ddt
Mafia Penguin
Now here is a cut and paste via the web that describes one reason an infinite series of events is absurd. It one of two. The other reason uses set (Attempting to form a set of actually infinite things).
Here is the first ;
"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.
Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.
Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.
Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.
It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."
First of all, I'd like to remark that the author didn't tell the Hilbert Hotel story to the end; here's the rest, as I wrote it up for this forum a year ago.
More importantly, however, the author of that piece doesn't seem to grasp the basic math needed to appreciate Hilbert's story. You can't do arithmetic on "infinite numbers" as you can with finite numbers. That doesn't mean that infinities are meaningless; on the contrary, Hilbert's Hotel is an example of how you can validly reason about infinite sets, and how it can be counterintuitive if you try to apply the same standards as with "normal" numbers.
Note also that this story only entails countable inifinities - i.e., sets with cardinality Aleph_0, the smallest infinite cardinal number, which are "as big as" the set of integral numbers. The set of real numbers (and the set of complex numbers) have cardinality c (which may or may not be Aleph_1), and are so much "bigger" that if you subtract a countably infinite set from them (e.g., the set of the integral numbers), the resulting set has the same cardinality.
I note that all physical theories use either real or complex numbers to model reality, so in the words of the blog you cite, even more absurd infinities than the blogger used in his failed rebuttal of infinity. When I type this, an uncountably infinite number of time points has passed since the Big Bang. Now, do you count the movement of an object as one single event, or a new event for each time point? In the last case, you do count up to infinitely many events.
I'll leave that latter line of reasoning to those more versed in physics than me. I'm just a simple math/CS guy, and for my part, anything that's possible to model in math exists, even if it has no observable counterpart in physical reality.