The certainty of God's existence.

To be a sound argument, both the logic must be valid and the premises must be true.
Yes. And a true conclusion does not imply that the logic is valid or that the premisses are true as some here seem to think.
 
I've been arguing the opposite. Under what theory can a series of events take place without time?

A series necessates that things happen before and after. There is no before and after without time.
Further to what I said before, imagine a hypothetical environment where a universe begins and ends. Then another universe begins and ends and the second universe has a slightly different law of physics, then a third universe with yet another law of physics begins and ends.

In this case there might be no meaning in the question "did universe 1 take longer than universe 2?", or "was there a gap between universe 1 and universe 2 and was it greater than the gap between universe 2 and universe 3?".

However if there is an overlap between the universes and the universes can interact in some way then this hypothetical environment also has time of some sort.

The other possibility is that in this hypothetical environment the question "was universe 1 before universe 2?" is meaningless, so there is no succession. But in such an environment it would be meaningless to say that any of the universes began to exist.

So an environment in which a universe might begin might

1. have time, or
2. have no time but still succession, or
3. have neither time nor succession.

This last is the theological meaning of eternity.
 
Wrong Pixi. The size of a black hole would make no difference as all require enough mass to create one, a million stellar mass black hole or a thousand stellar mass black would be have the same effects on our guy. The observer would see his friend stop at the event horizon.
No, complete nonsense. That's utterly impossible for the reasons I already pointed out. The observer would see his friend disappear into infinite red shift.

The difference between a small and a large black hole is the time it takes for the subject to disappear from view. For a small black hole, this would be very fast. For a sufficiently large black hole, you might actually be able to observe it.

Remember we also said that we were saying his freind could live through it.
Not relevant.

You forget that we said we could watch everything. If the observers could see everything it would happen just as I said *and the NASA astrophysicist said. I can pull another link if you like, or better yet why don't you provide the link this time?
The NASA astrophysicist said nothing of the sort. The point was that the subjects clock stopped at the event horizon. At the point that the subject's clock stops, they are entirely invisible to the external Universe, both practically and theoretically.
 
We know that by hawking radiation that information can enter a black hole and not be lost so I was demonstrating that cause and effect can exist where time according to the observed has stopped.
Nope. The information that escapes by Hawking radiation is randomised. It only escapes because there is a Universe outside the black hole where time is still passing.

If Pixie would of read my post I already indicated that time would seem to be unchanged to the friend not to the observer. To the observer it would seem that time had stopped for his friend at the event horizon as per me and the NASA astrophysics link.
Yes, relative to the observer, the subject's clock would stop at the event horizon. But the subject disappears from view due to asymptotic red shift as they approach the event horizon. The clock can never be observed to have stopped, because at the point that the clock would stop, the subject is no longer detectable in any way.
 
Hi Pixi Hi Robin Oops here comes Mrs Hokulele...Hey where did the angels go? I need them because I am going to get ganged up on....

; }>
 
Last edited:
Real Time and Real Space are indivisible to my way of thinking, we can’t exist with both, hence space-time. ‘Three D’ space that can be described mathematically is only a mathematical construct a mathematical reality. That’s why I said real time and real space are bound in the ‘real universe‘ (not Gods realm). Back to the math….without time it is not possible to ascertain distance and of course without distance we have only 'now' and one D space. Likewise, time does not exist independently of space except as a mathematical construct or as a theoretical musing. However this applies only in our universe after t-0.


Please explain how time can exist independently of space as a mathematical construct.

I was curious. In debate I can mold my questions either to your world or life experience. If you were a math professor I would ask my questions or make my statements differently than if you were in another field, especially when discussing Godel etc. See? But forget it, if it makes you uncomfortable.


It doesn't make me uncomfortable, it is completely irrelevent. If I do not understand something, I am perfectly happy to ask for cites or other clarification, or to go and do my own research. With that said, would you please provide the reference where either Dr. Craig or Quentin Smith describes the issue of time being created just after t=0? Your quote wasn't clear as to which one of these people you were referring.

I meant that they were created in the information contained in the BB, think in deistic terms.


Please clarify what you mean here. Deism generally refers to a deity that does not interfere with the universe, so I am not sure how that would relate to temporal agents being created specifically to interfere with the universe.

Its speculation, but its strange that God does not often appear in his form.


It isn't strange if it doesn't exist.

No need to get hostile.

That is a can of worms.

Ya think? Do you think..never mind. From now on I will say spacetime etc...


None of which addresses my points.

I was simply using the numbers to show that cause and effect could be exist without time. Or do you think differently yes or no?


Yes, I think differently. Please explain how "1" must cause "2".

If by now you don't know how the BB is important to the KCA then you haven't read a fraction of my posts! The BB simply demonstrates that the universe began. See p-1.


No, Big Bang cosmology states nothing about whether or not the universe "began", it simply describes the limit described by that model. As Robin has repeatedly demonstrated, the KCA has yet to differentiate between stating something has a beginning, and stating that something began to exist.

As an example, if you believe in the existence of an eternal soul, you could state that your life began at <fill in the blank>, but that you have always existed. Many new-age believers claim exactly this.

Again I am sick of going over this again. The cosmological argument is a blend of disciplines. Either go back and read why the bb is important to the KCA or read Craig or Koon I am tired of repeating it.


I know why you and Dr. Craig find Big Bang cosmology important to the KCA as you have framed it, but I have been explaining why it can't be. It is mixing apples and teal-green.

Inductive logic and cosmology may have worked for the ancient Greeks, but Galileo demonstrated not just how Aristotle was wrong, but why.

With all due respect I am afraid you do not know the material at all. I use P1 through P3 all easy to understand and sound. The reason that the BB is important to the KCA is beyond obvious.


Your premises are based on a flawed perception of Big Bang cosmology, and that is why they fail.

Every concern that you have mentioned here except for the time questions have been exhaustively debated here.


Debated, yes. Conclusions reached, no.
 
The definition has two meanings, you are focusing on the 2nd one, but only the first applies to 90% of us. Two is not a rephrase of one, it is a whole different meaning for the word atheism. The only person here using it in that sense is you. For the most part, we don't say there is no God, we say we don't believe there is a God.


I was focusing on the second one because that was the one I was using. I had no way of knowing if 10 or 100% were one strong or weak atheists.

Also, the dictionary is wrong. Who teaches this doctrine? Must it be adhered to? How is it enforced? Sadly, in this case, the word chosen for meaning two is less-than-best. Better would have been: 2. The assertion that is no God or gods. And this meaning would still only apply to universally strong atheists.

A doctrine does not have to be taught! Sadly this argument was started by father Z and its morphed to something that it wasn't when it started. I stand by my statements in the context they were written. If you want to critique or correct the Microsoft dictionary go get them, but with all due respect I will use Encarta Microsoft Encarta as an authority instead of your unsupported claims.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Hi Pixi Hi Robin Oops here comes Mrs Hokulele...Hey where did the angels go? I need them because I am going to get ganged up on....

; }>
Who's ganging up on you? My points are quite independent of anything PixyMisa and Hokulele are saying. You do like to characterise yourself as the victim don't you?
 
Hokulele said:
It doesn't make me uncomfortable, it is completely irrelevent.

No, it wasn't irrelevant and I told you why, but forget it its worth that much font and aggravation.

If I do not understand something, I am perfectly happy to ask for cites or other clarification, or to go and do my own research.

whatever.

With that said, would you please provide the reference where either Dr. Craig or Quentin Smith describes the issue of time being created just after t=0? Your quote wasn't clear as to which one of these people you were referring.

Both take the theist view even though Quentin is an atheist.

Please clarify what you mean here. Deism generally refers to a deity that does not interfere with the universe, so I am not sure how that would relate to temporal agents being created specifically to interfere with the universe.

I think God allows the universe to run on autopilot by natural law for the most part is deistic for the most part.

Yes, I think differently. Please explain how "1" must cause "2".

Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.

No, Big Bang cosmology states nothing about whether or not the universe "began", it simply describes the limit described by that model.

My head hurts from banging it on the table. That's so wrong. Anyway humor me, please prove it. Show me some outside sources that show that the (and these words have to be in the body of the cut and paste article that; standard hot model big bang cosmology states that the universe did not begin 13.7 or so years ago, and please do not insult my intelligence and come up with some cut and paste that says 'to begin' did not mean 'to begin'. There was nothing then there was something.There was no universe then there was a universe. See simple.

As Robin has repeatedly demonstrated, the KCA has yet to differentiate between stating something has a beginning, and stating that something began to exist.

What? The KCA implicitly states that anything that BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence. You know its really amusing to watch you guys attempt to weasel word around the fact that the universe began to exist. Really if you people are serious (I don't think you are) its truly sad.

As an example, if you believe in the existence of an eternal soul, you could state that your life began at <fill in the blank>, but that you have always existed. Many new-age believers claim exactly this.

Basic theology is that souls are eternal but created, however I think they can die.

I know why you and Dr. Craig find Big Bang cosmology important to the KCA as you have framed it, but I have been explaining why it can't be. It is mixing apples and teal-green

You don't know what you are talking about. I demonstrated and told you why that the BB is paramount to the KCA. If you want to critique every Dr of theology and philosophy that supports first cause cosmological arguments be my guest, but it sure does detract from your credibility as it would anyone's, including mine.

Inductive logic and cosmology may have worked for the ancient Greeks, but Galileo demonstrated not just how Aristotle was wrong, but why.

The KCA uses deductive logic. And if it didn't work today it wouldnt be debated in the venues and with the quality of the debater Nor would it be taught at the best universities in the nation and world.

Your premises are based on a flawed perception of Big Bang cosmology, and that is why they fail.

And that isn't so. You have yet to provide evidence for either claim. Pure speculation doesn't work.

"The cosmological argument for God's existence asserts that the universe had a beginning. This claim is backed with considerable experimental evidence. The big bang theory of the universe, which is the standard cosmology in use today, recognises that the observable universe itself- including space and time itself- is not eternal but had a beginning some 13.7 billion years ago.

http://www.apologetics-wiki.com/wiki/index.php/The_universe_began_to_exist:_Empirical_evidence

The Origin of the Universe: Scientific American
Our universe began with a hot big bang 13.7 billion years ago and has expanded and cooled ever since. It has evolved from a formless soup of elementary ...
www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id...the-universe - 7 hours ago


Debated, yes. Conclusions reached, no.

Debated yes conclusions reached yes, The KCA defeated NO. Have you read any professional debates between say Smith and Craig? Its not only telling its funny to watch Smith get crushed by Craig. I would be happy to provide a link. I will say in all fairness no one wins in a argument like this hands down. But even a stale mate is fine with me because the point made are valid, and expose the rebuttals as so much nonsense.

; {>
 
Who's ganging up on you? My points are quite independent of anything PixyMisa and Hokulele are saying.
No a lot of the material is redundant. I have covered much of it over and over and over.....

You do like to characterise yourself as the victim don't you?

Just like Mr Goodbar...BTW I know what to expect in a atheist (etc) dominated forum but that does not stop me from looking for a fair one where a double standard does not exist :duck:

: {>
 
The NASA astrophysicist said nothing of the sort. The point was that the subjects clock stopped at the event horizon. At the point that the subject's clock stops, they are entirely invisible to the external Universe, both practically and theoretically.

Are you for real? For the third time. We agreed that we could see both throughout the ordeal. One thing that I wonder about is that I know any person remotely knowledgeable about this knows that I am correct. But where are they? Its like lies by omission, except its ethics instead of lies. Par for the course.\

"Near a black hole, the slowing of time is extreme. From the viewpoint of an observer outside the black hole, time stops. For example, an object falling into the hole would appear frozen in time at the edge of the hole."

http://chandra.harvard.edu/BlackHoleExhibit/BH_Pages/primer/BH_whatare.php

; {>
 
Last edited:
No a lot of the material is redundant. I have covered much of it over and over and over.....
And a lot of it you have yet to respond to, even though you have time to spend starting unnecessary brush fires.
Just like Mr Goodbar...BTW I know what to expect in a atheist (etc) dominated forum but that does not stop me from looking for a fair one where a double standard does not exist :duck:

: {>
Oh please, we have all been there when we have submitted a post where there is going to be substantial disagreement, I got it when I posted on the possibility that science would reject the concept of matter, I got it when I posted that science had been helped in it's birth by religion, I got it when I posted that Dawkin's shouldn't have criticised the Pope over evolution, or called Gould a flabby coward over NOMA, I get flak from materialists and immaterialists alike whenever I start a thread on consciousness.

There is no double standard - when you look for debate, don't be surprised when you get debate.
 
And a lot of it you have yet to respond to, even though you have time to spend starting unnecessary brush fires.

Oh please, we have all been there when we have submitted a post where there is going to be substantial disagreement, I got it when I posted on the possibility that science would reject the concept of matter, I got it when I posted that science had been helped in it's birth by religion, I got it when I posted that Dawkin's shouldn't have criticised the Pope over evolution, or called Gould a flabby coward over NOMA, I get flak from materialists and immaterialists alike whenever I start a thread on consciousness.

There is no double standard - when you look for debate, don't be surprised when you get debate.

I can handle debate but not when...ummm.... well I cant even say it unless oops.... I cant say that either.

I can debate anyone on a one on one basis. However I can't debate five or six members with outside interference. I love good debate even with a modest amount of flame. Its my comfort zone however I can't debate well when everything is considered. I find my posts everwhere, and have 15 PMs in the last few hours if you know what that means.

Anyway I think you should know I was playing when I commented about the women. Oh I don't start anything if you don't believe me go back to where I first entered this thread. I spend my time defending myself and putting out fires. It might be time to mosey back over to one of the other forums and let the brush fires burn themselves out. When I return I won't answer ANY personal content. I will say that this forum has some swell members and is not the worst in other areas, and the quality of the members knowledge of the subject is better than most.

eh?

: }>
 
Last edited:
Yes. And a true conclusion does not imply that the logic is valid or that the premisses are true as some here seem to think.

The premises at least one through three are true. I said a few pages back that Craig and I think Koon support the other premises. I don't know their argument well enough to defend it nor would I want to as we believe differently in some areas.

Getting back to premises one through three, If the premises are true the logic is true and it completes a valid syllogism. So the KCA is a valid cosmological argument for the existence of God. I would kind of like to see it defeated so I can defend something else.

; {>
 
Last edited:
The KCA implicitly states that anything that BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence.

Yes, that is its assertion. That assertion is built on two premises, neither of which is impervious to challenge. You have yet to adequately face the challenges offered.

You know its really amusing to watch you guys attempt to weasel word around the fact that the universe began to exist. Really if you people are serious (I don't think you are) its truly sad.

This disappoints me. You where indignant over the slur, IDiot, and I think rightly so, but then you resort to this style of substance-free argument. You can do better.

You don't know what you are talking about. I demonstrated and told you why that the BB is paramount to the KCA. If you want to critique every Dr of theology and philosophy that supports first cause cosmological arguments be my guest, but it sure does detract from your credibility as it would anyone's, including mine.

And again you substitute slur for argument. If you believe Hokulele is misinformed on something, then focus on that something rather than level a blanket insult to her intelligence.

The KCA uses deductive logic. And if it didn't work today it wouldnt be debated in the venues and with the quality of the debater Nor would it be taught at the best universities in the nation and world.

All sorts of things are taught at the best universities in the nation and the world. We can learn from failures, too, remember.

"The cosmological argument for God's existence asserts that the universe had a beginning. This claim is backed with considerable experimental evidence. The big bang theory of the universe, which is the standard cosmology in use today, recognises that the observable universe itself- including space and time itself- is not eternal but had a beginning some 13.7 billion years ago.

I note that you switched from "began to exist" to "began". I note, too, it is an ambiguous usage that could have a similar meaning found in "our day began 22 hours ago."

Was there a cause for today worth discussing?
 
jsfisher said:
Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
The KCA implicitly states that anything that BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence.
Yes, that is its assertion. That assertion is built on two premises, neither of which is impervious to challenge. You have yet to adequately face the challenges offered.

Wrong all I have done is faced the challenges. Just read the posts for proof, I have offered links and rebuttals to be met with weak cherry picked counterarguments or simply no answer at all.

You make a silly vague statement and then drop it and run. If you want me to answer you will have to be specific. The rest of your post will go unanswered due to personal content.

; {>

ps
I note that you switched from "began to exist" to "began". I note, too, it is an ambiguous usage that could have a similar meaning found in "our day began 22 hours ago."

That quote was from the first premise of KCA no wonder you did not recognize it.

1 Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.

See what I have to put up with? You did not know that was the first premise of the KCA...
 
Last edited:
Both take the theist view even though Quentin is an atheist.


And you offered a reference for this. Would you please provide it?

I think God allows the universe to run on autopilot by natural law for the most part is deistic for the most part.


Which is fine, but it does make such an entity unfalsifiable. As such, there is no reason to believe in its existence.

Its an analogy and you did not answer my question.


I stated, "Yes, I do think differently." It may be an analogy, but it certainly doesn't address the issue of cause and effect. Causality requires relationships. Your number line does not.

My head hurts from banging it on the table. That's so wrong. Anyway humor me, please prove it. Show me some outside sources that show that the (and these words have to be in the body of the cut and paste article that; standard hot model big bang cosmology states that the universe did not begin 13.7 or so years ago, and please do not insult my intelligence and come up with some cut and paste that says 'to begin' did not mean 'to begin'. There was nothing then there was something.There was no universe then there was a universe. See simple.


Heck, even the Wikipedia entry describes it as a limit, not as a beginning:

Wikipedia said:
The Big Bang is the cosmological model of the initial conditions and subsequent development of the universe that is supported by the most comprehensive and accurate explanations from current scientific evidence and observation. As used by cosmologists, the term Big Bang generally refers to the idea that the universe has expanded from a primordial hot and dense initial condition at some finite time in the past, and continues to expand to this day.

<snip>

Without any evidence associated with the earliest instant of the expansion, the Big Bang theory cannot and does not provide any explanation for such an initial condition; rather, it describes and explains the general evolution of the universe since that instant.


My bolding. Nothing about "no universe, then there was a universe". It is an initial condition or a limit. Not "there was nothing". Sure, literature written for the layperson generally simplifies this into "the universe began", but the models themselves do no such thing.

What? The KCA implicitly states that anything that BEGINS TO EXIST has a cause for its existence. You know its really amusing to watch you guys attempt to weasel word around the fact that the universe began to exist. Really if you people are serious (I don't think you are) its truly sad.


Aha! Finally you are addressing Robin's point. Now, please show that our universe began to exist at some point.

Basic theology is that souls are eternal but created, however I think they can die.


If souls can be created and eternal, why can't your god? Methinks I hear the approaching footsteps of a special pleading.

You don't know what you are talking about. I demonstrated and told you why that the BB is paramount to the KCA. If you want to critique every Dr of theology and philosophy that supports first cause cosmological arguments be my guest, but it sure does detract from your credibility as it would anyone's, including mine.


I would critique anyone, regardless of background, if they use an incorrect formulation of what Big Bang cosmology entails to support their argument.

The KCA uses deductive logic. And if it didn't work today it wouldnt be debated in the venues and with the quality of the debater Nor would it be taught at the best universities in the nation and world.


There are many things that are taught and debated. That doesn't make all of them (or even any of them) true.

"The cosmological argument for God's existence asserts that the universe had a beginning. This claim is backed with considerable experimental evidence. The big bang theory of the universe, which is the standard cosmology in use today, recognises that the observable universe itself- including space and time itself- is not eternal but had a beginning some 13.7 billion years ago.

http://www.apologetics-wiki.com/wiki/index.php/The_universe_began_to_exist:_Empirical_evidence

The Origin of the Universe: Scientific American
Our universe began with a hot big bang 13.7 billion years ago and has expanded and cooled ever since. It has evolved from a formless soup of elementary ...
www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id...the-universe - 7 hours ago


So you keep claiming. As I mentioned, the articles written for a lay audience do word things that way. However, the language of Big Bang cosmology is mathematics, and the equations make no such statement.

Debated yes conclusions reached yes, The KCA defeated NO. Have you read any professional debates between say Smith and Craig? Its not only telling its funny to watch Smith get crushed by Craig. I would be happy to provide a link. I will say in all fairness no one wins in a argument like this hands down. But even a stale mate is fine with me because the point made are valid, and expose the rebuttals as so much nonsense.


A debate isn't the way to reach technical conclusions, as they are often won by oration rather than evidence. There is a good reason why most top biologists refuse to debate creationists, and it has nothing to do with lack of evidence or fear.
 
Last edited:
Wrong all I have done is faced the challenges. Just read the posts for proof, I have offered links and rebuttals to be met with weak cherry picked counterarguments or simply no answer at all.

I have read your posts. I don't find the proof you seem to think is there. I see misrepresentations and sweeping statements. Not much proof. I do see frequent histrionics such as quote here, though.

You make a silly vague statement and then drop it and run. If you want me to answer you will have to be specific. The rest of your post will go unanswered due to personal content.

You don't see the hypocrisy in this part of your post, do you? Not a very convincing way to evade what was actually a specific question, though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom