The certainty of God's existence.

Brother yrreg you should know by now that playing the empathy/sympathy card here is so not working.

; {>
Brother Yrreg? That explains the coherence of your "evidence" and "proofs". Supporting someone just because they are the same "faith"' as you despite them being so wrong and completely incoherent is truly amusing.
 
Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?

Yes, and that thread was up to your usual standards of inanity. Well done.

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.

Or that we enjoy using your threads in the same way a cat enjoys using a scratching post.

Here is a radical proposition: People do not need a reason to assume something does not exist when they have not been presented with evidence of that something's existence.

Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.
Atheists do no deny God despite evidence to the contrary. We deny God due to a lack of evidence. Those are two very different stances which you insist are one and the same. Until you understand the difference, your threads will be nothing more than sources of amusement.

You see, you tell people that babies who still have not the use of reason are atheists like yourselves.

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.

Wow, two factual statements in a row from Gerry. I never thought that would happen.

The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.
Except that we do not see all the evidence in the world testifying to the existence of God in out hearts and minds -- rather the opposite.

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.
Denial has nothing to do with it.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.
Epic argument failure -- you to not have to believe in something to deny its existence.

You also ignore that some of us like to participate in these threads because they are excellent practice in debunking silly claims.

Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:
I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​
Because that stance is a product of your fevered imagination.

That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.
No. I am an atheist because the evidence does not demand the existence of God to explain it.

Do that, then you will be free to no longer have to give any account of rational foundation of course pseudo at that for your denial of God.

Then you can go away.
Nope, your threads are too amusing.


Otherwise, you must examine your heart what are the motivations moving you to think up reasons to convince people that your denial of the certainty in your mind of God's existence is owing to your shall we call it enlightenment following so much time and trouble in the prevarication of your reasoning faculty.
This statement is true only about the straw atheist you insist on passing off as the actual thing.

Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.
Ditto.

Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,
The lady doth protest too much.​
Yrreg

Only in your fevered imagination.
 
<snip thinly veiled insults and projection>
The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.
Detail some of this evidence which you say we should see, please.

In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.
Wait...what? Posting here is proof of theism? How do you justify that leap of illogical thought?
Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​
But I do care for the reasons. Surely you don't want me to lie?

<snip more projection, and some not-so-thinly veiled insults>
 
Did anyone ever consider that the likes of yrreg are not so much trying to convince us or just to troll but simply to bind our resources?

Just imagine how many believers you could convert in the time you spend in these threads ...
 
No pretense here, just a rational mind

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.
Not exactly.

I agree that taking the time to compose a post indicates motivation, but the original motivation is not to prove to myself or the community here that I am right not to recognize God.

I have stated that there are definitions of God which would be acceptable to me. The various faces of the Abrahamic God are, in my mind a ridiculous fairy tale.

Of course, the various faces of the various Hindu gods are also, in my mind, ridiculous fairy tales, and I'm not on any Hindu boards taking Hindus to task for their beliefs. The claims made by astrologers are ridiculous in my mind, but I'm not troubling myself to attempt to reason with those who believe in astrology.

The main reason I spend my precious time arguing against the Christian belief set is because some Christian factions are attempting, in my country, to use their political muscle to push an explicitly anti-science anti-reason agenda.

I recognize the benefits the scientific method has brought to human society, and regard attacks on that method as attacks on human progress itself. That is what provides my motivation.

Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.
Because that would not be the truth.

In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.
Nonsense.

The fact that I take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that I have reasons to consider the God of the Creationists to be a laughable hodgepodge of invented characteristics indicates nothing of the sort.

On the other hand, the fact that you choose to ignore my reasons, and the reasons of everyone else who posts here, and waste your time claiming that you HAVE rational reasons for believing in some kind of God (perhaps the God of the Creationists), without ever either defining what kind of God you believe in or providing the rational reasons which you claim underpin your belief, indicates that you have nothing beyond an emotional need to believe.

Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.
Will you be daring enough to declare that you choose to believe in the man-made invention you call God, and don't care about justifying that belief with reason?

If you don't declare it and leave, never to return, you are a spineless coward.
 
Last edited:
All right, I guess I'll restate things in a more serious way. I don't "deny the existence of God." I am not an atheist. I do deny that there is any way in which to logically prove the "certainty of God's existence." I am not a theist. I choose to mindfully experience God as I understand the transcendence of God, so I am a contemplative. There is no understanding and no certainty; to speak about God is to fill a bowl which must be empty (there is also no bowl, no fullness, and no emptiness), so I am a mystic. The human mind is the most astonishing thing there is. :) I'm still trying to figure out a good theology for that. But really, yyreg, why not respond to some of these things? Why not prove that you want to do something with this thread besides baiting atheists?
 
Last edited:
Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?

Ok you are not talking to or about me: I don't have to strive at all. It is perfectly obvious and not very important. So I will address the rest of this post

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.

I think you will find you came here and asked about it. It is certainly true that some here are atheists. It is perfectly true that many are very willing to say why that is true. Are you not willing to say why you think what you do? Oh, wait......


Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.

Because that would not be true and it would not be polite. Hmmmm ...I begin to see why this is hard for you....


You see, you tell people that babies who still have not the use of reason are atheists like yourselves.

Yes.

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.

That is your privilege. I do not happen to think that belief systems are a maturational process because I notice that animals don't appear to have faith; and most people believe what they were taught about religion when they were children: unlike sex, which most animals do come to over time; and which people for the most part come to enjoy even if you teach them nothing at all. What evidence do you have on the other side?

The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.

Still waiting for that evidence, Yrreg. You are taking an awful long time to produce it, if it is so pervasive. But I will wait

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.

Doh!! I thought you had got the difference between logic and magic: but it seems not. Is it the -ic at the end that is distracting you? Oh and btw: stop calling me a liar unless you have something to show I have lied. I don't appreciate it.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

Oh, I know!! And black is white and war is peace and truth is a lie and feedom is slavery and ...... Don't be so silly

Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​



That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.

Because it would not be true.


Do that, then you will be free to no longer have to give any account of rational foundation of course pseudo at that for your denial of God.

Nope: it is not even that you haven't got the vocabulary down right: you haven't got the primary senses which would allow you to read and understand what you are told. Never mind: I am sure you can't help it.

Then you can go away.

Er... this is a sceptic board, Yrreg. Are you sure you have this the right way round?


Otherwise, you must examine your heart what are the motivations moving you to think up reasons to convince people that your denial of the certainty in your mind of God's existence is owing to your shall we call it enlightenment following so much time and trouble in the prevarication of your reasoning faculty.

You are beginning to doubt, it seems.

I asked you before, Yrreg: why are you so angry with atheists. I think it is because you know in the logic of your heart and mind that god does not exist and so you wilfully deny that simple fact so that you can get on with the guiltless pride.


Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.


Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,
The lady doth protest too much.​

I think you should put that mirror down. it seems to be annoying you
 
Last edited:
Did anyone ever consider that the likes of yrreg are not so much trying to convince us or just to troll but simply to bind our resources?

Just imagine how many believers you could convert in the time you spend in these threads ...
You are looking at it the wrong way.
The time Yrreg spends here is less time he spends chasing people away and deconverting people from his brand of "faith".
 
The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.


But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

Yrreg, why don't you apply what you say to yourself? If you did that before you came here, you wouldn't write half, no all, of what you actually write.

I could just as easily argue that the reason you spend so much time arguing with atheists is because you question your own belief in God and so the more you interact with those that find it easy and feel you are trumping them, the more you feel 'firm' in your beliefs. But that's just psychology woo don't listen to me.

I find that people do not seem to really understand what this quote was saying but you should really think about it

"I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all other gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."

You're just scared that your life is worthless without some god to give it meaning. Its alright though, I'm sure the good people on this forum would be willing to help you if you'd asked.

Instead you come here to unload your thoughts and completely disregard everything everyone has to say, even what I'm saying right now most definitely. That shear ignorance in itself is enough for anyone to see that you are lost and you do need help.

But I implore you to find 10 people on this planet that have not participated in any of your threads and ask them to read one, and see who they tend to agree with. Please do that. Maybe people convincing you in person would be different.
 
Last edited:
Did anyone ever consider that the likes of yrreg are not so much trying to convince us or just to troll but simply to bind our resources?

Just imagine how many believers you could convert in the time you spend in these threads ...

In my case, I don't really make any effort to "convert" believers anyway. (I guess that makes me only a New Militant Angry Fundamentalist Atheist, rather than the full-on New Militant Angry Fundamentalist Evangelical Atheist.)

yrreg's threads only divert me from other ways of wasting time on the internet.
 
Did anyone ever consider that the likes of yrreg are not so much trying to convince us or just to troll but simply to bind our resources?

Just imagine how many believers you could convert in the time you spend in these threads ...

I'm not interested in converting anyone. That's their gig, not mine.
 
Note that the universe began 13.7* years ago is basic well accepted cosmology. Of course there has been concerted efforts to avoid saying that the universe began to exist in the popular press and pop science magazines. I think the reason for this is because the BB does prove that the universe began, and that fits so well with theistic explanations cosmology. (science wrongly claimed the universe was eternal and static ie unchanging up until at least the mid 20the century).

It's more complicated than that. Big Bang cosmology simply states that at a point around 14 billion years ago the universe existed in a super dense, super hot state. It does not imply that prior to the Big Bang there was no universe, it only states that time, as we know it, began at this point. It may well be that asking what existed prior to the Big Bang may be like asking what is north of the North Pole. The universe may indeed have no beginning.
 
Did anyone ever consider that the likes of yrreg are not so much trying to convince us or just to troll but simply to bind our resources?

Just imagine how many believers you could convert in the time you spend in these threads ...
I'm not interested in converting folk. If someone posts to say I should believe in their god because x, y & z, then I'll happily argue about the value of x, y & z. Other than that, live and let live. In the UK religion is not a big deal anyway.

However, I'm still waiting for yrreg to post any reason why I should believe. He keeps saying there is lots of evidence, but never actually states what that evidence is.
 
The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.
All right Gerry, you've got me. My problem with God is that the bastard still owes me money.


Is Gerry even talking to any body but himself anymore?
 
Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.
Nice try, Gerry. I used to believe in God and now I don't because of reason. But I'm not surprised that you think that implications of cowardice will influence others to agree with you. I'm not surprised that you think this is a clever tactic. How about you, Gerry? Do you have the guts to transfer all of your money into my account? If you don't you are only confirming that you are a big chicken. Buk buk buk.

Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,The lady doth protest too much.
Like you regarding Buddhism?
 
Last edited:
Posted by me on another thread:
What is the need for a so-called god, not why I don’t believe in one.

What does a so-called god explain, well in the time before science it was the only way for many to explain how the world seemed to be and seemed to worked, it was used in a time when knowing anything about anything was so very limited, and many people seemed to have a need to have an answer, any answer, and we see this even today. It was something to use for an explanation when there seemed to be so many effects in the world without any cause or causes. People didn’t know about the weather so there was a so-called god for that and why the wind blew so there was a so-called god for that, or why the ground shook and again a so-called god, and how the hell the body worked and how it seemed to be so different from other things around you, so a so-called god for living things too. So people would use many different so-called gods for the unknowns of the world. Later some people made it just one so-called god to explain it all (which became three again). But does a so-called god explain anything, or does it only pushes the question off one more layer. Some people have learned more a about the world and universe by using the scientific method and see that there are answers to question, even if there are not known at the time. They know that there are answers and one doesn’t have to use a so-called god for a poor useless answer.

So why don’t I believe in a so-called god, because if anything it answers nothing. But if nothing else it has shown me how lots of people have a need for answers to questions, no matter how false and/or weak they are and how this leads to many falsehoods and prejudices.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I'm only going to respond to one member at a time. I have found that a theist in a predominantly atheist or secular forum quickly becomes overwhelmed by the number of rebuttals. I find myself typing out long explanations to four or five members while the members only have me to respond to. I will get to everyone eventually (as long as the discussion remains civil, if it digresses into even mild insults I have to stop posting altogether because by that point its not the subject being discussed its each others personal credibly etc.

Fair enough? Ok, onward ~

We are discussing the KCA yes? Therefore we are discussing the validity of the premises to construct a valid syllogism/argument via deductive reasoning. I described how the 'cause' that caused the universe to begin to exist did not begin to exist because it was atemporal and eternal. The reason it is eternal atemporal is as per Big Bang Cosmology which indicates space time was created in the Big Bang along with gravity etc. And the cause must exist due to the deductive logic of the KCA.

Now here is a cut and paste via the web that describes one reason an infinite series of events is absurd. It one of two. The other reason uses set (Attempting to form a set of actually infinite things).

Here is the first ;


"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.

Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.

Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.

Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."


; }>

Any argument that starts with the word imagine is probably not going to end well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom