RevDisturba
Muse
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 647
Argh, quote about fine tuning and it does not show any of the original calculation, if these arguments are going to be brought up then people should cite the ORIGINAL source, not some quote that has been copied to a bazillion websites.
I will look for the source paper, in the past this has been hysterically funny.
Go ahead please don't come back with a piece from some atheist apologist website. Until then ;
"Roger Penrose*, a famous British mathematician and a close friend of Stephen Hawking, wondered about this question and tried to calculate the probability. Including what he considered to be all variables required for human beings to exist and live on a planet such as ours, he computed the probability of this environment occurring among all the possible results of the Big Bang.
According to Penrose, the odds against such an occurrence were on the order of 10^10^123 to 1."
; }>
THIS JUST IN THIS IS THE ORIGINAL TEXT ;
(from the Emperor’s New Mind, Penrose, pp 339-345 copyright 1989, Penguin Books)
How special was the big bang?
This figure will give us an estimate of the total phase-space volume V available
to the Creator, since this entropy should represent the logarithm of the volume of
the (easily) largest compartment. Since 10^123 is the logarithm of the volume, the
volume must be the exponential of 10^123, i.e.
V = 10^10^123.
in natural units! (Some perceptive readers may feel that I should have used the
figure e^10^123, but for numbers of this size, the a and the 10 are essentially
interchangeable!) How big was the original phase-space volume W that the Creator
had to aim for in order to provide a universe compatible with the second law of
thermodynamics and with what we now observe? It does not much matter whether
we take the value
W = 10^10^101 or W = 10^10^88
given by the galactic black holes or by the background radiation, respectively, or a
much smaller (and, in fact, more appropriate) figure which would have been the
actual figure at the big bang. Either way, the ratio of V to W will be, closely
V/W = 10^10^123.
This now tells us how precise the Creator's aim must have been: namely to an
accuracy of one part in 10^10^123.
This is an extraordinary figure. One could not possibly even write the number
down in full, in the ordinary denary notation: it would be `1' followed by 10^123
successive `0 's! Even if we were to write a `0' on each separate proton and on each
separate neutron in the entire universe-and we could throw in all the other particles
as well for good measure-we should fall far short of writing down the figure
needed.
Anyone have some good recipes for crow?
; {>
Last edited:
