Remarkable. Absolutely remarkable.
RevD, your own argument says precisely this. You have specifically defined it this way.
Go back three spaces and miss a turn.
It's weird to see how these debates take odd turns, with each side accusing the other of strange things.
I don't think RevD's argument says
precisely this. RevD's argument says:
RevD said:
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
"This" in the sentence above refers to "the universe began from nothing". RevD does not believe that statement. i.e. he does not believe that the universe began from nothing. He believes that the universe began from God.
The reason it came up in the first place, though, is that RevD had attributed that belief to modern cosmologists and the big bang theory.
revD said:
Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.
Hokulele said:
No, Big Bang cosmology states nothing about whether or not the universe "began", it simply describes the limit described by that model.
My head hurts from banging it on the table. That's so wrong.
In this case, Hokulele is absolutely correct. The Big Bang theory does not say that the universe came from nothing. It says that the universe was once very, very, small, and is now much larger. That's all it says.
On the other hand, HghrSymmetry says, in reference to "the universe came from nothing,
Exactly. No credible scientist/cosmologist says anything of the sort.
Now, that's not precisely true either. I've seen that statement many times. However, it's not exactly a statement of "this happened". When I've seen credible cosmologists say it, it has been more of the form "it might have come from nothing".
Science cannot say, and may never be able to say, what happened "before" the big bang, or even if there was a "before". No credible scientist would claim to be able to do so. However, they are perfectly willing to speculate that the universe was indeed born suddenly out of nothing. Indeed, no credible scientist would say, "the universe came from nothing", but neither would any credible scientist say, "the universe did not come from nothing". At least, no credible scientist would say either of those things as a scientific assertion. Science simply cannot say anything about where the universe came from. Something? Nothing? We don't know.
So, RevD does not claim that the universe came from nothing. Meanwhile, scientists also do not make that claim. On the other hand, RevD asserts that the universe could not have come from nothing, while scientists claim that it may have come from nothing, or it may have always existed.