Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
No it’s DOGMA!

You know, from Whipples outdated model! :D

No, it is observation and measurement. And the only people who think scientists still adhere to Whipple's 1950 model, are complete idiots, and liars. Such as Thornhill, et al.
 
Aaaannd, the solar wind is nowhere near the comet when it is most active. Again.

Aaaaannnnd AGAIN not needed!

Double layer, double layer...or as you’d like to call them ambipolar electric fields!

Not even a diamagnetic cavity!! :D
 
No, it is observation and measurement. And the only people who think scientists still adhere to Whipple's 1950 model, are complete idiots, and liars. Such as Thornhill, et al.

Please point me to the new model, jd116.

Link will do, I’ve missed the memo, obviously . :p

We conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.
Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Hot off the press!
 
Last edited:
Aaaaannnnd AGAIN not needed!

Double layer, double layer...or as you’d like to call them ambipolar electric fields!

Not even a diamagnetic cavity!! :D

Christ, what is wrong with you? How is a frigging non-existent DL making water? ANSWER.
 
Please point me to the new model, jd116.

Link will do, I’ve missed the memo, obviously . :p

No, you missed an education, which is why you believe the crap that you do. Go type 'comet' into Google Scholar, and read any paper from 1986 onward.
 
Not even a diamagnetic cavity!!

Sorry? You mean the diamagnetic cavity detected at Halley? And the one at 67P? And the ones in the AMPTE experiments? Do you even know what 'diamagnetic' means? Doubtful.
 
No, it is observation and measurement. And the only people who think scientists still adhere to Whipple's 1950 model, are complete idiots, and liars. Such as Thornhill, et al.

The solid, core structure of a comet is known as the nucleus. Cometary nuclei are composed of an amalgamation of rock, dust, water ice, and frozen carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, methane, and ammonia.[13] As such, they are popularly described as "dirty snowballs" after Fred Whipple's model.[14] However, some comets may have a higher dust content, leading them to be called "icy dirtballs".[15] Research conducted in 2014 suggests that comets are like "deep fried ice cream", in that their surfaces are formed of dense crystalline ice mixed with organic compounds, while the interior ice is colder and less dense.[16]
wiki

Nope still the same story!

Another source

Facts About Comets

There are many misconceptions about comets, which are simply pieces of solar system ices travelling in orbit around the Sun. Here are some fascinating and true facts about comets.

The nucleus of a comet is made of ice and can be as small as a few meters across to giant boulders a few kilometres across.
The closest point in a comet’s orbit to the Sun is called “perihelion”. The most distant point is called “aphelion”.
As a comet gets closer to the Sun, it begins to experience heat. That causes some of its ices to sublimate (similar to dry ice sizzling in sunlight). If the ice is close to the comet’s surface, it may form a small “jet” of material spewing out from the comet like a mini-geyser.
Material streams from comets and populates the comet’s orbit. If Earth (or another planet) happens to move through that stream, those particles fall to Earth as meteor showers.
As a comet gets close to the Sun, it loses some of its mass due to the sublimation. If a comet goes around enough times, it will eventually break up. Comets also break up if they come TOO close to the Sun or another planet in their orbits.
Comets are usually made of frozen water and supercold methane, ammonia and carbon dioxide ices. Those are mixed with rock, dust, and other metallic bits of solar system debris.
Comets have two tails: a dust tail (which you can see with the naked eye) and a plasma tail, which is easily photographed but difficult to see with your eyes.
Comet orbits are usually elliptical.
Many comets formed in the Oort Cloud and Ku

Pretty much verbatim!

How about NASA, they know there stuff!

Comets are cosmic snowballs of frozen gases, rock and dust that orbit the Sun. When frozen, they are the size of a small town. When a comet's orbit brings it close to the Sun, it heats up and spews dust and gases into a giant glowing head larger than most planets. The dust and gases form a tail that stretches away from the Sun for millions of miles. There are likely billions of comets orbiting our Sun in the Kuiper Belt and even more distant Oort Cloud. The current number of known comets is: 3,528

Nope still dirty Snowballs!

Where would a kid wanting to find out about comets go for the REAL information, jd116?
 
Last edited:
wiki

Nope still the same story!

Another source



Pretty much verbatim!

How about NASA, they know there stuff!



Nope still dirty Snowballs!

Where would a kid wanting to find out about comets go for the REAL information, jd116?

Do you know what Google Scholar is? Obviously not.
 
No, you missed an education, which is why you believe the crap that you do. Go type 'comet' into Google Scholar, and read any paper from 1986 onward.

Why?

I’ve been reading the ones released this month.

Definitely NOT ditysnowballs, as AGREED by jd116 and tusenfem.

And there is no plan B for the mainstream, never was.

Or prove me wrong, jd116! :rolleyes:
 
Why?

I’ve been reading the ones released this month.

Definitely NOT ditysnowballs, as AGREED by jd116 and tusenfem.

And there is no plan B for the mainstream, never was.

Or prove me wrong, jd116! :rolleyes:


You've already been proved wrong. In case you missed it, there is a shed load of water and other volatiles coming from comets, they have very low densities, and none of the intellectually challenged woo from Thornhill et al has come to pass. You are the ones batting zero. Tell me again - how are you making water? And CO2? And CH4? And NH3?. And ice (both H2O and CO2)? Answer the question, or just admit that your loony beliefs are dead, but you're going to carry on believing them anyway. There is a word for that. It begins with R and ends with eligion.
 
Last edited:
You've already been proved wrong. In case you missed it, there is a shed load of water and other volatiles coming from comets, they have very low densities, and none of the intellectually challenged woo from Thornhill et al has come to pass. You are the ones batting zero. Tell me again - how are you making water? And CO2? And CH4? And NH3?. And ice (both H2O and CO2)? Answer the question, or just admit that your loony beliefs are dead, but you're going to carry on believing them anyway. There is a word for that. It begins with R and ends with eligion.

Smectite notronite
(Na0.33Fe2(Si,Al)4O10(OH)2 * 3H2O)

From the paper you linked to confirming my statement on hydrated minerals!

Do you believe the paper, jd116? :blush:
 
You've already been proved wrong. In case you missed it, there is a shed load of water and other volatiles coming from comets, they have very low densities, and none of the intellectually challenged woo from Thornhill et al has come to pass. You are the ones batting zero. Tell me again - how are you making water? And CO2? And CH4? And NH3?. And ice (both H2O and CO2)? Answer the question, or just admit that your loony beliefs are dead, but you're going to carry on believing them anyway. There is a word for that. It begins with R and ends with eligion.

Charge separation of the solar wind confirmed , check!
Ambipolar electric fields confirmed , check!
Electric Currents confirmed, check!

So which part are we still struggling with jd116?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom