The certainty of God's existence.

No, it implies no such thing. Please provide a source where the assumption of "it occured with one try" is made.
Yes, I would like to see that too. You would think if there was evidence for this then the ID crowd would be shouting it from the rooftops.
 
Remarkable. Absolutely remarkable.

RevD, your own argument says precisely this. You have specifically defined it this way.

Go back three spaces and miss a turn.

It's weird to see how these debates take odd turns, with each side accusing the other of strange things.

I don't think RevD's argument says precisely this. RevD's argument says:


RevD said:
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

"This" in the sentence above refers to "the universe began from nothing". RevD does not believe that statement. i.e. he does not believe that the universe began from nothing. He believes that the universe began from God.

The reason it came up in the first place, though, is that RevD had attributed that belief to modern cosmologists and the big bang theory.




revD said:
Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.


Hokulele said:
No, Big Bang cosmology states nothing about whether or not the universe "began", it simply describes the limit described by that model.
My head hurts from banging it on the table. That's so wrong.

In this case, Hokulele is absolutely correct. The Big Bang theory does not say that the universe came from nothing. It says that the universe was once very, very, small, and is now much larger. That's all it says.

On the other hand, HghrSymmetry says, in reference to "the universe came from nothing,
Exactly. No credible scientist/cosmologist says anything of the sort.

Now, that's not precisely true either. I've seen that statement many times. However, it's not exactly a statement of "this happened". When I've seen credible cosmologists say it, it has been more of the form "it might have come from nothing".

Science cannot say, and may never be able to say, what happened "before" the big bang, or even if there was a "before". No credible scientist would claim to be able to do so. However, they are perfectly willing to speculate that the universe was indeed born suddenly out of nothing. Indeed, no credible scientist would say, "the universe came from nothing", but neither would any credible scientist say, "the universe did not come from nothing". At least, no credible scientist would say either of those things as a scientific assertion. Science simply cannot say anything about where the universe came from. Something? Nothing? We don't know.

So, RevD does not claim that the universe came from nothing. Meanwhile, scientists also do not make that claim. On the other hand, RevD asserts that the universe could not have come from nothing, while scientists claim that it may have come from nothing, or it may have always existed.
 
We are debating the very same one.

Great. So, if I substitute "God" for every occurrence of "the universe", is the argument still valid? If not, why not?


...
The original reason I commented was that some members were obviously wrong in their critique of the expanded version of the KCA via Dr Craig.

That continues to be a misrepresentation of the fact. You injected the alternate premise because you misunderstood a response to something you posted.
 
In this case, Hokulele is absolutely correct. The Big Bang theory does not say that the universe came from nothing. It says that the universe was once very, very, small, and is now much larger. That's all it says.
OK, this might be what RevDisturba is referring to, a quote from William Lane Craig:
William Lane Craig said:
That initial explosion has come to be known as the "Big Bang." Four of the world's most prominent astronomers described that event in these words:


The universe began from a state of infinite density. . . . Space and time were created in that event and so was all the matter in the universe. It is not meaningful to ask what happened before the Big Bang; it is like asking what is north of the North Pole. Similarly, it is not sensible to ask where the Big Bang took place. The point-universe was not an object isolated in space; it was the entire universe, and so the answer can only be that the Big Bang happened everywhere.​
This event that marked the beginning of the universe becomes all the more amazing when one reflects on the fact that a state of "infinite density" is synonymous to "nothing." There can be no object that possesses infinite density, for if it had any size at all it could still be even more dense. Therefore, as Cambridge astronomer Fred Hoyle points out, the Big Bang Theory requires the creation of matter from nothing. This is because as one goes back in time, one reaches a point at which, in Hoyle's words, the universe was "shrunk down to nothing at all."[21] Thus, what the Big Bang model of the universe seems to require is that the universe began to exist and was created out of nothing.
 
Last edited:
OK, this might be what RevDisturba is referring to, a quote from William Lane Craig:


Those assumptions are based on General Relativity (which breaks down before t=0), rather than on Big Bang cosmology. This is essentially the issue astrophysicists had with the original Big Bang concept (hence the pejorative term "Big Bang"). It is odd that Craig is basing his assumptions on Sir Fred Hoyle, as Hoyle's arguments presented in the quote you provided were advanced specifically to rebut Big Bang cosmology. He thought those assumptions were absurd, so the Big Bang could not possibly be correct.

So yes, if modern cosmology was based solely on GR, those assumptions would be true and the KCA could then go on to fail at P5 or P6, rather than by P3.

However, since that isn't the case, P1-3 (as currently described by RevDisturba) are still unfounded assumptions.
 
Notice the definition of God that is being built up here:

Finite
Static
Only capable of producing one Universe

Try preaching that on Sunday.
 
ASTR 121, O'CONNELL. Study Guide 2 [Spring 2009]
The universe began about 14 billion years ago in an ultrahot and ultradense state ... to be invented--- these didn't exist in 1500 AD, when science began, either. ... History of Scientific Cosmology (American Institute of Physics) ...
www.astro.virginia.edu/class/oconnell/astr121/guide02.html

The problem is that in the last five to ten years theistic debate from well educated christian apologists has increased exponentially. Only in the last decade have the anti religious apologists seriously began to challenge the wording of how the universe began to exit. It sure is fun to watch but fairly disingenuous in a way too. Anyone that knows the rank basics modern cosmology is aware of the various theories other than what the standard model big bang theory implies. The standard model that is taught from grade middle school up implies that there is only one universe and it occurred with one try, because empirical (observational and otherwise) exists only for this assumption. Its as simple as that.

; {>
Okay, I'm getting really annoyed by this "One Universe on one try" nonsense, so I'm going to show you why even an open Universe implies no such thing.

According to the BB model that you're applying, the Universe started off as a singularity, then it expanded rapidly. But the space that it expanded into, and the time it takes expanding, are created by itself. We can have no knowledge or interaction with anything "outside" the Universe, and nothing from "outside" can interact or have knowledge of anything "inside" the Universe. In fact, it's likely that nothing "outside" the Universe can even know that this Universe exists.

Another interesting point to ponder is that the total sum energy of the Universe is zero, or so close to zero that it makes no difference.

http://www.curtismenning.com/ZeroEnergyCalc.htm

http://news.softpedia.com/news/Zero-Energy-and-the-Flat-Universe-98861.shtml

http://www.astrosociety.org/pubs/mercury/31_02/nothing.html

So, we have a Universe that starts as a singularity, cannot even be perceived from outside, and requires little or no energy to get started.

But we're surrounded by singularities. This Universe contains billions of them, each of which has enough energy to be the seed of a new universe. But since we cannot know about other Universes from outside them we'll never know if these singularities are forming new universes or not. They could all be universes, or maybe none of them are. But the possibility is there. And our Universe could have come from just such a singularity in another universe.

So, no big crunch no new universe?

Cobblers!

One Universe on one try?

Cobblers!

And, as I've pointed out before, the end state of this Universe says absolutely nothing abut its origin.

Your assertions are not supported by the theory you are claiming to base them on.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm getting really annoyed by this "One Universe on one try" nonsense, so I'm going to show you why even an open Universe implies no such thing.
I hoped somebody was about to mention that, the point occurred to me also but I don't have the physics to back it up.
 
What are your qualifications Rev?

He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy. Wolly knows full well that I am not wrong. Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.

I have no degree in astrophysics but rather have a masters in comparative theology with emphasis on ancient languages, and am attending night school in hopes of getting another piece of paper. Not that I need it, I simply want it to add to my credibility in debate.

; {>

BTW I am not saying that wolly is a liar but if he really does have even a recent BS with a astronomy (or related) major he knows that my claim is just as credible as his. Additionally I think that the empirical evidence (observational) is what tips the scales in my favor. So while not a bald face liar he is simply choosing anything that would not, or could not have a theistic implication. But that is a lie by omission if that is what he is claiming.

http://www.upscale.utoronto.ca/GeneralInterest/Harrison/GenRel/BigBangModel.html

Some excerpts ;

You may recall that in 1915 when Einstein was finishing the development of the General Theory of Relativity, the theory's prediction of an expanding universe was in conflict with firm philosophical beliefs of the day. Thus Einstein introduced a fudge factor, the cosmological constant, to force the universe to be static. When in 1929 Hubble showed that the universe really was expanding Einstein immediately dropped the cosmological constant, calling it "the biggest mistake of my life."

The Standard Hot Big Bang Model
There was a big bang some 15 billion years ago, when the size of the universe was zero and the temperature was infinite. The universe then started expanding at near light speed.

A crucial question was whether this decrease in the rate of expansion is sufficiently great that at some point the expansion would stop and reverse.

If yes, then at some point in the future the size of the universe will again be zero with infinite density and temperature, the Big Crunch. We call such a universe closed. In this case the geometry of the spacetime is similar to the surface of a sphere.

If no, the universe will expand forever. We call such a universe open. In this case the geometry is similar to the surface of a saddle.

The data for the long term fate of the universe is too close to call. Put another way, the geometry of the universe is almost flat.

The Rev states; That is true a lot of the mass and energy once thought to be missing has been found, however there is not enough observed mass to close the universe.

A variation of Big Bang cosmology is called the Bang-Bang-Bang one. If the universe is closed it will end in a Big Crunch. But the conditions of the Big Crunch are identical to the conditions of the Big Bang. Thus the end of this cycle of the universe is the beginning of the next.


Again we have the problem with the missing mass/energy***

*** Cosmology
Jun 2, 2007 ... Again, you get 5 to 15 times too little mass to close the universe. However, these measurements do not take into account all of the dark ...
www.astronomynotes.com/cosmolgy/s10.htm -

Cosmic Hide and Seek: The Search for the Missing Mass
... their existence had been predicted by theory long before there was any proof. .... And the flat universe has exactly enough mass to gravitationally stop the ... The time has surely come to open doors, not to seek to close them by ... "Astronomy Crisis Deepens As the Hubble Telescope Finds No Missing Mass. ...
www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/
 
Last edited:
He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy. Wolly knows full well that I am not wrong. Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.
Except for all the reasons that he has clearly said why you are wrong, yeah right.
I have no degree in astrophysics but rather have a masters in comparative theology with emphasis on ancient languages, and am attending night school in hopes of getting another piece of paper. Not that I need it, I simply want it to add to my credibility in debate.
What credibility? Your degree is about as relevant as an English Lit major.
 
Last edited:
He may have a PhD in (whatever) but I think he has employed the old smoke and mirrors game along with the argument from authority fallacy. Wolly knows full well that I am not wrong. Of course as I have said many times there are many competing ideas concerning the origins of the universe, however the most popular census (among scientists) is that the universe is open so applying the 'standard big bang hot model' the most popular view is that the universe has only banged once.

He's clearly explained where you're misinterpreting or oversimplifying theories, and you're responding with this?

Now, I'm not saying you're a liar, you just seem a long way out of your depth on this issue. I can understand why you want to hang on to this point, because it's a large part of your backing for the KCA. But you really can't justify it.
 
excerpt.....
Except for all the reasons that he has clearly said why you are wrong, yeah right.

He hasn't clearly said anything. Of course you would accept an atheist apologist over an theist no matter if he said the sky was falling. Typical.

; {>
 
He's clearly explained where you're misinterpreting or oversimplifying theories, and you're responding with this?

Now, I'm not saying you're a liar, you just seem a long way out of your depth on this issue. I can understand why you want to hang on to this point, because it's a large part of your backing for the KCA. But you really can't justify it.

I have already responded to him in prior posts why repeat myself? And I posted the links and sources for my claims but I am sure that you did not read them that fast, so your response is as typical as paximperiums issues which is to say not credible.

; {>
 
Last edited:
excerpt.....

He hasn't clearly said anything. Of course you would accept an atheist apologist no matter if he said the sky was falling. Typical.

; {>
Thanks for not actually saying anything at all. Ad hominem galore from the hypocrite. What did someone say again?
BTW, If your comments remain on a personal nature I will ignore them. I really should not of answered this reply but I am making an exception this time.
So are you going to refute his reasons or are you going to keep using your magic hand waving powers?
 
I have already responded to him in prior posts why repeat myself? And I posted the links and sources for my claims but I am sure that you did not read them that fast, so your response is as typical as paximperiums issues.

; {>
Responding =/= Refuting
 
Ignoring 1357 & 1358. If you cant stay on topic I will have no other choice than to use the ignore function.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom