The certainty of God's existence.

Sounds like good ol' confirmation bias to me. Anybody?

Why? What would you say creates or causes something (say a universe for example) to begin to exist out of nothing? Why does something exist (our universe) rather than nothing?

; {>
 
Last edited:
Oh, and can there be a sequence of events in something that is outside of time?

Certainly (doing my best three stooges impersonation). Cause and effect would seem to need time wouldn't it? A egg breaks but doesn't unbreak, time has an arrow but its a strange arrow indeed. Why? According to physics an egg should unbreak just as easily as it breaks. Events are like seeds in rye bread. Slice the bread and you see the seeds (events). You can see how the seeds are located spatially with no regard to time. Time is not required.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Why do you think that anything that has a beginning must have an antecedent cause?

I have no problem with the idea of the universe having an antecedent cause, it may or it may not. But I don't think it stands as a premiss.
 
Well I have only reviewed a few of his posts and don't draw the same conclusion as you. I see him as a fellow christian being ganged up on for his beliefs and not the validity of his claims. Of course I may change my mind. I know that at first glance I could be wrong.

IN any case originally I simply called him brother, a common salutation which elicited a taunting response from a secular/atheist member which seemed to vindicate some of what Daniel oops I mean rreg was saying. Oh I did not mean atheists have satanic tendencies, Christians are more prone to get a satanic attack, I think that in some instances the atheist members in these sites are influenced by demonic or spiritual forces...now the twilight music please.... we all are libel to such influence IMO. Now I think its time for a extra layer of tin foil on this silly hat...

; {>

Are you ever planning to address the question of people on this thread who are not atheists but who don't agree with you? Because if you don't, then it is very hard to avoid the conclusion that all you want to do is to bait atheists.
 
Certainly (doing my best three stooges impersonation).
No need for the three stooges impersonation, I also agree that sequence of events does not depend upon time, I just wanted to have you confirm that you were aware of this.

Would you also agree that P1 in your argument is not about time, but about sequence of events?
 
Last edited:
Are you ever planning to address the question of people on this thread who are not atheists but who don't agree with you? Because if you don't, then it is very hard to avoid the conclusion that all you want to do is to bait atheists.

I told you I would address the complicated questions in order. I am trying to get the simple ones out of the way which are not in order...Hey I thought everyone was atheist agnostic here ;)

; {>

ps I don't bait anyone I just state what I believe to be true. Additionally I like atheists as well as anyone else, it all depends on their respect (its then mutual) and friendliness. I may not call a atheist brother at first, but if I befriend him/her they are brother just a my christian brothers are.
 
Last edited:
No need for the three stooges impersonation, I also agree that sequence of events does not depend upon time, I just wanted to have you confirm that you were aware of this.

Would you also agree that P1 in your argument is not about time, but about sequence of events?

Hee hee sneaky. It is both. Time does not exist 'before' t-0. Some events are after t-0 but at least one has to be either 'before' t-0 or 'outside' time.

; }>
 
Last edited:
Hee hee sneaky. It is both. Time does not exist 'before' T-0. Some events are after t-0 but at least one has to be either 'before' or 'outside' time.

; }>
Well let me put the problem as I see it.

1. Every sequence of events must have a beginning.
2. Every beginning must have an antecedent cause.

That is, I think you will agree, a contradiction. (1) seems to be solid to me, so this suggests that the idea that (2) not solid.

Add to that my previous point, that there can be a logically consistent model of a universe with a beginning and no antecedent cause and yet nothing left unexplained.

If so that seems to point to the idea of "anything that begins must have an antecedent cause" as not being a logically valid premiss.

And it links to my question about your justification for using the concept of causality in a metaphysical argument.

(Don't forget that unless you can justify P6 then even if everything else in your argument is valid, you have not proved a God or anything like it.
 
I will say that brother Yrreg is more of a christian than I am, due to his reverent tolerance in this case at least, which garners even more respect from my me and my very short respect list.

I would not be nearly as tolerant and as graceful under attack as Brother Yrreg is.
I'm guessing that you missed his post in which Yrreg declared that atheists are incapable of experiencing love and beauty in their lives and then suggested that they should just commit suicide.
 
Why? What would you say creates or causes something (say a universe for example) to begin to exist out of nothing? Why does something exist (our universe) rather than nothing?

; {>

I don't believe the answer to that question is known. I said it was confirmation bias because you are picking and choosing certain ideas to fit with yours, and ignoring facts or substantiated assumptions that don't. Even if there was some supernatural cause that sparked the BB, its not like any of it confirms the Judeo-Christian god exists and it doesn't even lean in that direction.
 
I'm guessing that you missed his post in which Yrreg declared that atheists are incapable of experiencing love and beauty in their lives and then suggested that they should just commit suicide.

Really, well I might have to demote him. That is not christian attitude. Nor is it backed up by scripture. Dang that is brutal....


Well I am just taking up for myself now *cof*

; }>
 
You know, the Big Bang doesn't contradict circular time, because the universe could contract to a single particle at the end, and explode at the beginning.
 
You know, the Big Bang doesn't contradict circular time, because the universe could contract to a single particle at the end, and explode at the beginning.
But that would falsify that premise and cause Godel's silly "proof" to collapse just like the multitude of other flaws and a Christian can't have that now can he?
 
Ah yes, the Kalām cosmological argument:

Premise 1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause.

Premise 2. The universe began to exist.

Conclusion: The universe must have a cause.

This is nothing more than the "first cause" argument proposed by people like Maimonides and Aquinas. It boils down to "I assert that the universe had a creator and I assert that said creator was my god". The same old problems apply to this argument. First, we don't know that the universe had a beginning. It could be self contained and finite, but without an actual beginning or end, like the surface of a sphere. Second, it exempts the "first cause" i.e. "God" from the restrictions placed on the universe. It simply assumes an infinite regress and then asserts a convenient eternal construct to terminate the regress. Third, even if it was a valid argument, it does nothing to justify the faith of the Abrahamic religions of Rambam, Aquinas or the Kalām philosophy.
 
Don't be silly. The Creator is most definitely Klodsop the Celestial Drunk Goblin. What else could it be?
PS: Klodsop had sex with Klodsop which created Klodsop. It is Klodsop Incest to infinity.
 
Last edited:
Why? What would you say creates or causes something (say a universe for example) to begin to exist out of nothing? Why does something exist (our universe) rather than nothing?

; {>

If the answer is "God", then why is God exempt from the same question regarding its existence? Why is there a god instead of nothing?
 
I will say that brother Yrreg is more of a christian than I am, due to his reverent tolerance in this case at least, which garners even more respect from my me and my very short respect list.

Friend Yrreg has been suspended from this forum many times for breaking the rules, amongst other things for encouraging atheists to commit suicide. Tolerance is the last word I would use about Yrreg.

Maybe you should check out his posting history before you give him your respect?
 
I was right, you guys have no guts to outright deny God and just go away.

You guys still here trying to peddle your sordid and impoverished pretensions of reasoning that is perversion of reasoning to continue to convince yourselves that you are right to deny God?


Just declare that you arbitrarily and wilfully by your employment of free will choose to deny God, then go away.


That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist.





Remember, after that declaration of defiance, just go away, and leave people who know God for certainty to discuss among themselves the other more specific properties of God and how to relate to God and with God, aside from God's first property which every God knower from certainty accept without any reservations:


God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, the author of the scheme of intelligent order therein.​




Okay, turn in your declaration of total and irreversible arbitrary wilful defiance and denial of God, then go away.


Someone did that in mythology if you will, go do likewise if you have the guts he has.


Otherwise as I said already earlier:

The lady doth protest too much.​





Yrreg
 
We are fairly sure that nothing temporal existed 'before' T-0* (or outside time) according to the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker solutions of the gravitational field equations (of GR) in the case of a open example** of the universe. According to FRW the universe can be open or closed. We all know that space time energy etc did not expand into nothing when the BB began. So by using the KCA as a valid argument and assuming its premises are true then something before.outside time is demanded! And this thing we call it a 'cause' is nothing known to science.


There are plenty of things in modern physics that aren't temporal.

Its atemporal and can cause universes to begin to exist. Hmmm' what does that sound like to you?


Vacuum fluctations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom