The certainty of God's existence.

And once again, it implies no such thing, any more than the fact that I can only know my own thoughts with any certainty implies that I am the only thing to have ever existed, or ever will exist.

Your claim is simply solipsism on a cosmic scale.

BTW, after thinking about your past posts I wonder, do you know what solipsism is? I think you better Google it.

The reason I say that is that I do not deny that other minds exist, how could I be a Christian and a solipsist? I believe in God which is another mind and souls which need a mind, I think atheism would lend its self to solipsist beliefs more readily than theism because atheism (hard atheism) rejects a large part of what I believe to be true such as the mind that created all the other minds.
; {>
 
Last edited:
I was agreeing with Gardner et. al., but I was extending it to your previous comments about the 10^123 zeros discussion. We can't talk about how "improbable" this universe is. This universe exists. It is what it is. There's no rational way to have a discussion about how it might have been different, including any "probability" that it could have been different.

Of course we can talk of not only how it could be much different, but more importantly what caused the universe be able to support life when it shouldn't. That is what implies an intelligent agent:jaw-dropp may be tweaking the system!

; }>
 
Of course we can talk of not only how it could be much different,

We can speculate on what the universe may have been like. But to calculate the probabilities involved in universe creation? No, we really can't. As Terry Pratchett put it, that's like opening a box with the crowbar that's inside.

but more importantly what caused the universe be able to support life when it shouldn't.

Number one: derail attempt. Two:
Whoa, whoa, whoa, WHOA there pardner! Who says that it shouldn't be able to support life? How do you know that it "shouldn't be able"? What's the criteria for deciding that the universe is incapable of supporting life? Because obviously it is able to. Therefore, it should be able to. I mean, it really should be able to, otherwise we wouldn't be here!


That is what implies an intelligent agent:jaw-dropp may be tweaking the system!

Says who?

; }>

Honestly, RevD, the derail attempts are pathetic. Not only that, they get you nowhere. You hit the same wall you do in the regular topic.
 
Dancing David said:
Well, I looked at this
http://www.ws5.com/Penrose/


Well, I looked at this
http://www.ws5.com/Penrose/

Which contains some of the thinking behind Penrose's statement about the probability of the universe being 10^10^123.

?

With all due respect, what exactly do you mean by "the probability of the universe being 10^10^123" . What does that statement mean exactly? Maybe I am having a brain fart but please explain it. You are leaving out part of your sentence aren't you?

; }>
 
Last edited:
Honestly, RevD, the derail attempts are pathetic. Not only that, they get you nowhere. You hit the same wall you do in the regular topic.

You must learn to use your quote tags and learn to respect your elders. You don't make a very good case for your claims what ever they are.

; {>
 
No BBT states things like "due to relativity and space time we can not know at this time if there are other universes","what >>>brevity quote<<<So a modification of the theory would be essential to discuss anything prior to ~10^-36 sec.,

By using current physics We can speak with confidence down to t=10-43 seconds, just after the Big Bang (t=0). Anyway I stand by my claims, as I have said the BB implies one universe. We don't think there are an infinite number of universes when we are speaking about the BB, no we are assuming we are speaking about this, and only this universe.

I have not said that the BB rules out other universes. With that in mind the reason you will not find wording that indicates this is the universe the BB is speaking of is the same reason its not easy to find something like... oh you have a nose stuck on your face. Its a given eh?

; }>
 
Last edited:
BTW, after thinking about your past posts I wonder, do you know what solipsism is?


Yes, hence my labeling your "one universe, one try" cosmic solipsism.

I think you better Google it.


What do you think solipsism means?

The reason I say that is that I do not deny that other minds exist, how could I be a Christian and a solipsist? I believe in God which is another mind and souls which need a mind, I think atheism would lend its self to solipsist beliefs more readily than theism because atheism (hard atheism) rejects a large part of what I believe to be true such as the mind that created all the other minds.


And that is the third response you have made to my post. Why does your conclusion in this post directly contradict the one you made in your first response?
 
Yes, hence my labeling your "one universe, one try" cosmic solipsism.

Its cosmic common sense.

What do you think solipsism means?

"Solipsism is the philosophical idea that one's own mind is all that exists. thank you Wiki

And that is the third response you have made to my post. Why does your conclusion in this post directly contradict the one you made in your first response?

I was seeing if you were paying attention. Or, or, or,...Maybe its time for my warm milk toddy? >pant<

; {>
 
So you're coming to understand why our current theories don't support your 'one universe, one try' claim. Well done.

That post would have nothing to do with the bb implying OUOT. :rolleyes:

And its not my theory all of science is aware that the standard big bang theory implies one universe one try. (without add-ons or variations, that's why its called the standard theory). That is very basic cosmology and so obvious that I would be embarrassed to ask it to anyone that is qualified to answer it, like a K1 teacher.(if she had some college).

; {>
 
Last edited:
This thread is dead, unless someone can come up with some new material . Its pretty much degenerated onto personal innuendos and its getting worse. I think I am going to do another thread or revisit the last one I posted before getting hobbled so severely that I could not answer for fear of ..oopsie'....cant say that !.... I have been...oops! cant say that either...maybe I will just start a new thread all together...; {>
 
You must learn to use your quote tags and learn to respect your elders.

; {>


Ah. I did not realise. Ok people: this is the deal. RevDisturba is 93. He has held his beliefs for a very long time and like many old people he really does not want to have them challenged at this late stage in his life. Now your grandparents may not be like that: there is no reason why people have to become stuck in their ways because of age alone: but you know as well as I do that a lot do

Once you get to a certain level of maturity you realise it costs nothing to just avoid the issues they are batty on. They have probably done a lot of good over the years and raised families, been good neighbours, contributed to society. They have earned a peaceful twilight and it is nice if those who are still curious, and who might make some difference in the world, don't disturb that.

It is annoying to have to listen to their more outlandish views: but what does it really cost ?

I recommend we just indulge him
 
Its cosmic common sense.


In which case, philosophical solipsism is simply personal common sense. Lucky for science it doesn't rely on common sense.

"Solipsism is the philosophical idea that one's own mind is all that exists. thank you Wiki


Does this imply that you didn't know what solipsism was prior to looking it up on Wikipedia?

At any rate, I don't think that is the best concise definition. It would be more accurate to state that one's own self is all that exists. That allows the budding philosopher to avoid the quagmire of whether reality is materialistic or dualistic. This philosophy is based on the premise that there is no external evidence (or that there cannot be any such evidence) that anything else does exist.

Which, of course, ties back in to my original point.
 
That post would have nothing to do with the bb implying OUOT. :rolleyes:

It shows the limit of our current knowledge, and why the big bang theory doesn't imply one universe one try.


And its not my theory all of science is aware that the standard big bang theory implies one universe one try. (without add-ons or variations, that's why its called the standard theory). That is very basic cosmology and so obvious that I would be embarrassed to ask it to anyone that is qualified to answer it, like a K1 teacher.(if she had some college).

; {>

Perhaps if you hadn't been too embarrassed to ask, you'd have learned a bit more.
 
reply to post #1612


Heh heh heh....Now young lady you have the program....ahhhh I was going to say something else but I forgot it .

; {>


Youth and vigor will never defeat old age and treachery...author unknown but I can dig it....
 
Good bye sweet thread the last few posts vindicate what I said eh? I will check in to see if anything other than personal junk has been posted but thanks for all the replies....Rrreggg or whatever you can come back now...

; }>
 
Last edited:
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG RevDisturba has it handed to him
2. yrreG RevDisturba realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG RevDisturba turns tail and flees the thread
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG RevDisturba starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG RevDisturba eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists

I haven't seen evidence of hibernation mode on the Rev's part.
 
You must learn to use your quote tags and learn to respect your elders.
Pure's responses to sentences in posts are quite sensible.
You don't make a very good case for your claims what ever they are.
Your presumption of superiority due to age is both noted and valueless, as it is an insult to the poster.

; {>
...
 
Last edited:
Come on, what did everyone expect from a guy who repeatedly uses "of" instead of "have" after it has been pointed out to him?

So long... Thank you RevDisturba for all your convincing arguments. No, really. They were convincing. Unfortunately not in the way you intended.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom