Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Charge separation of the solar wind confirmed , check!
Ambipolar electric fields confirmed , check!
Electric Currents confirmed, check!

So which part are we still struggling with jd116?

What? How does that explain anything? How are you making water? Where is your EDM (lol)? Wandering arc discharges (oh dear!). Rock (double lol)?
You have zero scientific mechanisms, and zero evidence. Now go away. Your woo is dead.
 

What? Look at the table in the paper. What is the amount, by mass, of H2O In the clay? How are you getting it out? To what temperature are you heating it? How much would you need to process to get ~ 1000 kg/s at 67P? What is the maximum it could contribute to the water vapour at Tempel 1? How are you turning it into ice?
Go do some science, and figure out why this is a really dumb idea. Wasn't one of Thornhill's, was it?
 
So mainstream do NOT have a valid model, tusenfem?

That’s the currently accepted model, the outdated 1950’s Whipple model, no?
Sol88, this is getting very tiresome.

The topic of this thread is the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

If you really want to discuss something else, why not start a thread on it?

Is it too much to ask that you stick to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)?
 
Because it’s FATAL to a fluffy dust ball or to tusenfems oudated model of comets!
Sol88, this is getting very tiresome.

The topic of this thread is the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

If you really want to discuss something else, why not start a thread on it?

Is it too much to ask that you stick to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)?

The nucleus is composed of homogeneous consolidated refractory material with an organic coating!

ROCK :boggled:
And what is its density?

And where are the hydrated minerals?

The carbonates?

Why do you keep dodging my simple questions, Sol88?
 
;)

And YOU don’t see a problem, jd116, Jean tate, tusenfem, rc and any lurkers?

Hydrated minerals??? Very controversial!!!! :confused:

<stuff irrelevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) snipped>
And the density of ROCK composed of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron is ...?

And that density is what, ~equal to that of 67P? greater than that of 67P? less than that of 67P?
 
wiki

Nope still the same story!

Another source



Pretty much verbatim!

How about NASA, they know there stuff!



Nope still dirty Snowballs!

Where would a kid wanting to find out about comets go for the REAL information, jd116?
And the density of ROCK composed of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron is ...?

And that density is what, ~equal to that of 67P? greater than that of 67P? less than that of 67P?
 
A lie that any paper says comets are rock

Because ...
3 July 2018: A lie that any paper says comets are rock.

Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Thermal and mechanical material properties determine comet evolution and even solar system formation because comets are considered remnant volatile-rich planetesimals. Using data from the Multipurpose Sensors for Surface and Sub-Surface Science (MUPUS) instrument package gathered at the Philae landing site Abydos on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, we found the diurnal temperature to vary between 90 and 130 K. The surface emissivity was 0.97, and the local thermal inertia was 85 ± 35 J m(-2) K(-1)s(-1/2). The MUPUS thermal probe did not fully penetrate the near-surface layers, suggesting a local resistance of the ground to penetration of >4 megapascals, equivalent to >2 megapascal uniaxial compressive strength. A sintered near-surface microporous dust-ice layer with a porosity of 30 to 65% is consistent with the data.
 
More insanity on hydrated minerals in the Deep Impact ejecta that included water

And YOU don’t see a problem, jd116, Jean tate, tusenfem, rc and any lurkers?
3 July 2018: More insanity on hydrated minerals in the Deep Impact ejecta that included water ice and gas.

Spitzer Spectral Observations of the Deep Impact Ejecta (PDF) Lisse, C. et al.
Table 2 lists water ice and gas as well as phyllosilicates ("hydrated silicates") and other minerals.
 
More lying about ices and dust papers to derail from his many comet delusions

The MANY papers now, that call the rocky looking comets nucleus consolidated (as opposed to “fluffy”) refractory (not “ice/s”) material?
3 July 2018: More lying about ices and dust papers to derail from his many comet delusions.
Lies because of "rocky looking" and "fluffy". Comet nuclei are ices and dust. Comet nuclei are held together by gravity and other forces, i.e. are consolidated ices and dust.
Papers on the refractory material portion of ices and dust comets are obviously about the refractory material portion :eye-poppi

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Usual lie about Whipple's model

You know, from Whipples outdated model! :D
3 July 2018: Usual lie about Whipple's model
Whipple's model being updated (not outdated) does not support any insane delusions about comets. Essentially the only thing that has changed is the ratio if ices and dust in an average comet.
 
I no longer believe that we are discussing the official EU electric comet woo. I think it has morphed into Sol88's electric comet woo. All this nonsense about hydrated minerals and coulombic explosions doesn't appear to come from Thornhill, or anything I've seen on Dunderdolts, Hollowscience or in the electric comet woo pdf.
Here is what I think has happened; Thornhill and Talbott, not being very good at science, and getting pretty much all their material from press releases, didn't realise that the solar wind was known to be not getting anywhere near the nucleus since 1986. Earlier, if you throw in the AMPTE experiments, and even earlier than that from theory. A theory which Alfven agreed with, by the way.
So, the woo merchants have come up with this idiocy about solar wind H+ combining with non-existent O-, to form OH. A dumb idea already. They also failed to realise that what had been detected on multiple occasions since 1986 wasn't just OH, but H2O. So, when these things, which were easily researchable, have been pointed out in places like this, they start to panic, and make up a whole lot more woo to try to cover their embarrassment. Now we've got coulombic explosions and hydrated minerals! Because they are also starting to realise that the spectra of the jets is purely that of reflected sunlight, rather than electric discharge woo. As shown in the 'sunset' jets, for instance, which can only be seen when they emerge from shadow into sunlight, proving that they are not intrinsically lit. And, of course, they are now starting to also realise that there is no rock. Something that should have been bleedin' obvious from the Tempel 1 impact.
They also seemed to be totally ignorant of the solid ice excavated by that impact, and of that in the CO2 jets at Hartley 2.
So, they've gone into a real tail-spin of woo-making to try to account for stuff that has been known for years (decades, in some cases). Which just goes to show that not only are they crap at science, but research skills are not high on their list of abilities, either.

ETA:
I guess I should also add to the above the fact that they didn't appear to know quite how many asteroids had comet-like orbits, as pointed out most recently by indagator. And, for what it's worth, a fair number of those asteroids will have hydrated minerals on their surface. Oh yeah, and the D/H ratio of cometary water not matching that of solar wind H. I could go on, I suppose, but it's cruel to kick a silly idea when it's already dead.
 
Last edited:
What? How does that explain anything? How are you making water? Where is your EDM (lol)? Wandering arc discharges (oh dear!). Rock (double lol)?
You have zero scientific mechanisms, and zero evidence. Now go away. Your woo is dead.

Is there an ambipolar electric field centred on the nucleus?

We conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.

You also seem to forget this is a “low activity comet”!

So go play in your sand box with the other kiddies who believe in fairytales!

No matter which way you cut it, Whippels model is dead!

Sorry if the ELECTRIC COMET was all too complex for you, jd116. :blush:
 
Now, what was that other model for comets, jd116?

Here’s your chance to really show this dumb arse up to all the lurkers here jd116, why don’t you seal the deal?

What model do the mainstream use?

Or do the mainstream just ad lib?
 
So how do those “jets” work in this new mainstream model?

Sublimating ice?

That’s the dirty snowball model, the now outdated model.

What model might “conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.”

What mainstream model is that?

Have you got a alternative model jd116, tusenfem?

Or you just trolling?
 
Is there an ambipolar electric field centred on the nucleus?



You also seem to forget this is a “low activity comet”!

So go play in your sand box with the other kiddies who believe in fairytales!

No matter which way you cut it, Whippels model is dead!

Sorry if the ELECTRIC COMET was all too complex for you, jd116. :blush:

The electric comet woo is puerile, unscientific nonsense, dreamed up by scientifically illiterate Velikovskian loons. Correct?

And what the hell has an ambipolar field got to do with volatiles sublimating from the surface. How many times have I asked this? Answer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom