The certainty of God's existence.

You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.
I am well aware that there are folks that are certain of God's existence, for any definition of God. That one is certain of something does not mean that which one is certain of is in fact the case -- as has been explained to you ad nauseam, certainty is about belief, not knowledge. It is possible to be absolutely certain of something and be dead wrong.

That people are able to find logical grounds for their certain belief in God only goes to show how good humans are at rationalization (which is definitely not the same thing as being rational!).

I am sure you know what these psychological motivations are, but for the sake of readers here, just name only four psychological motivations of people logically certain of God.

  1. Fitting in with their social circle.
  2. Imprinting.
  3. Indoctrination at an early age.
  4. There is no 4th reason.
As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.
No, I do not go out of my way to topple people's belief structures, whether concerning God or anything else.

Unless, of course, they invite it by being obnoxious about it in my presence. :)

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.

On this forum? Because it is all about skepticism.

In the wide world? I generally don't -- it is seldom worth the bother.
 
*waits for evidence that any such person exists*



*knows no such thing*




*waits for these logical grounds to be laid out*



*wonders why the psychological motivations of people should vary between theists and non theist, any more than within either group*




*knows no such thing*



If they have logical grounds for that certainty that would be neither possible nor desirable.



* waits for evidence in support of this extraordinary claim*

It's a good thing you brought a pack of cards with you, on your way over to this thread.
 
Results 1 - 10 of about 2,750 for "certainty of god's existence". (0.18 seconds)


Yrreg do us all a favour , read them all and then only post about the best ones..

I'm happy to wait .............take your time...
 
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

As to P2: Why would an infinite number of events be an absurdity? Because we, as finite beings, can't grasp it?

As to P3: Here we have the age-old argument of the first cause. However, if there is a first cause, not caused by something else, either the universe itself, in some form or other is the first cause, or the first cause, being eternal (P5), is also infinite (P1) and therefore, according to this argument, absurd (P2).

If we bring the argument over the existence of God down to a concrete level we can deal with this upposed God in more meaningful terms. First, why doesn't God just come out and say, "Here I am," and show him/her/it self? The reason usually given for this is that God is testing our faith, that we will believe and be faithful without absolute certainty.This will separate the good (faithful) from the evil (faithless). However, those proposing this argument usually also believe in the miracles of Exodus, meaning that the israelites saw Moses part the Red Sea, ect. and yet were still faithless. So, show me a miracle, God, and let's see if I believe.

The other concrete issue of the existence of God seems to be that of ethics. Those who believe in God often assume that godlessness = evil and that without got ethic go down the toilet. Let's see if this is true. When I was a beleiver, I though it was wrong to harm people and right to help them. Now that I'm an atheist I beleive it's wrong to harm people and right to help them. So, what do I need God for?
 
Drop Kick Me Jesus Through the Goalposts of Life"-- 6,010 hits.
Nothing like musical appreciation, I always say!

When we realize that atheists are a minority that range from 2.5% (atheist) of the world's population to 12.7% (non-religious) according to Wikipedia, your figures Maia, only tell me that atheists like to evangelize more than the religious types. Or search on Google more, who knows?

[/quote]

I am confused now. What exactly does Drop Kick Me Jesus Through the Goalposts of Life have to do with evangelizing atheists? Although it's a really good song, and I've seen the songwriter perform it live. :)
 
Ryokan said:
Sorry. As you can see below my picture, I'm European. My last post in this thread was made at almost 3am my time. I really needed some beauty sleep :)

You really should see my pic if you think you need a beauty sleep, I need a beauty coma.

I'm ready to grant you that. That's really not where my contention is. At the same time as an infinite number of events is called absurd, an eternal 'cause' is not.

I understand how counter intuitive that would be to someone who's paradigm depends on neo-positivism rather than a metaphysical described reality. Again, by deductive reasoning we are left with that rather unpleasant conclusion. If the universe did begin to exist because it needed a 'cause' to cause it to begin to exist, deductive logic demands that this 'cause' is atemporal or eternal. Infinite no. Atemporal simply means time independent.

Infinite and eternal is close to being the same, so if an infinite number of events is absurd, I must conclude that an eternal personal cause must also be.

In this case I don't think we can exchange infinite with atemporal and/or eternal. Infinite regression stops with the atemporal (time independent) cause.

I understand that you're going to feel ganged up upon on this site in religious discussions, and that there will be far more questions for you than you can answer. But since I'm on almost the other side of the planet from you, with a daily rythm that is out of sync with yours, I'm afraid a continuous conversation will be difficult. I also see that there are people who can argue this much better than I can. If you want to 'attach' yourself to one of them instead, I will understand :)

Ha, ha, I will attempt to take on a couple of others. Thanks for your cordial reply.

; {>
 
Brother yrreg you should know by now that playing the empathy/sympathy card here is so not working.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Note that the universe began 13.7* years ago is basic well accepted cosmology. Of course there has been concerted efforts to avoid saying that the universe began to exist in the popular press and pop science magazines. I think the reason for this is because the BB does prove that the universe began, and that fits so well with theistic explanations cosmology. (science wrongly claimed the universe was eternal and static ie unchanging up until at least the mid 20the century).


No, the reason scientists avoid using the phrase "the universe began 13.7 billion years ago" is that it is inaccurate. We can find evidence for stuff back that far. Our models can be used to postdict events back that far. Beyond that, we don't currently know anything. There are several hypotheses as to what went on at t=0 and prior, but there is no knowledge.

You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.


AKA, confirmation bias.
 
You have no guts to just deny God without the pretension of being grounded on reason.

[...]

As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.



Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.


Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.


You see, you tell people that babies who still have not the use of reason are atheists like yourselves.

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.


The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​



That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.


Do that, then you will be free to no longer have to give any account of rational foundation of course pseudo at that for your denial of God.

Then you can go away.


Otherwise, you must examine your heart what are the motivations moving you to think up reasons to convince people that your denial of the certainty in your mind of God's existence is owing to your shall we call it enlightenment following so much time and trouble in the prevarication of your reasoning faculty.


Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.


Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,
The lady doth protest too much.​




Yrreg
 
<babble snipped>

Yrreg

So, you're still angry that you were fooled into believing in god(s)? Still ashamed to show what evidence so easily convinced you there are god(s)?

Um, do you believe in Santa Claus? I guess everyone has been assuming that you don't.
 
Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.


Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.


You see, you tell people that babies who still have not the use of reason are atheists like yourselves.

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.


The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.


In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.

Why don't you just declare to people of course first to yourselves thus:

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.​



That is the way to be pure 100% genuine atheist, namely, that you choose to arbitrarily by free choice to deny God, and period.


Do that, then you will be free to no longer have to give any account of rational foundation of course pseudo at that for your denial of God.

Then you can go away.


Otherwise, you must examine your heart what are the motivations moving you to think up reasons to convince people that your denial of the certainty in your mind of God's existence is owing to your shall we call it enlightenment following so much time and trouble in the prevarication of your reasoning faculty.


Okay, will you be daring enough now to declare that you choose to deny God and don't give a heck about reasons to deny God, then go away, or you really have no guts.


Otherwise it is very glaringly clear,
The lady doth protest too much.​




Yrreg

Is it past your bedtime Yrreg? You're making even less sense than usual, and you seem all grumpy.
 
Have I already introduced a thread here on the motivations of atheists, namely, people who have to strive to prove to themselves that there is no God?
Atheists aren't striving to prove to themselves that there is no god. Do you strive to prove to yourself that there are no leprachauns? Do you strive to prove to yourself that there is no Santa Claus?

The fact that you are here writing messages to show readers and fellow posters here and also myself that you have reasons to not recognize God, that is proof enough your denial of God is a motivated behavior, and the original motivation is to prove to yourselves that you are right to not recognize God.
My denial of god is not a motivated behavior. It really takes very little effort to not believe in things for which there is no evidence. I'm not motivated to deny ghosts, leprachauns, fairies, pixies, or Santa Claus. I recognize them all for what they are - fictional.


Why don't you just declare to people who ask you why you refuse to recognize God, just declare that you choose to deny God because you have the option to deny Him, and tell people it is none of their business and you don't have to present reasons why.
Or why don't I tell them the truth from my own perspective? If somebody asks me why I don't believe in god, isn't it polite to give them an answer? For someone who doesn't want any actual answers from real live atheists, you sure do ask a lot of questions.

Get it straight: Atheists DO NOT CHOOSE TO DENY GOD. They simply dismiss him as an imaginary being. There is no evidence of his actual existence. (Or the existence of any of the other thousands of gods and supernatural beings throughout the ages.)

I think you are being dishonest in calling babies atheists, because on the same token whatever you call them atheists, you can as well call them sterile in regard to sexual reproduction.
Ummmm, babies are sterile in regard to sexual reproduction. And they're not atheists, but they aren't god-believers either. It's not something they've thought about.

The difference between babies and you is that you have come to reason and can see for yourselves all the evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of God to your heart and mind.
There is no evidence in the world testifying to the certainty of god in my heart and mind. If there's so much evidence, could you just share a smidgeon of it, please? And not the moon again. The moon is NOT evidence of any god, and certainly not of your specific god.

But you choose to deny that certainty in your heart and mind which is certainly founded on your inborn logic becoming active in the course of your mental development.
As my mental development progressed, so did my certainty that all gods, including the god of Abraham, were all imaginery beings.

In brief, the fact that you take the time and trouble to write messages here to show people that you have reasons to deny God's existence, that alone is indicative of the certainty in your heart and in your mind of God's existence.
Way to completely misrepresent the perspective of the atheists on this forum. Saying that god doesn't exist =/= acknowledging his existence.

Does Santa Claus exist? If you deny it, it's only because in your heart and your mind, you know he really does. Huh? Is this really your best argument? "I know you are but what am I?" Seriously, find a schoolyard and argue with your peers if that's the best you can do. It's right up there with all the rest of the arguments you've ever presented on this forum.

<snipped inane repetitive babble>
 
I supported my claim and then asked you to support yours as well. No special pleading need apply.
You did? Huh...strange. People must have mistaken your "support" for a joke somewhere. Would you care to point me back to this "support" since it seems completely missing from the 3 pages of this thread?
Please support your claim in your own words. No lengthy cut and pastes that describe quantum gravity and open universes as per GR ie (FRW) answers concerning gravitational field equations of general relativity.*
So you DIDN'T understand what the Planck Epoch or Planck Time actually means?
I guess I'll use simple words you can understand. It basically means it is IMPOSSIBLE to extrapolate back beyond that so it is IMPOSSIBLE with our current knowledge and technology to know what occurred before this span of time. You do know what IMPOSSIBLE actually means don't you?

The honest answer is "Don't know" what happened "before" this time period or do you have some Nobel Prize winning hypothesis you're waiting to unleash upon us all?
No not at all I described my take on it. Most cosmologists do not avoid saying the universe began. Perhaps you can support that claim as well, in your own words?
Since it is impossible to know what happens "before" the Planck Epoch, saying the universe "began" continues to be a false statement. As I said, many cosmologist use the term "began" only in the colloquial sense. The honest answer is still "Don't know".
Again sorry you saying so just ain’t so, I supported my claim not its time for once that you support yours. Again sorry you saying so just ain’t so

Paximperium’s extemporized replies noted and saved for the outside chance he may actually be able to support them one day.
Yawn...What was that about hypocrisy again. Oh yeah did some hypocrite say:
Please lets keep the taunting rhetoric to yourself, this forum is better than that. I usually don't answer any reply that has a hint of hate or taunt in it because it leads down a slippery slope of derailing the thread and getting off topic. This paragraph proves it, as does the majority of the content in your reply.
Who was that again?
Oh yeah, if and when you decide to support your assertions instead of playing this martyr game is when you deserve anything but derision.
The point? That the universe began as per the BB.
So you keep claiming. Still waiting for any basis for this claim at all.
I have fought off many secular fourm members in other forums that did claim that the BB singularity was a black hole type.
So? Still no point huh?
In any case I supported my claims now its time for a little reciprocal action support all your claims or for starters support just one of your claims. That may at least prove you aren’t making up your responses as you go along.
I am making stuff up as I go along. I don't pretend to know the ultimate truth or some super secret "god". I'm not that arrogant or egotistical unlike some know-it-alls. I prefer to do some research and when "I don't know", I don't lie or misconstrue other people's work to back up their fantasies like most apologists do.

Do you see whats going on? An entire reply based on personal BS. Be aware that's the last time I will indulge that type of reply. Nevertheless thanks for the reply such that it was ~
Oh the irony. Of course you will ignore anyone you disagree with, speaking of BS, have you proven god yet or are you still ignoring the multitude of criticisms of your "proof of god" using a lame "I'm going to be overwhelmed" cop-out?

"Faith"? What a joke. Why must theist keep making crap up under the guise of "science" to back up their fantasies?

Edit:
PS: If you really have the guts, please start a thread on the "Beginning of the Cosmos and Proof of God" and make your claims in the "science and tech section". I look forward to the 4 or 5 physics professors who visit the site in teaching you a thing or two.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom