The certainty of God's existence.

Now here is a cut and paste via the web that describes one reason an infinite series of events is absurd. It one of two. The other reason uses set (Attempting to form a set of actually infinite things).

Here is the first ;


"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.

Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.

Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.

Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."

First of all, I'd like to remark that the author didn't tell the Hilbert Hotel story to the end; here's the rest, as I wrote it up for this forum a year ago.

More importantly, however, the author of that piece doesn't seem to grasp the basic math needed to appreciate Hilbert's story. You can't do arithmetic on "infinite numbers" as you can with finite numbers. That doesn't mean that infinities are meaningless; on the contrary, Hilbert's Hotel is an example of how you can validly reason about infinite sets, and how it can be counterintuitive if you try to apply the same standards as with "normal" numbers.

Note also that this story only entails countable inifinities - i.e., sets with cardinality Aleph_0, the smallest infinite cardinal number, which are "as big as" the set of integral numbers. The set of real numbers (and the set of complex numbers) have cardinality c (which may or may not be Aleph_1), and are so much "bigger" that if you subtract a countably infinite set from them (e.g., the set of the integral numbers), the resulting set has the same cardinality.

I note that all physical theories use either real or complex numbers to model reality, so in the words of the blog you cite, even more absurd infinities than the blogger used in his failed rebuttal of infinity. When I type this, an uncountably infinite number of time points has passed since the Big Bang. Now, do you count the movement of an object as one single event, or a new event for each time point? In the last case, you do count up to infinitely many events.

I'll leave that latter line of reasoning to those more versed in physics than me. I'm just a simple math/CS guy, and for my part, anything that's possible to model in math exists, even if it has no observable counterpart in physical reality.
 
You guys still here trying to peddle your sordid and impoverished pretensions of reasoning that is perversion of reasoning to continue to convince yourselves that you are right to deny God?


Just declare that you arbitrarily and wilfully by your employment of free will choose to deny God, then go away.


That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist.





Remember, after that declaration of defiance, just go away, and leave people who know God for certainty to discuss among themselves the other more specific properties of God and how to relate to God and with God, aside from God's first property which every God knower from certainty accept without any reservations:


God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, the author of the scheme of intelligent order therein.​




Okay, turn in your declaration of total and irreversible arbitrary wilful defiance and denial of God, then go away.


Someone did that in mythology if you will, go do likewise if you have the guts he has.


Otherwise as I said already earlier:

The lady doth protest too much.​





Yrreg

You're talking about Loki turning against Woden, yes? Or Prometheus against Zeus?

Sorry, Yrreg, you're no longer the top dog in this forum. RevDisturba is far more interesting to argue with.
 
Last edited:
Thus I refute thee

As Dr. Johnson said to the bishop, "Thus I refute thee":

anoiF said:
What went wrong with an atheist for him to proclaim himself Christian?

What went wrong with an atheist for him to proclaim himself a christian, turning away from reason and the real world joy of discovery?


So far I can say that all the christians I have the chance to exchange ideas with were atheists as babies; people who came from a scientific culture and society; or people who used to believe in Santa Claus, the primary supernatural prototype of all the beings called God in English everywhere -- where people speak English and one of their English vocabulary is Santa Clause with a capital S and a capital C: but grew out of it through the use of their inborn logic.

When I talk with anyone who does care to talk about his being a christian, eventually I learn from him or find out incidentally that he was a atheist before, or a believer in Santa Claus.

Now this christian will want to impress on me and others who care to listen to him, the reason why he turned to christianity, namely: because (as one of such ex-atheist now self-proclaimed christian says it, Yrreg), because he finds being a Christian affords him rational theism and guiltless discourtesy.


My own observation about human motivations is that people normally don't seek rational theism in their actions, but some human satisfaction of the material, carnal. or vanity, and compensation domains.


Material domain, the gain in the last analysis of monetary worth. There is no finer way to make a fortune than to get other folk to tithe

Carnal domain, for example, guiltless sexism for people who still feel they have to render their sexism guiltless on whatever ground they suffer guilt hang-up.

Vanity domain, to show to others that they are better off for being in on the True Truth tm and are very special on that account

Compensation domain, to get even against others, i.e. to assuage a grudge, or to compensate for one's own deficiency in any aspect of one's existence, person-hood, and circumstances,


What I always want to investigate with christians, notwithstanding their declaration that becoming a christian is all motivated by rational theism, what in reality motivates them from among one or all of the above material, carnal, vanity, and compensation impulses.

Right now I am checking on what I read somewhere that St Francis Borgia sought to take up a position as a nobleman in spain: and St Francis Xavier expected to be an aristocrat in the kingdom of Navarre, but the idea did not materialize for them.

That is one very fertile area for investigation, that because they were rejected for high office in the spanish court, they turned against reason and atheism


Another example, a woman, Heloise, who was a renowned scholar of her day fell in love with a noted philospher and teacher in Paris, called Pierre Abelard. But the relationship was rejected by her family and she was abused and he castrated. They both turned away from scholarship and took orders in the church.

Of course people who want to force other people to stay married when the relationship is violent: or to force other people to have children then watch them starve: or to condemn homosexuals to misery or death, they definitely will have a very strong grudge against atheism and the kind of morality inspired by secular values; same also with people seeking to enslave black people because secular values holds slavery as taboo.






anoiF
 
Anybody want to see yrreg's head asplode? Watch carefully...

Yrreg,

If god exists, he is outside space and time (transcendent).
If god exists, he is omnipresent
In order to be transcendent, god can't exist anywhere in space.
In order to be omnipresent, god must exist everywhere in space.
An omnipresent god is an impossibility.

Care to point out the error? Or is this correct and one major tenet (god's omnipresence) of your belief is shattered into a few million pieces?
 
I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of God's existence.


And my approach here is to look up with Google the following words, "certainty of God's existence", to find out what people whose writings are in the web say about the certainty of God's existence.


Just one request to posters here, please don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.





Yrreg




How ironic,from the past master at wasting bandwith.
 
Why don't you get it, YARRRRGH? (That's how I'm going to refer to you because it demonstrates the frustration you bring to this forum)

If we denied your god, we'd be acknowledging said gods existence in the first place. We are not going to 'willfully' deny your god. We are going to willfully deny your gods existence as a whole. I am reasonably certain that your idea of god doesn't exist in the physical world.

Solely on the grounds that there are way cooler gods out there than yours.
 
I can't believe it. Yrreg followed that checklist to a 't'. Forgive me for sounding like a woo but I believe someone pays Yrreg to be this relentless. You just can't get this kind of entertainment for free!

A career in stand-up beckons.
 
Anybody want to see yrreg's head asplode? Watch carefully...

Yrreg,

If god exists, he is outside space and time (transcendent).
If god exists, he is omnipresent
In order to be transcendent, god can't exist anywhere in space.
In order to be omnipresent, god must exist everywhere in space.
An omnipresent god is an impossibility.

Care to point out the error? Or is this correct and one major tenet (god's omnipresence) of your belief is shattered into a few million pieces?

Unfortunately, he just won't read this.
 
Unfortunately, he just won't read this.
Let's try again shall we?


Yrreg,

If god exists, he (or she) is perfect.
If god exists, he (or she) is the creator of the universe.
If god is perfect, whatever it creates must be perfect.
The universe is not perfect.
It is impossible for a perfect gos to have created the universe.
It is impossible for a perfect god to exist.

Care to point out the errors or has you entire belief system just been shattered by seeing god can't be perfect?

ETA - On deck, god's virtue...will it be the third strikeout?
 
Last edited:
I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of God's existence.


And my approach here is to look up with Google the following words, "certainty of God's existence", to find out what people whose writings are in the web say about the certainty of God's existence.


Just one request to posters here, please don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.






Yrreg


Not this again.
 
yrreg,

God is (according to the Judeo-Christian myth) a being of which no greater being can be thought.
Greatness includes the greatness of virtue.
God is a being of which no being could be more virtuous.
Virtue involves overcoming pains and danger.
A being can only be considered virtuous if it can suffer pain or be destroyed.
A god that can suffer pain or be destroyed is not one which no greater being can be thought of.
You can think of a greater being, one that is nonsuffering and indestructible.
God, a virtuous god, does not exist.

Want to point the error out or is this strike three?
 
yrreg, your biggest problem seems to be trying to decide whether atheists are stupid or just defiant. Unfortunately, either of those choices is dependent on atheists actively denying their belief in the existence of your god. Why do you fail to understand that this is not the case?

We're not too stupid to see the evidence; it's not there.
We're not denying the existence of the evidence before us; it's not there.
In short, we are not rebelling against your god because your god does not exist.

You claim to have all kinds of evidence for the existence of god, yet you've failed to produce a single shred of it, in spite our repeated requests. You just say, "Look at it! Look at it! I know you can see it! Why are you so blind, stupid, or defiant! Something must be wrong with you!"

Please, tell us what the evidence IS. We can't see something that isn't there. It might be obvious to you, in the same way that Santa Claus is obvious to young children. At least they can point to cookies that have been eaten and presents under their tree as evidence. (Not good evidence, mind you, but at least it's something.) You've got a santa claus with no cookies and no presents.

I'm not one to deny what's actually real, but I'm also not one to believe in something just because someone tells me it's real, or it will make me feel good. So what evidence is there beyond, "I believe it and other people believe it, therefore it must be true."
 
Stop tergiversating Gerry and have a real conversation

Tell you what, everyone here, I will just bring up reasons for a person's certainty of God's existence, instead of his feelings.


So that we will not waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.

It would save time if you didn't add worthless drivel, Gerry.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom