Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh oh oh, any charge seperation at comet, jd116?

I’d just like to hear you say again...
 
The electric comet woo is puerile, unscientific nonsense, dreamed up by scientifically illiterate Velikovskian loons. Correct?

And what the hell has an ambipolar field got to do with volatiles sublimating from the surface. How many times have I asked this? Answer.

What volatiles on the surface?

We see rock.
 
So how do those “jets” work in this new mainstream model?

Sublimating ice?

That’s the dirty snowball model, the now outdated model.

What model might “conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.”

What mainstream model is that?

Have you got a alternative model jd116, tusenfem?

Or you just trolling?

The stupid around here hurts sometimes. Sublimation of ice is SEEN. Understand? No electric woo is seen in the jets, or anywhere on the nucleus. Your woo is dead. Try to comprehend that.
 
What volatiles on the surface?

We see rock.

Somebody close this thread. This poster is merely trolling now.
For the intellectually challenged; THERE IS NO ROCK. How many times?
There are plenty of volatiles seen on the surface. And from the subsurface. As linked to dozens of times.
 
Christ, what is wrong with you? How is a frigging non-existent DL making water? ANSWER.

Any H- detected at comets?

Any OH+?

Any O2?

There is basically stuff going on both mainstream and the EC mob will find surprising.

But simpletons prefer simple explanations, like comets being melting ice cubes!
 
Any H- detected at comets?

Any OH+?

Any O2?

There is basically stuff going on both mainstream and the EC mob will find surprising.

But simpletons prefer simple explanations, like comets being melting ice cubes!

See what I mean about the stupid around here? There was a tiny amount of H- from the solar wind. Which is getting nowhere near the comet around perihelion. And the only way you are getting OH is from H2O! As it happens, the H2O is seen from 0 metres from the nucleus and up.
 
I no longer believe that we are discussing the official EU electric comet woo. I think it has morphed into Sol88's electric comet woo. All this nonsense about hydrated minerals and coulombic explosions doesn't appear to come from Thornhill, or anything I've seen on Dunderdolts, Hollowscience or in the electric comet woo pdf.
Here is what I think has happened; Thornhill and Talbott, not being very good at science, and getting pretty much all their material from press releases, didn't realise that the solar wind was known to be not getting anywhere near the nucleus since 1986. Earlier, if you throw in the AMPTE experiments, and even earlier than that from theory. A theory which Alfven agreed with, by the way.
So, the woo merchants have come up with this idiocy about solar wind H+ combining with non-existent O-, to form OH. A dumb idea already. They also failed to realise that what had been detected on multiple occasions since 1986 wasn't just OH, but H2O. So, when these things, which were easily researchable, have been pointed out in places like this, they start to panic, and make up a whole lot more woo to try to cover their embarrassment. Now we've got coulombic explosions and hydrated minerals! Because they are also starting to realise that the spectra of the jets is purely that of reflected sunlight, rather than electric discharge woo. As shown in the 'sunset' jets, for instance, which can only be seen when they emerge from shadow into sunlight, proving that they are not intrinsically lit. And, of course, they are now starting to also realise that there is no rock. Something that should have been bleedin' obvious from the Tempel 1 impact.
They also seemed to be totally ignorant of the solid ice excavated by that impact, and of that in the CO2 jets at Hartley 2.
So, they've gone into a real tail-spin of woo-making to try to account for stuff that has been known for years (decades, in some cases). Which just goes to show that not only are they crap at science, but research skills are not high on their list of abilities, either.

ETA:
I guess I should also add to the above the fact that they didn't appear to know quite how many asteroids had comet-like orbits, as pointed out most recently by indagator. And, for what it's worth, a fair number of those asteroids will have hydrated minerals on their surface. Oh yeah, and the D/H ratio of cometary water not matching that of solar wind H. I could go on, I suppose, but it's cruel to kick a silly idea when it's already dead.

All that is true, isn't it Sol? Embarrassing!
 
There is basically stuff going on both mainstream and the EC mob will find surprising.

How would you know? You follow loons who think that Earth used to orbit Saturn, among other impossible woo!
Everything we know about comets has been a surprise for the EU nutjobs, as none of the missions have turned up a single jot of evidence for their nonsense. Which, given that it is scientifically impossible, is not surprising. Well, not to anyone that understands science, anyway.
 
See what I mean about the stupid around here? There was a tiny amount of H- from the solar wind. Which is getting nowhere near the comet around perihelion. And the only way you are getting OH is from H2O! As it happens, the H2O is seen from 0 metres from the nucleus and up.

Plenty OH as well tied up in the rock, mainly the clays.

If we wind the clock back some what and ask the question “if the ice was incorporated into what is the nucleus, where did that water come from?”

Do you know, jd116?

I’d wager ya a fiver EM is involved and a comet will just be a low powered version of what happens around other celestial objects. :D

Could add that to the list as well JT! Cheers.

Also, if the Thunderbolts team are on the money with the whole comets (& Asteroids) are the debris, left over from an earlier epoch of solar system wide planetary orbital disruptions causing stupendous plasma phenomena witnessed by Homo sapiens world wide and recorded in myth and religion, then water would not be unexpected!

Does not mean comets are ice sublimating in the warmth of the Sun, taking the overall form of a dirtysnowball “melting”.
 
Last edited:
How would you know? You follow loons who think that Earth used to orbit Saturn, among other impossible woo!
Everything we know about comets has been a surprise for the EU nutjobs, as none of the missions have turned up a single jot of evidence for their nonsense. Which, given that it is scientifically impossible, is not surprising. Well, not to anyone that understands science, anyway.

Another wacky nut job question for you jd116, us ELECTRIC COMET mob state a comet is a charged object, moving thru the solar electric field immersed in a supersonic quasi neutral plasma flow.

Would you agree or disagree with this statement, jonesdave116, tusenfem for what it’s worth?

Or which point in the above is the wacky nut job part?


:whistling
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom