Hokulele said:
It doesn't make me uncomfortable, it is completely irrelevent.
No, it wasn't
irrelevant and I told you why, but forget it its worth that much font and aggravation.
If I do not understand something, I am perfectly happy to ask for cites or other clarification, or to go and do my own research.
whatever.
With that said, would you please provide the reference where either Dr. Craig or Quentin Smith describes the issue of time being created just after t=0? Your quote wasn't clear as to which one of these people you were referring.
Both take the theist view even though Quentin is an atheist.
Please clarify what you mean here. Deism generally refers to a deity that does not interfere with the universe, so I am not sure how that would relate to temporal agents being created specifically to interfere with the universe.
I think God allows the universe to run on autopilot by natural law for the most part is deistic for the most part.
Yes, I think differently. Please explain how "1" must cause "2".
Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.
No, Big Bang cosmology states nothing about whether or not the universe "began", it simply describes the limit described by that model.
My head hurts from banging it on the table. That's so wrong. Anyway humor me, please prove it. Show me some outside sources that show that the (and these words have to be in the body of the cut and paste article that; standard hot model big bang cosmology states that the universe did not begin 13.7 or so years ago, and please do not insult my intelligence and come up with some cut and paste that says 'to begin' did not mean 'to begin'. There was nothing then there was something.There was no universe then there was a universe. See simple.
As Robin has repeatedly demonstrated, the KCA has yet to differentiate between stating something has a beginning, and stating that something began to exist.
What? The KCA implicitly states that anything that
BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence. You know its really amusing to watch you guys attempt to weasel word around the fact that the universe began to exist. Really if you people are serious (I don't think you are) its truly sad.
As an example, if you believe in the existence of an eternal soul, you could state that your life began at <fill in the blank>, but that you have always existed. Many new-age believers claim exactly this.
Basic theology is that souls are eternal but created, however I think they can die.
I know why you and Dr. Craig find Big Bang cosmology important to the KCA as you have framed it, but I have been explaining why it can't be. It is mixing apples and teal-green
You don't know what you are talking about. I demonstrated and told you why that the BB is paramount to the KCA. If you want to critique every Dr of theology and philosophy that supports first cause cosmological arguments be my guest, but it sure does detract from your credibility as it would anyone's, including mine.
Inductive logic and cosmology may have worked for the ancient Greeks, but Galileo demonstrated not just how Aristotle was wrong, but why.
The KCA uses deductive logic. And if it didn't work today it wouldnt be debated in the venues and with the quality of the debater Nor would it be taught at the best universities in the nation and world.
Your premises are based on a flawed perception of Big Bang cosmology, and that is why they fail.
And that isn't so. You have yet to provide evidence for either claim. Pure speculation doesn't work.
"The cosmological argument for God's existence asserts that the universe had a beginning.
This claim is backed with considerable experimental evidence. The big bang theory of the universe, which is the standard cosmology in use today, recognises that the observable universe itself- including space and time itself- is not eternal but had a beginning some 13.7 billion years ago.
http://www.apologetics-wiki.com/wiki/index.php/The_universe_began_to_exist:_Empirical_evidence
The Origin of the Universe: Scientific American
Our universe
began with a hot big bang 13.7 billion years ago and has expanded and cooled ever since. It has evolved from a formless soup of elementary ...
www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id...the-universe - 7 hours ago
Debated, yes. Conclusions reached, no.
Debated yes conclusions reached yes, The KCA defeated NO. Have you read any professional debates between say Smith and Craig? Its not only telling its funny to watch Smith get crushed by Craig. I would be happy to provide a link. I will say in all fairness no one wins in a argument like this hands down. But even a stale mate is fine with me because the point made are valid, and expose the rebuttals as so much nonsense.
; {>