Oopsie....
That doesn't really answer my question. Do you believe that time can exist independently of space?
Real Time and Real Space are indivisible to my way of thinking, we can’t exist with both, hence space-time. ‘Three D’ space that can be described mathematically is only a mathematical construct a mathematical reality. That’s why I said real time and real space are bound in the ‘real universe‘ (not Gods realm). Back to the math….without time it is not possible to ascertain distance and of course without distance we have only 'now' and one D space. Likewise, time does not exist independently of space except as a mathematical construct or as a theoretical musing. However this applies only in our universe after t-0.
Please provide that reference. What I do for a living and my educational background should be irrelevent to this discussion.
I was curious. In debate I can mold my questions either to your world or life experience. If you were a math professor I would ask my questions or make my statements differently than if you were in another field, especially when discussing Godel etc. See? But forget it, if it makes you uncomfortable.
Did you mean "casually" or "causally"? And how would such an interaction take place? Are these liasons be created
ex nihilo?
I meant that they were created in the information contained in the BB, think in deistic terms. Its speculation, but its strange that God does not often appear in his form.
Who "us"? Perfection, much like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. Thank you for the clarification regarding limitations.
No need to get hostile.
Wrong. Time is simply a dimension, or a way of measuring something that exists in space-time. As a dimension, it certainly can stretch out to infinity either along the positive or negative axis, exactly as the three spatial dimensions can. Stating it cannot is like stating there must be a limit to integers.
That is a can of worms.
Now, objects that exist in the space-time continuum may be limited along these axes, but the dimensions themselves are not.
Ya think? Do you think..never mind. From now on I will say spacetime etc...
The main problem with your number analogy is that there is no causal link between them. Ordering something along a non-time axis tells us nothing about time. To use another analogy, I can line up a group of people by height, but it tells me nothing about the relationships between those people.
I was simply using the numbers to show that cause and effect could be exist without time. Or do you think differently yes or no?
[quoet]You are trying to use the Big Bang model as support for the KCA, aren't you? If the Big Bang doesn't work at the "time" required, replacing it with anything, including the KCA, is a complete
non sequitur. It simply doesn't follow.[/quote]
If by now you don't know how the BB is important to the KCA then you haven't read a fraction of my posts! The BB simply demonstrates that the universe began. See p-1.
If it isn't based on science, how can you use science to support it? That makes as much sense as using matrix algebra to support literary criticism.
Again I am sick of going over this again. The cosmological argument is a blend of disciplines. Either go back and read why the bb is important to the KCA or read Craig or Koon I am tired of repeating it.
Of course it offers an explanation for those who buy into its premises (several of which still have unaddressed issues). That is called circular reasoning.
With all due respect I am afraid you do not know the material at all. I use P1 through P3 all easy to understand and sound. The reason that the BB is important to the KCA is beyond obvious. Every concern that you have mentioned here except for the time questions have been exhaustively debated here.
; {>