The certainty of God's existence.

EXCERPTS OF HS's EXCELLENT POST

Part of the difficulty may be in the definitions. Seems theists use the word to signify "absolute nothing."
However, a cosmologist's definition is probably different.

So, RevD does not claim that the universe came from nothing. Meanwhile, scientists also do not make that claim. On the other hand, RevD asserts that the universe could not have come from nothing, while scientists claim that it may have come from nothing, or it may have always existed.

http://www.amazon.com/Hole-Universe-Scientists-Emptiness-Everything/dp/0156013177#reader

Thanks Mr Symmetry for trying to sort out the tangled web we have all woven...

; }>
 
Only if it is possible that physical constants have enough variance that there is a high probability of a universe that would not support life as we know it. We don't know if they're variable at all, maybe gravity has the value it has for the same reason that 2+2 must equal four: there's no other way it can be. Since the a priori probabilities are completely unknown, arguments from probability can't legitimately be used to defend or criticize fine-tuning.

Good post Mister ...

; {>
 
? Insults are the only thing you seem to be capable of generating, and that comes from a deep inferiority complex. Maybe if you gain some wisdom of years, you will decide to enrich yourself and others instead of trying to inflict harm ?

; {>

"Insults are the only thing you seem to be capable of generating,"
 
Yes I know I can be brutal or worse. However even though its not a Christian attribute and I have said many times that its my last stumbling block to having more than a toe hold in the pearly gates, I do not respond to insults very well.

snip

Don't let JREF stand between you and heaven.
 
Or maybe he is in no hurry to return for other reasons, kinda like avoiding the dentist, yes he gets something out of it but its painful? His thread is successful, I wonder why its one of the most visited threads on the forum?

; }>

Because the Rev is always good for a laugh.
 
Don't you recognize humor?

Of course I feel like I am wallowing in your personal extension of your atheistic love and kindness ....!!!not!!! :rolleyes: I don't feel the love Robin. Is my 'love feeler' broken?

In my opinion, you and a few others here are just frustrated because you can not readily defeat the KCA nor the argument from design (which we have only briefly touched on).

Hey smile TGIF...

; }>

Argument from design:

I'm here and I'm real special so god did it.
 
Go ahead please don't come back with a piece from some atheist apologist website. Until then ;

"Roger Penrose*, a famous British mathematician and a close friend of Stephen Hawking, wondered about this question and tried to calculate the probability. Including what he considered to be all variables required for human beings to exist and live on a planet such as ours, he computed the probability of this environment occurring among all the possible results of the Big Bang.

According to Penrose, the odds against such an occurrence were on the order of 10^10^123 to 1."

; }>

THIS JUST IN THIS IS THE ORIGINAL TEXT ;

(from the Emperor’s New Mind, Penrose, pp 339-345 copyright 1989, Penguin Books)

How special was the big bang?

This figure will give us an estimate of the total phase-space volume V available

to the Creator, since this entropy should represent the logarithm of the volume of

the (easily) largest compartment. Since 10^123 is the logarithm of the volume, the

volume must be the exponential of 10^123, i.e.



V = 10^10^123.



in natural units! (Some perceptive readers may feel that I should have used the

figure e^10^123, but for numbers of this size, the a and the 10 are essentially

interchangeable!) How big was the original phase-space volume W that the Creator

had to aim for in order to provide a universe compatible with the second law of

thermodynamics and with what we now observe? It does not much matter whether

we take the value

W = 10^10^101 or W = 10^10^88

given by the galactic black holes or by the background radiation, respectively, or a

much smaller (and, in fact, more appropriate) figure which would have been the

actual figure at the big bang. Either way, the ratio of V to W will be, closely



V/W = 10^10^123.



This now tells us how precise the Creator's aim must have been: namely to an

accuracy of one part in 10^10^123.




This is an extraordinary figure. One could not possibly even write the number

down in full, in the ordinary denary notation: it would be `1' followed by 10^123

successive `0 's! Even if we were to write a `0' on each separate proton and on each

separate neutron in the entire universe-and we could throw in all the other particles

as well for good measure-we should fall far short of writing down the figure

needed.


Anyone have some good recipes for crow?

; {>

What are the odds that I would post this.

Let's see (number of letters in English)(number of letters in sentence)= nonsense
 
All true, and not one single statement in the whole thing that says that this is the only Universe. Not one statement about how many attempts it took

Not one.

As I said some concepts are so obvious to be silly if mentioned. Mentioning that the big bang means that its talking about this universe and that the current theory implies this is the only universe is akin to stating that 'we see with our eyes', or that 'apples can be red', or that 'the sky just might might be blue some days':shocked: Yes, its just silly!

When a scientist wants to discuss multiple universe formation and use the big bang in some form other than the original hot standard model, he will say that its a variant of the standard hot model big bang theory. Of course if he wants to discuss other universes being created in something else than the big bang he will make clear what system (there are many non big bang models for meta universe formation or creation) may of formed them.

Some reasons for not believing in more than one universe;

"1) It's not science. Both Paul Davies and Martin Gardner claim that the proposition "the multiverse exists" has no empirical content and hence amounts to empty metaphysics. But the hypotheses that imply it do lead to testable predictions, some of which jibe with the evidence collected so far. In the next decade, as Max Tegmark points out, improved measurements of the microwave background radiation and of the large-scale distribution of matter may fortify or knock down two pillars of the multiverse: the infinitude of space and the theory of chaotic inflation.

2) Alternative universes should be shaved away by Occam's Razor. Both Davies and Gardner complain that the multiverse notion is too extravagant. "Surely the conjecture that there is just one universe and its Creator is infinitely simpler and easier to believe than that there are countless billions upon billions of worlds," Gardner writes. Is it? Our universe came into being with the big bang, and (as the Canadian philosopher John Leslie has observed) it would be exceedingly odd if the mechanism behind this event bore the label "THIS MECHANISM OPERATED ONLY ONCE." A computer program that prints out the entire sequence of numbers is much simpler than one that prints out only a single number of any length. And besides, why should simple theories be more probable than extravagant ones?

3) The multiverse, if real, would reduce our own world to a Matrix-like simulation. This objection, voiced by Davies, is surely the most bizarre of the lot. If there really were myriad universes, Davies argues, then some would contain advanced technological civilizations that could use computers to simulate consciousness and create endless virtual worlds. So, he continues, taking the multiverse theory at face value means "there is no reason to expect our world—the one in which you are reading this right now—to be real as opposed to a simulation." This is a terrible argument for at least two reasons. If it were valid, it would rule out technologically advanced civilizations in this universe since they, too, would presumably create such simulations. And the hypothesis that we are living in a simulation itself has no empirical content. We cannot even talk about it coherently, as Hilary Putnam has pointed out, since our words could refer only to things "inside" the alleged simulation."

http://www.slate.com/id/2087206/

; {>
 
Last edited:
Argument from design:

I'm here and I'm real special so god did it.

? Hey can I use that? Its true. You are very special. So far we are the only known species that are sentient enabled and can stand on a mountain top or the roof of our crib and ponder our existence. So yep we and our pale blue dot of a planet are special indeed. Profoundly so.

; {>
 
Some reasons for not believing in more than one universe;

"1) It's not science. Both Paul Davies and Martin Gardner claim that the proposition "the multiverse exists" has no empirical content and hence amounts to empty metaphysics.

I happen to agree with this, but I think it applies also to any calculations of "probability" about how the universe would be different if only it were...different. In other words, if only gravity were a bit bigger or smaller, or light were faster or slower, or planck's constant were a shade smaller.

To talk about the probability of any of those things being different is to speculate on the existence of some other universe. It's fun speculation, but, like speculation on those other universes, it has no empirical content, and is not scientific.
 
EXCERPTS OF HS's EXCELLENT POST



Thanks Mr Symmetry for trying to sort out the tangled web we have all woven...

; }>


No prob. I sometimes wonder just how much head banging would be reduced if we all understood each others definitions better.
 
I will pull a part of your post apart, structurally, to give you an insight into the way different parts of the conversation relate to one another. That way, you can see that you answer yourself in one post.

Fiona said:
All it is saying is that the big bang theory in any form has nothing to tell us about god or the cause of the universe or anything that happened until shortly after the big bang: not before/outside/in parallel with, or in any other conception which is not part of this universe.

So far as I can see this is just warm words for theists: it does not support the theist position: it does not challenge it either: it has absolutely nothing to say except "come on in: the science is lovely"

How you can pretend that this is helpful to your position is completely beyond me: if you need it to be true that is fine: as the article says
NASA said:
"Science is not the only way of acquiring knowledge about ourselves and the world around us. Humans gain understanding in many other ways, such as through literature, the arts, philosophical reflection, and religious experience
And so they do. But they cannot support theism in the way you have sought to establish. Science has nothing to say on the matter at all.

Click your heels together and say I want to go home. Your putting words into my mouth, and you aren't using quote tags so as to twist what the site is saying as well as what I am saying, as I said your credibility is now zero with me. For me to acknowledge anything you say you will have to back it up with sources or my or the sources words in quotes
Source requested. Aaannnnd...
RevDisturba said:
"This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution."

You can twist my and the NASA sites words around to fit your absolute abhorrence of God religion and theism but not the words above in quotes (something that you should learn to do) which demands that you recognize the words for what they are. Truth. I might add that if you and more of 'your people' ie that believe as you would take the same tact as the academy there might be some hope at reconciliation of religious belief and science.

I have been saying all along that ID and evolution is compatible, now you get to see it in black and red written by your own secular interests.
There go the goalposts!

Of course ID and evolution are compatible! Evolution + God = ID. Evolution is a necessary part of the theistic evolution theory. But the way you structured your posts and the way you made your arguments up to that point suggested you thought science had anything to say about God (i.e. proving his existence as per thread title, one would assume). Now, if you read the NASA bits and the green bits in the quoted material above, you will see that they are careful not to make any claims towards the existence of God. And that has everything to do with the fact that science, by definition, does not have the tools to make any positive or negative claims about this entity called God.

But if all you have been saying all along is that ID is compatible with the evolutionmodel, then I guess there was no disagreement, really. What do you think?
 
Last edited:
I happen to agree with this, but I think it applies also to any calculations of "probability" about how the universe would be different if only it were...different. In other words, if only gravity were a bit bigger or smaller, or light were faster or slower, or planck's constant were a shade smaller.

To talk about the probability of any of those things being different is to speculate on the existence of some other universe. It's fun speculation, but, like speculation on those other universes, it has no empirical content, and is not scientific.

That's what the quote was saying, that multiverses has no empirical evidence to support them, and so that was one of the three arguments against metaverses. Were you agreeing? If we are talking about the same quote, it's not that 'if the variables were off' but that 'there is no empirical evidence to support them existing'.

; {>
 
I will pull a part of your post apart, structurally, to give you an insight into the way different parts of the conversation relate to one another. That way, you can see that you answer yourself in one post.


Source requested. Aaannnnd...

There go the goalposts!

Of course ID and evolution are compatible! Evolution + God = ID. Evolution is a necessary part of the theistic evolution theory. But the way you structured your posts and the way you made your arguments up to that point suggested you thought science had anything to say about God (i.e. proving his existence as per thread title, one would assume). Now, if you read the NASA bits and the green bits in the quoted material above, you will see that they are careful not to make any claims towards the existence of God. And that has everything to do with the fact that science, by definition, does not have the tools to make any positive or negative claims about this entity called God.

But if all you have been saying all along is that ID is compatible with the evolutionmodel, then I guess there was no disagreement, really. What do you think?

Source for what? Annnnd', that was a side argument I got slammed for ie; that theistic evolution was a valid theory with such names as IDiot etc popping up from certain crow connoisseurs. The joke is on the insulter this time.

I have also been saying that the BB theory implies one universe, but does not rule out others, however to invoke metaverses you must use a variant of the original BB theory.

; {>
 
No prob. I sometimes wonder just how much head banging would be reduced if we all understood each others definitions better.

I think that it would be nice if everyone used the same terms etc. But we have a mixed audience in nearly every way possible and that is why I think we shouldn't be so term specific. We can always clarify later if need be.

; }>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom