Because if there is one try and the universe unfolds as it does (being able to support life etc) against some pretty fascinating odds it lends credence to several theist friendly theories. First and formost a OUOT theory would support the KCA. The argument from design is not as dependent for example ;
“British physicist P. C. W. Davies has calculated that the odds against the initial conditions being suitable for later star formation (without which planets could not exist) is one followed by a thousand billion billion zeroes, at least. He also estimates that a change in the strength of gravity or of the weak force by only one part in 10,100 would have prevented a life-permitting universe. Roger Penrose of Oxford University has calculated that the odds of the big bang’s low entropy condition existing by chance are on the order of one out of 10 to the 123rd power.”
I think I get it. The universe is fine tuned to support life, but if it got many tries, then it would be not surprising that one of those gazillion universes happened to support life. Is that it?
I think mister Davies is abusing the notion of "odds" myself. Yes, if gravity was just a tiny bit different, the universe wouldn't work. And? Gravity isn't a tiny bit different. I don't know how to compute a "probability" that gravity would be stronger or weaker.
Furthermore, I can't imagine how one would go about imagining how the universe would behave if gravity were stronger or weaker, but everything else was identical, which appears to be the premise on which these probability calculations are based. It strikes me as practically nonsensical.
That doesn’t stop some theoretical scientists from trying.
Not exactly. Physicists might speculate on how, given the laws of physics, huge quantities of matter/energy might suddenly spring into existence where none had been before, but that isn't exactly the same as answering the question about how the universe came into existence. There remains the question of how the "laws of physics" came to be, and that isn't answerable by science.
I can assure you that I am correct when I quote facts about cosmology or astronomy.
Well.....sort of. I haven't seen any glaring errors, except that there's a bit of "spin" on some of the statements.
The big bang is central to the KCA.
Is it the big bang that is central, or is it the emergence of the universe from nothing that is central?
The cosmological argument, and its variations including the one you have put forward, are, in my opinion, a very powerful argument against pure materialism. Why is there something instead of nothing? Even if matter were recycled from other universes, or if multiple universes popped into existence whenever conditions were right, as opposed to just once, or any variation thereof, it seems to me that we would still be left with a dilemma. Why did the laws of physics exist, and how did they suddenly take effect to create our universe?
Science explains everything through causal arguments. ("Causal" being used in the scientific sense, meaning that the state of a system is dependent on its prior state, as opposed to some future state.)The appearance of the universe can't be a result of a causal phenomenon. So, that throws a monkey wrench into anyone's effort to explain everything in scientific terms.
However, I can't manage to get from there to God. If I grant that some sort of non-physical "act" or "phenomenon" or whatever gave rise to the existence of the universe, how do I get from there to the idea that there is one mind that made me on purpose and knows what I'm thinking, or can turn me into a pillar of salt if it suits His fancy?
In terms of your argument as stated near the beginning of this thread, P5 and P6 don't seem to follow.