The certainty of God's existence.

“British physicist P. C. W. Davies has calculated that the odds against the initial conditions being suitable for later star formation (without which planets could not exist) is one followed by a thousand billion billion zeroes, at least. He also estimates that a change in the strength of gravity or of the weak force by only one part in 10,100 would have prevented a life-permitting universe. Roger Penrose of Oxford University has calculated that the odds of the big bang’s low entropy condition existing by chance are on the order of one out of 10 to the 123rd power.”

Did he mention anything about the odds for the existence of god(s)?
 
Personal opinion: I have to say that I doubt the truth of the highlighted portion, simply because to me "try" implies a motivated agent and I doubt most scientists believe an "agent" created the universe. That would mean the "one try" part goes out the window, whether or not there is one and only one universe.

Of course, if "try" is being used in some specialized astrophysical or cosmological or QM way (like "strangeness" and "charm"), that changes things.

No you get the wrong idea. The standard model of the BB wasn't invented by a bunch of theist scientists. (in earlier post I posted links that said the SBBM (standard Big Bang Model) was the most popular model, and it is). So if you believe that the SBBM is correct like most scientists and academics, you do not have to believe anything theistic is involved. One universe one try is just a easy way to phrase it without going into not needed detail and a way to delineate it between a variation of the standard model such a model where many universes are said to be (or could be) a product of inflation. Its much easier to say OUOT than write a couple of paragraphs each time.

Sorry if its confusing.

; {>
 
Did he mention anything about the odds for the existence of god(s)?


No he expected us to use common our sense and I suppose he wanted to keep his job. There are many references to the creator and such beings though...

; {>

Some related quotes;

“It would be very difficult to explain why the universe should have begun in just this way, except as the act of a God who intended to create beings like us.”
Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time

Arthur Eddington (astrophysicist): "The idea of a universal mind or Logos would be, I think, a fairly plausible inference from the present state of scientific theory.

Paul Davies (British astrophysicist): "There is for me powerful evidence that there is something going on behind it all....It seems as though somebody has fine-tuned nature’s numbers to make the Universe....The impression of design is overwhelming".

Alan Sandage (winner of the Crawford prize in astronomy): "I find it quite improbable that such order came out of chaos. There has to be some organizing principle. God to me is a mystery but is the explanation for the miracle of existence, why there is something instead of nothing."

Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance."

Frank Tipler (Professor of Mathematical Physics): "When I began my career as a cosmologist some twenty years ago, I was a convinced atheist. I never in my wildest dreams imagined that one day I would be writing a book purporting to show that the central claims of Judeo-Christian theology are in fact true, that these claims are straightforward deductions of the laws of physics as we now understand them. I have been forced into these conclusions by the inexorable logic of my own special branch of physics." (16) Note: Tipler since has actually converted to Christianity, hence his latest book, The Physics Of Christianity. (there is hope)

Frank Tipler (Professor of Mathematical Physics): "From the perspective of the latest physical theories, Christianity is not a mere religion, but an experimentally testable science."
 
Last edited:
No you get the wrong idea. The standard model of the BB wasn't invented by a bunch of theist scientists. (in earlier post I posted links that said the SBBM (standard Big Bang Model) was the most popular model, and it is). So if you believe that the SBBM is correct like most scientists and academics, you do not have to believe anything theistic is involved. One universe one try is just a easy way to phrase it without going into not needed detail and a way to delineate it between a variation of the standard model such a model where many universes are said to be (or could be) a product of inflation. Its much easier to say OUOT than write a couple of paragraphs each time.

Sorry if its confusing.

; {>


Please provide a reference to the claim that the universe required only one try.
 
Please provide a reference to the claim that the universe required only one try.


That was the intent of this debate. Maybe you should reread it all. Without a testable mechanism how can you show evidence for more than one try? We know that there has been at least one try, that's a given, so where are the others? Or where is the evidence for others? Or where is a testable mechanism that can produce others? ; {>
 
Had life not formed on this planet, what would be the probability we would now be debating the certainty of god's existence?
 
I was assuming "try" meant "event". The apparent reason RevDisturba requires the universe to have happened in one "try" is to avoid the possibility of infinite "tries", i.e. infinite events, something his P1 declared to be impossible and an absurdity.

ETA: Sorry, it was P2 that declared infinite events to be an absurdity. I will leave the original as is to show that I am perfectly happy to have my errors corrected.

The primary reason that the OUOT (or event if you wish if you want to call the universe an event) for other philosophical/cosmological reasons. I would be happy to go over them again but they have been covered many times earlier. If you are saving the original for me there is no need I do not doubt your credibility etc. I would even let you walk my mutt, and I don't let just anyone do that.

; {>
 
That was the intent of this debate. Maybe you should reread it all. Without a testable mechanism how can you show evidence for more than one try? We know that there has been at least one try, that's a given, so where are the others? Or where is the evidence for others? Or where is a testable mechanism that can produce others? ; {>

You misunderstand the scientific process. It doesn't go, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it right?" It goes, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it wrong? Okay, let's try that. Did it turn out to be wrong?"
You must show that there were no other tries. We don't have to show you that there was more than one.
 
Had life not formed on this planet, what would be the probability we would now be debating the certainty of god's existence?

I don't think we can calculate odds on that. But its possible that we could be debating this on another planet in another galaxy.
;{>
 
You misunderstand the scientific process. It doesn't go, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it right?" It goes, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it wrong? Okay, let's try that. Did it turn out to be wrong?"
You must show that there were no other tries. We don't have to show you that there was more than one.

OK prove OUOT wrong. The BB is a well thought out theory and it does not imply more than one universe. If you think differently show me where the standard hot model Big Bang Theory (not revised theories or modified theories) say that the universe is cyclic (google it) ?

Its all (cyclic or many tries) bad theory as the original was ie ; "In the 1930s, theoretical physicists, most notably Einstein, considered the possibility of a cyclic model for the universe as an (everlasting) alternative to the Big Bang. However, work by Richard C. Tolman showed that these early attempts failed because of the entropy problem that, in statistical mechanics, entropy only increases because of the Second law of thermodynamics."

The article goes on to say the next great HOPE (for a many tries or many universe theory) is DE and DM. Hey just call it faith instead of hope?

; {>
 
Last edited:
OK prove OUOT wrong. The BB is a well thought out theory and it does not imply more than one universe.
That is right, and it does not imply exactly one universe either, or one try.

What is so hard about saying that?
 
That was the intent of this debate. Maybe you should reread it all. Without a testable mechanism how can you show evidence for more than one try? We know that there has been at least one try, that's a given, so where are the others? Or where is the evidence for others? Or where is a testable mechanism that can produce others?


Aha! This is a slightly different claim than what you have been making up until now.

As has been admitted, there can be no evidence for anything outside this universe. Any claims as to the origin of this universe are pure speculation (including the premises used in the KCA). However, there is evidence that the conditions that can result in a universe exist in a singularity, there is evidence that singularities exist, and there is evidence that no outside energy would be required to start such a universe.

Granted, we cannot explicitly state that we have solved the question of the origin of the universe to a scientific standard, but we can start from the premise that multiple universes are not only possible, but are also plausible. The KCA starts from premises that are possible, but there is no scientific evidence to show that they are plausible, so therefore it is a weaker argument for the origin of the universe than the various scientific hypotheses currently under investigation.
 
The primary reason that the OUOT (or event if you wish if you want to call the universe an event) for other philosophical/cosmological reasons.


That would be circular reasoning.

P1. The premises up which the KCA is based are true because the Hot Big Bang model supports it.

P2. The Hot Big Bang theory is true because it supports the KCA.

C1. The KCA is true.
 
universe. If you think differently show me where the standard hot model Big Bang Theory (not revised theories or modified theories) say that the universe is cyclic (google it) ?
Are you saying that there are only two possibilities, one universe and a cyclic universe?

Again, the big bang theory does not imply more than one universe, but neither does it imply exactly one.
 
Last edited:
You misunderstand the scientific process. It doesn't go, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it right?" It goes, "Hey, we have a theory, how can we prove it wrong? Okay, let's try that. Did it turn out to be wrong?"
You must show that there were no other tries. We don't have to show you that there was more than one.

Ok prove OUOT wrong.

; {>
 
I already agreed with Wolly on that one. How did you miss it? That was this morning.

; {>
I can't find it, but I'll take your word. But why are you saying an open universe implies just one universe, do you think that the only possibilities are a cyclic universe or one universe?
 
Aha! This is a slightly different claim than what you have been making up until now.

Its the same claim and I don't make anything up.

As has been admitted, there can be no evidence for anything outside this universe.

I have never said anything different, however you should know that it means that nothing (in the realm of science) to say something is outside this universe.However its philosophically valid to ask such questions and make such statements VIA the KCA etc.

Any claims as to the origin of this universe are pure speculation

Not true. All scientific claims beyond T-0 are speculation.

(including the premises used in the KCA).

The KCA is a philosophical argument ie a cosmological argument which uses deductive logic and other items to support its claims, its much different and meets different criteria than a scientific theory.

However, there is evidence that the conditions that can result in a universe exist in a singularity, there is evidence that singularities exist, and there is evidence that no outside energy would be required to start such a universe.

Everything is correct EXCEPT for your last sentence. There are only theories none with empirical evidence that no energy would be required to start a universe. In fact these ZPE universes are not supported with any evdience save for a math construct.

Granted, we cannot explicitly state that we have solved the question of the origin of the universe to a scientific standard, but we can start from the premise that multiple universes are not only possible, but are also plausible.

Possible only, the OUOT is more probable with more empirical evdience to support it.

The KCA starts from premises that are possible, but there is no scientific evidence to show that they are plausible, so therefore it is a weaker argument for the origin of the universe than the various scientific hypotheses currently under investigation.

I disagree. In any case the KCA is a cosmological argument not a scientific theory and it meets all the criteria for such an argument. Currently science does not claim to know what happened before just before T-0 so that renders your argument moot. It was a good try though.

; }>
 
Last edited:
However its philosophically valid to ask such questions and make such statements VIA the KCA etc.
I agree
Not true. All scientific claims beyond T-0 are speculation.
Which would include the claim "one universe, one try".
The KCA is a philosophical argument ie a cosmological argument which uses deductive logic and other items to support its claims, its much different and meets different criteria than a scientific theory.
And I wish we could get back to that. But then again you brought in science to cover up the false dilemma in P1.

Incidentally, let's make it explicit that the KCA does not imply one universe, one try, nor does it imply a timeless cause.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom