Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12346962&postcount=3126
Excactly what it says?

Excactly what it says?

Last edited:

How would you know? You follow loons who think that Earth used to orbit Saturn, among other impossible woo!
...snipped.
So mainstream do NOT have a valid model, tusenfem?
That’s the currently accepted model, the outdated 1950’s Whipple model, no?
What IS needed is an AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELD, set up from the CHARGE SEPERATION from the solar wind!
Aaaaannnnd AGAIN not needed!
Double layer, double layer...or as you’d like to call them ambipolar electric fields!
Not even a diamagnetic cavity!!
What IS needed is an AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELD, set up from the CHARGE SEPERATION from the solar wind!
JD said:Aaaannd, the solar wind is nowhere near the comet when it is most active. Again.
Charge separation of the solar wind confirmed , check!
Ambipolar electric fields confirmed , check!
Electric Currents confirmed, check!
Is there an ambipolar electric field centred on the nucleus?
Also, if the Thunderbolts team are on the money with the whole comets
This sentence could not be more wrong.
We observe a spatial separation of the cometary electrons with respect to the cometary ions, and of the solar wind electrons with respect to the solar wind protons. Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
Wait a minute, first you say
And now you say to JD's comment:
the SW is not needed?
What is it, Sol88?
The ambipolar electric field is created by ions and electrons flowing out, the electrons faster than the ions, thereby creating an electric field which slows down the electrons and accelerates the ions, i.e. the ions are pulled along by the electrons.
There is no acceleration towards the nucleus, so no EDM or whatever other weird EC stuff is happening.
So now you got this, probably even quantitatively, so do something with it.
Apparently you do not read fully the literature you like to quote mine
Plenty OH as well tied up in the rock, mainly the clays.
I’d wager ya a fiver EM is involved and a comet will just be a low powered version of what happens around other celestial objects.
Another wacky nut job question for you jd116, us ELECTRIC COMET mob state a comet is a charged object, moving thru the solar electric field immersed in a supersonic quasi neutral plasma flow.
Would you agree or disagree with this statement, jonesdave116, tusenfem for what it’s worth?
Or which point in the above is the wacky nut job part?
All right, I proposed based on the latest data comets are an electrical discharge phenomena!
![]()
Electric fields are! This electriclay stress’s the rock releasing dust, once the Coulomb forces become too great!
Double layers, transforming capacitors!
No, we observe acceleration AWAY from the nucleus! In jets of machined dust from Coulomb explosions of the rocky nucleus from intense applied electric fields before being accelerated AWAY and into the coma!
And you have no method to get it out, and water is seen close to the nucleus, not OH. Fail.
Low powered version of what? Lol. Where is your EDM? Hahahaha. Fail.