The certainty of God's existence.

Good morning Mr. Agenda. Yes there could be other universes, I have said that so many times I am tired of saying it, we are not concerned with that. What the question is (until the question was perverted) are any of these theories are supported by evidence?
Yes, as Wollery has explained.
Again the one universe one try theory is the most popular theory and the one used in academia and when scientists speak in general terms about the big bang. I am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.
Argumentum ad populum again.
 
Except that, as has just been pointed out in a response to one of my posts in another thread, it's not a fallacy if the person really is an authority in the field under discussion.

Ok where is the proof that he is a PhD in Astrophysics? Due to the guidelines of this forum I will only say I do not see any indication (beyond a shadow doubt) that he holds a PhD in Astrophysics.
; {>
 
Doesn't anyone have a real job around here? I was hoping to get some ambush replies in before everyone got home or went on break.

; {>
 
How about answering Hokulele's query about the reference and supporting evidence for the "one try" theory of the universe? I have not heard of it before but if it is the most popular theory used by academia there ought to be a lot of stuff about it.
 
Last edited:
I over simplified my statements because I do not need differential geometry or complicated smoke and mirrors to explain why the idea of one universe one try is the most popular concept/theory of how our universe began etc. (in scientific and academia circles alike). If you want to believe him (that I am wrong) be my guest, you are only allowing him to delude you.
Argument from ignorance, argumentum ad populum, argument from authority, ad hominem, strawman.

I'm not saying his bluster is wrong just that the one universe one try is the most popular theory and the only one supported by empirical evidence.
Wrong, wrong, wrongity wrong. The most popular theory says absolutely nothing about how many universes there are or how many "tries" it took.
 
Ok where is the proof that he is a PhD in Astrophysics? Due to the guidelines of this forum I will only say I do not see any indication (beyond a shadow doubt) that he holds a PhD in Astrophysics.
Where's the proof that you are anything but a badly written Perl script?
 
RevDisturba has made a claim that there is supporting evidence for something outside of our universe, which seems a fairly earth shattering claim to me, I had no idea that we had supporting evidence for anything outside our universe.

I would like to see some references.
 
Ok where is the proof that he is a PhD in Astrophysics? Due to the guidelines of this forum I will only say I do not see any indication (beyond a shadow doubt) that he holds a PhD in Astrophysics.
; {>
Irrelevant.

Address the argument.

What evidence supports the one Universe one try interpretation above all other interpretations?
 
Please address the issues of why your opinion conflicts with the data from WMAP and how this requires a single Big Bang event. Simply reasserting this opinion isn't enough and 14 year old evidence isn't enough, you need to show the current data that supports it.

Let me say this one more time. Dark energy is theory. We haven't found any and we can't make it ok? That alone is enough to destroy the idea that the universe is closed even with the evidence from Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (whos mission wasnt to discover DM or DE). You see scientists are fond of speaking like dark matter actually exists. What we have now is a cottage industry that's grown up around the idea that 'dark junk' really exists and they (even the talking heads at the propaganda dept of NASA) are cranking out computer models and lots of new ideas about 'dark junk', but its not real science.

Tell me, where is the scientific method ? Worst of all there is no proof. We have no proof, it's been more than a decade and 'dark junk' has not even gotten up being a real theory yet, it's still just hopeful speculation and is nothing more than a tenet of faith! Hey maybe I should push it as such being a preacher and all! No I would surely go to hell for being a false prophet.

Dark Energy & Dark Matter are descriptive book ends for sets of physical phenomena that need to be understood in the context of the MANY models of how our universe works. I don't think any scientist ever said Dark Energy or Dark Matter are facts. I am going to send Wolly a t shirt that says OMEGA =1. The universe isn't closed its not flat its open according to empirical evidence. Of course if the DE and DM could be proven ie produced in an accelerator etc I would change my mind ...maybe.. (still the percentages would tell the story) until then I will go with the most popular best supported theory one (open) universe one try.

; {>

excerpt ; As important as dark matter is believed to be in the universe, direct evidence of its existence and a concrete understanding of its nature have remained elusive. Though the theory of dark matter remains the most widely accepted theory to explain the anomalies in observed galactic rotation, some alternative theories such as MOND and TeVeS have been proposed. None of these alternatives, however, have garnered widespread support in the scientific community.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter
 
Last edited:
GI am happy that at least you allow the possibility of this universe being the only one.
Has anyone here disallowed the possibility of this being the only universe? I haven't, I don't recall anybody doing so.
 
...until then I will go with the most popular best supported theory one (open) universe one try.
An open universe does not imply one universe or one try. I am not aware of anybody who says that it does.

If the "one try" theory is the most popular and best supported can you provide some cites - this is the first time I have even heard of "one try" with respect to cosmology.
 
Let me say this one more time. Dark energy is theory. We haven't found any and we can't make it ok? That alone is enough to destroy the idea that the universe is closed even with the evidence from Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (whos mission wasnt to discover DM or DE). You see scientists are fond of speaking like dark matter actually exists. What we have now is a cottage industry that's grown up around the idea that 'dark junk' really exists and they (even the talking heads at the propaganda dept of NASA) are cranking out computer models and lots of new ideas about 'dark junk', but its not real science.

Tell me, where is the scientific method ? Worst of all there is no proof. We have no proof, it's been more than a decade and 'dark junk' has not even gotten up being a real theory yet, it's still just hopeful speculation and is nothing more than a tenet of faith! Hey maybe I should push it as such being a preacher and all! No I would surely go to hell for being a false prophet.

Dark Energy & Dark Matter are descriptive book ends for sets of physical phenomena that need to be understood in the context of the MANY models of how our universe works. I don't think any scientist ever said Dark Energy or Dark Matter are facts. I am going to send Wolly a t shirt that says OMEGA =1. The universe isn't closed its not flat its open according to empirical evidence. Of course if the DE and DM could be proven ie produced in an accelerator etc I would change my mind ...maybe.. (still the percentages would tell the story) until then I will go with the most popular best supported theory one (open) universe one try.

; {>

excerpt ; As important as dark matter is believed to be in the universe, direct evidence of its existence and a concrete understanding of its nature have remained elusive. Though the theory of dark matter remains the most widely accepted theory to explain the anomalies in observed galactic rotation, some alternative theories such as MOND and TeVeS have been proposed. None of these alternatives, however, have garnered widespread support in the scientific community.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter

:confused:

http://www.nasa.gov/home/hqnews/2006/aug/HQ_06297_CHANDRA_Dark_Matter.html
 
Irrelevant.

Address the argument.

What evidence supports the one Universe one try interpretation above all other interpretations?

Its the (the most) popular theory and the reason it's the best theory is that it has the empirical evidence to support it. ie

"Many models for the evolution of the Universe are based on (Omega, I don't have scientific symbols on my key pad) OMEGA =1. There is no proof that this is the case, but alternative models have even larger problems to describe the Universe as we observe it today."

http://www.linnaeus.uu.se/online/phy/macrocosmos/openclosed_universe.html

; {>
 
Last edited:
But you've repeatedly relied on argument from authority throughout this thread. You do it in this same post:

(which is actually a combination of argument from authority and argument ad populum), and you've done it throughout the thread in telling us how brilliant and well-respected Craig is.

My links were from valid sources so Elizabeth helps me by her definition of an argument from authority ;

"Except that, as has just been pointed out in a response to one of my posts in another thread, it's not a fallacy if the person really is an authority in the field under discussion."

Thanks Eliz.

Oh my authorities such as the brilliant Dr Craig really are authorities and are heads of depts etc. I am not saying wolly isn't who says he is I simply have no proof.

; }?>
 
Last edited:

Read the rebuttals to that link.

Or..."These observations provide the strongest evidence yet that most of the matter in the universe is dark. Despite considerable evidence for dark matter, some scientists have proposed alternative theories for gravity where it is stronger on intergalactic scales than predicted by Newton and Einstein, removing the need for dark matter. However, such theories cannot explain the observed effects of this collision."

""As we move forward to understand the true nature of dark matter, this new result will be impossible to ignore."

Oh we don't know what it is really just that it exists...hmmmmm

"we've come closer than ever to seeing this invisible matter,"

Oh I thought y the way you were speaking you actually found something tangible, give me back that taxpayer grant money you are living on!

No proof.

; {>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom