The certainty of God's existence.

ASTR 121, O'CONNELL. Study Guide 2 [Spring 2009]
The universe began about 14 billion years ago in an ultrahot and ultradense state ... to be invented--- these didn't exist in 1500 AD, when science began, either. ... History of Scientific Cosmology (American Institute of Physics) ...
www.astro.virginia.edu/class/oconnell/astr121/guide02.html

The problem is that in the last five to ten years theistic debate from well educated christian apologists has increased exponentially. Only in the last decade have the anti religious apologists seriously began to challenge the wording of how the universe began to exit. It sure is fun to watch but fairly disingenuous in a way too. Anyone that knows the rank basics modern cosmology is aware of the various theories other than what the standard model big bang theory implies. The standard model that is taught from grade middle school up implies that there is only one universe and it occurred with one try, because empirical (observational and otherwise) exists only for this assumption. Its as simple as that.

; {>
 
Exactly. No credible scientist/cosmologist says anything of the sort.

When you do hear that statement, you can almost guarantee it's coming from a creationist, ID proponent, "philosopher", or some other manner of theist.

It's actually handy to hear it right up front, because it's a good barometer of what the rest of the conversation will be like (see this thread for an example).

The above is patently false. No ID or creation orientated or KCA apologist says anything of the sort. Your post is a prime example of the falsehoods that are spread by someone indoctrinated (perhaps unawares by them) into antitheist/religion beliefs.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Anyone that knows the rank basics modern cosmology is aware of the various theories other than what the standard model big bang theory implies.


Right, so then why do you ignore those alternative theories in discussion of the KCA?

The standard model that is taught from grade middle school up implies that there is only one universe and it occurred with one try, because empirical (observational and otherwise) exists only for this assumption. Its as simple as that.


No, it implies no such thing. Please provide a source where the assumption of "it occured with one try" is made.
 
The problem is that in the last five to ten years theistic debate from well educated christian apologists has increased exponentially.
Bolded by me. There's your problem.
Only in the last decade have the anti religious apologists seriously began to challenge the wording of how the universe began to exit.
Yes, because "well educated" apologists have dishonestly attempted to fit their little mini-god into the gaps of human knowledge.
It sure is fun to watch but fairly disingenuous in a way too.
Most definitely.
Anyone that knows the rank basics modern cosmology is aware of the various theories other than what the standard model big bang theory implies. The standard model that is taught from grade middle school up implies that there is only one universe and it occurred with one try, because empirical (observational and otherwise) exists only for this assumption.
So your entire justification for your entire argument rests in your understanding of a simple basic BB cosmology taught in High School. Congrats.
Its as simple as that.
High School level cosmology tends to be.
 
From page 1:

See what we have to put up with?

OK, tell me please what version of the KCA are we now debating???

We are debating the very same one. The extra points made were expanding on P-1-2-3. That's why after some comment I said that I would rather defend my interpretation of the third premise rather than speak for Craig, partly due to the fact that Craigs theories diverge from mine. The original reason I commented was that some members were obviously wrong in their critique of the expanded version of the KCA via Dr Craig.

; {>
 
Sorry to not be more help, Rev, cosmology is not my forte' I'm afraid. I don't understand the math at all. It seems perfectly reasonable to me though, that the beginning of the universe could have been a change in form in something already there, so it couldn't really be said to begin to exist when it came from something that already existed. I've heard that words like 'already' don't apply to the beginning of time though, so in the end it winds up being beyond my comprehension.
 
Last night I went to grab a little reading material for some "library time" prior to turning in. I almost grabbed my Stewart-MacDonald catalog, but having just composed my last post I was inspired to get my copy of A Brief History of Time from my shelves. Thumbing through it I came upon Carl Sagan's introduction. The last part seemed to me to be particularly apropos for this discussion.

"This is also a book about God... or perhaps about the absence of God. The word God fills these pages. Hawking embarks on a quest to answer Einstein's famous question about whether God had any choice in creating the universe. Hawking is attempting, as he explicitly states, to understand the mind of God. And this makes all the more unexpected the conclusion of the effort, at least so far: a universe with no edge in space, no beginning or end in time, and nothing for a Creator to do."
 
Right, so then why do you ignore those alternative theories in discussion of the KCA?

I don't ignore them, I know they exist and find some of them interesting. However I think we should choose the version of the BB that have empirical evidence. If you are speaking of alternative theories such as the expanded version of the KCA as per Craig (ie other than the first three premises) the reason is that I do not agree with them, and for my part I am trying to keep the discussion as simple as possible.

No, it implies no such thing. Please provide a source where the assumption of "it occured with one try" is made.

I already have explained why the universe is open to the disdain of wolly. However I do agree with wolly that if dark energy pans out that that could make up the vast amount of missing mass and close the universe, the gravitational effect providing the mechanism (to close the now open universe) .

I (and nearly all of science and academia) use the standard model that implies that this is the only universe because according to the empirical evidence that there is not enough mass to 'close' the universe (meaning that its open and will expand forever). If it were closed that would provide a mechanism to make this current universe only one in an infinite series of universes.

http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/~rkirshner/whowhatwhen/NYTJan98.pdf

; {>
 
Last edited:
Sorry to not be more help, Rev, cosmology is not my forte' I'm afraid. I don't understand the math at all. It seems perfectly reasonable to me though, that the beginning of the universe could have been a change in form in something already there, so it couldn't really be said to begin to exist when it came from something that already existed. I've heard that words like 'already' don't apply to the beginning of time though, so in the end it winds up being beyond my comprehension.

Well you are correct of course. Basic cosmology gives us all sorts of theoretical constructs to provide alternative methods for universe creation. And there are even modified Big Bang models that allow for more than one universe. The reason I choose the standard one universe model of the BB is that its the only one with empirical evidence to support it. But anything is possible I suppose.

; {>: <---- new lower lip piercing
 
Bolded by me. There's your problem.

How is it my problem?

Yes, because "well educated" apologists have dishonestly attempted to fit their little mini-god into the gaps of human knowledge.

That's what your handlers would have you believe.

Most definitely.

So your entire justification for your entire argument rests in your understanding of a simple basic BB cosmology taught in High School. Congrats.

Yes actually I could make a case for the KCA just using what I learned in middle school, or even K4. Its simple common sense. That's why its difficult to explain it to some people that arent here to learn or debate the issues. Only a rank miorinty fits that profile.

I use very little to no college lever concepts to explain the KCA.

High School level cosmology tends to be.

Look around many don't know even middle school cosmology/astronomy. BTW, If your comments remain on a personal nature I will ignore them. I really should not of answered this reply but I am making an exception this time.

; {>
 
Last edited:
I don't ignore them, I know they exist and find some of them interesting. However I think we should choose the version of the BB that have empirical evidence. If you are speaking of alternative theories such as the expanded version of the KCA as per Craig (ie other than the first three premises) the reason is that I do not agree with them, and for my part I am trying to keep the discussion as simple as possible.


The main problem is that the version of the Big Bang theory you are using is not supported by the observed evidence. Much of what you are arguing has been supplanted by an inflationary version of the Big Bang.

I already have explained why the universe is open to the disdain of wolly. However I do agree with wolly that if dark energy pans out that that could make up the vast amount of missing mass and close the universe, the gravitational effect providing the mechanism (to close the now open universe).


And as wollery and I have pointed out, the evidence does not point to an open universe. Have you heard of the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP)?

http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/news/

NASA WMAP Mission said:
A third major finding arising from the new WMAP data places tight constraints on the astonishing burst of growth in the first trillionth of a second of the universe, called “inflation”, when ripples in the very fabric of space may have been created. Some versions of the inflation theory now are eliminated. Others have picked up new support.

"The new WMAP data rule out many mainstream ideas that seek to describe the growth burst in the early universe," said WMAP principal investigator, Charles Bennett, of The Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Md. "It is astonishing that bold predictions of events in the first moments of the universe now can be confronted with solid measurements."


In fact, this data supports the notion that the universe is not open, but flat.

http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/uni_shape.html

NASA WMAP - Shape of the Universe said:
The WMAP spacecraft can measure the basic parameters of the Big Bang theory including the geometry of the universe. If the universe were open, the brightest microwave background fluctuations (or "spots") would be about half a degree across. If the universe were flat, the spots would be about 1 degree across. While if the universe were closed, the brightest spots would be about 1.5 degrees across.

Recent measurements (c. 2001) by a number of ground-based and balloon-based experiments, including MAT/TOCO, Boomerang, Maxima, and DASI, have shown that the brightest spots are about 1 degree across. Thus the universe was known to be flat to within about 15% accuracy prior to the WMAP results. WMAP has confirmed this result with very high accuracy and precision. We now know that the universe is flat with only a 2% margin of error.


This is why Big Bang cosmology has been updated to include the inflationary period over the last 15 years or so.

I (and nearly all of science and academia) use the standard model that implies that this is the only universe because according to the empirical evidence that there is not enough mass to 'close' the universe (meaning that its open and will expand forever). If it were closed that would provide a mechanism to make this current universe only one in an infinite series of universes.


And once again, what the standard model suggests regarding the future of this universe has nothing to do with any total number of possible universes, nor with the number of "tries" it may have taken. Please provide a reference to the "only one try" assertion.
 
ASTR 121, O'CONNELL. Study Guide 2 [Spring 2009]
The universe began about 14 billion years ago in an ultrahot and ultradense state ... to be invented--- these didn't exist in 1500 AD, when science began, either. ... History of Scientific Cosmology (American Institute of Physics) ...
www.astro.virginia.edu/class/oconnell/astr121/guide02.html
What is your point?

The problem is that in the last five to ten years theistic debate from well educated christian apologists has increased exponentially.
Argumentum ad populum.

Only in the last decade have the anti religious apologists seriously began to challenge the wording of how the universe began to exit.
Challenge the wording. Terrific. Let me know when you want to challenge the facts.

It sure is fun to watch but fairly disingenuous in a way too.
Fun, no. Disingenuous, certainly.

Anyone that knows the rank basics modern cosmology is aware of the various theories other than what the standard model big bang theory implies.
Yes.

The standard model that is taught from grade middle school up implies that there is only one universe and it occurred with one try, because empirical (observational and otherwise) exists only for this assumption.
It doesn't imply this at all. It is true that we can only have empirical evidence of one Universe - our own - by definition. We cannot know what caused it, how many tries it took, or how many other universes there may be.

This means that you can't assume it as a premise and use it as the basis for an argument for the existence of God.

Its as simple as that.
It is, indeed, that simple.
 
Last edited:
The above is patently false. No ID or creation orientated or KCA apologist says anything of the sort. Your post is a prime example of the falsehoods that are spread by someone indoctrinated (perhaps unawares by them) into antitheist/religion beliefs.
Remarkable. Absolutely remarkable.

RevD, your own argument says precisely this. You have specifically defined it this way.

Go back three spaces and miss a turn.
 
I already have explained why the universe is open to the disdain of wolly.
Wrong.

Go back and read those posts again. And keep reading them until you understand why you are wrong.

However I do agree with wolly that if dark energy pans out that that could make up the vast amount of missing mass and close the universe, the gravitational effect providing the mechanism (to close the now open universe).
That was not the point. Go back and re-read those posts. You still don't understand.

I (and nearly all of science and academia) use the standard model that implies that this is the only universe because according to the empirical evidence that there is not enough mass to 'close' the universe (meaning that its open and will expand forever).
Non-sequitur.

If it were closed that would provide a mechanism to make this current universe only one in an infinite series of universes.
True. If it were closed, that would be another reason why you were wrong, but even if it's open, you're still wrong.
 
How is it my problem?
It is your problem because you rely on biased sources. An apologists has a preconceived agenda. Instead of reading neutral science sources you rely on a biased spin on someone else's work.
That's what your handlers would have you believe.
Who might these handler's be? Oh yeah what did someone say:
BTW, If your comments remain on a personal nature I will ignore them. I really should not of answered this reply but I am making an exception this time.
Yes actually I could make a case for the KCA just using what I learned in middle school, or even K4. Its simple common sense. That's why its difficult to explain it to some people that arent here to learn or debate the issues. Only a rank miorinty fits that profile.
Which in no way makes KCA true, just easy.
BTW: "Common sense"(ie. Heuristics) is one of the least useful decision making tools out there since it is prone to significant errors. It is good for snap decisions. You may want to use logic, reason and evidence instead.
I use very little to no college lever concepts to explain the KCA.
Yes. So?
I could explain atoms using billiard balls but than in no way even comes close to what an atom really is and this analogy breaks down once you go into the real details. Your entire KCA collapses once you get into the details.
Look around many don't know even middle school cosmology/astronomy.
Yes. If there were, they'd be less attempts to use an argument like the KCA.
BTW, If your comments remain on a personal nature I will ignore them. I really should not of answered this reply but I am making an exception this time.
Please keep your threats to yourself. You seem to believe that people care.
 
That's what your handlers would have you believe.
That is egregiously dishonest, RevD. It's an insult to everyone present, including you.

Yes actually I could make a case for the KCA just using what I learned in middle school, or even K4. Its simple common sense.
Common sense, maybe. But wrong.

That's why its difficult to explain it to some people that arent here to learn or debate the issues.
We understand it just fine. It's wrong.

I use very little to no college lever concepts to explain the KCA.
Well, maybe that's something you should try, because you're not getting anywhere like this.

Look around many don't know even middle school cosmology/astronomy.
Wrong.

If your comments remain on a personal nature I will ignore them.
RevD, you frequently insult everyone in this thread and most of the posters in this forum, and then complain about imagined slights in return. This is, as I said, dishonest. Mote, beam, as it were.

I really should not of answered this reply but I am making an exception this time.
I know this is beside the point, but please: Should not HAVE.
 
Yes actually I could make a case for the KCA just using what I learned in middle school, or even K4. Its simple common sense. That's why its difficult to explain it to some people that arent here to learn or debate the issues. Only a rank miorinty fits that profile.
It was simple common sense that the sun revolved around the Earth. It was simple common sense that the Earth was flat. It was simple common sense that complexity could not develop from the bottom up by natural means. It was simple common sense that time was a universal constant. It was simple common sense that the surface of the Earth was fixed. And, to you, it is simple common sense that the universe came from nothing.

I use very little to no college lever concepts to explain the KCA.
Could you?

Look around many don't know even middle school cosmology/astronomy.
And yet the guy with a Ph.D. in astrophysics says that you are completely wrong.
 
Originally Posted by RevDisturba
The above is patently false. No ID or creation orientated or KCA apologist says anything of the sort. Your post is a prime example of the falsehoods that are spread by someone indoctrinated (perhaps unawares by them) into antitheist/religion beliefs.

Remarkable. Absolutely remarkable.

RevD, your own argument says precisely this. You have specifically defined it this way.

Go back three spaces and miss a turn.

We do love our irony around here.
;)
 
We are debating the very same one. The extra points made were expanding on P-1-2-3. That's why after some comment I said that I would rather defend my interpretation of the third premise rather than speak for Craig, partly due to the fact that Craigs theories diverge from mine. The original reason I commented was that some members were obviously wrong in their critique of the expanded version of the KCA via Dr Craig.

; {>
Ok, so you said:
That quote was from the first premise of KCA no wonder you did not recognize it.

1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.
and your original argument said:
Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
So can you clarify - are you sticking with "has a beginning" rather than "begins to exist"?

But I have already pointed out the ambiguity here. "Has a beginning" might refer to the beginning of a series of events - ie an event with no predecessor. Or it might refer to "begins to exist".

If you mean "begins to exist" then why not simply make that explicit?
 
It was simple common sense that the sun revolved around the Earth. It was simple common sense that the Earth was flat. It was simple common sense that complexity could not develop from the bottom up by natural means. It was simple common sense that time was a universal constant. It was simple common sense that the surface of the Earth was fixed. And, to you, it is simple common sense that the universe came from nothing.


Could you?


And yet the guy with a Ph.D. in astrophysics says that you are completely wrong.

What are your qualifications Rev?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom