sleepy_lioness; said:
You haven't read my biog either. I stated upthread that I am a Christian. Actually, I'm a very committed one, and it's a big part of my life, which is why I'm bothering to argue with you. I find it tragic that so many Christians seem to get stuck in a dead end of arguing with scientists over whether science proves God or not.
I admire you for your faith and that your ‘very committed’. Christianity is my life as well, its what I do in life (although If my NP’s keep running in the red I may have to take on a secular job).
You may not find it so tragic if you would read some e mails from fence sitters that decided to choose Christianity because of such things as the KCA, and the various science compatible reasons to choose Neo Meta/positive Christianity NMPC* ( my term). I have not even attempted to get anyone to convert, they simply read my beliefs and say ’hey I was raised Ipod enabled, Computer ,X box Bluetooth science geek type guy, and your ideas seem much more in synch with contemporary valid than the atheist’s world view.
My faith is separate from my knowledge of science, because I think, like the Scholastic theologians, that the world is a separate sphere of knowledge from God.
I find that an alien concept, because God, in my paradigm, is ‘in’ everything, while I do separate God from the natural world at a point, such as his realm being eternal and perfect, I find no scripture that tells us he can not interact with the material world. What I do find intensely interesting is that God sends envoys when he needs to speak Mano-a-mano to we humans. In fact save for Moses and perhaps one or two more instances (all where its questionable if they viewed God directly).
For this reason I find no conflict between God and science, and I don't need to try to marry up the two. It is a truism to me that God is behind everything and is the font of all knowledge, so to me insisting that certain scientific knowledge and theories *must* be wrong because they conflict with a narrow reading of the Bible or our own narrow ideas of what God *must* be, is self-defeating. God is always bigger than we can imagine.
I fully understand your views! Trust me I am from East Tennessee and you should see the looks I get when I go (usually uninvited) to a meeting of Clergy some of standing around in our frocks and preacher shirts, when I mention some of my more unorthodox ideas, I not only get homicidal vein popping out of the (red)neck looks but >>>!!!! stand back brother, <<<<!!! Or the every common >>>>I will pray for you son,<<<< along with a choir >>>> do you know you can go to hell for comments such as that!!! <<< To being asked to leave and don’t come back!
But I agree that God is not visually comprehensible to humans (with plenty of biblical reference), and he is omniscient
in his realm. That’s why he made our universe, which is limited, and runs on natural law including chaos and uncertainty etc. We perceive our universe as imperfect but is it really? No it’s a perfect universe, designed to be ‘imperfect’, to give us free will in an deterministic preordained as close as probabilities call allow universe.
(theological derail - non-Christians please feel free to skip)
On Christ - of course, the model of classical Christology, to which I along with most other Christians who've ever existed hold, only works if you assume, as the attendees at Chalcedon and the others who wrote it did, that the divine is of a different order and class of being than the human. Otherwise Christ's full humanity is impossible. To hold to the central paradox of Christianity, that Jesus was simultaneously divine and human, you have to believe that the divine was of such another order that it did not cancel out his humanity (from Origen, or possibly even earlier, theologians took it as read that Christ had to be human in order to be able to save humanity, but also more than human in order to overcome sin). This, it seems to me, is an excellent model for the relationship between human achievement, as shown in science, among other things, and God's power. The divine does not cancel out the human but works with it. God is always bigger than us, and we cannot understand or anticipate his actions by a science designed to understand the world, any more than we can get our heads around soteriology or the resurrection by using scientific reasoning.
(/theological derail)
I think Jesus was human, and had a direct link to God. We Christians and even non Christians are part divine because we have a soul, this is a spiritual that can not be broken, only diminished. Jesus was Human and God just as we are, however Jesus was a special creation and therefore gods holy presence and infusion into the flesh was nearly complete. As far as God and science goes, science is a tool that simple attempts to understand the truths of God, and God allows the evidences to emerge at a preordained pace. So I feel that we can know a bit of the mind of God and that God is practically shouting for us to use science to discover and proclaim his wonders to the world.
I don't, of course. Many people find that the more they study the natural world, the more awe they feel at God's creation. The question is whether that awe is allowed to stand or whether we feel the need to set limits on God by insisting that he conform to our own ideas of what science should be saying about him and his world.
God is unlimited in his realm, however this earth and this universe is not perfect. Emergence of truth be it finding the higgs boson at the LHC in Europe or if it was the emerging truth that the Big Bang gave us that confirmed that there was indeed a creation of the universe vs. the scientific idea that the universe was eternal and static, this emerging truth will always vindicate God in the end.
Hmmm ... Rev, not for the first time in this thread, this feels like motes and beams. First you accuse me of putting words in your mouth, then you go straight on to talk about MY 'beloved secular science academy of sciences'. As I am neither 'secular' (other than in the sense that I believe in a secular state), nor anything resembling a 'scientist', nor American, I feel little or no investment in NASA or whichever academy you're quoting this time. As others (and I) have pointed out upthread, besides, those quotes don't say what you think they say. They merely leave the question of the existence of God open, because neither evolutionary nor Big Bang theory have any bearing on the question of his existence.
I of course disagree, and would say that the references support my claims. Of course as you and I have said direct proof for God is not possible at this time, however science and philosophy etc has given us overwhelming evidence to point to the existence of God. As a Christian I would of hoped that you would support that, instead your beliefs sometimes read like an excerpt from the atheist manifesto.
For many centuries people were resistant to the heliocentric model of the universe because they thought that, if it were true, the Bible must be wrong and atheism would ensue. Yet it was shown to be true, and Christianity didn't collapse. God was bigger than the thinkers of the time.
That’s why all my ideas are supported by the bible first and science second. For a hundred years science said the bible was wrong the universe existed forever and was static. During this time science supported this theory and Christians (like you) were ridiculed and wrote off as ignorant. If I had been around in that time I would of said no the universe was created by God and we will have to wait until science catches up with the our faith, I guess you know how the story ends eh?
How do you know that the same isn't true of multiple world theory, evolution by natural selection, etc?
As I said I use the bible first. The bible does not mention many universes so I don’t say they do not exist, see?
I think, actually, we agree on the basics. There is a world which we can understand, to a certain limited extent, by use of our God-given brains. However, you are much less willing than I to think that God will survive and surpass all our attempts to understand him, and much more concerned to find him in the gaps that science cannot (yet) explain.
Yes because God WANTS us to understand him and to know him and his universe. The entire bible is about God yearning for us to understand him, that is why I use every god given talent and discipline to learn about God, and its ALL good! I have the faith that science will ALWAYS catch up with God the bible.
Personally I find that this diminishes his power. I don't seek to use scientific theory to 'prove' faith precisely because my faith thrives on doubt and mystery and awe.
God made all of us different. I find that when emerging science validates biblical concepts that it makes God even more real and gives me a tool to share God with unbelievers that may not be able to accept God on faith alone.
God doesn't 'exist' as a being in the way that other beings like us exist. He/she/it is beyond our comprehension, by definition. Why go around trying to set limits on what science can discover about the wonderful world we've been given? God isn't limited.
You see that’s what is so different between your relationship with God and mine. God is as real as my basset hound and I know him by his works. Its like a friendship or even being married. To know a friend or a spouse, you have to learn about them. The longer you know, and the more little nuances and such that you learn about them the more you love them, (I hope!!) God is the exactly the same way with me.
Oh, and if you decide that you can only believe because it is reasonable to do so, because you've convinced yourself that science backs up your beliefs, then what happens in future if you find that science contradicts something you believe?
I use reason and logic to define my reality if that goes away I will be in a rubber room in Belleview anyway. God will always make sense to me because he is as real as a sunrise. When practicing Buddhism, to become enlightenment is to be one with God in meditation usually. I have become one with God by many means, not just science or even the bible. The revelation of the universe describes God to me.
Do you lose your faith, or do you decide that God is bigger than that? Or do you, like those who opposed Galileo, decide that you have to close your eyes to science and reassert dogma? (that's what it looks very like you're doing here, I'm sorry to say).
Ha ha really you don’t know me very well or my faith do you? I appreciate you trying to save me from myself but please, its you that should remove the mote from your eye eh? I am not here attempting to tell you that your form of belief is wrong as you are doing to me. I am saying that if your ideas of religion and God work for you apply those and be happy.
Gah. I don't come to JREF to argue with Christians, I come to learn. But then I end up getting all upset by the way some Christians present the faith and I just can't help myself.
You may learn from me, I am a teacher of Christians and have brought many to God in my missions and church, but here is not the place to recruit eh? So what I say to you is be secure in your beliefs and don’t try to change the nuances of other Christians you may do much more harm than good. If a Christian believes what he must to be saved then don’t try to force your beliefs, just say what you beliefs and go on, if the seed you planted it will grow, but trust me I have already been where you are and have moved on from there.
; {>