The certainty of God's existence.

This astonishing requirement for the initial condition (as per Penrose) at creation suggests that the odds are no better than 1 in 10 raised to the 10th power raised to the 123rd power that the universe in which we live was created by random chance. If the math holds true and it has despite the best efforts of Christian haters and metaphysical skeptics, and this understanding is as logical as to give the impression intended, it means that the chance that means dear brothers and sisters, that the (fallacy and flight of fantasy) universe was created at random is so close to zero is as close to absolutely impossible as could hope to get!

; {>


one known universe/one known universe=1
one known universe/unknown=division by zero
one unknown universe potential/unknown possible universes=unknown

Penrose can NOT claim to know anything about initial conditions, he has not formulated GUT, nor has he seen beyond spacetime.
 
sleepy_lioness; said:
You haven't read my biog either. I stated upthread that I am a Christian. Actually, I'm a very committed one, and it's a big part of my life, which is why I'm bothering to argue with you. I find it tragic that so many Christians seem to get stuck in a dead end of arguing with scientists over whether science proves God or not.

I admire you for your faith and that your ‘very committed’. Christianity is my life as well, its what I do in life (although If my NP’s keep running in the red I may have to take on a secular job).

You may not find it so tragic if you would read some e mails from fence sitters that decided to choose Christianity because of such things as the KCA, and the various science compatible reasons to choose Neo Meta/positive Christianity NMPC* ( my term). I have not even attempted to get anyone to convert, they simply read my beliefs and say ’hey I was raised Ipod enabled, Computer ,X box Bluetooth science geek type guy, and your ideas seem much more in synch with contemporary valid than the atheist’s world view.


My faith is separate from my knowledge of science, because I think, like the Scholastic theologians, that the world is a separate sphere of knowledge from God.

I find that an alien concept, because God, in my paradigm, is ‘in’ everything, while I do separate God from the natural world at a point, such as his realm being eternal and perfect, I find no scripture that tells us he can not interact with the material world. What I do find intensely interesting is that God sends envoys when he needs to speak Mano-a-mano to we humans. In fact save for Moses and perhaps one or two more instances (all where its questionable if they viewed God directly).

For this reason I find no conflict between God and science, and I don't need to try to marry up the two. It is a truism to me that God is behind everything and is the font of all knowledge, so to me insisting that certain scientific knowledge and theories *must* be wrong because they conflict with a narrow reading of the Bible or our own narrow ideas of what God *must* be, is self-defeating. God is always bigger than we can imagine.

I fully understand your views! Trust me I am from East Tennessee and you should see the looks I get when I go (usually uninvited) to a meeting of Clergy some of standing around in our frocks and preacher shirts, when I mention some of my more unorthodox ideas, I not only get homicidal vein popping out of the (red)neck looks but >>>!!!! stand back brother, <<<<!!! Or the every common >>>>I will pray for you son,<<<< along with a choir >>>> do you know you can go to hell for comments such as that!!! <<< To being asked to leave and don’t come back!

But I agree that God is not visually comprehensible to humans (with plenty of biblical reference), and he is omniscient in his realm. That’s why he made our universe, which is limited, and runs on natural law including chaos and uncertainty etc. We perceive our universe as imperfect but is it really? No it’s a perfect universe, designed to be ‘imperfect’, to give us free will in an deterministic preordained as close as probabilities call allow universe.

(theological derail - non-Christians please feel free to skip)

On Christ - of course, the model of classical Christology, to which I along with most other Christians who've ever existed hold, only works if you assume, as the attendees at Chalcedon and the others who wrote it did, that the divine is of a different order and class of being than the human. Otherwise Christ's full humanity is impossible. To hold to the central paradox of Christianity, that Jesus was simultaneously divine and human, you have to believe that the divine was of such another order that it did not cancel out his humanity (from Origen, or possibly even earlier, theologians took it as read that Christ had to be human in order to be able to save humanity, but also more than human in order to overcome sin). This, it seems to me, is an excellent model for the relationship between human achievement, as shown in science, among other things, and God's power. The divine does not cancel out the human but works with it. God is always bigger than us, and we cannot understand or anticipate his actions by a science designed to understand the world, any more than we can get our heads around soteriology or the resurrection by using scientific reasoning.

(/theological derail)

I think Jesus was human, and had a direct link to God. We Christians and even non Christians are part divine because we have a soul, this is a spiritual that can not be broken, only diminished. Jesus was Human and God just as we are, however Jesus was a special creation and therefore gods holy presence and infusion into the flesh was nearly complete. As far as God and science goes, science is a tool that simple attempts to understand the truths of God, and God allows the evidences to emerge at a preordained pace. So I feel that we can know a bit of the mind of God and that God is practically shouting for us to use science to discover and proclaim his wonders to the world.

I don't, of course. Many people find that the more they study the natural world, the more awe they feel at God's creation. The question is whether that awe is allowed to stand or whether we feel the need to set limits on God by insisting that he conform to our own ideas of what science should be saying about him and his world.

God is unlimited in his realm, however this earth and this universe is not perfect. Emergence of truth be it finding the higgs boson at the LHC in Europe or if it was the emerging truth that the Big Bang gave us that confirmed that there was indeed a creation of the universe vs. the scientific idea that the universe was eternal and static, this emerging truth will always vindicate God in the end.

Hmmm ... Rev, not for the first time in this thread, this feels like motes and beams. First you accuse me of putting words in your mouth, then you go straight on to talk about MY 'beloved secular science academy of sciences'. As I am neither 'secular' (other than in the sense that I believe in a secular state), nor anything resembling a 'scientist', nor American, I feel little or no investment in NASA or whichever academy you're quoting this time. As others (and I) have pointed out upthread, besides, those quotes don't say what you think they say. They merely leave the question of the existence of God open, because neither evolutionary nor Big Bang theory have any bearing on the question of his existence.

I of course disagree, and would say that the references support my claims. Of course as you and I have said direct proof for God is not possible at this time, however science and philosophy etc has given us overwhelming evidence to point to the existence of God. As a Christian I would of hoped that you would support that, instead your beliefs sometimes read like an excerpt from the atheist manifesto.

For many centuries people were resistant to the heliocentric model of the universe because they thought that, if it were true, the Bible must be wrong and atheism would ensue. Yet it was shown to be true, and Christianity didn't collapse. God was bigger than the thinkers of the time.

That’s why all my ideas are supported by the bible first and science second. For a hundred years science said the bible was wrong the universe existed forever and was static. During this time science supported this theory and Christians (like you) were ridiculed and wrote off as ignorant. If I had been around in that time I would of said no the universe was created by God and we will have to wait until science catches up with the our faith, I guess you know how the story ends eh?

How do you know that the same isn't true of multiple world theory, evolution by natural selection, etc?

As I said I use the bible first. The bible does not mention many universes so I don’t say they do not exist, see?

I think, actually, we agree on the basics. There is a world which we can understand, to a certain limited extent, by use of our God-given brains. However, you are much less willing than I to think that God will survive and surpass all our attempts to understand him, and much more concerned to find him in the gaps that science cannot (yet) explain.

Yes because God WANTS us to understand him and to know him and his universe. The entire bible is about God yearning for us to understand him, that is why I use every god given talent and discipline to learn about God, and its ALL good! I have the faith that science will ALWAYS catch up with God the bible.

Personally I find that this diminishes his power. I don't seek to use scientific theory to 'prove' faith precisely because my faith thrives on doubt and mystery and awe.

God made all of us different. I find that when emerging science validates biblical concepts that it makes God even more real and gives me a tool to share God with unbelievers that may not be able to accept God on faith alone.

God doesn't 'exist' as a being in the way that other beings like us exist. He/she/it is beyond our comprehension, by definition. Why go around trying to set limits on what science can discover about the wonderful world we've been given? God isn't limited.

You see that’s what is so different between your relationship with God and mine. God is as real as my basset hound and I know him by his works. Its like a friendship or even being married. To know a friend or a spouse, you have to learn about them. The longer you know, and the more little nuances and such that you learn about them the more you love them, (I hope!!) God is the exactly the same way with me.

Oh, and if you decide that you can only believe because it is reasonable to do so, because you've convinced yourself that science backs up your beliefs, then what happens in future if you find that science contradicts something you believe?

I use reason and logic to define my reality if that goes away I will be in a rubber room in Belleview anyway. God will always make sense to me because he is as real as a sunrise. When practicing Buddhism, to become enlightenment is to be one with God in meditation usually. I have become one with God by many means, not just science or even the bible. The revelation of the universe describes God to me.

Do you lose your faith, or do you decide that God is bigger than that? Or do you, like those who opposed Galileo, decide that you have to close your eyes to science and reassert dogma? (that's what it looks very like you're doing here, I'm sorry to say).

Ha ha really you don’t know me very well or my faith do you? I appreciate you trying to save me from myself but please, its you that should remove the mote from your eye eh? I am not here attempting to tell you that your form of belief is wrong as you are doing to me. I am saying that if your ideas of religion and God work for you apply those and be happy.

Gah. I don't come to JREF to argue with Christians, I come to learn. But then I end up getting all upset by the way some Christians present the faith and I just can't help myself.

You may learn from me, I am a teacher of Christians and have brought many to God in my missions and church, but here is not the place to recruit eh? So what I say to you is be secure in your beliefs and don’t try to change the nuances of other Christians you may do much more harm than good. If a Christian believes what he must to be saved then don’t try to force your beliefs, just say what you beliefs and go on, if the seed you planted it will grow, but trust me I have already been where you are and have moved on from there.

; {>
 
Good morning Ms (I forgot or is it Ms or Mrs?) Hokulele.. Wait you said your husband is a Christian didn't you? So it has to be Mrs.

Anyway good morning. Hey, solipsism is not such a philosophical no mans land, it has a lot going for it, except for the name, I always envision a slug when I see it for some reason, I suppose that its because I feel that its an intellectually lazy argument.

However in playing the devils advocate I could say ‘I know’ that I am real, but you and everyone else is an abstract concept, and I, and everyone else am a abstract concept to you. How do you know I am real?

; {>
As I always say, Solipsism is pretty easily defeated. If I am the Solipsist then I composed St Matthew's Passion - so I sit down at the piano and test the theory by composing something else as good. Since I can't even compose something that doesn't make the dog howl then it is a pretty safe bet that I didn't write St Matthew's Passion.

Repeat with Milton's "Paradise Lost", T.S Eliot's "The Waste Land", Ian Dury's "New Boots and Panties", the Marx Brothers Films, Django's guitar playing - well you get the idea, there are mental artifacts that could not plausibly have originated from my mind therefore other minds exist.
 
Well you don't agree with me but the Academy of Sciences does. Its position that science is that its ok for science to be integrated with God, or are you ignoring the definition of theistic evolution ? I mean you cant get more cozy that that! BTW I like the ring of that term. ‘Theistic evolution’ And I heartily approve of their ’formal’ recognition.

Where is the disagreement? They say it is not incompatible: I say it is not incompatible: you say it is not incompatible. I really wonder why you are trying to construct conflict out of harmony. But whatever floats your boat


<snip>


I have never said that I use science to determine what happened ‘before’ the big bang, and have went to great lengths to say that the KCA etc are cosmological arguments and have different criteria to meet than a scientific argument. However BOTH are recognized as rational and reasonable methods for discovery and discussion. If I had a dollar for every time I had said this I could go on a coke binge, if I did coke, but I prefer Pepsi products.

We are agreed that science is irrelevant. Why are we talking about it in this thread, again? I did ask but you don't seem to have answered.



Because they are wrong?

No. That can't be it because you agree with them. Science has nothing to say about god. You know it and we know it. I think you need some other explanation.



No but it did confirm the BB as the ‘best’ theory , I was using the site to verify that fact among others. Many universes theories for example. Of course I have no way of knowing what you actually think, you just seem intent on proving anything I say is wrong. BTW what do you believe? Do you think that this is the only universe or that there were more? If you have no opinion why do you insist on deriding my beliefs?

Once again please point to where I have derided your beliefs. You can give me a third apology if you like: I am still waiting for the second.....



God is science.

Please elaborate on this odd statement


Science does not mention God or have anything to tell us about God ?

That is correct


Well look in the index of any theoretical physicists books and you will see a usually see a paragraph of page numbers referring to God! So I think you simply are ignoring the facts that science does say a lot about God, some science is steeped in the question of God.

Nope. Some scientists are theists and some of them discuss how scientific discovery relates to their religious belief. That has nothing to do with science and everything to do with the fact that scientists are people. If you disagree then please point to the experimental work and to the falsifiable hypotheses which are included in those passages.

Especially theoretical physics and the philosophy of science, and theistic evolution (get used to that term) and evolutionary biology (ie abiogenesis) to name a few. So no I don’t know what’s wrong with you when you can look at the facts and make comments like that !

I am familiar with the term theistic evolution: familiar enough to know that is it not the same as ID. Familiar enough to now that it it was "invented" to incorporate the strong evidence for evolution into a theistic world view. I am sorry that you do not understand that, but keep trying: you may get there in the end. I hope you do

Maybe if you get mad enough at me

It is true that I find you insulting and arrogant. It is not because you are a theist, though.....

and Christianity

Just keep repeating your hate-driven strawmen: someone might find it persuasive. You never know.

it will force you to hit the books and that would be a wonderful thing!

Well I have seen what you are capable of in reading a simplistic article designed for popular consumption. You do not understand what it says. I do. Perhaps if you had a better appreciation of your limitations you would not make such errors. But I do strongly urge you to consider the cliche "do not try to run before you can walk" because you are apt to fall over


Perhaps instead of reinforcing your disdain for Christianity (or perhaps its more of the meddling of Christianity in science according to you) , you may become an apostasied atheist and maybe, just maybe I will see your beautiful smiling face in church morrow.

I see you have already decided to keep repeating this strawman: I have no disdain for Christianity, RevDisturba. Nor does Christianity "meddle" in science. The scientific method is just that: it is method which helps us to gain knowledge of the natural world. It is there for all of us to use and it tells us nothing about the supernatural because it is not the right kind of tool. As NASA agrees. As you agree ( some of the time, anyway). Why do you persist with these lies?
 
Last edited:
I've been following this ENTIRE thread, believe it or not. I just never post because frankly, the physics is a tad beyond me (Scary math is involved! Run away, run away! :eek: ) But I do feel compelled to note that we have a spectrum of beliefs here, and that may not always be evident. It isn't monolithic. Rev is on one end, and Lioness seems to be somewhere over here in liberal Christian-land, and then I think we had some interesting pagan-ish beliefs over there, and then I'm wandering about in left field, not catching the mystical softballs. :) Not everyone is an atheist. It's perfectly possible to be all varieties of not-an-atheist and not agree with attempts to prove the existence of God through science. As Fiona and NASA continue to point out, the best way to understand this argument is probably to see it as consisting of two separate spheres, or as two great tastes that were never meant to go together, like tuna in tomato sauce with capers and triple Death by Chocolate cake. Trying to prove God through science is like trying to mix church and state-- of the two, the religious concept is harmed a lot more.

And then there's also this:

However in playing the devils advocate I could say ‘I know’ that I am real, but you and everyone else is an abstract concept, and I, and everyone else am a abstract concept to you. How do you know I am real?

Okay, THIS I can finally talk about intelligently. No, you don't know that you're real. But one thing you can indeed know is that if someone seriously believes that nobody else is "real", this may be a symptom of a personality disorder as defined by the DSM-IV-TR. It's a pretty classic sign of antisocial personality disorder. On the other hand, feeling that not only one's self, but everyone and everything else is unreal (while maintaining awareness that this does not represent reality) is one of the diagnostic criteria for depersonalization disorder, which is one of the dissociative disorders. So this isn't just a matter of a philosophical construct (solipsism), but of a mental disorder, of something which is not functioning correctly in the brain. We can also say that these aren't the same as mental illnesses because the general consensus is that they aren't biologically based (particularly dissociative disorders). Now clearly, this isn't to say that anyone specifically has a mental disorder. The point is that we can classify and quantify what this line of thinking means in terms of the human personality; we can say something scientific, science-based, about the question "how do I know that I am real"? We can't answer the question, but we CAN talk about what the question means, and the way I would address it is as a symptom of a mental disorder because that's the only way in which I could say anything intelligent about it.

I do think that in a way, that's the entire question on which this thread turns. What's actually a quantifiable question, and what isn't? When all is said and done, I just don't think that there's any way to turn "Can we have any certainty that God exists?" into that kind of question. But what we've been doing is to talk about what the question itself means.
 
Last edited:
I am afraid that many of the greatest minds of theoretical physics would disagree with you.

Which goes to show what happens when theoretical physicists go beyond their specialty and venture into philosophy. If the calculation and its implications were truly within the realm of theoretcial physics, then all of the greatest minds of theoretical physics would disagree with me.

Its its generally accepted that for our universe to have the extremely low entropy it now has required as the "starting point" at the big bang the selection of a virtually infinitesimally tiny volume of the total phase space of all possible universes.

OK. So we can conclude that there weren't a bunch of proto-universes wandering around in phase space waiting to happen, and the one that popped out just happened to have what it takes to be what we are.

And?

The universe happened. We don't know why. We can never know why.* We can never know if there is a "why". There's no reason to believe there are other universes, so it doesn't make a lot of sense to say that this particular universe supports our existence, but some other universe might not.

We know that if things were slightly different than they are, the universe would be different. That's not a really profound statement.

We also know that this universe wasn't "picked at random" from the probability space that Penrose defined.

So, what are the implications of that? How do we get from "The universe was not picked at random from the following probability space." to "There is a God?"

(And are there any really good English teachers in the house? The punctuation of that previous sentence just looks horribly wrong, but I think it follows the rules.)

*Scientifically, that is.
 
Go ahead please don't come back with a piece from some atheist apologist website. Until then ;

"Roger Penrose*, a famous British mathematician and a close friend of Stephen Hawking, wondered about this question and tried to calculate the probability. Including what he considered to be all variables required for human beings to exist and live on a planet such as ours, he computed the probability of this environment occurring among all the possible results of the Big Bang.

According to Penrose, the odds against such an occurrence were on the order of 10^10^123 to 1."
Assuming a closed, and indeed, cyclic Universe.

Anyone have some good recipes for crow?
First, catch your crow.
 
Trying to prove God through science is like trying to mix church and state-- of the two, the religious concept is harmed a lot more.

First I don't attempt to prove God VIA science, I simply show that God and religion is can be used to bolster one another. And if you think using science to help understand religion etc harms religion I started posting these kinds of subjects about two years ago, I would be happy to send you one hundred e mails where either the senders of the E mails were helped or actually converted to Christianity because my way of understanding God made sense to them. Then if you read those I could send you quite a few more! Nevertheless If just ONE person would of said I had helped them it would of been worth it.

Come to think of it, it wasn't until I started posting in atheists dominated web sites that every now and again I would hear that I am harming Christianity by defending it by logical arguments and science...hmmm. If I am harming Christianity all you christian bashers should be throwing in with me and encouraging me !:rolleyes:

I don't think anyone in this forum would come to Christianity via traditional methods anyway, that's nearly a given! But as I said I am not here to convert anyone, I'm here to defend Christianity from falsehoods and outright lies. Additionally and the main reason I am here I am here is to rebut those that say there is no logical argument for the existence of God, there are twenty at last count. And we have only just touched on two.

Religion and science are compatible, there should be no disagreement between them I always differentiate between a cosmological theory and a scientific one, I am afraid that many people still do not understand that distinction and the fact that I use both science and metaphysics as they should be used I have said many times that a cosmological argument has different criteria to meet than scientific theory, but this seems to of fell on quite a few deaf ears (by design?).

So again, I know I help Christians and Christianity. I am not happy with Christians who sit on their hands and criticize me while doing nothing to defend their faith.They are not following the teachings of Jesus Christ and they are definitely harming Christians and those that may become Christians by their apathy. Is science and religion/ Christianity in disagreement? NO! As the Academy of sciences said :

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth. This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution. Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."

Indeed right out of the secular horses mouth...

; {>
 
Last edited:
And once again, it implies no such thing, any more than the fact that I can only know my own thoughts with any certainty implies that I am the only thing to have ever existed, or ever will exist.

Your claim is simply solipsism on a cosmic scale.

:rolleyes: We will agree to disagree you can remain in your blissful world that is completely and fully sans true scientific knowledge.

: {>
 
, I simply show that God and religion is can be used to bolster one another.

No: they can't. This is your fundamental error.


the main reason I am here I am here is to rebut those that say there is no logical argument for the existence of God, there are twenty at last count. And we have only just touched on two.

Two? I have seen your syllogism which is certainly a logical argument for the existence of god: though it does not appear to be a very good one

What is the other *logical* argument. I have missed it

I am not happy with Christians who sit on their hands and criticize me while doing nothing to defend their faith.They are not following the teachings of Jesus Christ and they are definitely harming Christians and those that may become Christians by their apathy.

More insults based on mindreading? You are incorrigible, RevDisturba :D

Is science and religion/ Christianity in disagreement? NO!

Well yes, actually. Evolutionary theism is form of deism: it has nothing to do with Christianity at all.

As the Academy of sciences said :

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth. This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution. Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."

Indeed. It is, as I said, tautological to say that evolutionary theism is not in disagreeement with scientific explanations of evolution. Accommodating those is what it was "invented" for

Indeed right out of the secular horses mouth...

It does not say what you say it says, RevDisturba. Really your reading comprehension is quite shockingly bad. You should work on that

;{>

I think that religion and science are compatiable however even I differeniate between a cosmological theory and a sceinific one, I am afraid that many people still do not understand that distiction and the fact that I use both science and metaphyics as they should be used, and have said many times that a cosmological argument has diffierent critera to meet than scientific theory.

; {>

Don't see anybody who does not understand the distinction, RevDisturba. Some of us are a bit confused as to why you bring in science, since your own citations show it to be irrelevant to the existence of god.

Oh, I remember: it is because you do not understand that. Apparently
 
We will agree to disagree you can remain in your blissful world that is completely and fully sans true scientific knowledge.
Strawman, ad hominem.

RevD, since you keep claiming that big bang cosmology implies (in your words) "one universe, on try", I expect that you can show that this is the case.

Instead of just insulting people.

So, go ahead.
 
First I don't attempt to prove God VIA science
By a combination of misunderstood science, false premises, and flawed logic, to be precise.

I simply show that God and religion is can be used to bolster one another.
Nope.

Science is based on falsifiability. This is why it works. This is why it is useful.

Religion is based on unfalsifiability. This is why people seek comfort in it. This is also why it has no intrinsic value.

And if you think using science to help understand religion etc harms religion I started posting these kinds of subjects about two years ago, I would be happy to send you one hundred e mails where either the senders of the E mails were helped or actually converted to Christianity because my way of understanding God made sense to them.
"The lurkers support me in email."

Then if you read those I could send you quite a few more! Nevertheless If just ONE person would of said I had helped them it would of been worth it.
Perhaps it would be worth it to you. But you're still wrong.

Come to think of it, it wasn't until I started posting in atheists dominated web sites that every now and again I would hear that I am harming Christianity by defending it by logical arguments and science...hmmm. If I am harming Christianity all you christian bashers should be throwing in with me and encouraging me !
Strawman and ad hominem, yet again.

We are arguing with you because your premises are false and your logic faulty. If your premises were true and your logic valid, then what you have to say would be significant. They aren't, it isn't, and it's not.

I don't think anyone in this forum would come to Christianity via traditional methods anyway, that's nearly a given!
Many of us have already done so - and then left.

But as I said I am not here to convert anyone, I'm here to defend Christianity from falsehoods and outright lies.
Defence by logical fallacy? That's a new one.

Wait. No it's not.

Additionally and the main reason I am here I am here is to rebut those that say there is no logical argument for the existence of God, there are twenty at last count. And we have only just touched on two.
There is no sound logical argument for the existence of God.

As has been pointed out, your argument has been going backwards since you first presented it.

Religion and science are compatible, there should be no disagreement between them I always differentiate between a cosmological theory and a scientific one, I am afraid that many people still do not understand that distinction and the fact that I use both science and metaphysics as they should be used I have said many times that a cosmological argument has different criteria to meet than scientific theory, but this seems to of fell on quite a few deaf ears (by design?).
No.

So again, I know I help Christians and Christianity.
By committing an endless sequence of logical fallacies?

I am not happy with Christians who sit on their hands and criticize me while doing nothing to defend their faith.
That's your problem.

They are not following the teachings of Jesus Christ and they are definitely harming Christians and those that may become Christians by their apathy.
Or perhaps you're wrong.

Is science and religion/ Christianity in disagreement? NO! As the Academy of sciences said :

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth. This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution. Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."
This is drivel. Question-begging, special-pleading drivel.

Also, it contradicts your cherished Intelligent Design.

Still drivel.

Indeed right out of the secular horses mouth...
They're wrong too.
 
<personal comments removed>

Anyway good morning. Hey, solipsism is not such a philosophical no mans land, it has a lot going for it, except for the name, I always envision a slug when I see it for some reason, I suppose that its because I feel that its an intellectually lazy argument.

However in playing the devils advocate I could say ‘I know’ that I am real, but you and everyone else is an abstract concept, and I, and everyone else am a abstract concept to you. How do you know I am real?

:rolleyes: We will agree to disagree you can remain in your blissful world that is completely and fully sans true scientific knowledge.


What is the reasoning behind two such completely different reponses to my post?
 
That’s why all my ideas are supported by the bible first and science second. For a hundred years science said the bible was wrong the universe existed forever and was static. During this time science supported this theory and Christians (like you) were ridiculed and wrote off as ignorant. If I had been around in that time I would of said no the universe was created by God and we will have to wait until science catches up with the our faith, I guess you know how the story ends eh?
You seem to have a rather inaccurate view of the history of science and the history of the Bible. The Bible never states that the universe is temporally finite and expanding. It simply gives a creation myth borrowed from other cultures.

As I said I use the bible first. The bible does not mention many universes so I don’t say they do not exist, see?
Do you believe that there was a world-wide flood that only a single family of humans survived. Do you believe that Joseph the husband of Mary had two fathers?

The entire bible is about God yearning for us to understand him...
What are we to understand about God from the descriptions of the genocides he commanded his people to commit?

I have the faith that science will ALWAYS catch up with God the bible.
What has science yet to learn that the Bible predicts?
 
Nah. You haven’t read my bio where I have laid my soul bare and readily admitted that I had no faith at all to begin with. Not even the faith of a mustard seed cut into a sextillion pieces. Not even one of those pieces. I had zero faith. I was a good evangelical atheist. Very good! I came to God VIA science. I can not say for sure that if say some ET’s come down in a space ship and said they created our universe and created a few examples to prove that they could do it, I can not say that my faith wouldn’t be shaken! In fact the bible tells us that NO flesh would be saved unless the real Christ returned and saved all of us from worshiping the antichrist Christians and Muslims alike! Yep, I very well may back slide, but I doubt it. Faith is a funny thing, so I would like to think that my faith is sound because I have found truth, and its been truth for over a decade. Oh and look in the bible of the people that knew Jesus personally, and still went apostate !



How do you know that God did not use science to change me?



Are you going to put words in my mouth like a few others here have? Why do you feel the need to attempt to make me say what I do not believe? I posted a link where your own beloved secular science academy of sciences embraced theistic evolutionary theory.



Ha ha…hee hee..really! I actually think God did and there is scripture to prove it. But to answer your question God gave me science to solve scientific earthly problems, and the bible to solve metaphysical problems, sometimes they merge but that’s unavoidable because God is a master engineer of universes which we can understand and even manipulate by using our God given brain.

BTW do you claim any religious ID?

; {>

You claim to have found god but all I see is your ego. The universe whispers in your ear and all you hear is "How great thou art".

Your god seems to answer all your needs.
 
You seem to have a rather inaccurate view of the history of science and the history of the Bible. The Bible never states that the universe is temporally finite and expanding. It simply gives a creation myth borrowed from other cultures.


It is actually even stranger than that. The original creation story from Genesis wasn't necessarily a creation ex nihilo, but a use of pre-existing materials. In essence, according to the bible, the Hebrew god didn't actually generate new material, but rearranged stuff to form the heavens and the earth. This gets back to Robin's question of what is meant by "to begin" as opposed to "to begin to exist".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_nihilo#Arguments_against_ex_nihilo_creation
 
RevD, you have made several obvious mistakes in your reasoning in this thread. You just don't seem to want to acknowledge them.
First of all, you are so all-fired happy about this scientific institution "acknowledging" theistic evolution. Let me tell you something: it doesn't matter one bit. Theistic evolution says that God created the universe through evolution. Well, evolution has been proven correct many times. Science cannot prove that God does not exist (or that he does exist, for that matter), so neither part of the theory is strictly (or, at the very least, provably) false. All this "acknowledgement" means is that they're saying, "Yeah, well, I guess you could be right. There's no way to prove you wrong." But you're dancing around screaming "We won! We won! We won!" like they had all just converted.
You keep harping on the fact that the universe had a probability of 1 to 1^10^123 of turning out as it did. That's as may be; I can't prove you wrong, as I don't have a degree in advanced universe theoretics or mathematics or whatever. But I can tell you this; if the universe had turned out any different, its inhabitants would be sitting on the YGEF forums right now saying "you know, the probability of our universe existing is 1 to 1^10^123?" Somebody's gotta win that lottery. Might as well be us.
There are others, but I'll address these when you answer me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom