The certainty of God's existence.

We know that by hawking radiation that information can enter a black hole and not be lost so I was demonstrating that cause and effect can exist where time according to the observed has stopped.
Let's not loose sight of the goal posts. The point of discussion is about whether events can occure outside of time (does god exist outside of time)?
 
originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
I will check it out, thanks for the heads up. I have often wondered why there wasn't a lot of atheist aid groups. If I were an wealthy atheist I would found one.
; {>
That's a good question. For starters, there aren't a lot of atheists, and we've been pretty isolated until recently, I went my first forty years knowingly meeting only three atheists. Thanks to Meetup groups I now know about a hundred. We haven't formed a charity, but we raise money for the local food bank now and then. Anyway, the point is, it really hasn't been practical for atheists to organize to do much of anything except try to protect our rights until recently. There are about forty times as many Christians as atheists in America, why would you not expect atheist aid groups to be a tiny percentage of Christian aid groups?

For seconders, wealthy atheists have an excellent record for starting charities, they just don't use them to evangelize atheism. I have reservations myself about starting a charity with atheism in the name. Sure, I'm an outspoken atheist, but if my cause is to, say, assist in resettling refugees from Third World countries in America, I would be short-changing the refugees if I took the opportunity to say 'look how charitable atheists are!' by naming it 'Atheists for Smooth Resettlement of Refugees'. As you've pointed out, atheists aren't much-liked, this name is likely to reduce donations-especially from Christians and Muslims. Some of the people at Harvest Hope food bank know that Godless Columbia is one of their donors, that will have to be it for our advertising of atheist charity for now. Possibly a charity to benefit victims of religous violence could have atheist in the title without undermining the cause too much, but even then I'm not sure I'm comfortable with a title that would contribute to interested religous people feeling excluded. It's a good cause, and most religous folk I know don't condone any religously-motivated violence, so it isn't that atheistic.

I've meandered, was this any help at all?

Yes, thanks this forum needs more meandering members like you. Good post, some of my remarks were made partly out of anger and I know some reasons why atheists don't have tit for tat counterparts to the religious missions etc. However you brought up some points that I did not think of. Thanks....

; }>
 
Not true. That was the whole point of the Hawking-Thorne-Peskill bet.

That's right he lost didn't he ? That's good because he was trying to prove the universe did not have a beginning too. I want to research the topic a bit more before I concede. Maybe a particle can still enter and survive a short time which would not agree with the evaporating of a black hole but allow it to effect the temporal universe.

; {>
 
Let's not loose sight of the goal posts. The point of discussion is about whether events can occure outside of time (does god exist outside of time)?

Yes but that's not all that we were discussing! We were discussing if God could motivate in a atemoral realm. Can god cause a universe begin to exist ie cause and effect temporally. The premises of the KCA ie the logic tells us that God has to exist outside or before (for lack of a better word time was created.

; {>
 
This forum is slowing to a crawl at this end (if I use any advanced feature) time for a break and hope that the bandwidth vampires or the hackers get done!

; {>
 
That's right he lost didn't he ? That's good because he was trying to prove the universe did not have a beginning too. I want to research the topic a bit more before I concede. Maybe a particle can still enter and survive a short time which would not agree with the evaporating of a black hole but allow it to effect the temporal universe.


As ~enigma~ pointed out, Hawking conceded, but the question is still unresolved. Physicists still haven't come to a consensus as to whether or not information carried by Hawking radiation is based on information passing the event horizon, or completely new information (generated ex nihilo, something you have claimed to be impossible).

Preskill claims it is not new, Hawking agreed with Preskill in 2004 (but not for the reasons that have been mentioned in the thread thus far), and Thorne disagrees.

Further discussion on this gets into issues of asymptotic causality, and since you have already claimed that you do not deal with infinities, that conversation is left still-born.
 
Why don't you ask Pixi she is the one who first suggested it.
No, you suggested it. You brought up "What's His Name".

Besides I have already proved you wrong with outside evidence.
You've claimed victory in a semantic diversion. You have completely failed to support your position regarding the actual argument, the substance of which centered on your implication that atheists lack for charity, even going so far as to imply that I have a "guilt complex" because of this "fact".
 

Oopsie....

That doesn't really answer my question. Do you believe that time can exist independently of space?

Real Time and Real Space are indivisible to my way of thinking, we can’t exist with both, hence space-time. ‘Three D’ space that can be described mathematically is only a mathematical construct a mathematical reality. That’s why I said real time and real space are bound in the ‘real universe‘ (not Gods realm). Back to the math….without time it is not possible to ascertain distance and of course without distance we have only 'now' and one D space. Likewise, time does not exist independently of space except as a mathematical construct or as a theoretical musing. However this applies only in our universe after t-0.

Please provide that reference. What I do for a living and my educational background should be irrelevent to this discussion.

I was curious. In debate I can mold my questions either to your world or life experience. If you were a math professor I would ask my questions or make my statements differently than if you were in another field, especially when discussing Godel etc. See? But forget it, if it makes you uncomfortable.

Did you mean "casually" or "causally"? And how would such an interaction take place? Are these liasons be created ex nihilo?

I meant that they were created in the information contained in the BB, think in deistic terms. Its speculation, but its strange that God does not often appear in his form.

Who "us"? Perfection, much like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. Thank you for the clarification regarding limitations.

No need to get hostile.

Wrong. Time is simply a dimension, or a way of measuring something that exists in space-time. As a dimension, it certainly can stretch out to infinity either along the positive or negative axis, exactly as the three spatial dimensions can. Stating it cannot is like stating there must be a limit to integers.

That is a can of worms.

Now, objects that exist in the space-time continuum may be limited along these axes, but the dimensions themselves are not.

Ya think? Do you think..never mind. From now on I will say spacetime etc...

The main problem with your number analogy is that there is no causal link between them. Ordering something along a non-time axis tells us nothing about time. To use another analogy, I can line up a group of people by height, but it tells me nothing about the relationships between those people.

I was simply using the numbers to show that cause and effect could be exist without time. Or do you think differently yes or no?

[quoet]You are trying to use the Big Bang model as support for the KCA, aren't you? If the Big Bang doesn't work at the "time" required, replacing it with anything, including the KCA, is a complete non sequitur. It simply doesn't follow.[/quote]

If by now you don't know how the BB is important to the KCA then you haven't read a fraction of my posts! The BB simply demonstrates that the universe began. See p-1.

If it isn't based on science, how can you use science to support it? That makes as much sense as using matrix algebra to support literary criticism.

Again I am sick of going over this again. The cosmological argument is a blend of disciplines. Either go back and read why the bb is important to the KCA or read Craig or Koon I am tired of repeating it.

Of course it offers an explanation for those who buy into its premises (several of which still have unaddressed issues). That is called circular reasoning.

With all due respect I am afraid you do not know the material at all. I use P1 through P3 all easy to understand and sound. The reason that the BB is important to the KCA is beyond obvious. Every concern that you have mentioned here except for the time questions have been exhaustively debated here.

; {>
 
Last edited:
First we have made our amends so I don't know what you are talking about. If I just out of the blue insulted someone I would apologize. However, if over the hundreds of posts where in more than a few that I had been taunted, insulted, and needled with off color comments and veiled derogatory suggestive comments, not to mention the same treatment being applied to my God and religion and the same treatment applied to my friends by a few other than said member (Randy who I already have made amends), in not just one but more than one two or three posts, (or ten twenty or thirty posts) maybe Its I that is due the apology(s). One of many. Not a on your knees groveling post, just a sorry if I have offend you or your religion or your friends. So yes that would be nice, yes it would !

But thanks for your kind comments.

Some of the above tongue in cheek but not too much!

; {>

I have heard enough Christians and Muslims express an interest in getting to find out what happens to people (who disagree with them) in the afterlife (with a clear inference that it will be unpleasant) that I am willing to accept the majority who do so, for some reason, are just incapable of comprehending how profoundly insulting they are being. I don't know why that is (it seems obvious to me, kind of how 'someday, someone is going to give you what's coming to you' is obviously combining both insult and threat, while avoiding personal responsibility). You seem to be saying that lots of little offenses add up to license for you to say something malicious. I don't agree, but the things you find offensive wouldn't offend me...maybe if I saw them as provoking as you do, I would be more sympathetic. Certainly I can imagine visiting a Christian forum and getting tired of hearing comments they find innocuous but I find irritating, like 'I'll pray for you'. I can see how it might come to a point where I might say something to the unfortunate most recent offender like 'thanks, and I'll think for you!' I don't see how it might come to a point where I would say something like 'someday you'll get yours and I hope I'm there to see it when it happens!', though.

I've decided I should be more sympathetic to your impression of persecution. To us, what you're talking about is only holding you to our usual skeptic's standards of logic and evidence, plus a tendency to express frustration when you don't adhere to the same standards, and the occasional crude humor (in this case more provoked by Yrreg's insistence on repeatedly bringing sex organs into the conversation). You're not used to it, and having been a Christian, I can especially appreciate how the gutter humor can wear thin. I hope in turn you can accept that we don't mean anything by most of the comments you've found offensive--we don't even think they're mean. Having been a military man and a construction worker, I can especially appreciate how the most vile-sounding remarks can be delivered in good humor. I reconcile your apparent decency with your malicious-sounding remark by construing it be some sort of Christian version of a day-laborer impugning his co-worker's virility: fighting words in some circles, perfectly okay in others.
 
I have heard enough Christians and Muslims express an interest in getting to find out what happens to people (who disagree with them) in the afterlife (with a clear inference that it will be unpleasant) that I am willing to accept the majority who do so, for some reason, are just incapable of comprehending how profoundly insulting they are being. I don't know why that is (it seems obvious to me, kind of how 'someday, someone is going to give you what's coming to you' is obviously combining both insult and threat, while avoiding personal responsibility). You seem to be saying that lots of little offenses add up to license for you to say something malicious. I don't agree, but the things you find offensive wouldn't offend me...maybe if I saw them as provoking as you do, I would be more sympathetic. Certainly I can imagine visiting a Christian forum and getting tired of hearing comments they find innocuous but I find irritating, like 'I'll pray for you'. I can see how it might come to a point where I might say something to the unfortunate most recent offender like 'thanks, and I'll think for you!' I don't see how it might come to a point where I would say something like 'someday you'll get yours and I hope I'm there to see it when it happens!', though.

I've decided I should be more sympathetic to your impression of persecution. To us, what you're talking about is only holding you to our usual skeptic's standards of logic and evidence, plus a tendency to express frustration when you don't adhere to the same standards, and the occasional crude humor (in this case more provoked by Yrreg's insistence on repeatedly bringing sex organs into the conversation). You're not used to it, and having been a Christian, I can especially appreciate how the gutter humor can wear thin. I hope in turn you can accept that we don't mean anything by most of the comments you've found offensive--we don't even think they're mean. Having been a military man and a construction worker, I can especially appreciate how the most vile-sounding remarks can be delivered in good humor. I reconcile your apparent decency with your malicious-sounding remark by construing it be some sort of Christian version of a day-laborer impugning his co-worker's virility: fighting words in some circles, perfectly okay in others.

Where did you come from? You are like a breath of fresh air and I am happy that you understand the issues. And you have made me understand how my remarks harmed Randy...

So....

Ok, Randy I am truly sorry I made the remark about getting punished in the afterlife if I have harmed you in any way please accept my apology. Mister is correct.
; }>
 
You missed this;

a·the·ism Pronunciation (th-zm)
n.
1. Disbelief in or denial of the existence of God or gods.
2. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Atheists

mufff

; {>

Read number two again The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

Its items like this that makes debating with you pixi nearly impossible. And not know much of your subject matter, and not admitting when you are wrong even in the face of outside evidence.

; {>

The definition has two meanings, you are focusing on the 2nd one, but only the first applies to 90% of us. Two is not a rephrase of one, it is a whole different meaning for the word atheism. The only person here using it in that sense is you. For the most part, we don't say there is no God, we say we don't believe there is a God.

Also, the dictionary is wrong. Who teaches this doctrine? Must it be adhered to? How is it enforced? Sadly, in this case, the word chosen for meaning two is less-than-best. Better would have been: 2. The assertion that is no God or gods. And this meaning would still only apply to universally strong atheists.
 
Where did you come from? You are like a breath of fresh air and I am happy that you understand the issues. And you have made me understand how my remarks harmed Randy...

So....

Ok, Randy I am truly sorry I made the remark about getting punished in the afterlife if I have harmed you in any way please accept my apology. Mister is correct.
; }>

You continue to impress me, Rev. I am going to stop stealing company time now (I will stay a little late to pay them back!) and get back to work with a good feeling in my heart.
 
Are you sure that soundness does not apply to premises? I see it constantly used like that, and have used soundness as applicable to premises as well, even in this thread.


To be a sound argument, both the logic must be valid and the premises must be true.
 
I've been arguing the opposite. Under what theory can a series of events take place without time?

A series necessates that things happen before and after. There is no before and after without time.
Well it would have to be a purely theoretical construct, but for example if a universe contained nothing but a single discrete element that changed there would not be time. If a universe contained nothing but two discrete elements and they both changed but there was no causal connection between the two then there would not be time.

You could probably think up a lot of hypothetical universes that had change and not time. But as soon as you start having more than one thing that changes and a causal connection between the two then you have time, that is the way I see it.

Most people, when they say 'timeless' really just mean time that operates in a different way than it does in our Universe.
 
But as I point out, all this stuff about time, atemporality and eternity is quite beside the point, because the argument up to C2 does not mention time.

If time and change are not the same thing then any discussion of time is irrelevant.

RevDisturba, you have not even acknowledged that I have said this - is there any particular reason you want to avoid this point?
 
You continue to impress me, Rev. I am going to stop stealing company time now (I will stay a little late to pay them back!) and get back to work with a good feeling in my heart.

Likewise Mister...

"Do not forget to entertain strangers, for by so doing some people have entertained angels without knowing it." Hebrews 13:2

I have been extremely fortunate to have angels visit me at the least expected times, this time they seem to have piggyback on a temporal agent ....


; {>
 
Last edited:
RevDisturba,

Original|Suggested Amendment
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: If the universe did not begin to exist then either there was an infinite regress or causality is not exclusively sequential
Now let's get back to this. You have rejected the amendment on the basis that the part in blue has no empirical evidence.

This is obviously not a valid reason since the premiss is not claiming this is the case, only that it would be one of the options if the universe did not begin to exist.

If you reject the amendment on this basis and consistently apply this criterion to the original premiss you would have to say the original P1 is not valid.

So what is it to be, accept the amendment, reject the original P1 or find a reason for rejecting my amendment that would not also invalidate the original P1?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom