The certainty of God's existence.

The KCA is a philosophical argument ie a cosmological argument which uses deductive logic and other items to support its claims, its much different and meets different criteria than a scientific theory.


And if the "other items" are selected solely to support the KCA, we are back to circular reasoning again.

Everything is correct EXCEPT for your last sentence. There are only theories none with empirical evidence that no energy would be required to start a universe. In fact these ZPE universes are not supported with any evdience save for a math construct.


In that case, I will call my arguement a philosophical/cosmological one, rather than a scientific one, and use the mathematical constructs to support my case. After all, math has a solid grounding in both science and philosophy (formal logic). In which case I now claim that the existence of a multiverse has been proven to be true.

Possible only, the OUOT is more probable with more empirical evdience to support it.


Please demonstrate the probability calculations supporting this claim.

I disagree. In any case the KCA is a cosmological argument not a scientific theory and it meets all the criteria for such an argument. Currently science does not claim to know what happened before just before T-0 so that renders your argument moot. It was a good try though.


I have now defined the multiverse theory as a cosmological argument and not a scientific theory, and its premises are fundamentally as well as mathematically sound.

So now what?
 
Last edited:
RevDisturba said:
Hokulele said:
As has been admitted, there can be no evidence for anything outside this universe.
I have never said anything different...
Yes you did, and you repeated the claim later in the same post::
Possible only, the OUOT is more probable with more empirical evdience to support it.
There, you explicitly claim there is empirical evidence for something outside of the universe. So given that the cyclic universe is only one theory of many where is your empirical evidence for one universe, one try?

I am not aware that anybody has even proposed such a hypothesis.
 
If we are to be getting back to the KCA and to consider it entirely as a metaphysical argument then what about addressing some of the outstanding problems?

1. P1 contains a false dilemma
2. The term "Beginning" is ambiguous

(I am assuming here that you don't intend to defend anything after C2)
 
Last edited:
I don't think we can calculate odds on that. But its possible that we could be debating this on another planet in another galaxy.
;{>

Oh, quite the contrary. We can indeed and precisely calculate the odds for that. That was the whole point of the question. It points out that the complexity measure, tacitly being promoted as an absolute, really is more of a conditional probability.
 
Because if there is one try and the universe unfolds as it does (being able to support life etc) against some pretty fascinating odds it lends credence to several theist friendly theories. First and formost a OUOT theory would support the KCA. The argument from design is not as dependent for example ;

“British physicist P. C. W. Davies has calculated that the odds against the initial conditions being suitable for later star formation (without which planets could not exist) is one followed by a thousand billion billion zeroes, at least. He also estimates that a change in the strength of gravity or of the weak force by only one part in 10,100 would have prevented a life-permitting universe. Roger Penrose of Oxford University has calculated that the odds of the big bang’s low entropy condition existing by chance are on the order of one out of 10 to the 123rd power.”

I think I get it. The universe is fine tuned to support life, but if it got many tries, then it would be not surprising that one of those gazillion universes happened to support life. Is that it?

I think mister Davies is abusing the notion of "odds" myself. Yes, if gravity was just a tiny bit different, the universe wouldn't work. And? Gravity isn't a tiny bit different. I don't know how to compute a "probability" that gravity would be stronger or weaker.

Furthermore, I can't imagine how one would go about imagining how the universe would behave if gravity were stronger or weaker, but everything else was identical, which appears to be the premise on which these probability calculations are based. It strikes me as practically nonsensical.





That doesn’t stop some theoretical scientists from trying.

Not exactly. Physicists might speculate on how, given the laws of physics, huge quantities of matter/energy might suddenly spring into existence where none had been before, but that isn't exactly the same as answering the question about how the universe came into existence. There remains the question of how the "laws of physics" came to be, and that isn't answerable by science.
I can assure you that I am correct when I quote facts about cosmology or astronomy.

Well.....sort of. I haven't seen any glaring errors, except that there's a bit of "spin" on some of the statements.

The big bang is central to the KCA.

Is it the big bang that is central, or is it the emergence of the universe from nothing that is central?


The cosmological argument, and its variations including the one you have put forward, are, in my opinion, a very powerful argument against pure materialism. Why is there something instead of nothing? Even if matter were recycled from other universes, or if multiple universes popped into existence whenever conditions were right, as opposed to just once, or any variation thereof, it seems to me that we would still be left with a dilemma. Why did the laws of physics exist, and how did they suddenly take effect to create our universe?

Science explains everything through causal arguments. ("Causal" being used in the scientific sense, meaning that the state of a system is dependent on its prior state, as opposed to some future state.)The appearance of the universe can't be a result of a causal phenomenon. So, that throws a monkey wrench into anyone's effort to explain everything in scientific terms.

However, I can't manage to get from there to God. If I grant that some sort of non-physical "act" or "phenomenon" or whatever gave rise to the existence of the universe, how do I get from there to the idea that there is one mind that made me on purpose and knows what I'm thinking, or can turn me into a pillar of salt if it suits His fancy?



In terms of your argument as stated near the beginning of this thread, P5 and P6 don't seem to follow.
 
First and formost a OUOT theory would support the KCA.
As I pointed out before this is plain wrong.

The KCA, even if it is sound, says nothing whatsoever about whether the cause could make one or many universes.

An OUOT theory, if one were ever proposed, would support the fine-tuning argument.
 
Last edited:
Robin said:
; }>

Which would include the claim "one universe, one try".

I would disagree that the 'one universe one try' theory (of the Big Bang) is a philosophical argument. Rather its one of the best known scientific theory. And its the most popular theory. I can guarantee you when a school teacher be it a K4 teacher or a college professor mentioning the big bang he is implying the big bang where this universe is the only one. If he wishes to discuss the many universe theories he will indicate that these are variants of the orginal BB theory or new theories like the MWI (many worlds interpretation) theory from string theory.

Its certainly OK to believe in cyclic universes or the MWI theory even if its postulated by the non predictive string theory or any number of the many universe theories that abound, many well educated people do believe e these and have made lifetime jobs out of them. However as the majority of scientists and acdemics choose to believe the OUOT theory.

And I wish we could get back to that. But then again you brought in science to cover up the false dilemma in P1.

How is P1 a false dilemma? The only reason the BB aids cosmological arguments is that it indicates that the universe began to exist rather than its been here forever, so if it begins to exist it must have a cause for its existence. That's where the BB lends its helping hand, and it does so in lesser areas as well.

Incidentally, let's make it explicit that the KCA does not imply one universe, one try, nor does it imply a timeless cause.

I think you have is backwards which is ok we have turned the KCA inside out in the last thirty or so pages of debate! The KCA doesn't imply one universe the BB implies one universe (or its the most popular and best evidenced theory is the original one universe theory).

; {>
 
Last edited:
IScience explains everything through causal arguments. ("Causal" being used in the scientific sense, meaning that the state of a system is dependent on its prior state, as opposed to some future state.)
I would disagree that "causal" in the scientific sense implies dependence on a prior state.

So far science has dealt with things that behave like this, but that does not imply that science is limited to considering systems like this.

There is no rule in science that says "thou shall not transcend temporality". The only rule of physics is that something must be mathematically describable and empirically testable.

If something non-temporal can be described mathematically then it is within the purview of science.

There are speculative theories that do deal with causality that is not temporally bound and even speculation among physicists that one day time and space might be eliminated as the fundamental unit for the description of reality.
 
As I pointed out before this is plain wrong.

The KCA, even if it is sound, says nothing whatsoever about whether the cause could make one or many universes.

An OUOT theory, if one were ever proposed, would support the fine-tuning argument.

You are plain wrong. I already described why if the BB theory is correct in its original form the universe began to exist about 14B years ago. If say the universe has always existed lets say 'string theory universe' (don't you just love braned in membranes and 11 dimensions to describe our universe?) but anyway lets say the universe was proved to be eternal having no beginning that sure would harm P1 !!!You know the one that states everything that begins to exist must have a cause for its existence How in the world would P-1 be correct it the universe did not begin to exist?

; {>
 
Oh, quite the contrary. We can indeed and precisely calculate the odds for that. That was the whole point of the question. It points out that the complexity measure, tacitly being promoted as an absolute, really is more of a conditional probability.

Not so. If we can calculate with the information we have that the universe should of been a white hot plasma with no solid mass like you or I, we don't need every variable to make a claim that the universe has been tweaked (to support life), as many scientists even atheists have claimed.

; {>
 
I would disagree that "causal" in the scientific sense implies dependence on a prior state.

So far science has dealt with things that behave like this, but that does not imply that science is limited to considering systems like this.

There is no rule in science that says "thou shall not transcend temporality". The only rule of physics is that something must be mathematically describable and empirically testable.

If something non-temporal can be described mathematically then it is within the purview of science.

There are speculative theories that do deal with causality that is not temporally bound and even speculation among physicists that one day time and space might be eliminated as the fundamental unit for the description of reality.

Well we agree on something. And (the above) is why we can probe with logic and reason places that science can not tread. Its not satisfying like a good confirmed scientific theory (steak) is, but a salad (a cosmological argument and its implications) is/are better than nothing.

Pass the vinaigrette please ....

; {>
 
Meadmaker and everyone else I will try to catch up later tonite or in the morning...

Where is the owner of this thread? I need to bail for a bit....

; {>
 
I would disagree that the 'one universe one try' theory (of the Big Bang) is a philosophical argument. Rather its one of the best known scientific theory. And its the most popular theory. I can guarantee you when a school teacher be it a K4 teacher or a college professor mentioning the big bang he is implying the big bang where this universe is the only one.
Again, I disagree - when any scientist is discussing the big bang they are not implying anything at all about anything "outside" the universe.

Again, the BB theory does not imply more than one universe

Neither does it imply exactly one universe.

Both are speculation beyond the bounds of current cosmology.

If any college professor or K4 teacher implies that there is evidence for exactly one universe then they are being inaccurate.

My science teacher in school used to put it well: "Remember, a hypothesis says what it says, it does not say anything more or less"
If he wishes to discuss the many universe theories he will indicate that these are variants of the orginal BB theory or new theories like the MWI (many worlds interpretation) theory from string theory.
And if he wishes to discuss a "one universe one try" theory, this is also a variant on the original BB theory. One that has not, to my knowledge, ever been proposed.
Its certainly OK to believe in cyclic universes or the MWI theory even if its postulated by the non predictive string theory or any number of the many universe theories that abound, many well educated people do believe e these and have made lifetime jobs out of them. However as the majority of scientists and acdemics choose to believe the OUOT theory.
Again no, they don't. They believe in the classic Big Bang theory which says nothing at all about what else may exist outside the universe.

An OUOT theory has never been proposed as far as I am aware.
How is P1 a false dilemma?
Do I have to keep repeating myself?
The only reason the BB aids cosmological arguments is that it indicates that the universe began to exist rather than its been here forever, so if it begins to exist it must have a cause for its existence. That's where the BB lends its helping hand, and it does so in lesser areas as well.
So if you use the BB theory to support P1 then you should simply abandon the premiss, since you have already ruled out an infinite regress.

On the other hand if you are to continue to consider an infinite regress in P1 even though it has been ruled out by the BB but fail to also consider other possibilities then it is a false dilemma.

So again, to be consistent you have to abandon the premiss altogether or otherwise you should not imply that an infinite regress is uniquely implied by a universe not beginning to exist.
I think you have is backwards which is ok we have turned the KCA inside out in the last thirty or so pages of debate! The KCA doesn't imply one universe the BB implies one universe (or its the most popular and best evidenced theory is the original one universe theory).
Again, the BB does not imply one universe, but if it did then how would an "exactly one universe" theory relate to the KCA one way or the other?

And I should also mention the ambiguous use of "beginning" used as "beginning to exist" and "the beginning of a series of events". You need to settle on one.
 
RevDisturba said:
Robin said:
RevDisturba said:
First and formost a OUOT theory would support the KCA.
As I pointed out before this is plain wrong.

The KCA, even if it is sound, says nothing whatsoever about whether the cause could make one or many universes.

An OUOT theory, if one were ever proposed, would support the fine-tuning argument.
You are plain wrong. I already described why if the BB theory is correct in its original form the universe began to exist about 14B years ago.
Nice bait and switch Rev. You started talking about an OUOT theory and when I challenged this as being irrelevant to the KCA (as it is), you switched terms to BB.

Again, the BB is not an OUOT theory, it says nothing whatsoever about anything "outside" this universe.

Again if a theory does not imply more than one universe, this does not mean it implies exactly one universe or one try.
 
Not so. If we can calculate with the information we have that the universe should of been a white hot plasma with no solid mass like you or I, we don't need every variable to make a claim that the universe has been tweaked (to support life), as many scientists even atheists have claimed.


...except that isn't the calculation I proposed.
 
Well we agree on something. And (the above) is why we can probe with logic and reason places that science can not tread. Its not satisfying like a good confirmed scientific theory (steak) is, but a salad (a cosmological argument and its implications) is/are better than nothing.

Pass the vinaigrette please ....

; {>
And yet it requires a rigour even greater than that demanded of science. Science at least has the razor of experimental confirmation and falsifiability to prune the mistakes.

Pure reason and logic has no such razor and thus requires precision and rigour to the nth degree, without this it is simply meaningless. There is no room for looseness and ambiguity which is why I have been trying to rid the argument of these things.

I should point out that the version Craig presents in one of his articles is not even logically valid - there are arguments where the conclusion is not the same as the premiss they are supposed to be supporting.

My old DM lecturer would have awarded a zero and one of his famous withering glares.
 
No he expected us to use common our sense and I suppose he wanted to keep his job. There are many references to the creator and such beings though...

; {>

Some related quotes;

“It would be very difficult to explain why the universe should have begun in just this way, except as the act of a God who intended to create beings like us.”
Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time

I recommend reading the entire chapter in order to put that quote in context. Also from chapter eight:

Stephen Hawking said:
The idea that space and time may form a closed surface without boundary also has profound implications for the role of God in the affairs of the universe. With the success of scientific theories in describing events, most people have come to believe that God allows the universe to evolve according to a set of laws and does not intervene in the universe to break these laws. However, the laws do not tell us what the universe should have looked like when it started – it would still be up to God to wind up the clockwork and choose how to start it off. So long as the universe had a beginning, we could suppose it had a creator. But if the universe is really completely self-contained, having no boundary or edge, it would have neither beginning nor end: it would simply be. What place, then, for a creator?
 
Meadmaker and everyone else I will try to catch up later tonite or in the morning...

Where is the owner of this thread? I need to bail for a bit....

; {>
Yeah, Yrreg, come back and tell us about how we all hate God and are fearful of God.

That sort of stuff really shows Christianity in a good light.
 
OK, let's make this explicit, P1 says:

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events​

So you can't bring the BB in as confirmation of this premiss since the BB says nothing at all about what would be the case "If the universe has no beginning" (since it describes a universe that does have a beginning).

I don't get what you don't get about that.

So if you accept that the premiss is specifying what would be the case "If the universe has no beginning" then it is simply wrong, a universe that has "no beginning" would not necessarily have an infinite number of events.

It is a false dilemma.

I don't get what you don't get about that.
 
That was the intent of this debate. Maybe you should reread it all. Without a testable mechanism how can you show evidence for more than one try? We know that there has been at least one try, that's a given, so where are the others? Or where is the evidence for others? Or where is a testable mechanism that can produce others?
Argument from ignorance.

OK prove OUOT wrong. The BB is a well thought out theory and it does not imply more than one universe. If you think differently show me where the standard hot model Big Bang Theory (not revised theories or modified theories) say that the universe is cyclic (google it) ?
Argument from ignorance.

The article goes on to say the next great HOPE (for a many tries or many universe theory) is DE and DM. Hey just call it faith instead of hope?
Strawman, and by implication, argument from ignorance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom