The certainty of God's existence.

I have said from the start that I am picking the theory (the Standard BB, no inflationary funny stuff wolly) with the most popular scientific and academic following, and that is most validated by empirical evidence,
If you're using a Big Bang model that doesn't include inflation then you are hardly using the the one with the most popular following. Inflation is almost universally accepted, because without inflation it just doesn't work.

and that theory is the one universe one try universe. (with one universe how could there be more than one try?) .
Yeah, still waiting on the actual evidence for that. You know, the empirical data you told us existed that shows that there's only one Universe.

Its that easy. I haven't said all the other theories could not be true, or anything of the sort. But I have said all this at least three or four times as well.
And I've never said that there had to be more than one Universe. I've just pointed out the errors and weaknesses in your arguments.
 
If you're using a Big Bang model that doesn't include inflation then you are hardly using the the one with the most popular following. Inflation is almost universally accepted, because without inflation it just doesn't work.

Yes I agree. I have never denied inflation, although its hotly debated and not a sure thing. By 'Wolly stuff' I meant attempting to squeeze extra universes out of the inflationary era. ie;

Universe or Multiverse
In the variant introduced by Andrei Linde, inflation spawns a network of branching "bubble" universes .... His talk was more technical than the talks of Davies and Rees. .... Universe can have babies— inherit mother's characteristics ...
www.wisdomportal.com/Stanford/UniverseOrMultiverse.html

Yeah, still waiting on the actual evidence for that. You know, the empirical data you told us existed that shows that there's only one Universe.

If the universe is open that is the evidence that supports one universe one try! Where is the evidence using the standard BB and not variants of it (see above). I would love it if you would take my old astronomy professors word for it? He still teaches at ETSU or UT I am not sure which its been a year or so since I have spoke to him. Really with your knowledge I shouldn't even have to say this. Its like telling a man on the street that an apple is red.

And I've never said that there had to be more than one Universe. I've just pointed out the errors and weaknesses in your arguments.

You have? I don't see one comment I made where you have shown me wrong. Especially one that would have a serious impact on this discussion.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Three days? Sorry that is beyond T-0 and my brain does not go there. No seriously do you remember the post #? To everyone and I am guilty of sometimes forgetting to do this, please include the post number especially on old posts.

It's not necessary (and unreliable; post numbers in a thread can change); see the little arrow to the right of your name, at the beginning of the quote above? Click on it, and it will take you to the original post.
 
If the universe is open that is the evidence that supports one universe one try! Where is the evidence using the standard BB and not variants of it (see above). I would love it if you would take my old astronomy professors word for it? He still teaches at ETSU or UT I am not sure which its been a year or so since I have spoke to him. Really with your knowledge I shouldn't even have to say this. Its like telling a man on the street that an apple is red.
So you really didn't read my earlier post where I showed just why an open Universe doesn't only support the "one Universe one try" theory?

Here's a link for you. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5020914&postcount=1349

You have? I don't see one comment I made where you have shown me wrong. Especially one that would have a serious impact on this discussion.
And therein lies a huge part of your problem. You seem utterly unwilling to admit that your interpretation is just one of many, all of which have equal evidence to support them.

Let me put it in simple terms.

Your argument goes as follows;

If the Big Bang model is correct, and if the Universe is open, and if there can be no other universes without a big crunch, and if there could not have been any other universes prior to this one, then the probability that we live in a purely naturally occurring Universe is pretty much zero, so it was probably designed.

The problem with this argument are all the bits in bold. They're all conditional statements, none of them are by any means certain, and many of them are simply unknowable.

I will happily stipulate that your argument isn't actually wrong, but more importantly, it isn't very useful.
 
You missed this;

a·the·ism Pronunciation (th-zm)
n.
1. Disbelief in or denial of the existence of God or gods.
2. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Atheists

mufff

; {>

Read number two again The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

Its items like this that makes debating with you pixi nearly impossible. And not know much of your subject matter, and not admitting when you are wrong even in the face of outside evidence.

; {>
Here it is, post #1260. You spent 2 days arguing that somehow you can have a doctrine for a non-belief. If you really believed this, your life would be very full, you would need a seperate doctrine for each of your non-beliefs. I just find it more likely that you are engaged in special pleading for your religion.
 
So you really didn't read my earlier post where I showed just why an open Universe doesn't only support the "one Universe one try" theory?

Here's a link for you. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5020914&postcount=1349

I did not say it supported ONLY the one universe one try concept !~ Get your facts straight because what you imply is as important as what you say.

And therein lies a huge part of your problem. You seem utterly unwilling to admit that your interpretation is just one of many, all of which have equal evidence to support them.

Let me put it in simple terms.

Your argument goes as follows;

If the Big Bang model is correct, and if the Universe is open, and if there can be no other universes without a big crunch, and if there could not have been any other universes prior to this one, then the probability that we live in a purely naturally occurring Universe is pretty much zero, so it was probably designed.

Wrong-o-

I said the OUOT one universe one try was the most popular and best supported theory. It seems that you have attempted to from the start of our discussion, to twist my words around to fit your agenda....(wait...this just coming in) !!! UPDATE!!! Unsolved Disturba Mysteries has just learned that by Wolly,(admission) we almost have a consensus! Go to the last of this reply....

The problem with this argument are all the bits in bold. They're all conditional statements, none of them are by any means certain, and many of them are simply unknowable.

Yes but there are less unknowable and uncertain bits and pieces in the OUOT than the many universe or oscillating universe theories, and that is the point that everyone seems to miss.

I will happily stipulate that your argument isn't actually wrong, but more importantly, it isn't very useful.

Well that's a start. Its useful for my paradigm and a deaths nail for yours if true* and that's why its fought over tooth and nail eh?

If I am correct about the OUOT.

: {"> <------ waiter there is a roach in my mouth and its burning my lips...

PS (an edit by another set of letters)

And therein lies a huge part of your problem. You seem utterly unwilling to admit that your interpretation is just one of many, all of which have equal evidence to support them.

Wrong-0- again..Or at least partially so. I do not admit that they have equal evidence to support them. I don't know how you could miss where I posted links to support other theories or that I said other theories exist or that I said all could be true but I support the one that's most poplar and has the most empirical evidence to support it. I will agree that that is an subjective assessment because its difficult to compare a empirical bit of evidence to a bit of theoretical evidence. etc etc...

: {>
 
Last edited:
Here it is, post #1260. You spent 2 days arguing that somehow you can have a doctrine for a non-belief. If you really believed this, your life would be very full, you would need a seperate doctrine for each of your non-beliefs. I just find it more likely that you are engaged in special pleading for your religion.

Well I didn't bring that gem up someone else did. Then was it you (?) he continued to dispute this and that, got his terms and definitions all mixed up etc. I, or rather Encarta simply said that the atheist doctrine was the unbelief of Gods or something like that (it was a cut and paste). BTW, My life is very full but I don't understand what in the world you are talking about. The doctrine of theism is the belief in Gods or the metaphysical. Your special pleading accusation can not be processed because you are too vague.

Exactly what do I plead special about and why exactly do you think it fits the criteria of special pleading ? I really don't understand your case.

; {>
 
Can someone remind me why any of this Big Bang discussion matters when it comes to the subject of the existence of God?

It seems to me that RevDisturba's claim is that at one time the universe did not exist, then God created it.

Science says that the universe exists, and has some interesting properties, but can never say anything about why it exists or how it came to exist. We can say that there is a model for a sudden appearance of huge amounts of matter/energy, i.e. a Big Bang, and so we can say that everything we can observe was once all crammed into the same, very small, place, but that doesn't answer any questions about why it happened, or whether anything existed before all the matter got crammed into a very small space.

It seems to me that most of the recent posting isn't addressing any issues, except trying to show a lot of "you must not have a clue because you said...." followed by "No, I didn't...."

I know that, for me, Revdisturba's knowledge of cosmology and its currently accepted forms just isn't very interesting. If I want to know about cosmology, I'll ask a physicist, not a preacher. Meanwhile, although he has opined on the subject of cosmology, I don't think it's central to his argument, so I don't particularly care that there are errors in it.

Or did I miss something, RevD? If it turned out that scientific consensus did not agree completely with your version of events, would it make one whit of difference to the KCA?
 
Can someone remind me why any of this Big Bang discussion matters when it comes to the subject of the existence of God?

It seems to me that RevDisturba's claim is that at one time the universe did not exist, then God created it.

Science says that the universe exists, and has some interesting properties, but can never say anything about why it exists or how it came to exist. We can say that there is a model for a sudden appearance of huge amounts of matter/energy, i.e. a Big Bang, and so we can say that everything we can observe was once all crammed into the same, very small, place, but that doesn't answer any questions about why it happened, or whether anything existed before all the matter got crammed into a very small space.

It seems to me that most of the recent posting isn't addressing any issues, except trying to show a lot of "you must not have a clue because you said...." followed by "No, I didn't...."

I know that, for me, Revdisturba's knowledge of cosmology and its currently accepted forms just isn't very interesting. If I want to know about cosmology, I'll ask a physicist, not a preacher. Meanwhile, although he has opined on the subject of cosmology, I don't think it's central to his argument, so I don't particularly care that there are errors in it.

Or did I miss something, RevD? If it turned out that scientific consensus did not agree completely with your version of events, would it make one whit of difference to the KCA?
Been there done that:
Let's play.
I'll give you:
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

Now get from C3 to Jesus.
Still waiting for how you get from C1 to Jesus.

Been there done that. Oh you mean here. First we have to get past P-1. If we remain constipated I may start another thread and work not from 'before' the big bang forward but rather T-14B + or - years back.; {>
 
Last edited:
Let me put it in simple terms.

Your argument goes as follows;

If the Big Bang model is correct, and if the Universe is open, and if there can be no other universes without a big crunch, and if there could not have been any other universes prior to this one, then the probability that we live in a purely naturally occurring Universe is pretty much zero, so it was probably designed.
You left out:

And if the probability of Universe as we see it occurring naturally is pretty much zero.

That, again, is just an assumption.
 
I said the OUOT one universe one try was the most popular and best supported theory.
Yes, you did. It is completely untrue.

It seems that you have attempted to from the start of our discussion, to twist my words around to fit your agenda....
Ad hominem, appeal to motive, and completely false as well.

Wollery and others have addressed your claim directly, repeatedly, and in words of one syllable so that it's easy for you to follow.

Somehow, you still haven't worked it out.

(wait...this just coming in) !!! UPDATE!!! Unsolved Disturba Mysteries has just learned that by Wolly,(admission) we almost have a consensus! Go to the last of this reply....
Nonsense.

Yes but there are less unknowable and uncertain bits and pieces in the OUOT than the many universe or oscillating universe theories, and that is the point that everyone seems to miss.
No.

Well that's a start. Its useful for my paradigm and a deaths nail for yours if true* and that's why its fought over tooth and nail eh?
No.

What Wollery just said that if your premises are correct, and your logic is valid, then your argument is sound. Actually, he left out some of your premises. You still have to establish that your premises are correct and that your logic is valid, something you have comprehensively (there's that word again) failed to do.

If I am correct about the OUOT.
If. Which you cannot establish, and is only one of many premises that you cannot establish.

Wrong-0- again..Or at least partially so. I do not admit that they have equal evidence to support them. I don't know how you could miss where I posted links to support other theories or that I said other theories exist or that I said all could be true but I support the one that's most poplar and has the most empirical evidence to support it. I will agree that that is an subjective assessment because its difficult to compare a empirical bit of evidence to a bit of theoretical evidence. etc etc...
Do you know what a universe is, RevD? A universe is causally closed. You cannot establish the existence or non-existence of another universe. By definition, there can be no empirical evidence for other universes. So your assertion that there is no empirical evidence for other universes doesn't carry a whole lot of weight in establishing your claim that there aren't any.
 
I over simplified my statements because I do not need differential geometry or complicated smoke and mirrors to explain why the idea of one universe one try is the most popular concept/theory of how our universe began etc. (in scientific and academia circles alike). If you want to believe him (that I am wrong) be my guest, you are only allowing him to delude you. I'm not saying his bluster is wrong just that the one universe one try is the most popular theory and the only one supported by empirical evidence.

Personal opinion: I have to say that I doubt the truth of the highlighted portion, simply because to me "try" implies a motivated agent and I doubt most scientists believe an "agent" created the universe. That would mean the "one try" part goes out the window, whether or not there is one and only one universe.

Of course, if "try" is being used in some specialized astrophysical or cosmological or QM way (like "strangeness" and "charm"), that changes things.
 
Well I didn't bring that gem up someone else did. Then was it you (?) he continued to dispute this and that, got his terms and definitions all mixed up etc. I, or rather Encarta simply said that the atheist doctrine was the unbelief of Gods or something like that (it was a cut and paste). BTW, My life is very full but I don't understand what in the world you are talking about. The doctrine of theism is the belief in Gods or the metaphysical. Your special pleading accusation can not be processed because you are too vague.

Exactly what do I plead special about and why exactly do you think it fits the criteria of special pleading ? I really don't understand your case.

; {>
I'm disputing your contention that there is a "doctrine" of atheism. Not trying to be difficult, it's just that this comes up a lot with theists. No one would claim that a non-belief in any of the many things we share a non-belief in (the tooth fairy, the flying spagetti monster, islam, whatever) requires a special religion or doctrine. Yet somehow a non-belief in God does. You are saying that a special exception must be made in this particular case, non-belief in god must be a religion, while non-belief in UFO's doesn't have to be.
 
Exactly what do I plead special about and why exactly do you think it fits the criteria of special pleading ? I really don't understand your case.

; {>

Of course you don't. Let me help you.

What doctrine are people following who do not believe in fairies?
 
I said the OUOT one universe one try was the most popular and best supported theory.
This is your claim. Please provide some evidence that this is indeed true.

I don't know how you could miss where I posted links to support other theories or that I said other theories exist or that I said all could be true but I support the one that's most poplar and has the most empirical evidence to support it.
You keep saying that. What you have yet to do is provide support for what so far amounts to nothing more than a baseless assertion.
 
Last edited:
Can someone remind me why any of this Big Bang discussion matters when it comes to the subject of the existence of God?

<snipped for brevity>

Or did I miss something, RevD? If it turned out that scientific consensus did not agree completely with your version of events, would it make one whit of difference to the KCA?


I commented on this back on the previous page. I can see why it may have been lost in the scuffle. Please note, my post was responding to a comment wollery had made, so assume the "you" refers to him.

Seeing as how we are still waiting for references for the "one universe in one try" assertion, I figured I would tackle the other end of the problem.

It seems as if RevDisturba is trying to use the idea of an open (i.e. infinitely expanding) universe to suggest that there cannot be anything "after" this universe, whether it ends in a heat death or a "big rip" is irrelevant to this discussion. In other words, the material (matter and energy) from this universe cannot be recycled into a future universe. Therefore it is reasonable to assume that this universe was not recycled from material from a previous one, and must have been created by something we currently label "god". This also appears to be why RevDisturba argued so hard against virtual particle pairs as being "new" material.

If all of the above is true, does that really close the door on the possibilities of there being other universes, even an infinite number of them? As you stated towards the end of the post I quoted, I don't think it does. Claiming that this universe cannot be the result of of any prior universe is not the same thing as stating this universe cannot be the result of any known physical processes. Just because modern physics has not yet come to a consensus on one physical process to crown The Cause of the Known Universe is no reason to assume there isn't such a process.

We don't know, we may never know, but inventing something to fill the gap isn't necessarily the correct response to this. Again, as you stated in some other post, there is no reason or evidence to hold any one hypothesis as more likely to be true, however, known physical processes are at least plausible based on the evidence we do have.

Choosing the one that best fits P1-3 of KCA seems to me to be begging the question a bit (i.e. the question of which hypothesis is most likely to be true).
 
Personal opinion: I have to say that I doubt the truth of the highlighted portion, simply because to me "try" implies a motivated agent and I doubt most scientists believe an "agent" created the universe. That would mean the "one try" part goes out the window, whether or not there is one and only one universe.

Of course, if "try" is being used in some specialized astrophysical or cosmological or QM way (like "strangeness" and "charm"), that changes things.


I was assuming "try" meant "event". The apparent reason RevDisturba requires the universe to have happened in one "try" is to avoid the possibility of infinite "tries", i.e. infinite events, something his P1 declared to be impossible and an absurdity.

ETA: Sorry, it was P2 that declared infinite events to be an absurdity. I will leave the original as is to show that I am perfectly happy to have my errors corrected.
 
Last edited:
Meadmaker said:
Can someone remind me why any of this Big Bang discussion matters when it comes to the subject of the existence of God?

Because if there is one try and the universe unfolds as it does (being able to support life etc) against some pretty fascinating odds it lends credence to several theist friendly theories. First and formost a OUOT theory would support the KCA. The argument from design is not as dependent for example ;

“British physicist P. C. W. Davies has calculated that the odds against the initial conditions being suitable for later star formation (without which planets could not exist) is one followed by a thousand billion billion zeroes, at least. He also estimates that a change in the strength of gravity or of the weak force by only one part in 10,100 would have prevented a life-permitting universe. Roger Penrose of Oxford University has calculated that the odds of the big bang’s low entropy condition existing by chance are on the order of one out of 10 to the 123rd power.”

It seems to me that RevDisturba's claim is that at one time the universe did not exist, then God created it.

Yes something like that.

science says that the universe exists, and has some interesting properties, but can never say anything about why it exists or how it came to exist.

That doesn’t stop some theoretical scientists from trying. Such as Hawking or any number of eminent scientists. Of course we get into a sticky area where time may or may not exist, or some (science) claim that this is one of many perhaps an infinite number of universes.

We can say that there is a model for a sudden appearance of huge amounts of matter/energy, i.e. a Big Bang, and so we can say that everything we can observe was once all crammed into the same, very small, place, but that doesn't answer any questions about why it happened, or whether anything existed before all the matter got crammed into a very small space.

Not by hard science, but of course we have other tools that we may use instead of raw speculation.

It seems to me that most of the recent posting isn't addressing any issues, except trying to show a lot of "you must not have a clue because you said...." followed by "No, I didn't...."

Yes it sometimes degenerates to that.

I know that, for me, Revdisturba's knowledge of cosmology and its currently accepted forms just isn't very interesting.

I can assure you that I am correct when I quote facts about cosmology or astronomy. However if you really want to be put to sleep I will read you a sermon.

If I want to know about cosmology, I'll ask a physicist, not a preacher. Meanwhile, although he has opined on the subject of cosmology, I don't think it's central to his argument, so I don't particularly care that there are errors in it.

With all due respect, this is the reason that you should make yourself more knowledgeable on the subject. The big bang is central to the KCA.

Or did I miss something, RevD? If it turned out that scientific consensus did not agree completely with your version of events, would it make one whit of difference to the KCA?

Yes, while it would not destroy the KCA, the absence of a true standard big bang event would strip a huge amount of credibility from it. It would damage some purely theistic arguments as well.

; {>

You are correct in that I am not a professional astronomer, however I am a serious amateur astronomer, and keep current on the subject.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom