The certainty of God's existence.

I have already responded to him in prior posts why repeat myself? And I posted the links and sources for my claims but I am sure that you did not read them that fast, so your response is as typical as paximperiums issues which is to say not credible.

; {>

You've responded in prior posts, and missed the point entirely. I didn't read follow all the links you posted, but I did read the excerpts you copied, and even they don't back up what you're claiming. As you've already got it wrong at that point, why should I follow your other links?
 
So a master of theology is explaining a Ph.D in astrophysics the big bang.
LOL!
That amount of hubris is really astonishing!
RevDelusions takes an abstract of wikipedia as the last word on astrophsyics,
yes if someone likes it to get handed his ass on a silverplate!
 
Last edited:
He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy. Wolly knows full well that I am not wrong.
Technically, in the narrowest sense of the term, you aren't wrong.

I said that your assertions weren't supported by the theory that you were using, they are just one possible interpretation of the data, but the data is completely incapable of differentiating between any of the numerous interpretations. Your interpretation fits the data, but so do many others, and no one interpretation is better supported by it than any other interpretation.

Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.
Nope, it only says that this Universe won't bang again.

And the most popular view is not always the correct one.

By the way, using a phrase like "the most popular census (among scientists) is...." is making an argument from authority. Produce the data and the arguments, not the "experts".

eta and certainly not the number of experts who agree with you.

I have no degree in astrophysics but rather have a masters in comparative theology with emphasis on ancient languages, and am attending night school in hopes of getting another piece of paper. Not that I need it, I simply want it to add to my credibility in debate.
Pieces of paper do not give one credibility, arguments and data do. Interesting tack from someone who accused me of arguing from authority, when I have never actually made any statement about my credentials, or quoted "experts".

BTW I am not saying that wolly is a liar but if he really does have even a recent BS with a astronomy (or related) major he knows that my claim is just as credible as his.
And just as credible as a dozen or more other claims. Which is your major problem. You stick to one interpretation, because it supports your conclusion, when there are several other equally likely interpretations, and we will probably never know which one is correct.

Additionally I think that the empirical evidence (observational) is what tips the scales in my favor.
Either you didn't read my last post or you don't understand what empirical evidence means.

The empirical evidence at best says that this Universe may possibly be open, or not, depends, we can't say yet.

It says nothing about whether other universes exist or how many of them there may be or whether this Universe was seeded by another universe, or whether this Universe is seeding other universes. About those things it says not a peep. But you assert that it does.

So while not a bald face liar he is simply choosing anything that would not, or could not have a theistic implication. But that is a lie by omission if that is what he is claiming.
And you are choosing the one interpretation that has a theistic implication, so what does that make you? I'm simply pointing out why you can't make your assertions with any degree of certainty.

The data for the long term fate of the universe is too close to call. Put another way, the geometry of the universe is almost flat.

The Rev states; That is true a lot of the mass and energy once thought to be missing has been found, however there is not enough observed mass to close the universe.
Yet. And I see that, despite quoting most of his page, you missed out these parts;

On the data that seemed to suggest the Universal expansion was accelerating;
One should beware, however, that this data was very difficult to collect, and the final numbers are the result of many corrections, calibrations, and calculations. Attempts to replicate these results with greater accuracy and precision are currently under way.

And from his closing remarks;
Finally, up until about 10 years ago I used to state my hope that the question of whether the universe is open or closed would be experimentally answered in the foreseeable future. This hope is now dimmer.

And from your other links;

www.astronomynotes.com/cosmolgy/s10.htm
WMAP also gave a much improved measurement of the ripples. The distribution of the ripples peaks at the one-degree scale---the universe is flat.

http://www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/

Copyright © 1995
Just a wee tad behind the times, almost 10 years before WMAP results came in.

Oh, and let's not forget, of course, that there may be other forces at play, or at least, the forces we know may not be quite as they seem. Have a look at MOND theory sometime.


But the bottom line is this. You claim that the empirical evidence backs up your assertions. It doesn't, at least, no more than it backs up any of a dozen other assertions that could be made. And the evidence is equivocal at best. Nobody has found enough matter yet, but the data from WMAP shows that the Universe is most likely flat, and there may be other forces to account for. And we may even have got the forces that we do know about wrong.
 
Last edited:
I suspect he would prefer to be called by his given (screen) name of wollery, not wolly. At least where I come from, 'wally' or 'wolly' would be interpreted as an insult.
I don't care what people call me, only what arguments they offer.

Unless what they call me is obviously meant to be insulting.
 
You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.

I am sure you know what these psychological motivations are, but for the sake of readers here, just name only four psychological motivations of people logically certain of God.


As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.



Yrreg

Reasons People Believe in God
1. Fear of Unknown (Mostly Death)
2. Feelings of Helplessness in the face of hard times.
3. Feelings of Purposelessness
4. Tradition (My parents and their parents and so on believed...(You know, people believed back when we thought the Earth was the center of the universe and that it was flat, I SHOULD TOO!))

Reasons we think there is no God.
1. Because Children shouldn't be taught the world is less than 10,000 years old when it OBVIOUSLY isn't...
2. Because Prayer is an excuse for inaction, it's easy to say "I'll pray for you" rather than actually helping with a problem.
3. Because Fundamentalists reject the scientific method and prevent medical and scientific advances in the name of their Sky Faerie and other woo...
4. Because if I see another God crusader scream scripture at my gay friends I'm likely to throttle them...
 
Reasons we think there is no God.
1. Because Children shouldn't be taught the world is less than 10,000 years old when it OBVIOUSLY isn't...
2. Because Prayer is an excuse for inaction, it's easy to say "I'll pray for you" rather than actually helping with a problem.
3. Because Fundamentalists reject the scientific method and prevent medical and scientific advances in the name of their Sky Faerie and other woo...
4. Because if I see another God crusader scream scripture at my gay friends I'm likely to throttle them...

Those are reasons to oppose religion, not reasons to not believe in the existence of a fictional creator character.
 
He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy.

But you've repeatedly relied on argument from authority throughout this thread. You do it in this same post:

the most popular census (among scientists)

(which is actually a combination of argument from authority and argument ad populum), and you've done it throughout the thread in telling us how brilliant and well-respected Craig is.
 
Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.


Please address the issues of why your opinion conflicts with the data from WMAP and how this requires a single Big Bang event. Simply reasserting this opinion isn't enough and 14 year old evidence isn't enough, you need to show the current data that supports it.

NASA WMAP said:
The WMAP spacecraft can measure the basic parameters of the Big Bang theory including the geometry of the universe. If the universe were open, the brightest microwave background fluctuations (or "spots") would be about half a degree across. If the universe were flat, the spots would be about 1 degree across. While if the universe were closed, the brightest spots would be about 1.5 degrees across.

Recent measurements (c. 2001) by a number of ground-based and balloon-based experiments, including MAT/TOCO, Boomerang, Maxima, and DASI, have shown that the brightest spots are about 1 degree across. Thus the universe was known to be flat to within about 15% accuracy prior to the WMAP results. WMAP has confirmed this result with very high accuracy and precision. We now know that the universe is flat with only a 2% margin of error.


Source.
 
He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy.

Except that, as has just been pointed out in a response to one of my posts in another thread, it's not a fallacy if the person really is an authority in the field under discussion.
 
Except that, as has just been pointed out in a response to one of my posts in another thread, it's not a fallacy if the person really is an authority in the field under discussion.

I could still be a fallacy if someone assumes that something said by an expert is true simply because the person is an expert. What still really matters is the evidence or argument presented by said expert. Being a very successful researcher certainly adds weight to one's argument, but even experts can be dead wrong.

If I'd said "Wollery is an expert in astrophysics, therefor whatever he says is correct" then I would be making an appeal to authority. But he has presented a substantive argument based on his experience in his field of expertise. His argument carries more weight because he is specifically trained in the subject of which he speaks.
 
There could be an infinity of open universes fated to dissolve into a fizzle of quarks. Or just this one, or something in between. No way to tell and no evidence that points one way or another. If this universe is open, this universe won't collapse into a singularity which could spawn another universe, but it could have been 'preceded' by one or more closed universes, who knows? No one.
 
He's clearly explained where you're misinterpreting or oversimplifying theories, and you're responding with this?

I over simplified my statements because I do not need differential geometry or complicated smoke and mirrors to explain why the idea of one universe one try is the most popular concept/theory of how our universe began etc. (in scientific and academia circles alike). If you want to believe him (that I am wrong) be my guest, you are only allowing him to delude you. I'm not saying his bluster is wrong just that the one universe one try is the most popular theory and the only one supported by empirical evidence.

; {>
 
You've responded in prior posts, and missed the point entirely. I didn't read follow all the links you posted, but I did read the excerpts you copied, and even they don't back up what you're claiming. As you've already got it wrong at that point, why should I follow your other links?

How exactly/precisely did I miss the point?

; {>
 
I over simplified my statements because I do not need differential geometry or complicated smoke and mirrors to explain why the idea of one universe one try is the most popular concept/theory of how our universe began etc. (in scientific and academia circles alike).
Argument from Popularity
If you want to believe him (that I am wrong) be my guest, you are only allowing him to delude you.
Ad Hominem
I'm not saying his bluster is wrong just that the one universe one try is the most popular theory and the only one supported by empirical evidence.
Argument from popularity followed by False Statement.
 
There could be an infinity of open universes fated to dissolve into a fizzle of quarks. Or just this one, or something in between. No way to tell and no evidence that points one way or another. If this universe is open, this universe won't collapse into a singularity which could spawn another universe, but it could have been 'preceded' by one or more closed universes, who knows? No one.

Good morning Mr. Agenda. Yes there could be other universes, I have said that so many times I am tired of saying it, we are not concerned with that. What the question is (until the question was perverted) are any of these theories are supported by evidence?

Again the one universe one try theory is the most popular theory and the one used in academia and when scientists speak in general terms about the big bang. I am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.

; {>
 
Last edited:
I over simplified my statements because I do not need differential geometry or complicated smoke and mirrors to explain why the idea of one universe one try is the most popular concept/theory of how our universe began etc. (in scientific and academia circles alike). If you want to believe him (that I am wrong) be my guest, you are only allowing him to delude you. I'm not saying his bluster is wrong just that the one universe one try is the most popular theory and the only one supported by empirical evidence.


Please provide a reference for the claim that this universe happened with one try. I have been looking, but have not been able to find where this conclusion is supported by the evidence.
 
Please provide a reference for the claim that this universe happened with one try. I have been looking, but have not been able to find where this conclusion is supported by the evidence.
Yes, I would like to see the "one try" theory and supporting evidence. It is a new one to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom