He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy. Wolly knows full well that I am not wrong.
Technically, in the narrowest sense of the term, you aren't wrong.
I said that your
assertions weren't supported by the theory that you were using, they are just one
possible interpretation of the data, but the data is completely incapable of differentiating between any of the numerous interpretations. Your interpretation
fits the data, but so do many others, and no one interpretation is better supported by it than any other interpretation.
Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.
Nope, it only says that this Universe won't bang again.
And the most popular view is not always the correct one.
By the way, using a phrase like "the most popular census (among scientists) is...." is making an argument from authority. Produce the data and the arguments, not the "experts".
eta and certainly not the number of experts who agree with you.
I have no degree in astrophysics but rather have a masters in comparative theology with emphasis on ancient languages, and am attending night school in hopes of getting another piece of paper. Not that I need it, I simply want it to add to my credibility in debate.
Pieces of paper do not give one credibility, arguments and data do. Interesting tack from someone who accused me of arguing from authority, when I have never actually made any statement about my credentials, or quoted "experts".
BTW I am not saying that wolly is a liar but if he really does have even a recent BS with a astronomy (or related) major he knows that my claim is just as credible as his.
And just as credible as a dozen or more other claims. Which is your major problem. You stick to one interpretation, because it supports your conclusion, when there are several other equally likely interpretations, and we will probably never know which one is correct.
Additionally I think that the empirical evidence (observational) is what tips the scales in my favor.
Either you didn't read my last post or you don't understand what empirical evidence means.
The empirical evidence
at best says that this Universe may possibly be open, or not, depends, we can't say yet.
It says nothing about whether other universes exist or how many of them there may be or whether this Universe was seeded by another universe, or whether this Universe is seeding other universes. About those things it says not a peep. But you assert that it does.
So while not a bald face liar he is simply choosing anything that would not, or could not have a theistic implication. But that is a lie by omission if that is what he is claiming.
And you are choosing the one interpretation that has a theistic implication, so what does that make you? I'm simply pointing out why you can't make your assertions with any degree of certainty.
The data for the long term fate of the universe is too close to call. Put another way, the geometry of the universe is almost flat.
The Rev states; That is true a lot of the mass and energy once thought to be missing has been found, however there is not enough observed mass to close the universe.
Yet. And I see that, despite quoting most of his page, you missed out these parts;
On the data that seemed to suggest the Universal expansion was accelerating;
One should beware, however, that this data was very difficult to collect, and the final numbers are the result of many corrections, calibrations, and calculations. Attempts to replicate these results with greater accuracy and precision are currently under way.
And from his closing remarks;
Finally, up until about 10 years ago I used to state my hope that the question of whether the universe is open or closed would be experimentally answered in the foreseeable future. This hope is now dimmer.
And from your other links;
www.astronomynotes.com/cosmolgy/s10.htm
WMAP also gave a much improved measurement of the ripples. The distribution of the ripples peaks at the one-degree scale---the universe is flat.
http://www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/
Just a wee tad behind the times, almost 10 years before WMAP results came in.
Oh, and let's not forget, of course, that there may be other forces at play, or at least, the forces we know may not be quite as they seem. Have a look at MOND theory sometime.
But the bottom line is this. You claim that the empirical evidence backs up your assertions. It doesn't, at least, no more than it backs up any of a dozen other assertions that could be made. And the evidence is equivocal at best. Nobody has found enough matter yet, but the data from WMAP shows that the Universe is most likely flat, and there may be other forces to account for. And we may even have got the forces that we do know about wrong.