The certainty of God's existence.

Let me say this one more time. Dark energy is theory. We haven't found any and we can't make it ok? That alone is enough to destroy the idea that the universe is closed even with the evidence from Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe. You see scientists are fond of speaking like dark matter actually exists.
That's because there's very good reason to think that it does.

Or are you proposing a different explanation for galactic rotation curves?

excerpt ; As important as dark matter is believed to be in the universe, direct evidence of its existence and a concrete understanding of its nature have remained elusive. Though the theory of dark matter remains the most widely accepted theory to explain the anomalies in observed galactic rotation, some alternative theories such as MOND and TeVeS have been proposed. None of these alternatives, however, have garnered widespread support in the scientific community.
Because none of them explain the discrepancies any where near as well as dark matter does.

You see, the real problem isn't that we can't find the dark matter, the problem is that if it doesn't exist then pretty much all of our physics is wrong, which leaves your argument in the trash bin as well.

Dark Energy & Dark Matter are descriptive book ends for sets of physical phenomena that need to be understood in the context of the MANY models of how our universe works. I don't think any scientist ever said Dark Energy or Dark Matter are facts.
You're right, nobody ever said that, but they are the current best explanation for a whole host of discrepancies between theory and observation, and the explain them extremely well.

I am going to send Wolly a t shirt that says OMEGA =1. The universe isn't closed its not flat its open according to empirical evidence.
You mean like the empirical evidence from WMAP that shows the Universe to be as flat as the proverbial pancake? That empirical evidence?

Of course if the DE and DM could be proven ie produced in an accelerator etc I would change my mind
Since dark matter and dark energy don't interact with baryonic matter in normal ways that may not be possible, but there could be other ways to detect them.

until then I will go with the most popular best supported theory one (open) universe one try.
You still haven't shown us the evidence that supports this one try malarky. As a side note I think it pertinent to point out that since we know that a singularity with very little energy (or none at all) can start a universe, there's a strong case to be made for the idea I put forward in my earlier post having stronger evidence to support it than your one universe one try interpretation.

Anyway, still waiting for your actual evidence.

Oh, by the way, Omega=1 is a flat Universe, not an open one, so even the sites you're quoting are disagreeing with you.
 
Again, why does an open universe imply just one universe or one try?

If there is a cause of the universe then what mechanism is known to make it a one-shot? I have not heard of this theory before.

As far as I know multiverses and "exactly one universe" are currently just pure conjecture.
 
Okay, I'm getting really annoyed by this "One Universe on one try" nonsense, so I'm going to show you why even an open Universe implies no such thing.

According to the BB model that you're applying, the Universe started off as a singularity, then it expanded rapidly. But the space that it expanded into, and the time it takes expanding, are created by itself. We can have no knowledge or interaction with anything "outside" the Universe, and nothing from "outside" can interact or have knowledge of anything "inside" the Universe. In fact, it's likely that nothing "outside" the Universe can even know that this Universe exists.


Seeing as how we are still waiting for references for the "one universe in one try" assertion, I figured I would tackle the other end of the problem.

It seems as if RevDisturba is trying to use the idea of an open (i.e. infinitely expanding) universe to suggest that there cannot be anything "after" this universe, whether it ends in a heat death or a "big rip" is irrelevant to this discussion. In other words, the material (matter and energy) from this universe cannot be recycled into a future universe. Therefore it is reasonable to assume that this universe was not recycled from material from a previous one, and must have been created by something we currently label "god". This also appears to be why RevDisturba argued so hard against virtual particle pairs as being "new" material.

If all of the above is true, does that really close the door on the possibilities of there being other universes, even an infinite number of them? As you stated towards the end of the post I quoted, I don't think it does. Claiming that this universe cannot be the result of of any prior universe is not the same thing as stating this universe cannot be the result of any known physical processes. Just because modern physics has not yet come to a consensus on one physical process to crown The Cause of the Known Universe is no reason to assume there isn't such a process.

We don't know, we may never know, but inventing something to fill the gap isn't necessarily the correct response to this. Again, as you stated in some other post, there is no reason or evidence to hold any one hypothesis as more likely to be true, however, known physical processes are at least plausible based on the evidence we do have.

Choosing the one that best fits P1-3 of KCA seems to me to be begging the question a bit (i.e. the question of which hypothesis is most likely to be true).


ETA: Whoopsie, things have been happening while I went off for a cup of warm milk. I will try and catch up here.
 
Last edited:
Read the rebuttals to that link.

Or..."These observations provide the strongest evidence yet that most of the matter in the universe is dark. Despite considerable evidence for dark matter, some scientists have proposed alternative theories for gravity where it is stronger on intergalactic scales than predicted by Newton and Einstein, removing the need for dark matter. However, such theories cannot explain the observed effects of this collision."

""As we move forward to understand the true nature of dark matter, this new result will be impossible to ignore."

Oh we don't know what it is really just that it exists...hmmmmm

"we've come closer than ever to seeing this invisible matter,"

Oh I thought y the way you were speaking you actually found something tangible, give me back that taxpayer grant money you are living on!

No proof.

; {>

you have a link to a proper rebutal, i googled and only found woo stuff.
 
Choosing the one that best fits P1-3 of KCA is arbitrary seems to me to be begging the question a bit (i.e. the question of which hypothesis is most likely to be true).
I wouldn't have thought it mattered, the argument only specifies a cause, not that the cause was a one-shot.
 
I wouldn't have thought it mattered, the argument only specifies a cause, not that the cause was a one-shot.


I am guessing here, but I think RevDisturba wants it to be a one-shot, or else it reopens the whole can of infinite worms. In other words, if this universe isn't the only try, it is very possible that the eternal creator created an infinite number of universes.

Which is an absurdity, of course. ;)
 
I am guessing here, but I think RevDisturba wants it to be a one-shot, or else it reopens the whole can of infinite worms. In other words, if this universe isn't the only try, it is very possible that the eternal creator created an infinite number of universes.

Which is an absurdity, of course. ;)

Or if this universe isn't the only try, it does rather weaken fine-tuning / cosmological constants type arguments.
 
Those are reasons to oppose religion, not reasons to not believe in the existence of a fictional creator character.

Oh well then...
Because he isn't needed I guess...
If the Universe needs a creator why wouldn't "God"?
That's the laymen answer though...
 
Or if this universe isn't the only try, it does rather weaken fine-tuning / cosmological constants type arguments.
You would think so, wouldn't you.

But I have read a paper on the Discovery Institute website where they are already rehearsing arguments about how a multiverse would be fine-tuned for life.

Just in case, like.
 
Or if this universe isn't the only try, it does rather weaken fine-tuning / cosmological constants type arguments.


Oh I don't know, it might support it. I can just see god talking to himself:


Try 1: Whoa, that wasn't what I expected!
Try 2: Remember now, gravitational constant = 6.6728 x 10-11 m3kg-1s-2. Oops.
Try 3: Hmm, not enough hydrogen. Rats.
Try 4: Dammit, reversed my sign on the calculation for the speed of light. This calculus stuff is hard. I should make humans wait a while before I teach this to Newton.
Try 5: Crap!
Try 6: I think I've got it now.
Try 7: Meh, I'm gonna take a break.
 
Hey Yrreg you can come on back now (unless you were banned forever) and get your thread back I have em' all warmed up for ya'

; }>
 
wolly said:
Oh, by the way, Omega=1 is a flat Universe, not an open one, so even the sites you're quoting are disagreeing with you.

Well you know what I meant. Tell me if the universe is flat what does that mean? It means that it will expand forever just like if its open, the same thing for our discussion now do you get it Mr (***Cof***) PhD man ?

; {>

Let's keep it civil, please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Read the rebuttals to that link.

Or..."These observations provide the strongest evidence yet that most of the matter in the universe is dark. Despite considerable evidence for dark matter, some scientists have proposed alternative theories for gravity where it is stronger on intergalactic scales than predicted by Newton and Einstein, removing the need for dark matter. However, such theories cannot explain the observed effects of this collision."

""As we move forward to understand the true nature of dark matter, this new result will be impossible to ignore."

Oh we don't know what it is really just that it exists...hmmmmm

"we've come closer than ever to seeing this invisible matter,"

Oh I thought y the way you were speaking you actually found something tangible, give me back that taxpayer grant money you are living on!

No proof.

; {>

I take it that you don't believe in black holes either. Like dark matter, we can't directly observe black holes. We have evidence of their existence due to the effect they have on other phenomena that we can directly observe. We can "observe" black holes in the form of X-ray emissions as they consume matter from companion stars. We can observe their gravitational effects on nearby objects, especially at the center of the galaxy. Then there's gravitational lensing.

This case regarding dark matter is similar: we aren't able to directly observe it (although, unlike black holes, it may yet be possible to do so in the future), but we are able to see its effect on observable phenomena.

The more you attempt to defend your collapsed argument, the more you reveal your ignorance of the relevant science, indeed, the very scientific method itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom