The certainty of God's existence.

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.

P1: If this DVD has no beginning (read 00:00:00), there have been an infinite number of events in the movie.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, this DVD must have had a beginning (read 00:00:00).
P3: Everything which has a beginning (read 00:00:00) must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: This DVD must have been caused by something (read: pressed, burned, or however exactly a DVD is produced).


If C2 is true, then it is not because of the reasoning presented.


P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.

(Free will truly is a magic, mystical "problem" solver, huh? ;) )

P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

What am I even supposed to do here at C3? :confused:
 
In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

So the fact that we are willing state our reasons for not believing in something, proves that we believe in it. Gotcha.

Even by Yrreg standards, this is a gleaming gem of anti-logic. Is anyone keeping track of these for a future compilation? Where's Claus when we need him?
 
Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.


Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.


You see, you tell people that babies who still have not the use of reason are atheists like yourselves.

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.


The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​



That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.


Do that, then you will be free to no longer have to give any account of rational foundation of course pseudo at that for your denial of God.

Then you can go away.


Otherwise, you must examine your heart what are the motivations moving you to think up reasons to convince people that your denial of the certainty in your mind of God's existence is owing to your shall we call it enlightenment following so much time and trouble in the prevarication of your reasoning faculty.


Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.


Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,
The lady doth protest too much.​




Yrreg
I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.
 
Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​



That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.

You might want to check your dictionaries for the definition of "atheist". Again! For the umpteenth time.

And leave my period out of this.
 
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
Not strictly true, unless you consider "nothing happens" to be an event.

In other words, it could be, for example, that the universe is eternal, but static (unchanging) up until about 14 billion years ago, at which point something new happened.

P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
Not true. Even if the universe had a beginning, if it has no end the "life of the universe" may consist of an infinite number of events. It is also possible that it will enter a phase in which "nothing happens" (i.e., there is no change in state). In that case, once again, an infinite universe need not imply an infinite number of events.

C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
Current science posits that the universe did have a beginning, but that conclusion is not based on your line of reasoning.

P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
Agreed.

P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
Seems reasonable, but again, not for the line of reasoning you give.

P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
There is no reason to suppose that this is the case. One may just as plausibly propose that the universe itself is eternal, but that the limit of our knowledge is at a point 14 billion years in the past, which we therefore not altogether arbitrarily label "the beginning."

P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
Pure nonsense. If I assume gravity is eternal, the fact that this eternal force produces a spherical earth which is bound by time does not indicate that any free choice was involved.

P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
Since P5 and P6 are one part unsupported supposition and one part sheer nonsense, your line of reasoning implies nothing whatsoever about the cause of the universe.
 
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
Undischarged premiss. A beginning does not imply an antecedent cause.

In fact there is a model of the universe proposed by one of the major physicists of our time in which the universe has a beginning and no antecident cause.

Now it does not matter for the purposes of philosophy whether this model is right or not, the fact that you can model it mathematically demonstrates that it is logically possible.

If it is logically possible to have a universe with a beginning and no antecedent cause then this premiss is incorrect.

I am surprised, in fact, that people are still using this version of the arugment.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
Say what? I would love to see the reasoning behind this.

In any case if an eternal cause was itself unbound by time then there could be no sequence of events for it right? If there was a sequence of events then God would simply be bound by another kind of time.

An intentional choice implies sequence of events - an intention precedes and action.

Therefore if there is a sequence of events for God then we can just take God and run the the argument again from P1 and show that God must have been created by a personal God.

Big Gods have bigger Gods
There to expedite 'em
And bigger Gods have bigger Gods
And so ad infinitum
 
Last edited:
Brother Yrreg? That explains the coherence of your "evidence" and "proofs". Supporting someone just because they are the same "faith"' as you despite them being so wrong and completely incoherent is truly amusing.

Applied Ethics 101 summer redo education class. Oh Mr.Ms Paximperium I am happy to see you could make it. Welcome my name is Mr Manners and this is Ethics 101 special edition....

(we join the class already in progress)

I see paximperium somehow associates common courtesy as somehow supporting another members entire history of posting. Remarkable if it were true, but its not true, its remarkably wrong. I am a Christian, Yrreg is a Christian. The word 'brother' a common salutation, even a word of endearment amongst Christians and in no way is an indication of anything else.

I will say that brother Yrreg is more of a christian than I am, due to his reverent tolerance in this case at least, which garners even more respect from my me and my very short respect list.

I would not be nearly as tolerant and as graceful under attack as Brother Yrreg is. He was correct in some of his musings. And wrong in some others IMO. However, I think unprovoked (verbal) attacks upon Christians are often satanic in nature (satanically motivated and financed).

Now for the members in question; please don't get all vein popping, sputtering, self (un)righteous, stroking out mad. Its nothing personal. I don't mean that YOU personally are satanic.
No, what I mean is those that would insult taunt and needle Yrreg are deriving the energetic motivation by supernatural processes.

The old devil himself and his angels are doing working overtime to harm Yrreg and his religon. (man this is going to get the key boards a chattering). If fact they are doing exactly what the Gospels and even the OT predict ie persecuting Christians, however lightly.Hey I have a jug of extra holy water that I blessed this morning,and I would be happy to do an cleansing or even a exorcism for no charge.

~ that said ~

When some one picks a metaphysical paradigm to describe their reality it does not indicate his or her IQ. Ask Kurt Godel. I have no doubt that one day history will vindicate we metaphysical types. Have you got enough cheeks to turn until then brother Yrreg ? Got any extras? I'm all out, I ran out in 1990. God tells me they are back ordered and instead of turning the other cheek use a verbal right hook instead! <<<<<---- Lame attempt at humor that

Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If everyone isn't mad at me I will attempt to start in order and respond to the posts concerning the KCA etc....

Thanks for your patience so far...

; }>

bokonon said:
Pull your head out, that might get things moving.

If I do that my head will spin and I will puke green vomit all over you. I know its better than me spanking you in debate, but you will have to wait your turn...
 
Last edited:
I would not be nearly as tolerant and as graceful under attack as Brother Yrreg is.
Quite new and unfamiliar usage of the terms "tolerant" and "graceful".
He was correct in some of his musings.
Can you quote anything?
And wrong in some others IMO. However, I think unprovoked (verbal) attacks upon Christians are often satanic in nature (satanically motivated and financed).
Yrreg sets the attacking tone, so you can hardly call it unprovoked.
Now for the members in question don't get all vein popping, sputtering, self (un)righteous, stroking out mad. I don't mean that YOU personally are satanic.

No, what I mean is that the their motivation may be influenced by demonic power. They are being influenced by the old devil himself
Seems to me that if the old Devil was smart he would influence people to argue in favour of God but make their arguments risible and therefore counterproductive

So maybe you should consider that it is not we who are influenced by the Devil.

But don't worry I will be happy to perform an exorcism for a small charge.
When some one picks a metaphysical paradigm to describe their reality it does not indicate his or her IQ.
As far as I am aware nobody here has even remotely suggested that it does.

So perhaps you might take some of that straw out of your mouth.
 
paximperium said:
You did? Huh...strange. People must have mistaken your "support" for a joke somewhere. Would you care to point me back to this "support" since it seems completely missing from the 3 pages of this thread?
So you DIDN'T understand what the Planck Epoch or Planck Time actually means?
I guess I'll use simple words you can understand. It basically means it is IMPOSSIBLE to extrapolate back beyond that so it is IMPOSSIBLE with our current knowledge and technology to know what occurred before this span of time. You do know what IMPOSSIBLE actually means don't you?

Gawd.....:boggled:

First, look up cosmological argument. Then look up scientific theory. Two different things. We can only go back so far in big bang cosmology before our physics break down. The proper name for this is the The Planck Epoch and it is before t=10-43 seconds, immediately after the Big Bang (t=0). That is when all four forces were unified into a single Superforce and 1 force rules all of physics.

Now this is where the Cosmological argument takes over and leaves our classical physics behind. It claims to use logic and reason because we can't use our regular scientific tools for discovery. Its possible to make an logical reasonable argument for what happened ‘before’ (more accurately outside time) 'before/outside time when the universe began to exist.

OK I know that last sentence was new to you.

I am going to stop now and let this have time to soak in. Do some reading about ontological arguments and cosmological arguments in particular. The KCA is what you want to Google but Google the Kalam Cosmological Argument instead of KCA. Then if we are on the same page I may try to discuss this in more detail. Until then you either do not know what a cosmological argument is or have it confused with the BB model theory.

In the mean time I am going to move on to the several or more members that know the difference between a scientific theory and a cosmological argument and have a good grasp on both.

Gd day ; {>
 
I will say that brother Yrreg is more of a christian than I am, due to his reverent tolerance in this case at least, which garners even more respect from my me and my very short respect list.

You think that coming to a forum and starting a thread provoking people who don't believe in his god by asking loaded questions that don't get explained unless someone provides him with the answer he was looking for (Note: never the right one)and implying that atheists have a deep, hatred for his god when there is overwhelming evidence against everything that he stands for, is deserving of your respect?

:jaw-dropp

(I meant for the run-on sentence, by the way =])

If anybody has satanic tendencies, I don't think its the atheists..
 
Last edited:
Any argument that starts with the word imagine is probably not going to end well.
I think Hilbert's argument is quite sound. And in any case I don't think the idea of an infinite number of antecedent causes is a starter anyway.

On the other hand the premiss "some thing with a beginning has an antecent cause" does not seem supportable.

And the concept of causality is not, in itself, a priori, so I am not sure what it is doing in a metaphysical argument in the first place.
 
No, the reason scientists avoid using the phrase "the universe began 13.7 billion years ago" is that it is inaccurate. We can find evidence for stuff back that far. Our models can be used to postdict events back that far. Beyond that, we don't currently know anything. There are several hypotheses as to what went on at t=0 and prior, but there is no knowledge.

We are fairly sure that nothing temporal existed 'before' T-0* (or outside time) according to the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker solutions of the gravitational field equations (of GR) in the case of a open example** of the universe. According to FRW the universe can be open or closed. We all know that space time energy etc did not expand into nothing when the BB began. So by using the KCA as a valid argument and assuming its premises are true then something before.outside time is demanded! And this thing we call it a 'cause' is nothing known to science. Its atemporal and can cause universes to begin to exist. Hmmm' what does that sound like to you?

* there is no 'before' time zero and that is where things get extraordinarily difficult to describe. Instead of before T-0 outside the universe/time would be a better explanation.

** I use an open example of the universe because we have empirical evidence to support it. We have no such evidence to support a closed universe.

; {>
 
Last edited:
We are fairly sure that nothing temporal existed before that according to the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker solutions of the gravitational field equations (of GR) in the case of a open example of the universe. According to FRW the universe can be open or closed. We all know that space time energy etc did not expand into nothing when the BB began. So by using the KCA as a valid argument and assuming its premises are true then something before.outside time is demanded! And this thing we call it a 'cause' is nothing known to science. Its atemporal and can cause universes to begin to exist. Hmmm' what does that sound like to you?

; {>

Sounds like good ol' confirmation bias to me. Anybody?
 
Gawd.....:boggled:

First, look up cosmological argument. Then look up scientific theory. Two different things.
But if there can be a mathematical model for a physical theory then it is shown to be logically possible.

Metaphysics and physics inhabit the same logical space - you cannot argue for the logical impossibility of something in metaphysics that has been shown to be logically possible in physics.

Incidentally - what is your justification for using the concept of causality in a metaphysical arugment? Is causality an a priori concept?

And what is your justification for P6?
 
So by using the KCA as a valid argument and assuming its premises are true then something before.outside time is demanded!
Oh, and can there be a sequence of events in something that is outside of time?
 
You think that coming to a thread, provoking people who don't believe in his god by asking loaded questions that don't get explained unless someone provides him with the answer he was looking for (Note: never the right one)and implying that atheists have a deep, hatred for his god when there is overwhelming evidence against everything that he stands for, is deserving of your respect?If anybody has satanic tendencies, I don't think its the atheists..

Well I have only reviewed a few of his posts and don't draw the same conclusion as you. I see him as a fellow christian being ganged up on for his beliefs and not the validity of his claims. Of course I may change my mind. I know that at first glance I could be wrong.

IN any case originally I simply called him brother, a common salutation which elicited a taunting response from a secular/atheist member which seemed to vindicate some of what Daniel oops I mean rreg was saying. Oh I did not mean atheists have satanic tendencies, Christians are more prone to get a satanic attack, I think that in some instances the atheist members in these sites are influenced by demonic or spiritual forces...now the twilight music please.... we all are libel to such influence IMO. Now I think its time for a extra layer of tin foil on this silly hat...

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom