The certainty of God's existence.

PixyMisa said:
RevDisturba[/quote said:
That was the intent of this debate. Maybe you should reread it all. Without a testable mechanism how can you show evidence for more than one try? We know that there has been at least one try, that's a given, so where are the others? Or where is the evidence for others? Or where is a testable mechanism that can produce others?
Argument from ignorance.
Yes, you might as well ask "where is the testable mechanism that limits it to a one-shot?"

There is no testable mechanism for either case so "many universes" and "exactly one universe" are equally speculative.
 
RevDisturba said:
The BB is a well thought out theory and it does not imply more than one universe.
OK, a quick lesson in logic:
[latex]\neg ( p \rightarrow q )[/latex]​

is not the same as:

[latex]p \rightarrow \neg q[/latex]​

Correct me if I am wrong.
 
No you get the wrong idea. The standard model of the BB wasn't invented by a bunch of theist scientists. (in earlier post I posted links that said the SBBM (standard Big Bang Model) was the most popular model, and it is). So if you believe that the SBBM is correct like most scientists and academics, you do not have to believe anything theistic is involved. One universe one try is just a easy way to phrase it without going into not needed detail and a way to delineate it between a variation of the standard model such a model where many universes are said to be (or could be) a product of inflation. Its much easier to say OUOT than write a couple of paragraphs each time.

Sorry if its confusing.

Who's trying?
 
OK, a quick lesson in logic:
[latex]\neg ( p \rightarrow q )[/latex]​

is not the same as:

[latex]p \rightarrow \neg q[/latex]​

Correct me if I am wrong.
Ah, yes of course.

To make this explicit Rev.

"There is no evidence for the existence of other universes" is not the same as "There is evidence that this is the only Universe"

So, I ask again, where is your evidence that this is the only Universe? And no hand-waving, "The Big Bang implies it", because it does no such thing. You said the empirical evidence implies it. What empirical evidence?
 
Good morning Mr. Agenda. Yes there could be other universes, I have said that so many times I am tired of saying it, we are not concerned with that. What the question is (until the question was perverted) are any of these theories are supported by evidence?

Again the one universe one try theory is the most popular theory and the one used in academia and when scientists speak in general terms about the big bang. I am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.

; {>

You seem to have this weird conceit that the universe must be able to be confined within your head.

Sorry It's bigger than both of us.
 
Since I am dealing with definitions, let's go back to your definition of "begin":
RevDisturba said:
I mean begin as before the universe began there was nothing material. No space, no time, no energy, no subatomic particles, no quantum loop gravity, no quantum foam, nothing that could be considered material.
Let's substitute the definition, so P1 becomes:

P1: If there was something material before the universe began then there would have been an infinite number of events​

And P3: becomes:
P3: Everything which has nothing material before it began must have been caused​

Yes?

"Before" in this context means a non-temporal succession, right?

Now the entire argument appears to hinge upon this concept of 'material'. I would have thought that the ability to cause something defined it as material.

P1 and P3 now seem even more problematical - in what way does materiality imply an infinity of events?

And the intuition of P3 is a lot less clear - how does the fact of not being preceded in any way by material things imply a cause?

(And I note also that the definition of "begin" has the word "began" in it)
 
Last edited:
Hmmm', 15 email notifications in a few hours from the certainty of Gods existence...WHERE ARE YOU RREGGG????? Well to be truthful its better than no responses and thanks to all of you for taking the time to respond.

And if the "other items" are selected solely to support the KCA, we are back to circular reasoning again.

I don't see your reasoning here! Any scientist etc selects sources that supports his claims. I see absolutely no circular reasoning.

In that case, I will call my arguement a philosophical/cosmological one, rather than a scientific one, and use the mathematical constructs to support my case. After all, math has a solid grounding in both science and philosophy (formal logic). In which case I now claim that the existence of a multiverse has been proven to be true.

Ok what is your proof of multiverses? And your argument with premises ? Remember I only claim evidences for the existence of God which would include the KCA,

Please demonstrate the probability calculations supporting this claim.

The (many) claims made by hawking and penrose etc that indicate that the universe should be a hot plasma etc rather than lumpy?

I have now defined the multiverse theory as a cosmological argument and not a scientific theory, and its premises are fundamentally as well as mathematically sound.

The KCA is a logically should syllogism where is your argument. Simply claiming it is so doesn't make it so.

So now what?

Start with your premises and then make sure they support a valid sound conclusion. Otherwise you have no argument, simply a statement.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Ah, yes of course.

To make this explicit Rev.

"There is no evidence for the existence of other universes" is not the same as "There is evidence that this is the only Universe"

So, I ask again, where is your evidence that this is the only Universe? And no hand-waving, "The Big Bang implies it", because it does no such thing. You said the empirical evidence implies it. What empirical evidence?

The big bang implies it, until you admit that the Big Bang theory when used in its most popular form implies one universe>>> THIS one<<<. It doesnt imply that there are an infinite number of universes. The standard BB theory implies this universe is the only one. Why do you think that when discussing many universes spawned from the inflationary era (of the BB) for example astronomers say that theory is a variant of the standard model?

Its difficult to find a source that tells me that apples are red and to attempt to find a source that states the big bang implies that this is the only universe is more difficult than that. Its that simple. And its statements to the contrary that I begin to doubt anyone credibility.

So here is the deal folks. I can't help that you take Wollys opinion over mine in issues of basic cosmology, or insist that something that you may of read out of context means that the standard model (of the BB) implies that there were an infinite number of universes (boy would that ever PO the string theory and ZPE multi-verse adherents!). Or to think that because OUOT may just lend credence to the God theory that its to be rejected out of hand. No that is beyond me.

We will simply have to agree to disagree on the subject. No worries that is common even amongst astrophysicists and cosmologists. Many observational astronomers have a severe distrust of astrophysicists anyway, and I am beginning to see why!

; {>
 
Relevent snips from the bonafide (I loved the brother where art thou movie) NASA WMAP Site

"The Big Bang theory is one of the most strongly supported theories in all of science. It explains the observed facts; it has made successful predictions; it has stood the test of time; and there is no alternate theory that the professional scientific community deems valid."

[Yes I know that but some here should read the bold red type, its important! It may convince them that all the many universe theories are not so wonderful...]

"The Big Bang theory says that the universe was very hot and concentrated in the distant past and, ever since then, space has been stretching and cooling. This is the only theory that successfully explains the observations made by astronomers."

[Hmmm']

"So far, measurements indicate that space is very nearly flat. This is, of course, the easiest shape for us to mentally picture. "

The academy of sciences report ;

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.

[DO TELL but I have already said as much many times here, but its heart warming to have an esteemd group to validate my statements.]

Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."

http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/site/faq.html

; {>
 
Last edited:
Yeah, Yrreg, come back and tell us about how we all hate God and are fearful of God.

That sort of stuff really shows Christianity in a good light.

Don't you recognize humor?

Of course I feel like I am wallowing in your personal extension of your atheistic love and kindness ....!!!not!!! :rolleyes: I don't feel the love Robin. Is my 'love feeler' broken?

In my opinion, you and a few others here are just frustrated because you can not readily defeat the KCA nor the argument from design (which we have only briefly touched on).

Hey smile TGIF...

; }>
 
Last edited:
You seem to have this >>>breivty snip <<< both of us.

? Insults are the only thing you seem to be capable of generating, and that comes from a deep inferiority complex. Maybe if you gain some wisdom of years, you will decide to enrich yourself and others instead of trying to inflict harm ?

; {>
 
Last edited:
Of course I feel like I am wallowing in your personal extension of your atheistic love and kindness ....!!!not!!! :rolleyes: I don't feel the love Robin. Is my 'love feeler' broken?
Hey, have you read some of your own stuff? :rolleyes:

And I have got a Christian in my house who feels the love just fine.
In my opinion, you and a few others here are just frustrated because you can not readily defeat the KCA
The KCA can't be defeated for the same reason that the Titanic can't be sunk.


(argument from design - bring it on)
 
Last edited:
“British physicist P. C. W. Davies has calculated that the odds against the initial conditions being suitable for later star formation (without which planets could not exist) is one followed by a thousand billion billion zeroes, at least. He also estimates that a change in the strength of gravity or of the weak force by only one part in 10,100 would have prevented a life-permitting universe. Roger Penrose of Oxford University has calculated that the odds of the big bang’s low entropy condition existing by chance are on the order of one out of 10 to the 123rd power.”
Argh, quote about fine tuning and it does not show any of the original calculation, if these arguments are going to be brought up then people should cite the ORIGINAL source, not some quote that has been copied to a bazillion websites.

I will look for the source paper, in the past this has been hysterically funny.
 
The big bang implies it, until you admit that the Big Bang theory when used in its most popular form implies one universe>>> THIS one<<<. >


That is just argument by assertion and fallacy of construction. the BBE does not say that this is only universe, you assert that.
It is a combination of BBe and relativity/model of space/time that says we may not see outside the universe.

The fact that we can not see outside the universe at this time, it a statement based upon the models of space/time, it does not say that "There is only one universe", it states "At this time we can only have knowledge of the universe".

And an appeal that the popular understanding of something implies something is still a fallacy of construction.

You assert it, the BBT does not imply it at all.
 
Relevent snips from the bonafide (I loved the brother where art thou movie) NASA WMAP Site

"The Big Bang theory is one of the most strongly supported theories in all of science. It explains the observed facts; it has made successful predictions; it has stood the test of time; and there is no alternate theory that the professional scientific community deems valid."

[Yes I know that but some here should read the bold red type, its important! It may convince them that all the many universe theories are not so wonderful...]

; {>

Hmmm. I'm no scientist (I am, incidentally, a Christian), but I don't see how any of the quotes support your OUOT theory. That there was a Big Bang doesn't seem open to dispute, but surely that doesn't say anything about whether it was the only ever Big Bang, or whether other universes exist, which, as I understand it, are the points on which you are arguing with other (much politer, less arrogant and vastly more qualified) posters here?
 
Relevent snips from the bonafide (I loved the brother where art thou movie) NASA WMAP Site

"The Big Bang theory is one of the most strongly supported theories in all of science. It explains the observed facts; it has made successful predictions; it has stood the test of time; and there is no alternate theory that the professional scientific community deems valid."

[Yes I know that but some here should read the bold red type, its important! It may convince them that all the many universe theories are not so wonderful...]

"The Big Bang theory says that the universe was very hot and concentrated in the distant past and, ever since then, space has been stretching and cooling. This is the only theory that successfully explains the observations made by astronomers."

[Hmmm']

"So far, measurements indicate that space is very nearly flat. This is, of course, the easiest shape for us to mentally picture. "

The academy of sciences report ;

"Many religious persons, including many scientists, hold that God created the universe and the various processes driving physical and biological evolution and that these processes then resulted in the creation of galaxies, our solar system, and life on Earth.

This belief, which sometimes is termed 'theistic evolution,' is not in disagreement with scientific explanations of evolution.

[DO TELL but I have already said as much many times here, but its heart warming to have an esteemd group to validate my statements.]

Indeed, it reflects the remarkable and inspiring character of the physical universe revealed by cosmology, paleontology, molecular biology, and many other scientific disciplines."

http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/site/faq.html

; {>

You are kidding, right?

I read your link. It is written for people like me: that is for people who know little or nothing about astronomy/cosmlogy/science etc. I suspect it is for children. It is certainly popularising some basic ideas.

It confirms what those who are knowledgeable about these matters have been saying to you in this thread, so far as I can see.


What happened before the Big Bang? What happened right at the moment of the Big Bang?
We don't know.

Those who have been discussing this with you have made this point over and over: your position is that you do know. This article does not support you

"Scientists, like many others, are touched with awe at the order and complexity of nature. Indeed, many scientists are deeply religious. But science and religion occupy two separate realms of human experience. Demanding that they be combined detracts from the glory of each."

All it is saying is that the big bang theory in any form has nothing to tell us about god or the cause of the universe or anything that happened until shortly after the big bang: not before/outside/in parallel with, or in any other conception which is not part of this universe.

So far as I can see this is just warm words for theists: it does not support the theist position: it does not challenge it either: it has absolutely nothing to say except "come on in: the science is lovely"

How you can pretend that this is helpful to your position is completely beyond me: if you need it to be true that is fine: as the article says

"Science is not the only way of acquiring knowledge about ourselves and the world around us. Humans gain understanding in many other ways, such as through literature, the arts, philosophical reflection, and religious experience

And so they do. But they cannot support theism in the way you have sought to establish. Science has nothing to say on the matter at all.

Give it up, RevDisturba. Stick with your syllogism and try to address some of the inherent logical problems others have identified: your excursion into science is a non-starter.
 
Again the one universe one try theory is the most popular theory and the one used in academia and when scientists speak in general terms about the big bang. I am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.

Start with your premises and then make sure they support a valid sound conclusion. Otherwise you have no argument, simply a statement.


Mr. Petard meet Mr. Hoist.

PS If you are unaware of Wollery's position and employment and why he might be qualified to speak on the nature of cosmology as taught by cosmologists then perhaps you should find out why?

And then to counter his arguments, you should cite cosmologists who say that Xis X and Y is Y.

You may have some knowledge of cosmology, many of us do, but because I read Guth's pop book on inflation does not mean I can speak for the community that studies the theories of inflation.
 
Mr. Petard meet Mr. Hoist.

PS If you are unaware of Wollery's position and employment and why he might be qualified to speak on the nature of cosmology as taught by cosmologists then perhaps you should find out why?

And then to counter his arguments, you should cite cosmologists who say that Xis X and Y is Y.

You may have some knowledge of cosmology, many of us do, but because I read Guth's pop book on inflation does not mean I can speak for the community that studies the theories of inflation.

FYI Wolly asked me not to mention or speak about his employment, or credentials because I was working on a false assumption, or simply information true or untrue, supplied by a third party (a forum member) concerning his credentials. I have no way of knowing what Mr Wollys credientials are but I usally accept what someone tells me as true UNLESS they make gross errors that someone in that field of work would not make.

BTW, I usually do provide links and quotes relevant to my claims. Additionally, you have no way of knowing the extent of my knowledge of observational astronomy, cosmology astrophysics or theology for that matter. You are clueless to the awards I have received or the papers I have written or even the specific courses I took as a perpetual (; }>) student in college.

Lastly let Wolly speak for himself, its meddling such as yours (even if attempting to defend Mr Wolly) that was one reason Wolly and I got off to a bad start. Thanks to you and your friends he didn't even answer my questions about upgrading my telescope....

; {>
 
Hey, have you read some of your own stuff? :rolleyes:
And I have got a Christian in my house who feels the love just fine.

Yes I know I can be brutal or worse. However even though its not a Christian attribute and I have said many times that its my last stumbling block to having more than a toe hold in the pearly gates, I do not respond to insults very well.

That said if you go back to the first post I made and watch its progress, its obvious who the usual suspects are and its not me. For some reason (of course I know what it is) they have to start needing and making off color remarks about religious icons etc, attempting to irritate, and sometimes they succeed. Then after repeated insults slurs and innuendos when a christian does say something to defend himself its 'oh and you call that a christian attitude'. That is an typical 'bad apple' atheist tactic (bad apple to differentiate the few bad apples that give the majority of good ashiest a bad name).

So I don't start the stuff, and like my bar and club days, I would walk up to someone giving me the evil eye and tell them don't start any poo and there will be no poo....

The KCA can't be defeated for the same reason that the Titanic can't be sunk. (argument from design - bring it on)

Right. Tell that to anyone that is still professionally debating it. The reason the KCA has not been defeated is because its logic is impeccable and its a philosophical argument, there is no defeat or winning it simply is an opinion supported by reason and logic. You can't sink something that can walk on water.

; {>
 
Last edited:
FYI Wolly asked me not to mention or speak about his employment, or credentials because I was working on a false assumption, or simply information true or untrue, supplied by a third party (a forum member) concerning his credentials. I have no way of knowing what Mr Wollys credientials are but I usally accept what someone tells me as true UNLESS they make gross errors that someone in that field of work would not make.
You mean grossly ignorant errors like saying "before the Big Bang" and "there was nothing and then there was something"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom