The certainty of God's existence.

That's what the quote was saying, that multiverses has no empirical evidence to support them, and so that was one of the three arguments against metaverses. Were you agreeing? If we are talking about the same quote, it's not that 'if the variables were off' but that 'there is no empirical evidence to support them existing'.

; {>

I was agreeing with Gardner et. al., but I was extending it to your previous comments about the 10^123 zeros discussion. We can't talk about how "improbable" this universe is. This universe exists. It is what it is. There's no rational way to have a discussion about how it might have been different, including any "probability" that it could have been different.
 
Well, I looked at this
http://www.ws5.com/Penrose/

Which contains some of the thinking behind Penrose's statement about the probability of the universe being 10^10^123.

That is saying that is the probability of this particular universe in the phase space of possible universe.

Which is sort of like saying that the number of baryons in the universe is 10^80 and that the proton in an accelerator has a unique possibility of 1/10^80.

So the universe could have turned out 10^10^123-1 other ways. Since we can't know anything about the uniqueness of the universe, unless GUT of possible string theory says other wise is not a meaningful statement. The probability of unknowable perturbations is the equivalent of dividing by zero.

It could be that there is only one universe, it could be that there are any where from 1 to 10^10^123 universes out there. Statistics have no meaning in this context. There is only one data point in an unknown set, so the frequency of occurrence is division by zero (1/unknown) or the probability is 1.

The frequency of the universes occurrence is (unknown number of existing universes)/(unknown number of possible universes). Divide one unknown by another and you get unknown.
 
I have also been saying that the BB theory implies one universe, but does not rule out others, however to invoke metaverses you must use a variant of the original BB theory.

; {>


No BBT states things like "due to relativity and space time we can not know at this time if there are other universes","what we due know is the the Hubble constant exists and until another mechanism explains the redshift relation to distance, it looks as though the universe expanded from a very small state to a very large state", "the model breaks down at times ~ less that 10^-36 sec. after the hypothesized BBE, until the resolution of GUT, the actual model of the BBE remains very unclear the the plank time and plank scale".

So a modification of the theory would be essential to discuss anything prior to ~10^-36 sec., so any resolution of states prior to that will be an extension of the theory anyway.

The BBT is a variation from the original theory as is true of almost any theory. (Democrates atom, Rutherford atom, Bohr atom, modern shell theory of probability distributions.Of which only the first is a-tom.)
 
I was agreeing with Gardner et. al., but I was extending it to your previous comments about the 10^123 zeros discussion. We can't talk about how "improbable" this universe is. This universe exists. It is what it is. There's no rational way to have a discussion about how it might have been different, including any "probability" that it could have been different.


Wow, much clearer. Thanks!
 
? Hey can I use that? Its true. You are very special. So far we are the only known species that are sentient enabled and can stand on a mountain top or the roof of our crib and ponder our existence. So yep we and our pale blue dot of a planet are special indeed. Profoundly so.

; {>

Pondering our existence or staring at our navels?
 
And once again, it implies no such thing, any more than the fact that I can only know my own thoughts with any certainty implies that I am the only thing to have ever existed, or ever will exist.

Your claim is simply solipsism on a cosmic scale.

Oh, SNAP! You got served! (Rev that is, not Hokulele) :D
 
Last edited:
No I use quote tags so they speak for themselves

You do use quote tags; you use the quotes out of context.


Its an official NASA site for adults.

I will take your word for it.

And Its confirming what I have been telling everyone else.

If you now claim that you have been telling everyone that science is not incompatible with god, I agree. Science has nothing to say about god at all, either way. That is my position; that is NASA's position; that is your position. I just wonder why we are discussing it in a thread called "the certainty of god's existence". You raised it iirc: why did you? It is clearly off-topic.

Your statement reads like the other member who said I don't understand half the stuff you are talking about but I know you are wrong! :boggled:

I do not understand the cosmology: fortunately I don't have to to understand the article you cited. I understand plain english. I understand what the article said. It said we do not know what happened before the Big Bang nor what happened at the moment of the Big Bang. I understand that many, many posters have pointed this out to you but for some reason you are arguing with them. I understand that the article said absolutely nothing about whether this is the only universe or not.

Sheesh! By you not understanding (by design maybe?) that the excerpts and site supports what I have been saying indicates to me that you would disagree with me if I said an apple can be red. Productive debate with you is nearly impossible.

If what you have been saying is that science has nothing at all to tell us about god then we have no issue.

It supports my case very well.

See above.


It doesn't say that at all.

Of course it does. I will quote it again if it pleases you

"Science is not the only way of acquiring knowledge about ourselves and the world around us. Humans gain understanding in many other ways, such as through literature, the arts, philosophical reflection, and religious experience. Scientific knowledge may enrich aesthetic and moral perceptions, but these subjects extend beyond science's realm, which is to obtain a better understanding of the natural world."

and

What happened before the Big Bang? What happened right at the moment of the Big Bang?
We don't know.

What part of that are you having trouble with ?

ANd please use quotes,

Yes, I did use quotes. I just did it again.


due to your past history of putting words in my mouth,

I invite you to prove this statement: or apologise. You may be referring to your posts #1111 and #1116. Your wriggling was not impressive then and it is no better now. I would go so far as to say it was disingenous. Note that I do not "suggest" it was disingenuous by qualifying it as "borderline".

I don't believe you.

That is your privilege: but not for the reason given.


You have shown yourself use whatever tactics necessary to discredit me, either by design or by really not understanding the material.

That is a lie

Yes warm words from a NASA/academy of science site, too bad eh? Why does that irritate you so?

It doesn't. It is very much in line with my own position.

Because it supports what I have been saying all along. That's a fact.

If you have been saying all along that science has nothing to say on the subject of god then I agree.

You yourself said you do not understand basic cosmology. I do understand basic astronomy and cosmology

Now that I know that you agree it is utterly irrelevant to the "certainty of god's existence" I cannot imagine why you think your understanding of astronomy and cosmology would be of any interest to the topic at hand. But bully for you. :)

so why do you insist on attempting to discredit me?

I had somehow got the impression that you were attempting to support "the certainty of god's existence". And for some reason I had the idea that you thought the big bang theory and science in general had something to say on the subject. Since I was clearly wrong on both counts I was wasting my time in pointing out that the article you cited does not support that position. I fail to see how that is an attempt to discredit you. I misunderstood your purpose in citing it, is all.


something, (your utter disdain for religion and the fear that we might just be right?) blinds you to that fact.

As it happens I do not hold religion in disdain. And as it happens I have no fear at all that theists might be right. But don't worry about it, RevDisturba: I do not think anyone can read minds, so your failure is to be expected



Click your heels together and say I want to go home. Your putting words into my mouth, and you aren't using quote tags so as to twist what the site is saying as well as what I am saying, as I said your credibility is now zero with me. For me to acknowledge anything you say you will have to back it up with sources or my or the sources words in quotes

I know: you were not trying to support theism through science at all. Why did you introduce big bang theory, again? I forget.

I have as others used science exactly how the academy of science allowed was a permissible and even valid way to.

By agreeing it has nothing to say on the subject of god, either way. Yes

You are shocked to find that even secular science agrees with me and rejects your hate of theism.

How could I be shocked to find that secular science has nothing to say on the subject of god? That has always been my view. Oh and by the way, in case you missed it the first time, I still don't hate theism :)

Oh here read it AGAIN ;

According to the National Academy of Sciences (NAS):

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.


You can twist my and the NASA sites words around to fit your absolute abhorrence of God religion and theism but not the words above in quotes (something that you should learn to do) which demands that you recognize the words for what they are. Truth. I might add that if you and more of 'your people' ie that believe as you would take the same tact as the academy there might be some hope at reconciliation of religious belief and science.

I have been saying all along that ID and evolution is compatible, now you get to see it in black and red written by your own secular interests.

; {>?

I have twisted no words, RevDisturba. "theistic evolution" is not incompatible with scientific views of evolution: indeed it was developed because many theists are neither dogmatic nor apt to deny that which is supported by strong evidence. It is not a scientific theory in itself: it is a rational way for theists to accommodate the knowledge we have gained from the biological sciences. It clearly could not be incompatible with it. Its compatibility is virtually a tautology.
 
According to the National Academy of Sciences (NAS):

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.
I'll get back to this in a moment.

You can twist my and the NASA sites words around to fit your absolute abhorrence of God religion and theism but not the words above in quotes (something that you should learn to do) which demands that you recognize the words for what they are.
Strawman, ad hominem, tu quoque.

I have been saying all along that ID and evolution is compatible, now you get to see it in black and red written by your own secular interests.
This is completely wrong and is completly unrelated to what you quoted "in black and red" above.

If you are unaware of the difference between Theistic Evolution and Intelligent Design, and why they are inherently incompatible, then you don't understand either concept at all.
 
Rev, don't you think that it shows a disturbing lack of faith for you to want certainty by eagerly scanning scientific theory for chinks whereby you can let God in? If, tomorrow, science was to prove somehow that God exists, wouldn't that be the end of faith?

Do you have so little faith in God's greatness and goodness that you need confirmation from scientists that he *might* exist? Are you so fanatical that you need to shut down legitimate areas of scientific inquiry, such as the many worlds theory, in case they contradict your own understanding of God? Are you so sure that you understand the mind of God that you can set limits on his creation? How do you know that he didn't make several universes ...?
 
The Slam Dunk Reality of the Penrose calculation.

I was agreeing with Gardner et. al., but I was extending it to your previous comments about the 10^123 zeros discussion. We can't talk about how "improbable" this universe is. This universe exists. It is what it is. There's no rational way to have a discussion about how it might have been different, including any "probability" that it could have been different.

I am afraid that many of the greatest minds of theoretical physics would disagree with you. These names include Hawking, Penrose, Davis, etc. The famous Penrose equations weren't speaking of how improbable the universe was, that’s obvious! Look around to see the truth of that. Rather it was about conditions were evident at a time very close to the non time of t-0 (and beyond or before*). Yes we do have the math to explain this era. (Google phase space).

Our universe is in a state of very low entropy. Astonishingly low entropy actually, and it has to be for we biological entities to live. Our very bodies are an example of a highly ordered low entropy structure or system. Pick up a rock or a piece of wood, or consider our entire planet or its sun and the other stars, or the universe with all its hard lumpy 'masses'*, all these things are more ordered than the dispersed interstellar gas clouds, and the space (space is anything but empty space) that our planet and the stars and other systems ie galaxies etc. are immersed in, hanging in what I have always found profound,** the gravity wells in the fabric of spacetime. This interstellar medium which includes the interstellar gas clouds are all examples of a systems with varying degrees of low entropy.

Its its generally accepted that for our universe to have the extremely low entropy it now has required as the "starting point" at the big bang the selection of a virtually infinitesimally tiny volume of the total phase space of all possible universes. What that means that according to the Penrose calculation the universe (this OUOT) we live in apparently began at a point make up of in the order of, according to Penrose, 1 part in 10 raised to the 10th power raised to the 123rd power of the entire phase space volume of all possible universes!

That is the profound conclusion of the Penrose calculation! This is a wildly large number, that you could not even come close to writing out if you wrote out the number one and then wrote the zeros at the rate of one thousand a min you would not even be started good before the universe ended. (according to the heat death theory.

This astonishing requirement for the initial condition (as per Penrose) at creation suggests that the odds are no better than 1 in 10 raised to the 10th power raised to the 123rd power that the universe in which we live was created by random chance. If the math holds true and it has despite the best efforts of Christian haters and metaphysical skeptics, and this understanding is as logical as to give the impression intended, it means that the chance that means dear brothers and sisters, that the (fallacy and flight of fantasy) universe was created at random is so close to zero is as close to absolutely impossible as could hope to get!

I hope that this write helps some of you understand what the Penrose calculation really means. I need a good solid write to go on my upcoming blog anyway, so this will serve many purposes.

notes

* Lumpy means all the stuff that is in an high entropy state.

** The full moon fascinated me as a child because I wondered how another world could hang in space like that! Still when I look at the full moon I am humbled to think that its sitting in a gravity well that’s distorting the fabric of space time.

; {>
 
Last edited:
sleepy_lioness said:
Rev, don't you think that it shows a disturbing lack of faith for you to want certainty by eagerly scanning scientific theory for chinks whereby you can let God in? If, tomorrow, science was to prove somehow that God exists, wouldn't that be the end of faith?

Nah. You haven’t read my bio where I have laid my soul bare and readily admitted that I had no faith at all to begin with. Not even the faith of a mustard seed cut into a sextillion pieces. Not even one of those pieces. I had zero faith. I was a good evangelical atheist. Very good! I came to God VIA science. I can not say for sure that if say some ET’s come down in a space ship and said they created our universe and created a few examples to prove that they could do it, I can not say that my faith wouldn’t be shaken! In fact the bible tells us that NO flesh would be saved unless the real Christ returned and saved all of us from worshiping the antichrist Christians and Muslims alike! Yep, I very well may back slide, but I doubt it. Faith is a funny thing, so I would like to think that my faith is sound because I have found truth, and its been truth for over a decade. Oh and look in the bible of the people that knew Jesus personally, and still went apostate !

Do you have so little faith in God's greatness and goodness that you need confirmation from scientists that he *might* exist?

How do you know that God did not use science to change me?

Are you so fanatical that you need to shut down legitimate areas of scientific inquiry, such as the many worlds theory, in case they contradict your own understanding of God?

Are you going to put words in my mouth like a few others here have? Why do you feel the need to attempt to make me say what I do not believe? I posted a link where your own beloved secular science academy of sciences embraced theistic evolutionary theory.

Are you so sure that you understand the mind of God that you can set limits on his creation? How do you know that he didn't make several universes ...?

Ha ha…hee hee..really! I actually think God did and there is scripture to prove it. But to answer your question God gave me science to solve scientific earthly problems, and the bible to solve metaphysical problems, sometimes they merge but that’s unavoidable because God is a master engineer of universes which we can understand and even manipulate by using our God given brain.

BTW do you claim any religious ID?

; {>
 
Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
I have also been saying that the BB theory implies one universe...

And once again, it implies no such thing, any more than the fact that I can only know my own thoughts with any certainty implies that I am the only thing to have ever existed, or ever will exist.

Your claim is simply solipsism on a cosmic scale.

Good morning Ms (I forgot or is it Ms or Mrs?) Hokulele.. Wait you said your husband is a Christian didn't you? So it has to be Mrs.

Anyway good morning. Hey, solipsism is not such a philosophical no mans land, it has a lot going for it, except for the name, I always envision a slug when I see it for some reason, I suppose that its because I feel that its an intellectually lazy argument.

However in playing the devils advocate I could say ‘I know’ that I am real, but you and everyone else is an abstract concept, and I, and everyone else am a abstract concept to you. How do you know I am real?

; {>
 
Nah. You haven’t read my bio where I have laid my soul bare and readily admitted that I had no faith at all to begin with. Not even the faith of a mustard seed cut into a sextillion pieces. Not even one of those pieces. I had zero faith. I was a good evangelical atheist. Very good! I came to God VIA science. I can not say for sure that if say some ET’s come down in a space ship and said they created our universe and created a few examples to prove that they could do it, I can not say that my faith wouldn’t be shaken! In fact the bible tells us that NO flesh would be saved unless the real Christ returned and saved all of us from worshiping the antichrist Christians and Muslims alike! Yep, I very well may back slide, but I doubt it. Faith is a funny thing, so I would like to think that my faith is sound because I have found truth, and its been truth for over a decade. Oh and look in the bible of the people that knew Jesus personally, and still went apostate !

You haven't read my biog either. I stated upthread that I am a Christian. Actually, I'm a very committed one, and it's a big part of my life, which is why I'm bothering to argue with you. I find it tragic that so many Christians seem to get stuck in a dead end of arguing with scientists over whether science proves God or not.

My faith is separate from my knowledge of science, because I think, like the Scholastic theologians, that the world is a separate sphere of knowledge from God. For this reason I find no conflict between God and science, and I don't need to try to marry up the two. It is a truism to me that God is behind everything and is the font of all knowledge, so to me insisting that certain scientific knowledge and theories *must* be wrong because they conflict with a narrow reading of the Bible or our own narrow ideas of what God *must* be, is self-defeating. God is always bigger than we can imagine.

(theological derail - non-Christians please feel free to skip)

On Christ - of course, the model of classical Christology, to which I along with most other Christians who've ever existed hold, only works if you assume, as the attendees at Chalcedon and the others who wrote it did, that the divine is of a different order and class of being than the human. Otherwise Christ's full humanity is impossible. To hold to the central paradox of Christianity, that Jesus was simultaneously divine and human, you have to believe that the divine was of such another order that it did not cancel out his humanity (from Origen, or possibly even earlier, theologians took it as read that Christ had to be human in order to be able to save humanity, but also more than human in order to overcome sin). This, it seems to me, is an excellent model for the relationship between human achievement, as shown in science, among other things, and God's power. The divine does not cancel out the human but works with it. God is always bigger than us, and we cannot understand or anticipate his actions by a science designed to understand the world, any more than we can get our heads around soteriology or the resurrection by using scientific reasoning.

(/theological derail)

How do you know that God did not use science to change me?

I don't, of course. Many people find that the more they study the natural world, the more awe they feel at God's creation. The question is whether that awe is allowed to stand or whether we feel the need to set limits on God by insisting that he conform to our own ideas of what science should be saying about him and his world.

Are you going to put words in my mouth like a few others here have? Why do you feel the need to attempt to make me say what I do not believe? I posted a link where your own beloved secular science academy of sciences embraced theistic evolutionary theory.

Hmmm ... Rev, not for the first time in this thread, this feels like motes and beams. First you accuse me of putting words in your mouth, then you go straight on to talk about MY 'beloved secular science academy of sciences'. As I am neither 'secular' (other than in the sense that I believe in a secular state), nor anything resembling a 'scientist', nor American, I feel little or no investment in NASA or whichever academy you're quoting this time. As others (and I) have pointed out upthread, besides, those quotes don't say what you think they say. They merely leave the question of the existence of God open, because neither evolutionary nor Big Bang theory have any bearing on the question of his existence.

Ha ha…hee hee..really! I actually think God did and there is scripture to prove it. But to answer your question God gave me science to solve scientific earthly problems, and the bible to solve metaphysical problems, sometimes they merge but that’s unavoidable because God is a master engineer of universes which we can understand and even manipulate by using our God given brain.

BTW do you claim any religious ID?

; {>

For many centuries people were resistant to the heliocentric model of the universe because they thought that, if it were true, the Bible must be wrong and atheism would ensue. Yet it was shown to be true, and Christianity didn't collapse. God was bigger than the thinkers of the time.

How do you know that the same isn't true of multiple world theory, evolution by natural selection, etc?

I think, actually, we agree on the basics. There is a world which we can understand, to a certain limited extent, by use of our God-given brains. However, you are much less willing than I to think that God will survive and surpass all our attempts to understand him, and much more concerned to find him in the gaps that science cannot (yet) explain. Personally I find that this diminishes his power. I don't seek to use scientific theory to 'prove' faith precisely because my faith thrives on doubt and mystery and awe. God doesn't 'exist' as a being in the way that other beings like us exist. He/she/it is beyond our comprehension, by definition. Why go around trying to set limits on what science can discover about the wonderful world we've been given? God isn't limited.

Oh, and if you decide that you can only believe because it is reasonable to do so, because you've convinced yourself that science backs up your beliefs, then what happens in future if you find that science contradicts something you believe? Do you lose your faith, or do you decide that God is bigger than that? Or do you, like those who opposed Galileo, decide that you have to close your eyes to science and reassert dogma? (that's what it looks very like you're doing here, I'm sorry to say).

Gah. I don't come to JREF to argue with Christians, I come to learn. But then I end up getting all upset by the way some Christians present the faith and I just can't help myself.
 
::::::::::: (the small amount of) Personal content ignored ::::::::::::::::::::

Fiona said:
If you now claim that you have been telling everyone that science is not incompatible with god, I agree. Science has nothing to say about god at all, either way. That is my position; that is NASA's position; that is your position. I just wonder why we are discussing it in a thread called "the certainty of god's existence". You raised it iirc: why did you? It is clearly off-topic.

Well you don't agree with me but the Academy of Sciences does. Its position that science is that its ok for science to be integrated with God, or are you ignoring the definition of theistic evolution ? I mean you cant get more cozy that that! BTW I like the ring of that term. ‘Theistic evolution’ And I heartily approve of their ’formal’ recognition.

I do not understand the cosmology: fortunately I don't have to to understand the article you cited. I understand plain English. I understand what the article said. It said we do not know what happened before the Big Bang nor what happened at the moment of the Big Bang.

None of us need a degree, even a GED to intelligently discuss the issues here, and you do a very good job debating the subject, including your general knowledge of the subject material what I like even better you remain civil in the face of adversity. That said, science doesn’t know what happened ‘before’ the BB, however theoretical physicists are working on it.

I have never said that I use science to determine what happened ‘before’ the big bang, and have went to great lengths to say that the KCA etc are cosmological arguments and have different criteria to meet than a scientific argument. However BOTH are recognized as rational and reasonable methods for discovery and discussion. If I had a dollar for every time I had said this I could go on a coke binge, if I did coke, but I prefer Pepsi products.

I understand that many, many posters have pointed this out to you but for some reason you are arguing with them.

Because they are wrong?

I understand that the article said absolutely nothing about whether this is the only universe or not.

No but it did confirm the BB as the ‘best’ theory , I was using the site to verify that fact among others. Many universes theories for example. Of course I have no way of knowing what you actually think, you just seem intent on proving anything I say is wrong. BTW what do you believe? Do you think that this is the only universe or that there were more? If you have no opinion why do you insist on deriding my beliefs?

If what you have been saying is that science has nothing at all to tell us about god then we have no issue.

God is science. Science does not mention God or have anything to tell us about God ? Well look in the index of any theoretical physicists books and you will see a usually see a paragraph of page numbers referring to God! So I think you simply are ignoring the facts that science does say a lot about God, some science is steeped in the question of God.

Especially theoretical physics and the philosophy of science, and theistic evolution (get used to that term) and evolutionary biology (ie abiogenesis) to name a few. So no I don’t know what’s wrong with you when you can look at the facts and make comments like that !

Maybe if you get mad enough at me and Christianity it will force you to hit the books and that would be a wonderful thing! Perhaps instead of reinforcing your disdain for Christianity (or perhaps its more of the meddling of Christianity in science according to you) , you may become an apostasied atheist and maybe, just maybe I will see your beautiful smiling face in church morrow.

; {>
 
Last edited:
As I said some concepts are so obvious to be silly if mentioned. Mentioning that the big bang means that its talking about this universe and that the current theory implies this is the only universe is akin to stating that 'we see with our eyes', or that 'apples can be red', or that 'the sky just might might be blue some days':shocked: Yes, its just silly!
No, it isn't. If the Big Bang actually implies that this is the only Universe then that's a BIG implication, and would be right up there with all the other information.

When a scientist wants to discuss multiple universe formation and use the big bang in some form other than the original hot standard model, he will say that its a variant of the standard hot model big bang theory. Of course if he wants to discuss other universes being created in something else than the big bang he will make clear what system (there are many non big bang models for meta universe formation or creation) may of formed them.
Depends on what version of multiple universe creation theory you're talking about. Plus, of course, the Inflationary Hot Big Bang doesn't deal with the origins of the Universe, just its development since shortly after the start of the expansion.

Some reasons for not believing in more than one universe;

"1) It's not science. Both Paul Davies and Martin Gardner claim that the proposition "the multiverse exists" has no empirical content and hence amounts to empty metaphysics. But the hypotheses that imply it do lead to testable predictions, some of which jibe with the evidence collected so far. In the next decade, as Max Tegmark points out, improved measurements of the microwave background radiation and of the large-scale distribution of matter may fortify or knock down two pillars of the multiverse: the infinitude of space and the theory of chaotic inflation.
Umm, okay. You really should do some more research into these things before you tout them as being in favour of your thesis. We'll start with the first bit. Yes, indeed, the statement "the multiverse exists" has no empirical content, and is metaphysics, but the statement "the multiverse does not exist" also has no empirical content, and is equally metaphysical.

As for the hypotheses that lead to the idea of a multiverse not jibing with the evidence, and the quote from Max Tegmark, these all refer to multiverses that are in some way causally linked to this Universe, or were seeded from the same Big Bang, or created by QM splitting.

None of this precludes there being causally unlinked multiple universes, nor does it preclude the suggestion I made earlier about black holes seeding new universes.

2) Alternative universes should be shaved away by Occam's Razor. Both Davies and Gardner complain that the multiverse notion is too extravagant. "Surely the conjecture that there is just one universe and its Creator is infinitely simpler and easier to believe than that there are countless billions upon billions of worlds," Gardner writes. Is it? Our universe came into being with the big bang, and (as the Canadian philosopher John Leslie has observed) it would be exceedingly odd if the mechanism behind this event bore the label "THIS MECHANISM OPERATED ONLY ONCE." A computer program that prints out the entire sequence of numbers is much simpler than one that prints out only a single number of any length. And besides, why should simple theories be more probable than extravagant ones?
This section points out one of the weakness in the second argument. And in fact the real weakness is that Occams razor does not say what Davies and Gardner seem to be suggesting it says. One Universe with a creator is not simpler than multiple universes without a creator.

3) The multiverse, if real, would reduce our own world to a Matrix-like simulation. This objection, voiced by Davies, is surely the most bizarre of the lot. If there really were myriad universes, Davies argues, then some would contain advanced technological civilizations that could use computers to simulate consciousness and create endless virtual worlds. So, he continues, taking the multiverse theory at face value means "there is no reason to expect our world—the one in which you are reading this right now—to be real as opposed to a simulation." This is a terrible argument for at least two reasons. If it were valid, it would rule out technologically advanced civilizations in this universe since they, too, would presumably create such simulations. And the hypothesis that we are living in a simulation itself has no empirical content. We cannot even talk about it coherently, as Hilary Putnam has pointed out, since our words could refer only to things "inside" the alleged simulation."
Again, this section points out why the argument is utterly specious. It's a totally ridiculous argument.


So only one of the three argument carries any weight, and even that only does so for a specific set of multiple universe theories.

Care to try again?
 
Some reasons for not believing in more than one universe;

"1) It's not science. Both Paul Davies and Martin Gardner claim that the proposition "the multiverse exists" has no empirical content and hence amounts to empty metaphysics. But the hypotheses that imply it do lead to testable predictions, some of which jibe with the evidence collected so far. In the next decade, as Max Tegmark points out, improved measurements of the microwave background radiation and of the large-scale distribution of matter may fortify or knock down two pillars of the multiverse: the infinitude of space and the theory of chaotic inflation.

2) Alternative universes should be shaved away by Occam's Razor. Both Davies and Gardner complain that the multiverse notion is too extravagant. "Surely the conjecture that there is just one universe and its Creator is infinitely simpler and easier to believe than that there are countless billions upon billions of worlds," Gardner writes. Is it? Our universe came into being with the big bang, and (as the Canadian philosopher John Leslie has observed) it would be exceedingly odd if the mechanism behind this event bore the label "THIS MECHANISM OPERATED ONLY ONCE." A computer program that prints out the entire sequence of numbers is much simpler than one that prints out only a single number of any length. And besides, why should simple theories be more probable than extravagant ones?

3) The multiverse, if real, would reduce our own world to a Matrix-like simulation. This objection, voiced by Davies, is surely the most bizarre of the lot. If there really were myriad universes, Davies argues, then some would contain advanced technological civilizations that could use computers to simulate consciousness and create endless virtual worlds. So, he continues, taking the multiverse theory at face value means "there is no reason to expect our world—the one in which you are reading this right now—to be real as opposed to a simulation." This is a terrible argument for at least two reasons. If it were valid, it would rule out technologically advanced civilizations in this universe since they, too, would presumably create such simulations. And the hypothesis that we are living in a simulation itself has no empirical content. We cannot even talk about it coherently, as Hilary Putnam has pointed out, since our words could refer only to things "inside" the alleged simulation."

http://www.slate.com/id/2087206/

; {>
Hmm... remarkably honest post Rev, I congratulate you.

The devil on my left shoulder says you didn't read it properly before you posted it but the angel on my right shoulder says you are putting both sides of the argument squarely.
 
Only if it is possible that physical constants have enough variance that there is a high probability of a universe that would not support life as we know it. We don't know if they're variable at all, maybe gravity has the value it has for the same reason that 2+2 must equal four: there's no other way it can be. Since the a priori probabilities are completely unknown, arguments from probability can't legitimately be used to defend or criticize fine-tuning.
Well, all I meant was that when RevDisburba suggested that an OUOT argument supported the KCA it did not seem to make sense as the number of universes does not come into the KCA.

But presumably it would be relevant to the fine-tuning argument.

I can't really speak for the soundness or even validity of the fine-tuning argument as I have never actually seen it stated explicitly, despite having looked for this.
 
Yes I know I can be brutal or worse.
I haven't noticed you being brutal, but you do resort to insults.
I do not respond to insults very well.
Well you shouldn't initiate them. Because neither do we.
Then after repeated insults slurs and innuendos when a christian does say something to defend himself its 'oh and you call that a christian attitude'. That is an typical 'bad apple' atheist tactic (bad apple to differentiate the few bad apples that give the majority of good ashiest a bad name).
That is precisely the tactic Yrreg uses. When Yrreg started posting and asking questions of atheists, I responded honestly and, I think, quite vulnerably. But as these threads progress it is obvious that Yrreg does not care for our honest opinion, but only repeats his insulting prejudices over and over again. Clearly people start getting annoyed by this and insult him back and then we hear about how atheists are always insulting people.

When you chimed in telling us what a graceful and tolerant person Yrreg was and how atheists were often satanically motivated I naturally assumed that you were also playing his game.
So I don't start the stuff,
But you do - when you make generalisations about atheists you are attacking people who have not attacked you first.
Right. Tell that to anyone that is still professionally debating it.
Put me in touch with them and I will. Is there really such a profession as debating?
The reason the KCA has not been defeated is because its logic is impeccable
It has a very rudimentary logical strucure so it should not be difficult to make that impeccable, nevertheless, as I pointed out earlier Craig still managed to get it wrong.

And you presented the argument with no definitions, new terms like "eternal" introduced with no explanation and no apparent relevance to earlier premisses or conclusions.

Ambiguity in a logical argument is far from impeccable.

And when I asked you to clarify which meaning you intended for "begin" you provided a circular definition. So I think you have not really thought that term "impeccable" before applying it.

I challenged you earlier to provide a formalisation of this argument (I would find it hard to believe that this has not been done). When I see that then we can talk about impeccability.
... and its a philosophical argument, there is no defeat or winning it simply is an opinion supported by reason and logic.
If an argument has a conclusion different to the premiss it is supposed to be supporting (as is the case with Craig's version of the argument) then that argument has been defeated, there is no need to engage in further debate - an invalid logical structure invalidates the argument. Full stop.

And with the version you presented, even you retreated from P6 when pressed on it, which would also leave P5 a dangling premiss. P1 is looking pretty sick, P3 would depend upon how "has a beginning" is defined.

I don't mind P2 since the idea of a finite God kinda appeals to me.
You can't sink something that can walk on water.
Tell that to Peter.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom