…) would discharge it completely in just under three hours; so not only would the ‘discharges’ stop, the electrostatic force would go away.
Now of course I still might have slipped up somewhere, if so please feel free to correct the above.

Ergo

This would happen, no electric comet :(

But

We have charge separation happening dynamically around a charged nucleus as it plows head long into the solar wind. :D

Now if he’d added kinetic plasma effects that we ALL know, now, ha-ppen around comets and he redid his sums...

So smarter people than me may have looked at this but if they believe the same as you wrt charge separation then yeah, nuff’n would happen!
So yeah, ‘ol Harvey slipped up! :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
whatever you like
keep us informed on what data you use, and brief to the point reports on your analysus methods

Ok from J. Agarwal and her mates paper Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03


We have discussed two possible forms of such energy storage (a pressurized cavity and near-surface amorphous ice), but the viability of these propositions will have to be tested by future in-depth thermal models and comparison to a larger data set.
and found to be complete...forced fitted into an out of date model.

(xii) We conclude that the release of energy stored in the subsurface must have supported the acceleration of dust.

No where in her paper is charged dust mentioned...:blush:

Did she not know about Rosetta’s negative charge?


So she might of made, like me ‘ol,mate Harvey, a slip up!
 
Last edited:
And pigs will fly before you actually do. You know better than to attempt an argument based on math. Prose provides endless opportunity for equivocation, your stock-in-trade.

Better grab your brolly, ‘cos here come those pigs. ;)

Maths is crap if your assumptions are the same!

SISO!

So without even lifting a decimal place, you can see where he turned left, instead of right!

So the assumption should now be, kinetic plasma effects are in play!

So, go have fun with your maths, especially if you like the real hard complicated stuff!

Or you could use the best approximation math, MHD, see how that turns out! :)
 
Last edited:
then it is about time you actually show evidnce, the necessary data can be found on psa and pds

expectantly looking forward to your data analysis

your's truly
tusenfem

Me ‘ol chestnut, the diamagnetic cavity is back on the table now kinetic plasma effects are in play!

Our simulation results show that an increase of the electron pressure, introduced by a parametrized local electron heating process, leads to an ambipolar electric field that is strong enough to push out the cometary ions and create a magnetic field-free region.
A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Sounds pretty much like a Langmuir sheath!

Problem is, even though they use a multi fluid plasma approach they;
Because we assume charge neutrality, snip...

.Here,the Hall velocity and the ambipolar electric field are neglected snip....
I can see the error here!

The Rosetta probe flew, more or less, along the boundary of this sheath and the sheath responded to the changing solar wind, compressing and expanding in response to the increased electrical stress. This would propagate thru the rest of the double layers as they respond to the electrical potential change until all layers accomodate the new environment...which changes on very quick timescales and very small spatial scales!

CMEimpact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Mmmmm......
 
Last edited:
no mechanism?

I only needed the one mechanism. :thumbsup:

And it’s CONFIRMED :D

The rest will just fall into place...

The DIRTYSNOWBALL is dead and the mainastream have NO viable alternative!

Unless there is a secret model no one knows about.

This is a false dichotomy. Even if you could show that conventional physics theories about comets is wrong, it would not make EU theories right. Especially not when they can be shown to have no basis in physics.
 
This is a false dichotomy. Even if you could show that conventional physics theories about comets is wrong, it would not make EU theories right. Especially not when they can be shown to have no basis in physics.

Charge separation has no basis in physics?
 
This is what you believe, so...



Ergo

This would happen, no electric comet :(

But

We have charge separation happening dynamically around a charged nucleus as it plows head long into the solar wind. :D

Now if he’d added kinetic plasma effects that we ALL know, now, ha-ppen around comets and he redid his sums...

So smarter people than me may have looked at this but if they believe the same as you wrt charge separation then yeah, nuff’n would happen!
So yeah, ‘ol Harvey slipped up! :thumbsup:

What a complete load of crap! That merely shows your scientific illiteracy. You need a charge on the comet to cancel out 80% of the mass. It has been worked out. It is ludicrous. Kinetic plasma effects have NOTHING to do with the calculation. TRY AGAIN.
 
Ok from J. Agarwal and her mates paper Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03


and found to be complete...forced fitted into an out of date model.



No where in her paper is charged dust mentioned...:blush:

Did she not know about Rosetta’s negative charge?


So she might of made, like me ‘ol,mate Harvey, a slip up!

More scientifically illiterate garbage. Of course she knows about the charge on Rosetta. Why is it affecting this outburst and not others?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom