The certainty of God's existence.

Argh, quote about fine tuning and it does not show any of the original calculation, if these arguments are going to be brought up then people should cite the ORIGINAL source, not some quote that has been copied to a bazillion websites.

I will look for the source paper, in the past this has been hysterically funny.

Go ahead please don't come back with a piece from some atheist apologist website. Until then ;

"Roger Penrose*, a famous British mathematician and a close friend of Stephen Hawking, wondered about this question and tried to calculate the probability. Including what he considered to be all variables required for human beings to exist and live on a planet such as ours, he computed the probability of this environment occurring among all the possible results of the Big Bang.

According to Penrose, the odds against such an occurrence were on the order of 10^10^123 to 1."

; }>

THIS JUST IN THIS IS THE ORIGINAL TEXT ;

(from the Emperor’s New Mind, Penrose, pp 339-345 copyright 1989, Penguin Books)

How special was the big bang?

This figure will give us an estimate of the total phase-space volume V available

to the Creator, since this entropy should represent the logarithm of the volume of

the (easily) largest compartment. Since 10^123 is the logarithm of the volume, the

volume must be the exponential of 10^123, i.e.



V = 10^10^123.



in natural units! (Some perceptive readers may feel that I should have used the

figure e^10^123, but for numbers of this size, the a and the 10 are essentially

interchangeable!) How big was the original phase-space volume W that the Creator

had to aim for in order to provide a universe compatible with the second law of

thermodynamics and with what we now observe? It does not much matter whether

we take the value

W = 10^10^101 or W = 10^10^88

given by the galactic black holes or by the background radiation, respectively, or a

much smaller (and, in fact, more appropriate) figure which would have been the

actual figure at the big bang. Either way, the ratio of V to W will be, closely



V/W = 10^10^123.



This now tells us how precise the Creator's aim must have been: namely to an

accuracy of one part in 10^10^123.




This is an extraordinary figure. One could not possibly even write the number

down in full, in the ordinary denary notation: it would be `1' followed by 10^123

successive `0 's! Even if we were to write a `0' on each separate proton and on each

separate neutron in the entire universe-and we could throw in all the other particles

as well for good measure-we should fall far short of writing down the figure

needed.


Anyone have some good recipes for crow?

; {>
 
Last edited:
FYI Wolly asked me not to mention or speak about his employment, or credentials because I was working on a false assumption, or simply information true or untrue, supplied by a third party (a forum member) concerning his credentials. I have no way of knowing what Mr Wollys credientials are but I usally accept what someone tells me as true UNLESS they make gross errors that someone in that field of work would not make.

Hey. Did you know the word "gullible" is written on your ceiling?
...
Sorry, couldn't resist.


BTW, I usually do provide links and quotes relevant to my claims. Additionally, you have no way of knowing the extent of my knowledge of observational astronomy, cosmology astrophysics or theology for that matter. You are clueless to the awards I have received or the papers I have written or even the specific courses I took as a perpetual (; }>) student in college.

Except for the fact that we have witnessed (even if I myself haven't understood half of it) several of your blatant errors and self-contradictions concerning this matter. Therefore, I think it is safe to assume that you do not hold a Ph.D. in Astrophysics. Or whatever.

Lastly let Wolly speak for himself, its meddling such as yours (even if attempting to defend Mr Wolly) that was one reason Wolly and I got off to a bad start. Thanks to you and your friends he didn't even answer my questions about upgrading my telescope....

Maybe he doesn't know how? You don't know his experience in that field. Maybe he only works with data, not with telescopes. Or maybe he doesn't work in that field at all. Who knows?
; {>

But you may want to check whether it's cheaper to upgrade your current telescope or to buy a new one. If they're anything like computers...
 
You mean grossly ignorant errors like saying "before the Big Bang" and "there was nothing and then there was something"?

THE ONLY GROSSLY IGNORANT THING HERE R YOUR STATEMENTS. i HAVE QUANTIFIED MORE THAN TEN TIMES (OOPS CAP) I have said many times that I use the word 'before' as a simplification to outside time etc for brevity. It saves about a paragraph of font.

Whats wrong with "there was nothing and then there was something" actually that was a (strawman?) plagiarized quote from a PhD describing the BB. I thought it would be great to catch the usual suspects flatfooted.

Google it.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Hey. Did you know the word "gullible" is written on your ceiling?...
Sorry, couldn't resist.

Well it doesn't take me long to catch a fake eh, I mean in poker or such things ? There has to be some trust in a debate. I am sure you do the same thing.

Except for the fact that we have witnessed (even if I myself haven't understood half of it) several of your blatant errors and self-contradictions concerning this matter. Therefore, I think it is safe to assume that you do not hold a Ph.D. in Astrophysics. Or whatever.

Yeah right you claim this and that but never have the specifics. And I am sure you don't half understand it? Do you realize how silly that sounds? "You don't understand half of what I am saying but you know its wrong?" I ought to frame that one brother. BTW I haven't claimed to hold a PhD. My degree is in theology.

But you may want to check whether it's cheaper to upgrade your current telescope or to buy a new one. If they're anything like computers...

Thanks for the advice but scopes aren't like computers. I want to upgrade to a ten or twelve inch reflector or may be switch to a refractor which is more expensive but may be better suited to my kind of observing which is planetary.

; }>
 
Last edited:
Relevent snips from the bonafide (I loved the brother where art thou movie) NASA WMAP Site

"The Big Bang theory is one of the most strongly supported theories in all of science. It explains the observed facts; it has made successful predictions; it has stood the test of time; and there is no alternate theory that the professional scientific community deems valid."

[Yes I know that but some here should read the bold red type, its important! It may convince them that all the many universe theories are not so wonderful...]

"The Big Bang theory says that the universe was very hot and concentrated in the distant past and, ever since then, space has been stretching and cooling. This is the only theory that successfully explains the observations made by astronomers."

[Hmmm']

"So far, measurements indicate that space is very nearly flat. This is, of course, the easiest shape for us to mentally picture. "

The academy of sciences report ;

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.

[DO TELL but I have already said as much many times here, but its heart warming to have an esteemd group to validate my statements.]

Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."

http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/site/faq.html

; {>
All true, and not one single statement in the whole thing that says that this is the only Universe. Not one statement about how many attempts it took

Not one.
 
As I pointed out before this is plain wrong.

The KCA, even if it is sound, says nothing whatsoever about whether the cause could make one or many universes.

An OUOT theory, if one were ever proposed, would support the fine-tuning argument.

Only if it is possible that physical constants have enough variance that there is a high probability of a universe that would not support life as we know it. We don't know if they're variable at all, maybe gravity has the value it has for the same reason that 2+2 must equal four: there's no other way it can be. Since the a priori probabilities are completely unknown, arguments from probability can't legitimately be used to defend or criticize fine-tuning.
 
FYI Wolly asked me not to mention or speak about his employment, or credentials because I was working on a false assumption, or simply information true or untrue, supplied by a third party (a forum member) concerning his credentials. I have no way of knowing what Mr Wollys credientials are but I usally accept what someone tells me as true UNLESS they make gross errors that someone in that field of work would not make.

BTW, I usually do provide links and quotes relevant to my claims. Additionally, you have no way of knowing the extent of my knowledge of observational astronomy, cosmology astrophysics or theology for that matter. You are clueless to the awards I have received or the papers I have written or even the specific courses I took as a perpetual (; }>) student in college.

Lastly let Wolly speak for himself, its meddling such as yours (even if attempting to defend Mr Wolly) that was one reason Wolly and I got off to a bad start. Thanks to you and your friends he didn't even answer my questions about upgrading my telescope....

; {>

You still contradicted yourself and do not follow your own advice, which is the reason for the post.
Quote:
Again the one universe one try theory is the most popular theory and the one used in academia and when scientists speak in general terms about the big bang. I am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.
Quote:
Start with your premises and then make sure they support a valid sound conclusion. Otherwise you have no argument, simply a statement.
 
Go ahead please don't come back with a piece from some atheist apologist website. Until then ;

"Roger Penrose*, a famous British mathematician and a close friend of Stephen Hawking, wondered about this question and tried to calculate the probability. Including what he considered to be all variables required for human beings to exist and live on a planet such as ours, he computed the probability of this environment occurring among all the possible results of the Big Bang.

According to Penrose, the odds against such an occurrence were on the order of 10^10^123 to 1."

; }>

THIS JUST IN THIS IS THE ORIGINAL TEXT ;

(from the Emperor’s New Mind, Penrose, pp 339-345 copyright 1989, Penguin Books)

How special was the big bang?

This figure will give us an estimate of the total phase-space volume V available

to the Creator, since this entropy should represent the logarithm of the volume of

the (easily) largest compartment. Since 10^123 is the logarithm of the volume, the

volume must be the exponential of 10^123, i.e.



V = 10^10^123.



in natural units! (Some perceptive readers may feel that I should have used the

figure e^10^123, but for numbers of this size, the a and the 10 are essentially

interchangeable!) How big was the original phase-space volume W that the Creator

had to aim for in order to provide a universe compatible with the second law of

thermodynamics and with what we now observe? It does not much matter whether

we take the value

W = 10^10^101 or W = 10^10^88

given by the galactic black holes or by the background radiation, respectively, or a

much smaller (and, in fact, more appropriate) figure which would have been the

actual figure at the big bang. Either way, the ratio of V to W will be, closely



V/W = 10^10^123.



This now tells us how precise the Creator's aim must have been: namely to an

accuracy of one part in 10^10^123.




This is an extraordinary figure. One could not possibly even write the number

down in full, in the ordinary denary notation: it would be `1' followed by 10^123

successive `0 's! Even if we were to write a `0' on each separate proton and on each

separate neutron in the entire universe-and we could throw in all the other particles

as well for good measure-we should fall far short of writing down the figure

needed.


Anyone have some good recipes for crow?

; {>

You might want some, I will examine penroses train of thought and see where it ends, but you should of course be aware that the fine tunig argument is fraught with peril and frequent mistake. Nice quote, funny how it doesn't contain the derivation, now does it.
 
Last edited:
THE ONLY GROSSLY IGNORANT THING HERE R YOUR STATEMENTS. i HAVE QUANTIFIED MORE THAN TEN TIMES (OOPS CAP) I have said many times that I use the word 'before' as a simplification to outside time etc for brevity. It saves about a paragraph of font.
And is still just as unjustified an assumption. "Outside time" may well be completely meaningless, being based on a fundamental misconception. Most laypeople have a mental model of Big Bang cosmology that features a vast, eternal emptiness into which suddenly and mysteriously explodes the universe. They imagine it from the outside. But for most cosmologists there is no "outside" of space/time.

Whats wrong with "there was nothing and then there was something" actually that was a (strawman?) plagiarized quote from a PhD describing the BB. I thought it would be great to catch the usual suspects flatfooted.

Google it.
I did Google it. I came up with a single page from a laughable website called s8tint.com referencing a 1996 article in New Scientist by an astronomer named David Darling. It is rather poorly written and is rife with baseless assertions, straw men and arguments from personal incredulity. What it lacks is any logical argument.
 
THE ONLY GROSSLY IGNORANT THING HERE R YOUR STATEMENTS. i HAVE QUANTIFIED MORE THAN TEN TIMES (OOPS CAP) I have said many times that I use the word 'before' as a simplification to outside time etc for brevity. It saves about a paragraph of font.
Yeah, we know. It's still wrong. You have two completely unrelated versions of causality and you're attempting to use one to prove something about the other.

Fail.

Whats wrong with "there was nothing and then there was something" actually that was a (strawman?) plagiarized quote from a PhD describing the BB. I thought it would be great to catch the usual suspects flatfooted.
You thought wrong.
 
That said if you go back to the first post I made and watch its progress, its obvious who the usual suspects are and its not me.
Actually, yes, it mostly is you, at least since Yrreg got suspended.

Right. Tell that to anyone that is still professionally debating it. The reason the KCA has not been defeated is because its logic is impeccable and its a philosophical argument, there is no defeat or winning it simply is an opinion supported by reason and logic. You can't sink something that can walk on water.
Nope, wrong in every respect. It's just the Black Knight fallacy again.

First, the logic is deeply flawed.

Second, none of the premises are true.

And third, it's not "simply is an opinion supported by reason and logic". Your premises are statements of fact - albeit false - and you are trying to establish a statement of fact. At which task you have, of course, failed.
 
On the other hand, HghrSymmetry says, in reference to "the universe came from nothing,

Now, that's not precisely true either. I've seen that statement many times. However, it's not exactly a statement of "this happened". When I've seen credible cosmologists say it, it has been more of the form "it might have come from nothing".

Science cannot say, and may never be able to say, what happened "before" the big bang, or even if there was a "before". No credible scientist would claim to be able to do so. However, they are perfectly willing to speculate that the universe was indeed born suddenly out of nothing. Indeed, no credible scientist would say, "the universe came from nothing", but neither would any credible scientist say, "the universe did not come from nothing". At least, no credible scientist would say either of those things as a scientific assertion. Science simply cannot say anything about where the universe came from. Something? Nothing? We don't know.

So, RevD does not claim that the universe came from nothing. Meanwhile, scientists also do not make that claim. On the other hand, RevD asserts that the universe could not have come from nothing, while scientists claim that it may have come from nothing, or it may have always existed.

Part of the difficulty may be in the definitions. Seems theists use the word to signify "absolute nothing."
However, a cosmologist's definition is probably different.

http://www.amazon.com/Hole-Universe-Scientists-Emptiness-Everything/dp/0156013177#reader
 
He always waits several days beyond his suspension so that it's his idea to come back. Control issues.

Or maybe he is in no hurry to return for other reasons, kinda like avoiding the dentist, yes he gets something out of it but its painful? His thread is successful, I wonder why its one of the most visited threads on the forum?

; }>
 
Last edited:
That is just argument by assertion and fallacy of construction. the BBE does not say that this is only universe, you assert that.
It is a combination of BBe and relativity/model of space/time that says we may not see outside the universe.

The fact that we can not see outside the universe at this time, it a statement based upon the models of space/time, it does not say that "There is only one universe", it states "At this time we can only have knowledge of the universe".

And an appeal that the popular understanding of something implies something is still a fallacy of construction.

You assert it, the BBT does not imply it at all.

I don't imply that this is the only universe, the BB implies it by indicating that there is not enough observed mass in it to close it. Additionally most who are casually speaking of the Big Bang would say this is the only universe, unless special conditions are added etc.

As I said we can agree to disagree about it.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Or maybe he is in no hurry to return for other reasons, kinda like avoiding the dentist, yes he gets something out of it but its painful? His thread is successful, I wonder why its one of the most visited threads on the forum?

; }>

The most common comparison is train wreck fascination.
 
I don't imply that this is the only universe, the BB implies it by indicating that there is not enough observed mass in it to close it.
Wrong.

Additionally most who are casually speaking of the Big Bang would say this is the only universe, unless special conditions are added etc.
Then they're wrong too.

As I said we can agree to disagree about it.
Nope. It's not a matter of opinion. You're just wrong.
 
Fiona said:
You are kidding, right?

No I use quote tags so they speak for themselves

I read your link. It is written for people like me: that is for people who know little or nothing about astronomy/cosmlogy/science etc. I suspect it is for children. It is certainly popularising some basic ideas. It confirms what those who are knowledgeable about these matters have been saying to you in this thread, so far as I can see.

Its an official NASA site for adults. And Its confirming what I have been telling everyone else. Your statement reads like the other member who said I don't understand half the stuff you are talking about but I know you are wrong! :boggled:

Sheesh! By you not understanding (by design maybe?) that the excerpts and site supports what I have been saying indicates to me that you would disagree with me if I said an apple can be red. Productive debate with you is nearly impossible.

Those who have been discussing this with you have made this point over and over: your position is that you do know. This article does not support you

It supports my case very well.

All it is saying is that the big bang theory in any form has nothing to tell us about god or the cause of the universe or anything that happened until shortly after the big bang:

It doesn't say that at all. ANd please use quotes, due to your past history of putting words in my mouth, I don't believe you. You have shown yourself use whatever tactics necessary to discredit me, either by design or by really not understanding the material.

So far as I can see this is just warm words for theists: it does not support the theist position: it does not challenge it either: it has absolutely nothing to say except "come on in: the science is lovely"

Yes warm words from a NASA/academy of science site, too bad eh? Why does that irritate you so?

How you can pretend that this is helpful to your position is completely beyond me: if you need it to be true that is fine: as the article says

Because it supports what I have been saying all along. That's a fact. You yourself said you do not understand basic cosmology. I do understand basic astronomy and cosmology so why do you insist on attempting to discredit me? something, (your utter disdain for religion and the fear that we might just be right?) blinds you to that fact.

And so they do. But they cannot support theism in the way you have sought to establish. Science has nothing to say on the matter at all.

Click your heels together and say I want to go home. Your putting words into my mouth, and you aren't using quote tags so as to twist what the site is saying as well as what I am saying, as I said your credibility is now zero with me. For me to acknowledge anything you say you will have to back it up with sources or my or the sources words in quotes

Give it up, RevDisturba. Stick with your syllogism and try to address some of the inherent logical problems others have identified: your excursion into science is a non-starter.

I have as others used science exactly how the academy of science allowed was a permissible and even valid way to. You are shocked to find that even secular science agrees with me and rejects your hate of theism. Oh here read it AGAIN ;

According to the National Academy of Sciences (NAS):

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.


You can twist my and the NASA sites words around to fit your absolute abhorrence of God religion and theism but not the words above in quotes (something that you should learn to do) which demands that you recognize the words for what they are. Truth. I might add that if you and more of 'your people' ie that believe as you would take the same tact as the academy there might be some hope at reconciliation of religious belief and science.

I have been saying all along that ID and evolution is compatible, now you get to see it in black and red written by your own secular interests.

; {>?
 
Last edited:
The most common comparison is train wreck fascination.

Yes, it fits. I really don't know enough about the guy to comment. This is the truth, but I never slow to look at wrecks, and get irritated at those that do. But I havent always been like that.

; {>
 
Wrong.


Then they're wrong too.


Nope. It's not a matter of opinion. You're just wrong.

Just to let you know that I do at least skim your posts and don't ignore you Pixy. I will comment on the relevant items that I haven't already answered somewhere else.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom