The certainty of God's existence.

That quote was from the first premise of KCA no wonder you did not recognize it.

1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.

See what I have to put up with? You did not know that was the first premise of the KCA...
From page 1:
RevDisturba said:
Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
See what we have to put up with?

OK, tell me please what version of the KCA are we now debating???
 
Are you for real? For the third time. We agreed that we could see both throughout the ordeal. One thing that I wonder about is that I know any person remotely knowledgeable about this knows that I am correct. But where are they? Its like lies by omission, except its ethics instead of lies. Par for the course.\

"Near a black hole, the slowing of time is extreme. From the viewpoint of an observer outside the black hole, time stops. For example, an object falling into the hole would appear frozen in time at the edge of the hole."

http://chandra.harvard.edu/BlackHoleExhibit/BH_Pages/primer/BH_whatare.php

; {>
That's both a very simplistic explanation and also doesn't address the actual observability of the event in question.

Ask yourself what happens to the light emitted by an object as its clock rate slows.

What happens is that the observed time interval between successive peaks of the EM wave are longer, resulting in a longer observed wavelength, i.e. a redshift. As the time slows down further the redshift increases, first beyond the visible spectrum, then beyond the infra-red, submillimetre, and radio spectrum, until, as the observed time rate slows almost to a stop the emitted light is almost infinitely redshifted, and the object becomes impossible to observe.

Whilst you could never observe an object actually fall into the event horizon of a black hole it would become invisible as it approached it.
 
ps

That quote was from the first premise of KCA no wonder you did not recognize it.

1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.

See what I have to put up with? You did not know that was the first premise of the KCA...

Now you are just making stuff up. I responded to specific statements you made in the post I quoted. Now, you reproduce just my response, stripped of the context from your post, and claim it to be something it wasn't.

You can do better.
 
That's both a very simplistic explanation and also doesn't address the actual observability of the event in question.

Ask yourself what happens to the light emitted by an object as its clock rate slows.

What happens is that the observed time interval between successive peaks of the EM wave are longer, resulting in a longer observed wavelength, i.e. a redshift. As the time slows down further the redshift increases, first beyond the visible spectrum, then beyond the infra-red, submillimetre, and radio spectrum, until, as the observed time rate slows almost to a stop the emitted light is almost infinitely redshifted, and the object becomes impossible to observe.

Whilst you could never observe an object actually fall into the event horizon of a black hole it would become invisible as it approached it.

It was simplistic for a reason we wanted it simple....Wolly,wolly, wolly Pixi and I agreed that it was like a thought experiment not an actual trip. So as a thought experiment If you were on earth and could see me (despite the fact that you really couldn't) head for the black hole you would see me slowing down and stopping at the event horizon. Its that simple.

; {>

Approaching the horizon, you would notice nothing special, but someone observing you from the outside would see you freeze in place and become a lot dimmer because light that you emit at the boundary takes a long time to get out, Hamilton said.

Many people think you would be engulfed in darkness when you fall in, but that is a common misconception, Hamilton points out. The view of the outside universe would become distorted, but would not disappear.

Once you pass the horizon -- or go over Niagara Falls, in the waterfall analogy -- you would be falling faster than the speed of light toward the black hole's center -- called a singularity -- and feeling the effects, Hamilton said.

http://edition.cnn.com/2009/TECH/space/04/27/falling.into.black.hole/index.html

Black hole - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia The black hole has a one-way surface, called an event horizon, ..... see an object falling into a black hole slow down as it approaches the event horizon, .... the black hole will spin more slowly and may even stop spinning eventually. ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole -
 
Last edited:
That quote was from the first premise of KCA no wonder you did not recognize it.

1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.

See what I have to put up with? You did not know that was the first premise of the KCA...
From page 1:
RevDisturba said:
Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
See what we have to put up with?

OK, tell me please what version of the KCA are we now debating???


Can we expect a response / clarification anytime soon?
 
Are you for real?
No, I'm complex. (Blank looks.) Never mind.

For the third time. We agreed that we could see both throughout the ordeal.
What we see, then, is the subject becoming infinitely red-shifted. In reality, this means they vanish.

One thing that I wonder about is that I know any person remotely knowledgeable about this knows that I am correct.
Bare assertion.

But where are they?
Here disagreeing with you.

Its like lies by omission, except its ethics instead of lies. Par for the course.
Something like that, yeah.

"Near a black hole, the slowing of time is extreme. From the viewpoint of an observer outside the black hole, time stops. For example, an object falling into the hole would appear frozen in time at the edge of the hole."

http://chandra.harvard.edu/BlackHoleExhibit/BH_Pages/primer/BH_whatare.php
Yes. Which is why the object disappears from view. Time has stopped for the object relative to the observer, so no information from the object can reach the observer. It's gone just as much as if it had crossed the event horizon; it's just that the precise details of what you observe as it approaches the event horizon are different.
 
It was simplistic for a reason we wanted it simple....Wolly,wolly, wolly Pixi and I agreed that it was like a thought experiment not an actual trip. So as a thought experiment If you were on earth and could see me (despite the fact that you really couldn't) head for the black hole you would see me slowing down and stopping at the event horizon. Its that simple.
Except that this is not what we'd observe. We'd see you slowing down and disappearing into asymptotic red-shift.

Approaching the horizon, you would notice nothing special, but someone observing you from the outside would see you freeze in place and become a lot dimmer because light that you emit at the boundary takes a long time to get out, Hamilton said.
Yurrrgh. No. The light still travels at the speed of light. It takes exactly as long to get out as before. It's just lower energy - not dimmer, which is the number of photons, but red-shifted.

Many people think you would be engulfed in darkness when you fall in, but that is a common misconception, Hamilton points out. The view of the outside universe would become distorted, but would not disappear.
That seems correct. Light still comes in, it just can't get out.

Except that you never experience yourself crossing the event horizon. It recedes in front of you until you smack into the singularity.

Once you pass the horizon -- or go over Niagara Falls, in the waterfall analogy -- you would be falling faster than the speed of light toward the black hole's center -- called a singularity -- and feeling the effects, Hamilton said.
Um, no, that's wrong too. You can certainly cross the event horizon as measured by a stationary observer while travelling slower than the speed of light.

Yeah, unfortunately they go wrong when they're not quoting Hamilton directly.

Black hole - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia The black hole has a one-way surface, called an event horizon, ..... see an object falling into a black hole slow down as it approaches the event horizon, .... the black hole will spin more slowly and may even stop spinning eventually. ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole -
That, and the Wikipedia article on event horizons, are much better on the specific details. Do read them.
 
Last edited:
Well well I see the kind Buddhist is showing a bit of his true nature. You fooled me which is remarkable. You must be swilling that juice to excess if you think I would take the your advice. I had reached enlightenment before you were born my fake friend.

I am simply offering you a window to the path to true enlightenment. This thread is called "The certainty of God's existence." The teachings of Nichiren Buddhism address the fallacy of a god deity worship and expound the nature of the truth about the Mystic Law. These are teachings originating in the most divine and wise Shakyamuni Bhudda. Thus they are perfectly topical for this conversation. I assure you faith in those teachings are very real for millions of people who are devoted to true enlightenment and something I have studied in great detail.

One more thing bud your attempt at proselytizing (a direct attempt to convert me) in your earlier post is a violation of this sites tos. Please cease and desist.

: {>

BTW my mantra is Jesus Christ Is love.... Jesus Christ Is love,,,,

Yes, doesn't one of the main tenets of your faith speak of the need for compassion and understanding? I don't think it's necessary to be hostile to someone who simply wants to show you a better way. Shaku buku is a most venerable act. Does not Christianity rely on evangelism? I don't see where in the MA it tells me not to show you the fallacies of misguided faith in the god of the Israelites and expound to you the superior knowledge discovered by those who have abandoned the crutches of a god complex.

One simply needs to look at the utter failure and strife caused in the name of that deity you worship to see its inherent flaws. I do not refute the life of Jesus or that he expounded great virtues of love. I only tell you that he was simply a man and had a limited grasp on the concepts of attaining enlightenment and purity of being. I am well within my rights and priviledges to do so.

Peace.

For RevDisturbia's path to peace...

Nam Myoho Renge Kyo - The secret of the Lotus Sutra
 
Last edited:
I think God allows the universe to run on autopilot by natural law for the most part is deistic for the most part.
Special pleading.

Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.
It's a false analogy.

My head hurts from banging it on the table.
Well, don't do that then.

That's so wrong.
No, it is strictly correct.

Anyway humor me, please prove it.
From Wikipedia:

Without any evidence associated with the earliest instant of the expansion, the Big Bang theory cannot and does not provide any explanation for such an initial condition; rather, it describes and explains the general evolution of the universe since that instant.
(Their italics.)

Show me some outside sources that show that the (and these words have to be in the body of the cut and paste article that; standard hot model big bang cosmology states that the universe did not begin 13.7 or so years ago
What are you talking about?

and please do not insult my intelligence and come up with some cut and paste that says 'to begin' did not mean 'to begin'. There was nothing then there was something.There was no universe then there was a universe. See simple.
And wrong.

What? The KCA implicitly states that anything that BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence.
You mean explicitly.

And as you have defined "begins to exist", nothing in the Universe can be said to ever begin to exist. So it's not much of a premise.

You know its really amusing to watch you guys attempt to weasel word around the fact that the universe began to exist. Really if you people are serious (I don't think you are) its truly sad.
The Universe began.

Basic theology is that souls are eternal but created, however I think they can die.
So they're not eternal?

You don't know what you are talking about. I demonstrated and told you why that the BB is paramount to the KCA.
You and Dr Craig are both relying on a misunderstanding of big bang cosmology.

If you want to critique every Dr of theology and philosophy that supports first cause cosmological arguments be my guest, but it sure does detract from your credibility as it would anyone's, including mine.
Not at all. They're just all wrong.

The KCA uses deductive logic.
Poorly.

And if it didn't work today it wouldnt be debated in the venues and with the quality of the debater
Argument from authority, affirming the consequent.

Nor would it be taught at the best universities in the nation and world.
It isn't.

And that isn't so. You have yet to provide evidence for either claim. Pure speculation doesn't work.
No. This has already been explained. You just completely misunderstood the explanation.

"The cosmological argument for God's existence asserts that the universe had a beginning. This claim is backed with considerable experimental evidence. The big bang theory of the universe, which is the standard cosmology in use today, recognises that the observable universe itself- including space and time itself- is not eternal but had a beginning some 13.7 billion years ago.
And?

The Origin of the Universe: Scientific American
Our universe began with a hot big bang 13.7 billion years ago and has expanded and cooled ever since. It has evolved from a formless soup of elementary ...
www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id...the-universe
And?

What Hokulele said was precisely correct.

Debated yes conclusions reached yes, The KCA defeated NO.
And yet, every one of your premises remain false.

Have you read any professional debates between say Smith and Craig? Its not only telling its funny to watch Smith get crushed by Craig. I would be happy to provide a link.
Please do.

I will say in all fairness no one wins in a argument like this hands down. But even a stale mate is fine with me because the point made are valid, and expose the rebuttals as so much nonsense.
No. No, not even remotely. All your premises remain false.
 
If there is a linkage between the KCA and the BB then this should be made explicit, so that it can be determined that the linkage is valid.

At the moment it sounds suspiciously like:

1: If the KCA from P1 to C1 is sound then the universe began to exist
2: The universe began to exist
C: Therefore the KCA from P1 to C1 is sound

Which is the fallacy of affirming the consequent.
 
There was nothing then there was something.There was no universe then there was a universe. See simple.
Too simple. I'll post my previous explanation from post #548 again with a bit of elaboration. Please read it and think about it.

It is difficult for us to imagine dimensions beyond the three spatial ones that we experience. We can imagine a point location. Then we can imagine a line extending from that point. That's one dimension. Then we can imagine another line extending from the same point at a 90 degree angle to the other line. That's two dimensions. Another line at a 90 degree angle to both of the previous two lines gives us three dimensions. Beyond this our ability to visualize more dimensions fails us. We can describe four line segments, all originating from the same point, and all four measuring 90 degrees from the other three, but we can't visualize it. To help us understand the concept we can imagine a model universe in which the beings contemplating said universe exist in a two dimensional plane. They know that their universe is expanding and they have determined that in the future it will contract. In this universe time is a dimension that runs perpendicular to their two dimensional plane. To them, the third dimension is every bit as mysterious as the fourth is to us but its relationship is the same. In this universe space/time is spherical. The flatlander's "Big Bang" is located at the "north pole" of their universe and their "Big Crunch" is located at the "south pole" of their universe. They experience time in the third dimension running from "north" to "south" in their experience of space/time. If you add time as a fourth dimension to the other three that we think of as space then you have what we seem to experience in this universe. This is why cosmologists say that asking what was before the Big Bang is likely as meaningless as asking what is north of the North Pole. When you understand this you will also understand why Stephen Hawking once asked "Why do we remember the past but not the future?". You are still thinking of time as something that stretches to infinity in either direction. But time does not stretch back beyond the Big Bang event any more than "up" does. Do you see how the universe could be eternal but still be finite?
 
Last edited:
1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.

Let me reiterate my criticisms since I just can't seem to get an answer.


KCA is spurious because:
  • It has no explanatory power.
  • It posits an unknown entity (the creator).
  • It posits unknown forces (magic, miracles, etc.)
M-Theory and other theories on the other hand don't posit unknown entities and unknown forces. They have explanatory power. M-Theory doesn't posit time paradoxes.

Theoretical physicists aren't interested in KCA because they are prejudiced. They aren't interested in it because it doesn't tell us anything.
 
Last edited:
I don't where they get this "the universe began from nothing" claim from. It seems to be nothing more than a dishonest attempt to twist things for obvious reasons.

The Big Bang doesn't say the universe had a beginning. What it says is the current state of the universe had a beginning. The universe expanded from some sort of singularity. This is a change from one form to another, singularity to expanding universe, which is not an absolute starting point from "nothing". A singularity is clearly something. How the singularity came to be there, why it expanded and what occurred previous to the expansion, is simply unknown at this point.
 
Last edited:
I've been arguing the opposite. Under what theory can a series of events take place without time?

A series necessates that things happen before and after. There is no before and after without time.

Its not easy to visualize and that is at least part of the difficulty. I may go out on a limb and speculate that events taking place without time could be events that happen inside an event horizon of a black hole etc.

Time does not actually stop (for both parties at least) at the event horizon but would appear to stop if a friend could watch you falling into the black hole from a safe distance. If you could live through the experience you would notice nothing strange, but to your observer it would appear that you were slowing down and eventually stopping 'at' the event horizon. So time would appear to the observer to of stopped. So that may be a bad example.
This was where the black hole debate started.

So, let's go back to this and start again.

You claim that as someone approaches a black hole an outside observer would see their clock slow down, until it stopped, and that's what an event without time is like.

Okay, let's for a minute go with your thought experiment and assume that we can see the chap approaching the event horizon, ignoring the redshift. As he approaches the event horizon his clock slows down, and so does he. For the sake of argument we'll say that he's waving a flag. As his clock appears to slow, so does his flag waving, until, in the limit, just as he "reaches" the event horizon, his clock stops, and so does his flag waving. He's stuck there, on the edge of oblivion, forever frozen in the same pose, his flag completely static, his clock never ticking.

So what event are we talking about that's happening without time?
 
I don't where they get this "the universe began from nothing" claim from. It seems to be nothing more than a dishonest attempt to twist things for obvious reasons.

The Big Bang doesn't say the universe had a beginning. What it says is the current state of the universe had a beginning. The universe expanded from some sort of singularity. This is a change from one form to another, singularity to expanding universe, which is not an absolute starting point from "nothing". A singularity is clearly something. How the singularity came to be there, why it expanded and what occurred previous to the expansion, is simply unknown at this point.
Since Bing Bang theory DOES NOT claim that the universe "began", I still don't see your point.
And this was post #20.

He has to defend this claim no matter what facts and science says otherwise or his entire basis of the KCA claim will collapse...well besides it completely worthless in proving his god even if true.
 
It would be interesting to go back through the thread and collate a list of all the flaws we've highlighted in the KCA. Then we could just sit here and say "17", or "43b" or whatever.
 
I don't where they get this "the universe began from nothing" claim from. It seems to be nothing more than a dishonest attempt to twist things for obvious reasons.

Exactly. No credible scientist/cosmologist says anything of the sort.

When you do hear that statement, you can almost guarantee it's coming from a creationist, ID proponent, "philosopher", or some other manner of theist.

It's actually handy to hear it right up front, because it's a good barometer of what the rest of the conversation will be like (see this thread for an example).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom